A06_-_Attachment_3_-_2015_Sample_Testing_Results.pdf

March 30, 2017 1775393

Mr. Ken Czapski Sanders & Czapski Associates, PLLC 109 Front Street, Suite 210 Marquette, Michigan 49855

RE: ASBESTOS LABORATORY RESULTS – PILOT ISLAND LIGHT STATION, PLUM ISLAND LIGHT

STATION, AND PLUM ISLAND LIFE-SAVING STATION

Dear Mr. Czapski:

This letter report summarizes the asbestos laboratory results for samples that Sanders & Czapski Associates, PLLC collected, bagged, and labeled from buildings at Pilot Island Light Station, Plum Island Light Station, and Plum Island Life-Saving Station for laboratory analysis by Golder Associates Inc. (Golder).

This letter report documents testing of potential asbestos containing material (PACM) or asbestos containing material (ACM) based on the samples provided for laboratory analysis. Quantities present on the site of the sampled materials were not provided with the samples. This report is not intended to be a full asbestos survey, rather an analysis of the samples provided. Under no circumstances should this letter report be considered a full asbestos survey utilized as a bidding document or utilized as a project specification document.

Thirty-one bulk samples of PACM were provided in individual containers. The samples were sent to a National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP)/American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA) accredited laboratory for analysis. Samples were submitted to Schneider Laboratories, Richmond, Virginia and analyzed using method EPA 600. The Schneider Laboratory report and sample chain-of-custody is attached.

The structures, sample numbers, descriptions/locations, and laboratory results are included in Table 1, attached.

Samples containing ACM materials including caulk, siding, floor tile and mastic, pipe insulation, and vinyl flooring are highlighted in bold print in the table. ACM was found to be present in two of the 14 samples from Pilot Island Light Station, five of the nine samples from Plum Island Light Station, and two of the eight samples from Plum Island Life-Saving Station.

Golder appreciates this opportunity to assist Sanders & Czapski Associates, PLLC. The undersigned attest that Golder conducted the work described herein following practices and principles consistent with that level of care and skill ordinarily exercised by members of this profession currently practicing under similar conditions and in substantial accordance with proposal P1775393. Please contact us if you need additional information.

Sincerely, GOLDER ASSOCIATES INC.

R. Robb Cookman, PE Mark A. Bergeon Senior Project Engineer Program Leader and Associate

Attachments:

Table 1 - Laboratory Asbestos Results Schneider Laboratory Analytical Report

Golder Associates Inc.

220 W. Washington Street, Suite 240

Marquette, MI 49855 USA Tel: (906) 273-2525 Fax: (906) 273-2528 www.golder.com

Golder Associates: Operations in Africa, Asia, Australasia, Europe, North America and South America

Golder, Golder Associates and the GA globe design are trademarks of Golder Associates Corporation597

Structure Sample Number Description/Location Friable Layer

Asbestos Content

Site Grounds S-1 (1) Shingle debris pile near NW corner of Keepers' Dwelling/Light (red)

Shingle Paper

None Detected None Detected

Fog Signal Building S-2 (2) Shingle debris inside Fog Signal Building (green)

Shingle Paper

None Detected None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-3 (3) Basement - wall plaster Plaster None Detected Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-4 (4) Basement - plaster debris on floor Debris None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-5 (5) First floor, north Kitchen - wall plaster Plaster None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-6 (6) First floor, south Kitchen - wall plaster Plaster None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-7 (7) First floor, south Kitchen - sheet flooring Flooring None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-8 (8) First floor, Dining Room - ceiling plaster Plaster None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-9 (9) Second floor, NE Bedroom - wall plaster Plaster None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-10 (10) Second floor, SW Bedroom - wall plaster Plaster None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-11 (11) Second floor , Bathroom - sheet flooring & mastic Flooring None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-12 (12) Attic Hardboard paneling Panel None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-13 (13) Lantern - caulking/mastic at base of lantern No Caulk 5% Chrysotile

Keepers' Dwelling/Light S-14 (14) Light Tower - asbestos cement board siding at exterior walls No Siding 15% Chrysotile

Note: Bolded samples are ACMs

Table 1

Pilot Island Light Station

Plum Island Life-Saving Station Pilot Island Light Station, Plum Island Light Station, and

