Attachment 5 Evaluation Factors.pdf
PDF 112 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- 2025-NIH-0RF-DTR-ROBOTS
About this file
This document is an Attachment 5: Evaluation Factors for a federal contract solicitation involving robotic systems for utility plant operations. The evaluation contains Go/No Go factors and eight detailed technical evaluation factors with specific weights. The solicitation requires a robotic system capable of concurrent operation with multiple sensing capabilities, including PTZ analog-gauge reading, IR/thermal imaging, acoustic/vibration sensing, gas-leak detection, and manipulator arm functionality, all on a single unified power and control stack.
Key technical requirements include demonstrating runtime and mobility in utility environments, providing turnkey installation and training, ensuring enterprise data integration with systems like IBM Maximo and AVEVA PI, meeting robust cybersecurity standards, maintaining a U.S. supply-chain posture, offering lifecycle support, and implementing validated elevator/manipulation workflows. Critical evaluation criteria emphasize sovereign-control mitigations, United States data residency, United States-persons-only support, and OEM-signed evidence for firmware, security artifacts, and configuration authorization. The technical factors are weighted, with technical compliance (20%), cybersecurity (20%), and runtime/mobility (15%) receiving the highest priorities.
View the file
Other files
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
ATTACHMENT 5: EVALUATION FACTORS
Go/No Go Factors Response is received within the RFP closing date and addresses all sectors of the RFP. Pass/Fail Single-point accountability and OEM-signed evidence.
The offer includes OEM-signed: (a) firmware/signing/update control and patch/vulnerability governance for the robot and OEM-validated payloads; (b) API/SDK maintenance and change control for manipulation/elevator workflows and enterprise integrations; (c) ATO artifacts (as listed in Factor 5); (d) warranty/parts/training authorization for the integrated configuration; and
(e) sovereign-control acceptance (United States data residency; United States-persons-only support; no non-United States data flows; OEM control of telemetry and firmware signing/updates).
Pass only if all items are provided; otherwise Fail Pass/Fail
Technical Factors Weight
1. Technical compliance with true concurrency. The system must operate PTZ analog-gauge reading, IR/thermal imaging, acoustic/vibration sensing, gas-leak detection, and the manipulator arm simultaneously on a single, unified power and control stack, with no manual payload swaps or reconfiguration during a mission. 20
2. Runtime, mobility, and field validation in utility plants. Demonstrated performance in stairs, tunnels, and rough/dirty/wet environments, with persistent mapping and obstacle avoidance suitable for central-utility-plant operations (evidence from comparable utility/industrial deployments). 15
3. Turnkey installation, training, and documentation. A complete engineering/installation and commissioning plan, on-site training, and operator/maintenance documentation, delivering robots operational within the enterprise at handoff. 10
4. Enterprise data and integrations. SCADA/historian-consistent tagging; an on-premises database sized for ≥4,000 inspection points; native or documented integration with IBM Maximo and AVEVA PI (historian), including alerting across thermal/acoustic/mechanical/electrical/visual/leak-detection modalities. 15
5. Cybersecurity and ATO. Encrypted communications, documented firmware update/patch and vulnerability-management posture, secure remote access suitable for federal enterprise networks, and OEM-signed ATO artifacts (for example, Software Bill of Materials, encryption specifications, patch/vulnerability management plan, and network/data-flow diagrams). 20
6. U.S. supply-chain posture (jurisdiction and sovereign-control mitigations). The prime offeror is U.S.-incorporated and operating under United States jurisdiction, discloses any foreign parent or controlling interest, and accepts sovereign-control mitigations at award: United States data residency, United States-persons-only support, no data flows to non-United States entities, and OEM control of firmware signing/update pipelines and telemetry endpoints. 5
7. Lifecycle support, warranty, and program management. Multi-year warranty options, spare-parts availability, training/repairs, acceptance testing, and a program-management cadence (for example, bi-weekly reviews), plus demonstrated experience across at least five (5) facilities of similar scale and complexity within the last five years. 10
8. Validated elevator/manipulation workflow. A site-specific, scripted routine implemented via the OEM API/SDK at commissioning to enable autonomous multi-floor operation using the manipulator (for example, call button, entry/exit, floor selection, and safe ride). 5
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .