Attachment L-6 NASA FAR Supplement (NFS) Companion Guide (CG) 1872 ACQUISITION OF INVESTIGATIONS.pdf
PDF 321 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- 80LARC27R0003
About this file
This is the NASA Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement (NFS) Companion Guide for the Acquisition of Investigations (NFS CG 1872), which prescribes policies and procedures for acquiring flight investigations for science, exploration, or technology space flight missions.
The guide establishes a Flight Investigation Acquisition System based on Announcements of Opportunity (AO), recognized as a form of full and open competition and Broad Agency Announcement (BAA). The system is applicable when NASA has general goals that can be furthered through novel experimental approaches and benefits from choosing among competing objectives and methodologies proposed by investigators. It is not applicable when requirements can be pre-defined in a Statement of Work, when close ongoing Agency participation is required (suitable for Cooperative Agreement Notices), when investigations are modest in size on a best-efforts basis (suitable for NASA Research Announcements), or when programs are complex and costly enough to require directed assignment to a NASA Center. The acquisition process comprises three major phases: Announcement of Opportunity, Evaluation of Proposals, and Recommendation, Selection, and Debriefing. Standard proposal submission periods are at least 90 days after AO release, with a minimum 30-day advance community announcement. The Principal Investigator on selected proposals receives responsibility and authority for investigation success through a contract, which is the preferred instrument for large investments. Evaluation uses three core criteria addressing intrinsic science/technology merit, implementation merit and feasibility, and technical/management/cost (TMC) feasibility, with assessment conducted by independent peer review panels, categorization performed by government employees at headquarters level, and validation by a Steering Committee to ensure process integrity and compliance with regulations. The system incorporates strict ethics requirements, conflict-of-interest reviews, and confidentiality protections applicable to all participants, including government employees, non-government evaluators, and NASA Center investigators proposing under AO competitions.
View the file
Other files
Show all 12
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
NASA Federal Acquisition Regulation Supplement (NFS) Companion Guide (CG)
NFS CG 1872
ACQUISITION OF INVESTIGATIONS
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1872.000 Scope.
1872.001 Definitions.
1872.1 THE FLIGHT INVESTIGATION ACQUISITION SYSTEM
1872.11 General.
1872.12 Key features of the system.
1872.13 Management authorities and responsibilities.
1872.14 Procurement integrity and conflicts of interest.
1872.15 Organizational conflicts of interest.
1872.16 Confidentiality of proposal information and trade secrets.
1872.2 APPLICABILITY
1872.21 General.
1872.22 Criteria for determining applicability.
1872.23 Approval.
1872.3 THE ANNOUNCEMENT OF OPPORTUNITY
1872.31 General.
1872.32 Preparatory effort.
1872.33 Responsibilities.
1872.34 Proposal opportunity period.
1872.35 Guidelines for the Announcement of Opportunity.
1872.36 Proposals submitted by NASA investigators.
1872.4 EVALUATION OF PROPOSALS
1872.41 General.
1872.42 Criteria and Factors.
1872.43 Assessment.
1872.44 Categorization.
1872.45 Validation.
1872.46 Accommodation.
1872.47 Variations in Validation and Accommodation.
1872.48 Two-Step acquisitions.
1872.5 RECOMMENDATION, SELECTION, AND DEBRIEFING
1872.51 General.
1872.52 Recommendation.
1872.53 Selection.
1872.54 Award, notification of proposers, and debriefing.
bookmark://SubPart1872_1/ bookmark://SubPart1872_2/ bookmark://SubPart1872_3/ bookmark://SubPart1872_4/ bookmark://SubPart1872_5/
NFS CG 1872
ACUISITION OF INVESTIGATIONS
1872.000 Scope of Part.
This part prescribes policies and procedures for the acquisition of flight investigations.
1872.001 Definitions.
“An investigation,” means a goal-driven effort to obtain new scientific or technical knowledge that includes both acquiring and analyzing data and designing, developing or adapting, deploying, and operating flight instrumentation and necessary platform flight systems.
“Implementation merit and feasibility” means the capacity of a proposed investigation implementation, if successfully deployed and operated, to achieve its planned scientific or technical objectives.