Laboratory Asbestos Results

Number Description/Location Friable Layer

Asbestos Content

Fog Signal Building S-1 (15) Exterior - asphalt roof shingles (black-red) Shingle None Detected

Fog Signal Building S-2 (16) Exterior -cement board siding on west addition No Siding 15% Chrysotile

Fog Signal Building S-3 (17) West addition - 12"x12" acoustic wall and ceiling tile Plaster None Detected

Fog Signal Building S-4 (18) West addition - 9"x9" floor tile (beige) and mastic No

Floor Tile Mastic

2% Chrysotile 5% Chrysotile

Fog Signal Building S-5 (19) West addition - 9"x9" floor tile (red) and mastic No

Floor Tile Mastic

4% Chrysotile 5% Chrysotile

Fog Signal Building S-6 (20) Attic ceiling insulation Insulation None Detected Keepers' Dwelling S-7 (21) First floor - wall plaster Plaster None Detected

Keepers' Dwelling S-8 (22) Basement - pipe insulation (loose on floor) Yes

Pipe insulation

30% Amosite and 5% Chrysotile

Keepers' Dwelling S-9 (23) Basement - fibrous pipe insulation Yes

Pipe insulation 25% Chrysotile

Note: Bolded samples are ACMs

Plum Island Light Station

Table 1 (continued) Pilot Island Light Station, Plum Island Light Station, and

Laboratory Asbestos Results Plum Island Life-Saving Station

Number Description/Location Friable Layer

Asbestos Content

Crew Quarters/LSS S-1 (24) Basement - fibrous pipe wrap material Pipe Wrap None Detected

Crew Quarters/LSS S-2 (25) Basement - pipe insulation (fiberglass)

Insulation Cover

None Detected None Detected

Crew Quarters/LSS S-3 (26) Basement - discarded fibrous 12"x12" ceiling tiles Tile None Detected

Crew Quarters/LSS S-4 (27) First floor - wall plaster Plaster None Detected

Crew Quarters/LSS S-5 (28) First floor, SW Bedroom - sheet vinyl flooring and mastic No

Flooring Mastic

20% Chrysotile None Detected

Crew Quarters/LSS S-6 (29) First floor, ceiling insulation (above Bathroom) Insulation None Detected

Crew Quarters/LSS S-7 (30)

Second floor, stair tower hallway - 9"x9" floor tiles (beige), paper underlayment and mastic No

Tile Mastic

4% Chrysotile None Detected

Crew Quarters/LSS S-8 (31) Tower, upper level - sheet vinyl or linoleum flooring material Plaster None Detected

Note: Bolded samples are ACMs

Table 1 (continued) Pilot Island Light Station, Plum Island Light Station, and

Laboratory Asbestos Results

Plum Island Life-Saving Station

Plum Island Life-Saving Station

Attn:

Address: 3730 Chamblee Tucker Road Order #: 206988 Atlanta, GA 30341

Project: Sanders & Czapski Env. Testing

Per March 14, 2017 agreeme

Golder Associates (MLSA) (4932)Customer:

1775393Number: PO Number:

Received 03/24/17

Schneider Laboratories Global, Inc 2512 W. Cary Street • Richmond, Virginia • 23220-5117 804-353-6778 • 800-785-LABS (5227) • Fax 804-359-1475

03/26/17

Location: Plum Island & Pilot Island, WI

Analyzed

03/29/17Reported

Analysis Report

PLM Analysis

Cust. IDSample ID LocationCollected Asbestos Fibers Other Materials

EPA 600/R-93/116 & 600/M4-82-020Method:

Near NW Corner KD/L03/21/17 S-1 (1)206988-001

Red/Back, Bituminous ShingleLayer 1: None Detected

Sample was inhomogenous, subsamples of each component were analyzed separately.

CELLULOSE FIBER15%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL70%

SYNTHETIC FIBER15%

Black, Bituminous/Fibrous PaperLayer 2: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER45%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

SYNTHETIC FIBER45%

Inside Fog Sig Bld03/21/17 S-2 (2)206988-002

Gray/Black, Bituminous ShingleLayer 1: None Detected

Sample was inhomogenous, subsamples of each component were analyzed separately.

