Attachment C 1238 Asbestos Survey.pdf

MOBILE · MONTGOMERY · SUMMERDALE · DESTIN · PANAMA CITY · PENSACOLA · TALLAHASSEE · BATON ROUGE · MANDEVILLE · NEW ORLEANS · LONG BEACH

PANAMA CITY OFFICE

7500 McElvey Road, Ste. A

Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Tel: (850) 769-4773 Fax: (850) 872-9967 www.soearth.com

DCF – Florida State Hospital May 4, 2023 100 North Main Street – Building 1153 File No.: P23-0213 Chattahoochee, FL 32324-1198

Attention: Mr. Rick Rogers & Ms. Crystall Wells

Subject: Building 1238, Pre-Renovation Asbestos Survey

Florida State Hospital, Chattahoochee, Florida

Dear Mr. Rogers:

As requested, Southern Earth Sciences, Inc. has completed an asbestos survey of Building 1238 at the Florida State Hospital in Chattahoochee, Florida. The survey did not include the occupied (laboratory) area of the building and roofing samples were not collected to prevent damaging the existing roofing. We understand that the building may be renovated.

1.0 INTRODUCTION

On April 18, 2023, asbestos surveyors with our firm obtained sixty (60) bulk samples of suspect asbestos-containing building material for analysis. Eighty-eight (88) samples were analyzed after separation of layered materials. The samples consisted of pipe insulation (white chalk-like, fiberglass with mudded elbows, fiberglass with black mastic/jacket, foam glass insulation with mastic), HVAC duct mastic, floor tile (9”x9” and 12”x12”, various colors), floor tile mastic, ceiling tiles, plaster, and window glazing. The bulk samples were sent to Eurofins CEI, an analytical laboratory in Cary, NC. Bulk samples were analyzed by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM), E.P.A. Method 600/R-93/116. Test results and sample locations are included in the attached Asbestos Analytical Report / Chain of Custody.

2.0 DEFINITIONS

Asbestos Containing Building Materials (ACBM): Building materials used for construction of a structure that are known or are suspect for containing asbestos.

Asbestos: Asbestos is the asbestiform varieties of chrysotile, crocidolite, amosite, anthophyllite, tremolite, and actinolite.

Florida State Hospital Building 1238

Asbestos Inspection: An evaluation performed by a trained and E.P.A. certified inspector to determine the presence or absence of Asbestos-containing materials. Asbestos inspectors engage in the survey and assessment of ACBM.

Category I non-friable ACM: asbestos-containing packing’s, gaskets, resilient floor covering and asphalt products.

Category II non-friable ACM: any material, excluding Category I ACM, that when dry, cannot be crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by hand pressure.

Demolition: the removal of load-bearing walls or structural components.

Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

Regulated Asbestos Containing Material (RACM): (a) Friable asbestos materials, (b) Category I non-friable ACM that has become friable, (c) Category I non-friable ACM that will be or has been subjected to sanding, grinding, cutting, or abrading, or, (d) Category II non-friable ACM that has a high probability of becoming or has become crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by the forces expected to act on the material in the course of demolition or renovation operations regulated by NESHAPS.

Renovation: the removal of any other building components other than load-bearing walls or structural components.

3.0 PHYSICAL SURVEY

The building is a 2-story building with a basement and crawl space. The first-floor east wing of the building contained the laboratory which was not included in our survey. Floor plans showing areas not accessible are attached.

Exterior window glazing was located on the windows. Screens covering window openings were in place and we could not determine if caulking was present or sample that material (if present).

A crawlspace was located under the south section of the building. We did not have access to the crawlspace under the laboratory (if present). The floor in the crawlspace was exposed soil.

Pipe insulation (white chalk-like) and elbow insulation debris was observed in the crawlspace. Intact pipe insulation included fiberglass piping with paper jacket with mudded elbows and white chalk like insulation.

The air handling room/mechanical room had fiberglass piping with paper jacket and mudded elbows and foam glass pipe insulation with black mastic. Duct insulation was fiberglass with black duct mastic.

The elevator lobby and hallway had white chalk-like pipe insulation, fiberglass pipe insulation with mudded elbows, and fiberglass insulation with pvc/plastic elbows. The lower mechanical space had fiberglass insulation with pvc/plastic elbows. Over the high voltage room was fiberglass piping with mudded elbows which continued to the north caged storage room.

Upper floors – The ceilings were suspended ceiling tiles under fiberglass suspended ceiling tiles under concrete deck. Ceilings in the bathrooms, janitors’ closets and work rooms were plaster.

The lower portions of all walls were covered with ceramic tile. Walls were plaster in the hallways, bathrooms, storage rooms and patient rooms. The floors were 9”x9” vinyl floor tile or 12”x12” vinyl floor tile. There were two layers of vinyl floor tile in the nurse’s station area.

Ceramic tile was located on the floors in the bathrooms.

Pipe insulation (fiberglass with mudded elbows and fiberglass with black mastic) was located in pipe chases and above plaster ceilings in the bathrooms. Enclosed in pipe chases in the corners of patient rooms was piping with fiberglass insulation. Piping associated with the radiators was metal covered with neoprene. No mastic was observed on the radiator piping. Duct mastic was associated with individual air conditioning units in patient rooms. Duct mastic was also present above suspended ceilings in the hallways and in the ceiling space in the nurse’s station area.

Stairwells had concrete stairs, plaster walls and ceilings.

4.0 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS

The E.P.A. definition for an asbestos-containing material is a building material that contains more than 1 percent asbestos when analyzed by PLM and is placed into two categories: friable and non-friable. Friable ACM is a material that can be easily pulverized with hand pressure as opposed to non-friable ACM.

4.1 FRIABLE ACM

The white chalk-like pipe insulation contains 15% Chrysotile asbestos. The pipe insulation was located in the crawlspace and in the hallway in the basement. Debris was noted in the crawl space. There was approximately 250 linear feet of the white chalk-like pipe insulation.

Mudded elbow insulation contained 2-15% Chrysotile asbestos. The elbows are associated with fiberglass pipe insulation. Elbows were noted in the crawlspace, basement hallway, basement caged area, above plaster ceilings in bathrooms on upper floors and in pipe chases in bathrooms and patient rooms. There was approximately 1300 linear feet of pipe insulation with elbows in the basement. We have ESTIMATED approximately 460 linear feet of pipe insulation in patient room pipe chases, 700 linear feet of pipe insulation above plaster ceilings in bathrooms, in bathroom pipe chase and in pipe chases in the nurses’ station areas. We should note pipe insulation debris (ACM) was observed in the lower level of the mechanical room near the high voltage room and in the crawlspace.

4.2 NON-FRIABLE ACM

Black mastic on foam glass pipe insulation contained 5% Chrysotile asbestos. The foam glass pipe insulation was located in the mechanical room/HVAC room in the basement. There was approximately 75 linear feet of foam glass insulation with ACM black mastic.

The black mastic on pipe insulation contained 7% Chrysotile asbestos. The pipes with the mastic were observed in pipe chases in the bathrooms. There was approximately 1100 linear feet of this insulation in pipe chases.

The mastic on the HVAC ductwork in the basement contained 5% Chrysotile asbestos. There was approximately 150 linear feet of duct work in the basement. There was approximately 4000 linear feet of duct mastic in the upper floors.

The 9”x9” vinyl floor tile (various colors) contained 2-3% Chrysotile asbestos. The floor tile was located in patient rooms, hallways and storage rooms. The 9”x9” floor tile was also located under 12”x12” vinyl floor tile in the nurse’s station area. There was approximately 22,000 square feet of floor tile. We should note that none of the floor tile mastic samples tested positive for asbestos.

5.0 CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

In accordance with the National Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAPS), 40 CFR Part 61, Subpart M, Regulated Asbestos Containing Materials (RACM) are required to be removed prior to renovations that would disturb asbestos containing materials and prior to demolition.

At this time, we do not know what renovations are planned for the building. Any plans to remove flooring or update HVAC system and plumbing would require removal of asbestos containing materials.

Please be advised that there was friable asbestos containing debris observed in the crawlspace and in the lower level of the mechanical room near the high voltage room. The asbestos debris must either be removed by a Florida licensed asbestos abatement contractor or restrict access to these areas to persons with proper asbestos training.