Subpart 1872.1—The Flight Investigation Acquisition System
1872.11 General.
The investigation acquisition system depends on the participation of investigators in the definition and selection of investigations that contribute most effectively to the advancement of NASA's scientific and technological objectives. It is a system separate from the general Federal acquisition process for goods and services but requires similar management and discipline to assure compliance with statutory requirements and considerations of equity and quality. Its primary application is the acquisition of science, exploration, or technology space flight investigations via complete flight instrumentation and, where required, platform flight systems.
1872.12 Key features of the system.
(a) Use of the system commences with the determination by the originating Mission Directorate Associate Administrator (MDAA) that the acquisition process is appropriate for a program (but see NFS CG1872.22). The Announcement of Opportunity (AO) is recognized as a type of full and open competition (10 U.S.C. 3012). The AO is a form of Broad Agency Announcement (BAA) (see FAR 35.102 for general BAA requirements) and supports an open, fair and transparent competitive evaluation and selection process that is based on review of proposals by peer scientists or other appropriate technical experts applying their communities’ standards of merit. An AO does not specify the investigations to be proposed but solicits investigator ideas that can contribute to broad, publicly documented objectives. A formal competitive evaluation process is utilized to determine which submitted proposal(s) must be selected. Evaluations for merit and feasibility are conducted by peer experts in the fields represented in the proposals. Care is taken to avoid personal and organizational conflicts of interest, both actual and perceived. Evaluators are chosen by NASA and may be from NASA, other Government agencies, universities, or the commercial sector, or other experts. In addition to the evaluation for intrinsic merit and implementation merit and feasibility, aspects of engineering, cost, schedule, management, and risk are reviewed by specialists in those areas. The evaluation results are combined with considerations of relevance and affordability and other programmatic factors to determine investigation(s) to be selected.
(b) The AO acquisition system incorporates the following key elements (“phases”) and component sub-elements (“processes”):
(1) The Announcement of Opportunity (see NFS CG1872.3)
(2) Evaluation of Proposals (see NFS CG1872.4; processes defined in NFS
CG1872.41)
(3) Recommendation, Selection, and Debriefing (see NFS CG1872.5; processes defined in NFS CG 1872.51).
(c) Some AO acquisitions are conducted using a two-step system, where a subset of submitted proposals are selected through the processes described in NFS CG1872.48(a).
1872.13 Management authorities and responsibilities.
(a) For simplicity, this policy assumes that an acquisition is sponsored by a division within a directorate that is responsible for its execution. The policy and its phases and processes can be mapped onto other organizational structures as needed. The authorities and responsibilities for the major phases and their component processes emanate from the MDAA and are exercised as follows:
(1) The MDAA retains the authority and responsibility for final approval of the AO and its release as well as for proposal evaluation and resulting selection(s).
(2) The sponsoring division of a solicitation is responsible for development of the AO (see NFS CG1872.3), management and oversight of the assessment (see NFS CG 1872.43) and Accommodation (see NFS CG 1872.46) processes of the Evaluation phase as well as the recommendation (see NFS CG 1872.5), and award, notification of proposers, and debriefing (see NFS CG 1872.54) processes of the Recommendation, Selection, and Debriefing phase. During AO preparation, the division is responsible for adapting (if necessary) the standard evaluation criteria (see NFS CG 1872.42) and development of any optional specialty criteria required for the acquisition. Examples of specialty criterion would be an additional criterion for evaluating proposed technology demonstrations or student investigations. The division designates a Division Program Acquisition Lead (AL) to carry out these functions.
(3) The management and oversight of the categorization (see NFS CG 1872.44) and validation (see NFS CG 1872.45) processes of the evaluation phase, and of the selection process (see NFS CG 1872.53) of the recommendation and selection phase, are the responsibility of a senior directorate-level official appointed by the MDAA as Directorate AL. The Directorate designates a Technical, Management, and Cost (TMC) Acquisition Manager (TAM) to oversee the TMC assessments, including development of the TMC feasibility evaluation reports and to represent their results during subsequent acquisition phases. During the acquisition process, the TAM works closely with the Division Program AL.
(b) The MDAA, or other Selection Official if designated by the MDAA, selects the proposal(s) that is/are to be funded for execution.