CELLULOSE FIBER15%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL70%

SYNTHETIC FIBER15%

Black, Bituminous/Fibrous PaperLayer 2: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER45%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

SYNTHETIC FIBER45%

Basement03/21/17 S-3 (3)206988-003

White/Gray, Granular Wall PlasterLayer 1: None Detected NON FIBROUS MATERIAL100%

Basement03/21/17 S-4 (4)206988-004

White, Granular DebrisLayer 1: None Detected NON FIBROUS MATERIAL100%

1st Flr N Kitchen03/21/17 S-5 (5)206988-005

White, Powdery Wall PlasterLayer 1: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER4%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL96%

1st Flr S Kitchen03/21/17 S-6 (6)206988-006

White/Gray, Granular Wall PlasterLayer 1: None Detected ANIMAL HAIR2%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL98%

Reporting Limit: 1% Gravimetrically Reduced Reporting Limit: 0.01% PLM analysis is based on Visual Estimation and NESHAP recommends that any asbestos content less than 10 percent be verified by PLM Point Count or TEM Analysis. The EPA recommends that any vermiculite should be treated as Asbestos Containing Material (ACM). This report must not be reproduced except in full with the approval of the laboratory. The test results reported relate only to the samples submitted.

PLM Analysis

Cust. IDSample ID LocationCollected Asbestos Fibers Other Materials

EPA 600/R-93/116 & 600/M4-82-020Method:

1st Flr S Kitchen03/21/17 S-7 (7)206988-007

Gray/Olive, Org.Bound/Brittle Sheet FlooringLayer 1: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER10%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL80%

SYNTHETIC FIBER10%

1st Flr Dining Rm03/21/17 S-8 (8)206988-008

Gray, Granular Ceiling PlasterLayer 1: None Detected ANIMAL HAIR3%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL97%

2nd Flr NE Bedroom03/21/17 S-9 (9)206988-009

Gray, Granular Wall PlasterLayer 1: None Detected ANIMAL HAIR3%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL97%

2nd Flr SW Bedroom03/21/17 S-10 (10)206988-010

Green/Gray, Granular Wall PlasterLayer 1: None Detected ANIMAL HAIR2%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL98%

2nd Flr Bathroom03/21/17 S-11 (11)206988-011

Tan, Org.Bound/Fibrous Sheet FlooringLayer 1: None Detected

Sample was inhomogenous, subsamples of each component were analyzed separately.

CELLULOSE FIBER20%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL65%

SYNTHETIC FIBER15%

Attic03/21/17 S-12 (12)206988-012

Tan, Fibrous PanelLayer 1: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER90%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

Lantern03/21/17 S-13 (13)206988-013

Black, Bituminous CaulkingLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL95%CHRYSOTILE5%

Light Tower03/21/17 S-14 (14)206988-014

Gray, Hard SidingLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL85%CHRYSOTILE15%

Ext Roof03/21/17 S-1 (15)206988-015

Red/Black, Bituminous Roof ShingleLayer 1: None Detected

Sample was inhomogenous, subsamples of each component were analyzed separately.

CELLULOSE FIBER15%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL70%

SYNTHETIC FIBER15%

Ext W Addition03/21/17 S-2 (16)206988-016

Gray, Hard SidingLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL85%CHRYSOTILE15%

W Addition03/21/17 S-3 (17)206988-017

White, Fibrous Ceiling TileLayer 1: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER90%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

Reporting Limit: 1% Gravimetrically Reduced Reporting Limit: 0.01% PLM analysis is based on Visual Estimation and NESHAP recommends that any asbestos content less than 10 percent be verified by PLM Point Count or TEM Analysis. The EPA recommends that any vermiculite should be treated as Asbestos Containing Material (ACM). This report must not be reproduced except in full with the approval of the laboratory. The test

EPA 600/R-93/116 & 600/M4-82-020Method:

W Addition03/21/17 S-4 (18)206988-018

Beige, Organically Bound Floor TileLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL98%CHRYSOTILE2%

Black, Bituminous MasticLayer 2: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL95%CHRYSOTILE5%

W Addition03/21/17 S-5 (19)206988-019

Red, Organically Bound Floor TileLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL96%CHRYSOTILE4%

Black, Bituminous MasticLayer 2: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL95%CHRYSOTILE5%