Removal of asbestos containing materials must be performed by an Asbestos Abatement Contractor licensed by the State of Florida, with certified personnel. ACM abatement must comply with the State of Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation, Chapter 469, licensing, and training; Chapter 62-701.520, Waste Disposal Rules; Chapter 62-257, DEP 1999, Asbestos Program and OSHA 29 CFR 1926.1100 (Construction Industry Standard).

NESHAPS requires a 10-working day notification to the Florida Department of Environmental Protection (FDEP) Division of Air Management prior to the start date of an asbestos abatement project and/or prior to demolition.

6.0 GENERAL COMMENTS

This asbestos survey has been performed to identify asbestos containing materials in the existing buildings and is not intended as abatement specifications and drawings. Quantities of materials would be verified during preparations of plans and specifications. We should note that destructive sampling was not performed, and additional materials may be located within wall chases and above plaster ceilings.

Comments and observations given above reflect an opinion as to the various materials and conditions visually observed during the inspections and should not be construed as a representation or warranty expressed or implied, as to scope, thoroughness, or accuracy of the inspection.

A conscious effort is made to identify all suspect materials. There is a possibility that conditions or materials may exist which could not be identified during our survey due to physical inaccessibility and the use of nondestructive sampling methods. Materials that typically do not contain asbestos have not been sampled. These materials include but are not limited to plastics, wood, fiberglass, etc.

Conclusions and recommendations given in this report are based upon our interpretation of current regulatory standards. Changes in regulatory standards may require changes in our conclusions and recommendations.

We appreciate the opportunity to be of service to you on this project. Should you have any questions or require additional information, please contact our office.

Sincerely, SOUTHERN EARTH SCIENCES, INC.

Tammie Barry Mark E. Wilson, P.E.

Project Manager Consultant No. AX 85 Asbestos Inspector No. 230043-8922 State of Florida

Laboratory Data

April 26, 2023

Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

CLIENT PROJECT: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

CEI LAB CODE: B238632

Dear Customer:

Enclosed are asbestos analysis results for PLM Bulk samples received at our laboratory on April 21, 2023. The samples were analyzed for asbestos using polarizing light microscopy (PLM) per the EPA 600 Method.

Sample results containing >1% asbestos are considered asbestos-containing materials (ACMs) per EPA regulatory requirements. The detection limit for the EPA 600 Method is <1% asbestos by weight as determined by visual estimation.

Thank you for your business and we look forward to continuing good relations.

730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Tianbao Bai, Ph.D., CIH Laboratory Director

Kind Regards, ASBESTOS ANALYTICAL REPORT

By: Polarized Light Microscopy

Prepared for

Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

CLIENT PROJECT:

LAB CODE:

TEST METHOD: EPA 600 / R93 / 116 and EPA 600 / M4-82 / 020

REPORT DATE:

TOTAL SAMPLES ANALYZED:

# SAMPLES >1% ASBESTOS:

FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

04/26/23

B238632

730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Asbestos Report Summary By: POLARIZING LIGHT MICROSCOPY

PROJECT: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213 LAB CODE: B238632

Client ID Lab ID Color Sample Description

ASBESTOS

%Layer

METHOD: EPA 600 / R93 / 116 and EPA 600 / M4-82 / 020

01 B238632.01 White,Off-white Pipe Insulation Chrysotile01 15% 02 B238632.02 White,Off-white Pipe Insulation Chrysotile02 15% 03 B238632.03 Brown,Tan Pipe Insulation Chrysotile03 15% 04 B238632.04 Gray,Tan Elbow Insulation Chrysotile04 2% 05 B238632.05 Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation Chrysotile05 15% 06 B238632.06 Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation Chrysotile06 15% 07 B238632.07 Black Mastic On Fiberglass Insulation None Detected07

08 B238632.08 Black Mastic On Fiberglass Insulation None Detected08

09 B238632.09 Black Mastic On Fiberglass Insulation None Detected09

10 B238632.10 Black Mastic On Hvac Duct Chrysotile10 5% 11 B238632.11 Black Mastic On Hvac Duct Chrysotile11 5% 12 B238632.12 Black Mastic On Hvac Duct Chrysotile12 5% 13 B238632.13 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile13 5% 14 B238632.14 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile14 5% 15 B238632.15 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile15 5% 16 B238632.16 Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation Chrysotile16 10% 17 B238632.17 Brown,Tan Pipe Insulation Chrysotile17 15% 18 B238632.18 White,Off-white Paper None Detected18