(c) The Principal Investigator (PI) on each selected proposal is assigned responsibility and authority for success of the investigation through a contract between NASA and his or her institution. A contract is the preferred instrument for an AO award because the Agency’s investment in a flight investigation is large and only one contract provides sufficient enforcement and insight mechanisms to ensure that this investment is well managed. However, for awards to a NASA Center or other Government entities, other appropriate instruments are used. Participation by foreign investigators, or by U.S. investigators in a foreign program, is defined and governed on a no-exchange of funds basis by a formal international Space Act Agreement between NASA and the foreign sponsoring governmental agency or responsible entity (per NPD 1360.2).
(d) The MDAA may delegate Program Management responsibility for overseeing execution of the selected investigation(s) to a Program Office.
1872.14 Procurement integrity and conflicts of interest.
(a) Every participant in the AO process must be individually responsible for following applicable standards of conduct. Participants in the AO process are engaged in a Federal acquisition process, which is subject to overarching statutes and regulations, including the Federal Acquisition Regulation (FAR), which states, “Government business must be conducted in a manner above reproach, except as authorized by statute or regulation, with complete impartiality and with preferential treatment for none.” (see FAR 3.101-1) Government employees and nonemployees involved in the AO process are all obligated to conduct themselves in accordance with applicable ethical standards.
(1) Government employees, including Inter-governmental Personnel Act (IPA) appointees, are subject to and deemed to know their obligations under all applicable statutes and regulations governing the conduct of their official responsibilities. Participants’ attention is directed, in particular, to the following statutes and regulations that are regularly applied in NASA acquisition matters:
(A) 18 U.S.C Section 208, which prohibits participation in a particular matter, such as an AO acquisition, while holding a personal financial interest in a party involved in the acquisition;
(B) The Standards of Ethical Conduct for Employees of the Executive Branch, 5 C.F.R. part 2635 (note, in particular, those provisions defining parties with whom an employee has a covered relationship);
(C) FAR 3.101, Improper Business Practices and Personal Conflicts of Interest, and 1803.101; and
(D) The Procurement Integrity Act, 41 U.S.C. Chapter 21, as applicable.
(2) Non-government employee participants in the AO process are subject to—
(A) Applicable portions of FAR 3.101, Improper Business Practices and Personal Conflicts of Interest and corresponding provisions of NFS 1803.1;
(B) Applicable provisions of Procurement Integrity Act, 41 U.S.C.
Section 2102 et seq. (Prohibitions on disclosing and obtaining procurement information);
(C) NASA Agency and Mission Directorate policies governing actual and apparent conflicts of interest, to the extent those policies are incorporated into contracts, as well as all instructions in the NASA Solicitation and Proposal Integrated Review and Evaluation System (NSPIRES); and
(D) Clause(s) of any contract or agreement, between the government and the Participant or the Participant’s employer, under which the participant supports AO processes, and which prohibits, restricts, or places conditions upon participation in any government acquisition.
(b) Participants are deemed to have knowledge of the parties (companies, universities, non-profit organizations, and governmental organizations) proposing to NASA under the AO acquisition. The Division Program AL is responsible for compilation of a list of parties proposing under an AO as soon as possible after proposals are submitted and must distribute the list to AO acquisition process participants before the proposal evaluation (or the individual participant’s evaluation activity) begins. This list must include proposing organizations, as well as every party named in a proposal as a co-proposing organization or funded participant in the proposed investigation.
(c) Each AO acquisition process participant must review the list of parties involved in the acquisition and identify all parties with whom the participant has an interest or covered relationship. The participant must report all such interests and relationships to the Directorate or Division Program AL and Office of the General Counsel (OGC) before commencing any participation in the acquisition, including attendance at any meeting pertaining to the acquisition. The Directorate or Division Program AL must require acquisition meeting attendees to sign in on a meeting attendance sheet, which will remind the attendees of their obligation to ensure that any report of a conflicting interest or relationship be resolved with the assistance of agency counsel prior to the meeting. Any government employee who has filed either an OGE Form 278 or OGE 450 must be aware that the assets and positions reported there may not include all interests that could give rise to a conflict, that filing a disclosure report does not, by itself, resolve a conflict, and that resolution of a conflict reported for a prior acquisition does not resolve the conflict for the present and subsequent acquisitions.