Attic Ceiling03/21/17 S-6 (20)206988-020

White, Fibrous InsulationLayer 1: None Detected MINERAL/GLASS WOOL90%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

1st Flr03/21/17 S-7 (21)206988-021

Gray, Granular Wall PlasterLayer 1: None Detected ANIMAL HAIR2%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL98%

Basement03/21/17 S-8 (22)206988-022

White/Gray, Fibrous Pipe InsulationLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL65%AMOSITE30%

CHRYSOTILE5%

Basement03/21/17 S-9 (23)206988-023

Gray, Fibrous Pipe InsulationLayer 1: CELLULOSE FIBER45%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

SYNTHETIC FIBER20%

CHRYSOTILE25%

Basement03/21/17 S-1 (24)206988-024

Gray, Fibrous Pipe WrapLayer 1: None Detected NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

SYNTHETIC FIBER90%

Basement03/21/17 S-2 (25)206988-025

Yellow, Fibrous Pipe InsulationLayer 1: None Detected MINERAL/GLASS WOOL90%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

White, Fibrous CoverLayer 2: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER90%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

Basement03/21/17 S-3 (26)206988-026

White, Fibrous Ceiling TileLayer 1: None Detected CELLULOSE FIBER90%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

Reporting Limit: 1% Gravimetrically Reduced Reporting Limit: 0.01% PLM analysis is based on Visual Estimation and NESHAP recommends that any asbestos content less than 10 percent be verified by PLM Point Count or TEM Analysis. The EPA recommends that any vermiculite should be treated as Asbestos Containing Material (ACM). This report must not be reproduced except in full with the approval of the laboratory. The test

EPA 600/R-93/116 & 600/M4-82-020Method:

1st Flr03/21/17 S-4 (27)206988-027

Gray, Granular Wall PlasterLayer 1: None Detected ANIMAL HAIR2%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL98%

1st Flr SW Bedroom03/21/17 S-5 (28)206988-028

Beige, Org.Bound/Fibrous Vinyl Sheet FlrngLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL55%

SYNTHETIC FIBER25%

CHRYSOTILE20%

Brown, Brittle/Soft MasticLayer 2: None Detected NON FIBROUS MATERIAL100%

1st Flr Above Bathroom03/21/17 S-6 (29)206988-029

Gray/Silver, Granular/Soft InsulationLayer 1: None Detected NON FIBROUS MATERIAL10%

VERMICULITE90%

2nd Flr Stair Tower Hall03/21/17 S-7 (30)206988-030

Beige, Organically Bound Floor TileLayer 1: NON FIBROUS MATERIAL96%CHRYSOTILE4%

Black, Bituminous MasticLayer 2: None Detected NON FIBROUS MATERIAL100%

Tower Upper Level03/21/17 S-8 (31)206988-031

Red, Org.Bound/Fibrous LinoleumLayer 1: None Detected

Sample was inhomogenous, subsamples of each component were analyzed separately.

CELLULOSE FIBER20%

NON FIBROUS MATERIAL55%

SYNTHETIC FIBER25%

Data Management Reviewed By: Charles Lynch

Total layers analyzed on order: 38 206988-03/29/17 02:33 PM

EPA Regulatory Limit: 1%

Analyst Elsamani Abdelfadiel

Reporting Limit: 1% Gravimetrically Reduced Reporting Limit: 0.01% PLM analysis is based on Visual Estimation and NESHAP recommends that any asbestos content less than 10 percent be verified by PLM Point Count or TEM Analysis. The EPA recommends that any vermiculite should be treated as Asbestos Containing Material (ACM). This report must not be reproduced except in full with the approval of the laboratory. The test

88 Empire Drive St Paul, MN 55103 Tel: 651-642-1150 Fax: 651-642-1239

RE: Analytical Services

Bloomington, MN 55437

June 01, 2015

Work Order Number: 1501941

Bach Pham

Client Manager II

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service bpham@legend-group.com

Enclosed are the results of analyses for samples received by the laboratory on 05/22/15. If you have any questions concerning this report, please feel free to contact me.

Results are not blank corrected unless noted within the report. Additionally, all QC results meet requirements unless noted.

All samples will be retained by Legend Technical Services, Inc., unless consumed in the analysis, at ambient conditions for 30 days from the date of this report and then discarded unless other arrangements are made. All samples were received in acceptable condition unless otherwise noted.