19 B238632.19A Beige Floor Tile Chrysotile19 3% B238632.19B Black Mastic None Detected

20 B238632.20A Beige Floor Tile Chrysotile20 3% B238632.20B Black Mastic None Detected

21 B238632.21 Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation Chrysotile21 10% 22 Layer 1 B238632.22 White Jacket None Detected22

Layer 2 B238632.22 Black Mastic None Detected

23 B238632.23 White,Gray Ceiling Tile None Detected23

24 B238632.24 White,Gray- Yellow

Ceiling Tile None Detected24

25 Layer 1 B238632.25 White,Off-white Plaster Skim Coat None Detected25

Layer 2 B238632.25 Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat None Detected

26 Layer 1 B238632.26 White,Off-white Plaster Skim Coat None Detected26

Page 1 of 3730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

PROJECT: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213 LAB CODE: B238632

Client ID Lab ID Color Sample Description

ASBESTOS

%Layer

METHOD: EPA 600 / R93 / 116 and EPA 600 / M4-82 / 020

Layer 2 B238632.26 Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat None Detected

27 B238632.27 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile27 5% 28 B238632.28 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile28 5% 29 B238632.29 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile29 5% 30 B238632.30A Gray,Tan Floor Tile Chrysotile30 2%

B238632.30B Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile 2% B238632.30C Black Mastic None Detected

31 B238632.31A Gray,Tan Floor Tile Chrysotile31 3% B238632.31B Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile 3% B238632.31C Black Mastic None Detected

32 B238632.32A Off-white,Tan Floor Tile None Detected32

B238632.32B Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile 3% B238632.32C Black Mastic None Detected

33 B238632.33A Off-white,Tan Floor Tile None Detected33

B238632.33B Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile 3% B238632.33C Black Mastic None Detected

34 B238632.34A Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile34 3% B238632.34B Black Mastic None Detected

35 B238632.35A Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile35 3% B238632.35B Black Mastic None Detected

36 B238632.36 White,Gray Ceiling Tile None Detected36

37 B238632.37 White,Gray Ceiling Tile None Detected37

38 B238632.38 White,Gray Ceiling Tile None Detected38

39 B238632.39 Black Mastic None Detected39

40 B238632.40 Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation Chrysotile40 5% 41 Layer 1 B238632.41 White,Off-white Plaster Skim Coat None Detected41

Layer 2 B238632.41 Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat None Detected

42 B238632.42A Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile42 3% B238632.42B Black Mastic None Detected

43 B238632.43A Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile43 3% B238632.43B Black Mastic None Detected

Page 2 of 3730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

PROJECT: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213 LAB CODE: B238632

Client ID Lab ID Color Sample Description

ASBESTOS

%Layer

METHOD: EPA 600 / R93 / 116 and EPA 600 / M4-82 / 020

44 B238632.44A Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile44 3% B238632.44B Black Mastic None Detected

45 B238632.45A White,Off-white Floor Tile None Detected45

B238632.45B Yellow,Off-white

Mastic None Detected

B238632.45C Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile 2% B238632.45D Black Mastic None Detected

46 B238632.46A White,Off-white Floor Tile None Detected46

B238632.46B Yellow,Off-white

Mastic None Detected

B238632.46C Beige,Off-white Floor Tile Chrysotile 2% B238632.46D Black Mastic None Detected

47 B238632.47 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile47 7% 48 B238632.48 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile48 7% 49 B238632.49 Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation Chrysotile49 7% 50 B238632.50 White,Gray Ceiling Tile None Detected50

51 B238632.51 White,Gray Ceiling Tile None Detected51

52 B238632.52 White,Gray- Yellow

Ceiling Tile None Detected52

53 B238632.53 White,Gray- Yellow

Ceiling Tile None Detected53

54 Layer 1 B238632.54 White,Off-white Plaster Skim Coat None Detected54

Layer 2 B238632.54 Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat None Detected

55 Layer 1 B238632.55 White,Off-white Plaster Skim Coat None Detected55

Layer 2 B238632.55 Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat None Detected

56 Layer 1 B238632.56 White,Off-white Plaster Skim Coat None Detected56

Layer 2 B238632.56 Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat None Detected

57 B238632.57 Black Mastic None Detected57

58 B238632.58 Black Mastic None Detected58

59 B238632.59 Brown,Tan Pipe Insulation Chrysotile59 10% 60 B238632.60 Off-white,White Window Glazing None Detected60

Page 3 of 3730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

ASBESTOS BULK ANALYSIS

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

White,Off-white Pipe Insulation01

B238632.01 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

45% 25%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

15% Chrysotile

White,Off-white Pipe Insulation02

B238632.02 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

45% 25%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

15% Chrysotile

Brown,Tan Pipe Insulation03

B238632.03 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 10%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

15% Chrysotile

Gray,Tan Elbow Insulation04

B238632.04 15% 8%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

45% 30%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

2% Chrysotile

Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation05

B238632.05 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 10%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

15% Chrysotile

Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation06

B238632.06 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 10%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

15% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Fiberglass Insulation

B238632.07

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Page 1 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Black Mastic On Fiberglass Insulation

B238632.08

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Black Mastic On Fiberglass Insulation

B238632.09

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Black Mastic On Hvac Duct10

B238632.10 Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Hvac Duct11

B238632.11 Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Hvac Duct12

B238632.12 Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.13

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.14

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Page 2 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.15

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation16

B238632.16 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 15%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

10% Chrysotile

Brown,Tan Pipe Insulation17

B238632.17 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 10%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

15% Chrysotile

White,Off-white Paper18

B238632.18 100%Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

Cellulose None Detected

Beige Floor Tile19

B238632.19A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.19B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Beige Floor Tile20

B238632.20A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Page 3 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Black MasticB238632.20B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation21

B238632.21 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 15%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

10% Chrysotile

White

B238632.22

60%Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

40%Cellulose Binder None Detected Layer 1

Jacket

Black Mastic

B238632.22 <1%Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% 5%

Cellulose Tar Metal Foil

None DetectedLayer 2

White,Gray Ceiling Tile23

B238632.23 60% 20%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

15% 5%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Perlite Paint

None Detected

White,Gray- Yellow

Ceiling Tile24 B238632.24

90%Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

10% <1%

Fiberglass Binder Paint

None Detected

White,Off-white

B238632.25

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Binder Silicates

None Detected Layer 1

Plaster Skim Coat

Page 4 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat

B238632.25 <1%Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Cellulose Silicates Binder

None DetectedLayer 2

White,Off-white

B238632.26

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Binder Silicates

None Detected Layer 1

Plaster Skim Coat

Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat

B238632.26 <1%Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Cellulose Silicates Binder

None DetectedLayer 2

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.27

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.28

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.29

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

95% Tar 5% Chrysotile

Gray,Tan Floor Tile30

B238632.30A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

98% Vinyl 2% Chrysotile

Page 5 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Beige,Off-white Floor TileB238632.30B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

98% Vinyl 2% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.30C Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Gray,Tan Floor Tile31

B238632.31A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Beige,Off-white Floor TileB238632.31B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.31C Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Off-white,Tan Floor Tile32

B238632.32A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Vinyl None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor TileB238632.32B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

Page 6 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Black MasticB238632.32C Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Off-white,Tan Floor Tile33

B238632.33A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Vinyl None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor TileB238632.33B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.33C Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor Tile34

B238632.34A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.34B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor Tile35

B238632.35A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

Page 7 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Black MasticB238632.35B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

White,Gray Ceiling Tile36

B238632.36 60% 20%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

15% 5%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Perlite Paint

None Detected

White,Gray Ceiling Tile37

B238632.37 60% 20%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

15% 5%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Perlite Paint

None Detected

White,Gray Ceiling Tile38

B238632.38 95%Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

5%Fiberglass Paint None Detected

Black Mastic39

B238632.39 Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Brown,Tan Elbow Insulation40

B238632.40 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 20%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

5% Chrysotile

White,Off-white

B238632.41

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Binder Silicates

None Detected Layer 1

Plaster Skim Coat

Page 8 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat

B238632.41 <1%Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Cellulose Silicates Binder

None DetectedLayer 2

Beige,Off-white Floor Tile42

B238632.42A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.42B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor Tile43

B238632.43A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.43B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor Tile44