1872.15 Organizational conflicts of interest.
Organizational conflicts of interest can arise from a variety of circumstances in which a party competing in a government acquisition has a conflicting role potentially resulting in that party obtaining an unfair competitive advantage. Circumstances creating an actual or apparent organizational conflict of interest include, but are not limited to, an organization assisting or advising a government agency in its acquisition or a competing party, or having some role in defining Government requirements. Any AO process participant who becomes aware that a competing organization: 1) supports the government in conducting the acquisition; 2) has access to nonpublic information about the AO acquisition; 3) contributes to preparation of the AO solicitation; 4) or plays any role in the AO process affording that organization a competitive advantage; 5) must notify the Division Program AL and the OGC of these circumstances. A government employee whose organizational unit (at NASA, the organizational unit is the Center) is performing a role related to an AO (either in support of the government administration of the AO or as a member of a team competing under the AO) must seek instruction from the Division Program AL and the OGC before engaging as a participant in the AO.
1872.16 Confidentiality of proposal information and trade secrets.
(a) Participants in the AO process must properly handle and maintain the confidentiality of proposal information, trade secrets and source selection information (as defined by FAR section 2.101) obtained through the AO process. The following statutes, regulations and standards apply to all participants in the AO process:
(1) The Procurement Integrity Act, 41 U.S.C. 2102 et seq.;
(2) FAR section 3.104-4 (Disclosure, protection and marking contractor bid or proposal information and source selection information); and
(3) All instructions for proposal handling and non-disclosure agreements in
NSPIRES.
(b) In addition to the statutes and regulations listed in paragraph (a) of this section, Government employees are subject to the Trade Secrets Act, 18 U.S.C. 1905, which imposes criminal sanctions for mishandling of trade secrets.
(c) Non-NASA employees are subject to clause(s) of any contract or agreement between the government and the participant or the participant’s employer, under which the participant supports AO processes, and which prohibits, restricts, or places conditions upon receipt, and handling and transfer of data.
(d) Participants must immediately consult the Division Program AL or Directorate AL when they become aware of any mishandling of proposal information, trade secrets or source selection information. If needed, participants must, in consultation with the Division Program AL or Directorate AL, obtain advice from the OGC concerning the handling of proposal information, trade secrets and source selection information.
1872.2—Applicability
1872.21 General.
The AO system used for acquisition of science, technology, or exploration flight investigations is different and separate from the Agency procedures for acquisitions for prior known requirements. The decision to use the AO acquisition system is based on a determination that it is the most appropriate to meet program needs.
1872.22 Criteria for determining applicability.
The AO system can be used when conditions in (a) are met and conditions in (b) are not met.
(a) A general distinction between normal acquisitions for goods or services and AO investigation acquisitions is that AO proposers define not only how they will accomplish investigation objectives but also the objectives themselves within the framework of broader articulated NASA goals. Unlike a proposal responding to a Request for Proposals, an AO proposal effectively defines a Statement of Work in addition to the approach (and cost) for how the proposer plans to carry it out. All of the following conditions must exist for the AO acquisition system to be applicable:
(1) NASA has a general goal that can be furthered through novel experimental approaches. To develop such approaches, NASA wishes to draw upon the broadest possible reservoir of ideas;
(2) It benefits the Agency to be able to choose from among competing objectives advancing the general goals and their approach for doing so;
(3) Full responsibility and broad authorities for investigation success will be vested in the Principal Investigator(s) of selected proposal(s); and
(4) Execution of the selected investigation(s) will be subject to standard flight program management policies and procedures detailed in NPR 7120.5.
(b) The investigations acquisition process must not be used when any of the following characteristics are present:
(1) The requiring office can characterize a requirement sufficiently to define in advance a common statement of work against which all proposals will be evaluated. This calls for a Request for Proposals (RFP);
(2) The investigation is conducted on collaborative basis that requires close and ongoing Agency participation in tactical management and decision-making. A proposer may also offer a partnership contribution to the joint effort. In this case, a Cooperative Agreement Notice would be appropriate;
(3) The investigation is of modest size and is to be conducted on a best-efforts basis and deliverables are limited to progress reporting and, if applicable, publication of final results. In this case a NASA Research Announcement (NRA) solicitation, usually but not always resulting in a grant (a financial assistance agreement), would be more suitable. Execution of such investigations may be subject to NPR 7120.8; or
(4) The program is so complex, costly, or risky, as to require specialized integration or coordination extending over a lengthy period where NASA’s institutional capabilities may be required for successful execution. Such investigations may be directed to one of NASA’s Centers. Even in such cases, however, it may be desirable for the reasons in paragraph (a) above to compete subordinate investigation elements (such as instrumentation) via one or more AOs.