Prepared by, LEGEND TECHNICAL SERVICES, INC

Mr. Robert McGinn

5600 American Blvd West

Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.

Tel: 651-642-1150 Fax: 651-642-1239

Project:

Project Number:

Project Manager:

Analytical Services

Plum Island

Mr. Robert McGinnBloomington, MN 55437 06/01/15Date Reported:

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Work Order #: 15019415600 American Blvd West

Sample ID Laboratory ID Date Sampled

ANALYTICAL REPORT FOR SAMPLES

Date ReceivedMatrix

8 1501941-01 Paint 05/12/15 00:00 05/22/15 12:36

9 1501941-02 Paint 05/12/15 00:00 05/22/15 12:36

Shipping Container Information

Default Cooler Temperature (°C):

Received on ice: No Temperature blank was not present Received on ice pack: No

Received on melt water: No Ambient: Yes Acceptable (IH/ISO only): Yes

Custody seals: No

Case Narrative:

This report contains data that was produced by a subcontracted laboratory certified for the field of testing performed. The lead analysis was performed by TestAmerica Laboratories, Inc., Phoenix, AZ, AIHA-LAP, LLC, Accreditation # 154268.

Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced in its entirety.

Tel: 651-642-1150 Fax: 651-642-1239

Project:

Project Number:

Project Manager:

Analytical Services

Plum Island

Mr. Robert McGinnBloomington, MN 55437 06/01/15Date Reported:

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Work Order #: 15019415600 American Blvd West

6010B TestAmerica Phoenix

Result Analyte RL Units Dilution Batch Prepared Analyzed Method Notes MDL

8 (1501941-01) Paint Sampled: 05/12/15 00:00 Received: 05/22/15 12:36

64560 05/29/15 06/01/15 mg/KgPb 5000 D26010B_ELLAP Metals (ICP)

57000 120 1000

9 (1501941-02) Paint Sampled: 05/12/15 00:00 Received: 05/22/15 12:36

64560 05/29/15 06/01/15 mg/KgPb 140 D16010B_ELLAP Metals (ICP)

1200 3.3 10

Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced

Tel: 651-642-1150 Fax: 651-642-1239

Project:

Project Number:

Project Manager:

Analytical Services

Plum Island

Mr. Robert McGinnBloomington, MN 55437 06/01/15Date Reported:

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Work Order #: 15019415600 American Blvd West

Result Units Level

Spike

Result

Source

%REC

%REC

Limits %RPD

%RPD

Limit Notes Analyte

6010B - Quality Control TestAmerica Phoenix

RL MDL

Batch 64560 - 3050B LCS (LCS 550-64560/3) Prepared: 05/29/15 Analyzed: 06/01/15

Pb mg/Kg 6.61 80-1201006.59 <4.84.8 0.11

LCSD (LCSD 550-64560/) Prepared: 05/29/15 Analyzed: 06/01/15

Pb mg/Kg 6.72 80-12084 165.62 <4.94.9 0.11 20

MB (MB 550-64560/1-) Prepared: 05/29/15 Analyzed: 06/01/15

Pb mg/Kg -ND <4.94.9 0.12

Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced

Tel: 651-642-1150 Fax: 651-642-1239

Project:

Project Number:

Project Manager:

Analytical Services

Plum Island

Mr. Robert McGinnBloomington, MN 55437 06/01/15Date Reported:

U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Work Order #: 15019415600 American Blvd West

Notes and Definitions D2 Sample required dilution due to high concentration of analyte.

D1 Sample required dilution due to matrix.

Sample results reported on a dry weight basis

Relative Percent DifferenceRPD dry

Less than value listed<

Not applicable. The %RPD is not calculated from values less than the reporting limit.NA

MDL Method Detection Limit

RL Reporting Limit

LCS

MS

Laboratory Control Spike = Blank Spike (BS) = Laboratory Fortified Blank (LFB)

Matrix Spike = Laboratory Fortified Matrix (LFM)

Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced

Tel: 651-642-1150 Fax: 651-642-1239

Legend Technical Services, Inc. The results in this report apply to the samples analyzed in accordance with the chain of custody document. This analytical report must be reproduced