B238632.44A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

97% Vinyl 3% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.44B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Page 9 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

White,Off-white Floor Tile45

B238632.45A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Vinyl None Detected

Yellow,Off-white MasticB238632.45B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Mastic None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor TileB238632.45C Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

98% Vinyl 2% Chrysotile

Black MasticB238632.45D Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

White,Off-white Floor Tile46

B238632.46A Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Vinyl None Detected

Yellow,Off-white MasticB238632.46B Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Mastic None Detected

Beige,Off-white Floor TileB238632.46C Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

98% Vinyl 2% Chrysotile

Page 10 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Black MasticB238632.46D Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.47

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

93% Tar 7% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.48

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

93% Tar 7% Chrysotile

Black Mastic On Pipe Insulation

B238632.49

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

93% Tar 7% Chrysotile

White,Gray Ceiling Tile50

B238632.50 60% 20%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

15% 5%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Perlite Paint

None Detected

White,Gray Ceiling Tile51

B238632.51 60% 20%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

15% 5%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Perlite Paint

None Detected

White,Gray- Yellow

Ceiling Tile52 B238632.52

90%Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

10% <1%

Fiberglass Binder Paint

None Detected

Page 11 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

White,Gray- Yellow

Ceiling Tile53 B238632.53

90%Heterogeneous

Fibrous Bound

10% <1%

Fiberglass Binder Paint

None Detected

White,Off-white

B238632.54

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Binder Silicates

None Detected Layer 1

Plaster Skim Coat

Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat

B238632.54 <1%Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Cellulose Silicates Binder

None DetectedLayer 2

White,Off-white

B238632.55

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Binder Silicates

None Detected Layer 1

Plaster Skim Coat

Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat

B238632.55 <1%Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Cellulose Silicates Binder

None DetectedLayer 2

White,Off-white

B238632.56

Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Binder Silicates

None Detected Layer 1

Plaster Skim Coat

Beige,Tan Plaster Base Coat

B238632.56 <1%Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

65% 35%

Cellulose Silicates Binder

None DetectedLayer 2

Page 12 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Lab Code: B238632 Date Received: 04-21-23 Date Analyzed: 04-26-23 Date Reported: 04-26-23

Client ID Lab ID

Lab Attributes

Lab Description

ASBESTOS

ASBESTOS BULK PLM, EPA 600 METHOD

NON-ASBESTOS COMPONENTS

Non-Fibrous

Client: Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

7500 McElvey Road, Suite A Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Project: FL St. Hosp Bldg 1238, P23-0213

Fibrous

Black Mastic57

B238632.57 Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Black Mastic58

B238632.58 Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

100% Tar None Detected

Brown,Tan Pipe Insulation59

B238632.59 10% 5%

Heterogeneous

Fibrous Loosely Bound

60% 15%

Cellulose Fiberglass

Binder Calc Carb

10% Chrysotile

Off-white,White Window Glazing60

B238632.60 Heterogeneous

Non-fibrous Bound

75% 20% 5%

Binder Calc Carb Paint

None Detected

Page 13 of 14730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

LEGEND: Non-Anth = Non-Asbestiform Anthophyllite Non-Trem = Non-Asbestiform Tremolite Calc Carb = Calcium Carbonate

METHOD: EPA 600 / R93 / 116 and EPA 600 / M4-82 / 020

REPORTING LIMIT: <1% by visual estimation

REPORTING LIMIT FOR POINT COUNTS: 0.25% by 400 Points or 0.1% by 1,000 Points

REGULATORY LIMIT: >1% by weight

Due to the limitations of the EPA 600 method, nonfriable organically bound materials (NOBs) such as vinyl floor tiles can be difficult to analyze via polarized light microscopy (PLM). EPA recommends that all NOBs analyzed by PLM, and found not to contain asbestos, be further analyzed by Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM). Please note that PLM analysis of dust and soil samples for asbestos is not covered under NVLAP accreditation. Estimated measurement of uncertainty is available on request.

This report relates only to the samples tested or analyzed and may not be reproduced, except in full, without written approval by Eurofins CEI. Eurofins CEI makes no warranty representation regarding the accuracy of client submitted information in preparing and presenting analytical results.