(c) Typical examples where the use of AOs is most applicable are solicitation of complete small- and intermediate-size investigations (larger and more costly than suborbital-class research but smaller and less expensive than the largest and most expensive strategic flight investigations), of instrument investigations on larger investigations whose overall management is assigned to a NASA Center, or of space flight instrument investigations contributed to a non- NASA mission.
1872.23 Approval.
Generally, the MDAA determines whether or not to use the AO acquisition system. On the largest investigations, a decision whether to use the AO system may be made by the Agency Acquisition Strategy Process (NPD 1000.5), under the aegis of the NASA Associate Administrator or designee, based on Agency-level programmatic considerations.
1872.3—The Announcement of Opportunity
1872.31 General.
The AO provides a clear statement of the requirements for acceptable proposals (including proposers’ specification of objectives, technical approach to achieve these objectives, and management strategies and partnerships), as well as NASA’s method of proposal evaluation and the format and content of submitted proposals. The purpose of the AO is to obtain sufficient information from offerors to correctly and equitably assess the relevance, merit, cost, and likelihood of success (risk) of proposed investigations. The solicitation must be conducted in such a way as to ensure that all potentially capable and interested offerors are alerted to the AO’s release enough in advance and are provided with enough background information to enable them to submit proposals that are fully compliant with AO requirements and can be accurately evaluated.
1872.32 Preparatory effort.
(a) The originating directorate incorporates in AO planning and development the best available information on opportunities for advancement in the chosen area, including, where appropriate, results from preparatory studies and exploratory analyses.
(b) The Directorate will—
(1) Forecast the approximate time frame for AO release on an appropriate
NASA web site;
(2) Synopsize the AO in the Governmentwide point of entry (GPE) prior to release;
(3) Concurrent with AO release, collect relevant technical and other information necessary for proposal preparation and post this information on the appropriate AO web site (i.e., AO solicitation library);
(4) Define AO provisions, including the evaluation process for proposals, that express a clear exposition of the acquisition’s unique objectives, constraints, and requirements;
and
(5) Post on the web an Evaluation Plan, specific to the AO, preferably concurrent with the AO release, but certainly well before receipt of proposals. This plan must detail the steps in the overall process, including how the evaluations are conducted and their sequence, procedures for avoiding conflicts of interest, and any special features of the evaluation process.
(c) In some cases, the best source of technical support needed to develop key elements of an AO resides at a NASA Center whose personnel will participate as proposer(s) to the AO. It is essential, out of concern for possible impairment of judgment or its appearance, to isolate these personnel and their efforts from individuals at their Center involved in any proposal development activity for the AO in question. In this case, special steps must be taken to ensure process integrity.
(1) At a NASA Center, the line management of AO support personnel must take responsibility for training and implementing firewall isolation of the individuals involved from people at that Center with proposal participation. The Directorate AL will work with the Division Program AL and Center management to put the necessary documentation in place.
Except for statutory financial conflicts of interest with non-Governmental participants in proposals (for which Center Chief Counsel must be consulted), requirements for avoiding possible bias or impairment of judgment flow from the Directorate’s widely recognized research community standards.
(2) At the Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL), a formal waiver for an organizational conflict of interest is also required and must be approved by the NASA headquarters Office of Procurement (OP). this will involve the Directorate and Division, the JPL NASA Office of JPL Management Office (NOJMO), and the OGC.
(d) Additional means of publicizing the AO may also be used, such as press releases, newsletters, and announcements at professional meetings, as appropriate, consistent with the policies of equal treatment and maximizing the pool of qualified potential proposers.
1872.33 Responsibilities.
(a) The overall responsibility for issuing AOs resides with the MDAA. The cognizant MDAA may delegate, with coordination with the OP, responsibility for development of an AO to a Program Office (see NFS CG 1872.32(c)(1)).
(b) The originating Directorate is responsible for the content of the AO and its coordination with other concerned Headquarters offices and where Headquarters has retained the task of AO development, with the related Program Office. At Headquarters, development of the AO and subsequent acquisition steps are generally performed by the Division Program AL and TAM, under the oversight of the Directorate AL (see NFS CG 1872.14 (a)(2) and (3)). All personnel involved in the evaluation of proposals are responsible for familiarizing themselves and complying with part 1872 and other applicable regulations, including those addressing ethics and procurement integrity standards (see NFS CG 1872.15, 16, and 17). To this end, they are expected to seek advice and guidance as needed from the OP, OGC, and Office of International and Interagency Relations (OIIR).
(c) The AO is released, with the concurrence of the OP, the OGC, and the Office of Interagency and International Relations, over the signature of the originating MDAA.
1872.34 Proposal opportunity period.
(a) It is good practice to issue a draft AO in advance of the final AO, with a subsequent period for comments and questions, nominally 30 days. If a draft AO has not been released, at a minimum the key elements of a pending AO must be described in a community announcement to the potential proposer community via the NSPIRES and the Governmentwide point of entry (GPE) no less than 30 days before the release of a final AO. (See FAR 5.201)
(b) Responses to questions about a draft AO judged to be material to preparation of a responsive proposal will be publicly promulgated via posting by the Division Program AL as soon as possible on the AO web site. The goal is to ensure that the same AO clarifications are made available simultaneously to all proposers.
(c) The standard time allocated for proposal submission after release of the final AO is at least 90 days. Other periods may be used with approval of the Directorate AL.
(d) In general, an AO is issued with a firm and definite proposal submission due date.
Omnibus AOs are issued without specific proposal opportunities; specific proposal opportunities are added to omnibus AOs by amendment, and each specific proposal opportunity must have a firm and definite proposal submission date. However, an AO may be amended with late clarifications or changes, or to extend the due date to ensure adequate time for development of quality proposals, for whatever reason. Proposers must be promptly informed of departures from provisions in a released AO by the same means as its release NSPIRES.
1872.35 Guidelines for the announcement of opportunity.
(a) An AO must be tailored to the particular needs of the contemplated investigations and be complete in itself. To assist AO development and promote consistency between solicitations, the baseline required format and minimum necessary contents of the AO may be defined in a template Standard AO. Tailoring may include addition of evaluation Criteria, deletion or modification of standard evaluation Factors, or incorporation of additional factors specific to program requirements (see NFS CG 1872.42(a)).
(b) An AO must incorporate proposal instructions and provisions necessary to address any AO-unique aspects.
(c) Requirements and guidelines for foreign participation in AO-solicited programs must be clearly articulated in the AO and be consistent with NPD 1360.2 and NPD 2190.1. Foreign proposals or U.S. proposals with foreign participation must be treated in accordance with NFS 1835.016-70.
(d) Proposals must be submitted electronically via NSPIRES.
(e) Noncompliant (including late) proposals may be declined without review.
1872.36 Proposals submitted by NASA investigators.
(a) NASA accepts and evaluates proposals submitted by NASA Centers in response to an AO. A NASA investigator may team with one or more non-Government co-investigators.
(1) The competitive AO process serves as a means of selecting proposals that offer the best value for the government in accordance with the evaluation factors in the AO. During the proposal preparation phase, non-government sources can assemble their research teams and select hardware fabricators and service providers without being subject to procurement rules requiring full and open competition. Although NASA Centers have the same focus of putting together a winning team, they are bound by the competition requirements of the Competition in Contracting Act (CICA) and Government ethics standards.
(2) Where a non-government partner/team member is identified in a NASA Center’s proposal to have substantial involvement in conducting the investigation, but is not also providing hardware, equipment or instrumentation, selection of the proposal for funding under the AO satisfies the regulatory competition requirements for any award(s) to the participating non-government partner/team member(s) named in the proposal. The Center may directly award a contract to such entity without additional competition or approval of a Justification of Other than Full and Open Competition (JOFOC). The AO constitutes a competition that encompasses proposals submitted by all team members of every offeror including NASA Centers.
(3) Acquisition by a NASA Center of supplies or services that do not constitute research, i.e., equipment, materials, software, facilities, or non-research services incidental to the proposed investigation, must be treated differently. Examples of non-research services include program/project management assistance, supplies, and/or administrative support services.
Procurement requirements for competition under an AO are not satisfied by the AO competition itself for acquisition of non-research supplies and services. Such items may be acquired under existing contract vehicles. Otherwise, they must be acquired through a newly competed contract or acquired non-competitively with support of a JOFOC.