Interpretation of the analytical results is the sole responsibility of the client. Samples were received in acceptable condition unless otherwise noted. This report may not be used by the client to claim product endorsement by NVLAP or any other agency of the U.S. Government.

Information provided by customer includes customer sample ID and sample description.

ANALYST: APPROVED BY:

Tianbao Bai, Ph.D., CIH Laboratory Director

Jacob Cox

Scott Minyard

730 SE Maynard Road • Cary, NC 27511 • 919.481.1413

Photographs

Building 1238 Taken by Tammie Barry Florida State Hospital

Photograph 1: Fiberglass pipe insulation with mudded elbows - ACM - crawlspace

Photograph 2: White Chalk like insulation – ACM crawlspace

Photograph 3: Elbow/pipe insulation debris in crawlspace

Photograph 4: Fiberglass insulation with mudded elbows – ACM – note debris below pipes

Photograph 5: White chalk like pipe insulation debris in crawlspace

Photograph 6: Duct mastic – ACM in mechanical room adjacent to crawlspace

Photograph 7: White chalk like insulation in hallway with elevator landing

Photograph 8: View over high voltage room – mix of pipe insulation

Photograph 9: Duct mastic and foam glass pipe insulation with ACM mastic in HVAC mechanical room

Photograph 10: Lower level – new pipe – fiberglass with PVC/plastic elbows – non-acm

Photograph 11: Lower level mix of newer and older pipe (black mastic – ACM)

Photograph 12: fiberglass pipe with black mastic

Photograph 13: ACM Debris in lower area near high voltage room

Photograph 14: View of pipe chase with fiberglass piping and elbow insulation - ACM

Photograph 15: fiberglass pipe with elbow insulation in chase – ACM

Photograph 16: Neoprene insulation (NON ACM) in wall mounted radiators

Photograph 17: Wall mounted radiator

Photograph 18: Pipe insulation with mudded elbows above plaster ceiling in bathrooms

Photograph 19: Fiberglass pipe insulation in janitor’s closet

Photograph 20: Radiator with chase to the right – also ACM vinyl floor tile

Photograph 21: Showing fiberglass pipe (with elbows ?) inside corner chase

Photograph 22: ACM Duct mastic

Photograph 23: Showing fiberglass pipe with elbows above plaster ceiling of adjacent bathroom

Photograph 24: Pipe with mudded elbow above plaster ceiling in bathroom

Photograph 25: Duct mastic and ACM elbows in nurses’ station area/hallway note 2 layers of ceiling tile

FLOOR PLANS

Southern Earth Sciences, Inc.

Licenses & Certifications

Julie I. Brown, SecretaryRon DeSantis, Governor

STATE OF FLORIDA

DEPARTMENT OF BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL REGULATION

ASBESTOS LICENSING UNIT

THE ASBESTOS BUSINESS ORGANIZATION HEREIN IS LICENSED UNDER THE

PROVISIONS OF CHAPTER 469, FLORIDA STATUTES

SOUTHERN EARTH SCIENCES INC

Do not alter this document in any form.

MARK E. WILSON

LICENSE NUMBER: ZA0000092

EXPIRATION DATE: NOVEMBER 30, 2023

This is your license. It is unlawful for anyone other than the licensee to use this document.

2467 CENTERVILLE ROAD

TALLAHASSEE FL 32308

Always verify licenses online at MyFloridaLicense.com https://www.myfloridalicense.com/LicenseDetail.asp?SID=&id=75aff38a57c5b9b414ba911eec62cef1

RRcertifies

Tammie C. Barry Southern Earth Sciences 7500 McElvey Road, Suite A 750 , Panama City Beach, FL 32408

Having passed a 25-question exam with a score of 70% or higher has successfully met training requirements for

Asbestos Refresher: Inspector FDBPR Asbestos Licensing Unit: Provider #0000995; Course #FL49-0004731 (½ Day; 3.40 Contact Hours)

(Reaccreditation for Inspector under TSCA Title II/AHERA) Conducted

08/02/2022

Certificate #: 230043-8922 Exam Date: 08/02/2022 EPA accreditation expires: 08/02/2023 Principal Instructor: Brian Duchene, PE, LAC CEUs: .4 FBPR LAC: #0000995; Course #0004731 FBPE CEHs: #0004021; Course #0009083/Educational Institutions: 4 CEHs