(b) In addition to complying with proposal preparation instructions contained in the AO, proposals submitted by NASA Centers must address the following matters:
(1) Co-investigators, Instrument Offerors, and Spacecraft Offerors.
(A) The proposal must describe the process that was used for selecting proposed team members, which includes both spacecraft and instrument providers. While a formal solicitation is not required, the process should include the following aspects: notice of the opportunity to participate to potential sources, submissions from and/or discussions with potential sources, and objective criteria for selecting team members among interested sources.
(B) The proposal must also include a representation that NASA investigators and any other Government employees have examined their financial interests and have determined that no personal conflict of interest exists.
(2) Supplies and support services.
(A) The proposal must indicate that the supplies or support services are available under an existing Government contract; or
(B) The proposal must state that the supplies or support services will be acquired under a full and open competition; or
(C) The proposal must explain the basis of a justification for acquiring the supplies or support services noncompetitively (FAR 6.1 and NFS 1806.1).
(c) A selection decision approving the non-Government research team members as selected co-investigators satisfies legal and regulatory requirements without other competition or justification.
1872.4—Evaluation of Proposals
1872.41 General.
(a) The Evaluation phase comprises a series of processes that begin with the expert review of each proposal against standard criteria and ends before formulation of specific recommendations for selection by the Selection Official. These processes, founded on the use of formal evaluation criteria and factors, constitute a series of distinct steps to consolidate and validate each proposal’s characteristics that determine eligibility for selection. These Criteria and Factors and the processes that must be conducted in the evaluation of proposals received in response to any AO (Assessment, Categorization, Validation, and, only if required, Accommodation), are as follows:
(1) Criteria and factors. (see NFS CG 1872.42) The Standard AO template provides a generally used set of three major evaluation criteria, each with its own set of subordinate Factors that are used by evaluation panels as the rubric for their reviews. These can be adjusted in an AO to suit the needs of its program goals.
(2) Assessment. (see NFS CG 1872.43) The purpose of assessment is to determine the quality, relevance, and select ability of a proposed investigation in terms of science, exploration, or technology investigation intrinsic merit, implementation merit and feasibility, and TMC feasibility. The TMC feasibility includes a cost risk assessment that incorporates an analysis of cost threats such as schedule and performance risk.
(3) Categorization. (NFS CG 1872.44) The purpose of categorization is to assign to each proposed investigation, based on the assessment results, an integrated appraisal of its overall select ability;
(4) Validation. (NFS CG 1872.45) The Validation phase reviews the end-to-end acquisition activity to this point from the AO through Categorization. The fundamental objective is to ensure that selection options that are presented to the Selection Official via the accommodation and recommendation phases have undergone a review that is expertly thorough, equitable, conflict-free, and defensible; and
(5) Accommodation. (see NFS CG 1872.46 and 1872.47) In some acquisitions, such as instrumentation for flight on a shared platform, system and operational constraints of various kinds (e.g. mass, power, location on the platform, pointing and viewing geometry, and thermal factors) may determine which instrument combinations are ultimately implementable, and therefore, selectable, for flight. Accommodation analysis thus may impact downstream integrated payload Recommendation decisions.
(b) The assessment, categorization, and validation processes must be accomplished in every investigation acquisition; the accommodation process must be executed where applicable.
An overriding principle is the separation of the inputs, processes and criteria, and outputs for each of the sequential steps from assessment through accommodation. Some latitude is afforded as long as this principle is maintained, and the method employed clearly ensures the traits listed in paragraph (a)(4) of this section.
(c) In general, several components of the Assessment process are conducted in parallel (see NFS CG 1872.43). Categorization follows when the assessment process is complete and must be completed before proceeding to validation.
(d) Although the purposes of the validation and accommodation processes are distinct, they can be implemented in various combinations to suit the acquisition’s needs. For example, acquisitions for multiple instrumentation investigations for a tightly constrained legacy platform could have two Accommodation stages. After Assessment or Categorization, an initial individual accommodation analysis can be performed for each favorably assessed instrument. This could be followed by a second more comprehensive integrated accommodation analysis during the later recommendation process (see NFS CG 1872.52) to identify implementable multi-instrument payload configurations. See NFS CG 1872.47 for additional information.
(e) Persons not having an official role in AO evaluation meetings, which often deal with confidential and proprietary proposer material, may attend only with the explicit approval of the Directorate AL, subject to provisions of NFS CG 1872.15 and NFS CG 1872.16. They are not permitted to speak unless invited to do so by the meeting chair.
1872.42 Criteria and Factors.
(a) Standards and adjustments.
(1) Each AO and its posted evaluation plan must describe the criteria and their subordinate factors that evaluators will apply in evaluating proposals. This information will be used by proposers to focus their proposals’ presentation of objectives and approaches. In most cases these criteria will be the set of core criteria and their standard factors. The three core criteria and their standard factors, are defined in (b)(1) through (b)(3) below; additional criteria may be added to these three per the AO’s particular needs (e.g., for student collaboration plan evaluation; see NFS CG 1872.35(a)). Alternatively, Factor C-3 may be deleted from solicitations for instrument-only investigations (i.e., where no platform is solicited);
(2) Criteria in the AO and evaluation plan may have deleted or modified Factors or additional Factors specific to the acquisition in question (see NFS CG 1872.35(a));
(3) The assessment factors that support each criterion must be explicitly provided in the AO and posted evaluation plan;
(4) The relative weighting of each Criterion must be stated in the AO if they are unequal; and
(5) Any adjustments to the criteria or factors after the release of the AO must be documented in a formal AO amendment and released via NSPIRES, generally with an extension of the due date for submitting proposals.
(b) Core criteria and standard factors.
(1) Intrinsic Science, Technology, or Exploration Merit (Evaluation Criterion A).
Factor A-1. Compelling nature and priority of the proposed investigation’s science, exploration, or technology goals and objectives Factor A-2. Programmatic value of the proposed investigation Factor A-3. Likelihood of science, exploration, or technology success Factor A-4. Science, exploration, or technology value of the threshold investigation
(2) Science or Technology Implementation Merit and Feasibility of the Investigation (Evaluation Criterion B).
Factor B-1. Merit of the instruments and investigation design for addressing the science, exploration, or technology goals and objectives Factor B-2. Probability of technical success Factor B-3. Merit of the data and/or sample analysis plan Factor B-4. Science, exploration, or technology resiliency Factor B-5. Probability of investigation team success
(3) Technical, Management, and Cost (TMC) Feasibility of the Investigation Implementation, Including Cost Risk (Evaluation Criterion C).
Factor C-1. Adequacy and robustness of the instrument implementation plan Factor C-2. Adequacy and robustness of the investigation design and plan for mission operations Factor C-3. Adequacy and robustness of the flight systems Factor C-4. Adequacy and robustness of the management approach and schedule, including the capability of the management team Factor C-5. Adequacy and robustness of the cost plan, including cost feasibility and cost risk
(c) Note that Factors B and C at NFS CG 1872.42(b)(2) and (b)(3) address proposed instrumentation but from different perspectives. In order to obtain a comprehensive evaluation against each of these Criteria, independent assessments are developed by reviewers with appropriate expertise in separate panels. The Division Program AL and the TAM will ensure that instrument weaknesses identified by either panel are shared with the other panels for consideration and also against the other panel’s Factors. Any inconsistencies between the reports of the two panels will be considered during the categorization process.
1872.43 Assessment.
(a) One or more panels of community experts free from personal and organization conflicts of interest, evaluate proposals against the criteria. Criteria A and B are evaluated by the same science, exploration, or technology peer review panel. Criterion C is evaluated by a TMC peer review panel. Panel members will act in the capacity of individuals. For each Factor in each criterion, the panels will develop assessment findings or state that there are none. Panel chairs will prepare for each proposal a report Form on findings for each Criterion that captures the major points made during its consideration of the Criteria Factors. The findings for each Factor are expressed in short narratives for identified Major Strengths, Minor Strengths, Major Weaknesses, and Minor Weaknesses. The chair will also poll the members individually on their ratings for each of the Criteria on a standard scale and record them on its Criterion’s Forms (Form A for Criterion A, Form B for Criterion B, and Form C for Criterion C). “Comments to the Proposer” and “Comments to NASA” may be added; the latter are not provided to the proposers.
(b) Use of any approach other than the one defined in (a) above must conform to the principles and constraints in sections NFS CG 1872.15 and NFS CG 1872.16 and requires consultation with the OGC and the OP and the approval of the MDAA.
(c) Products of the assessment process. At the conclusion of this phase, Forms A and B for each proposal are combined with the corresponding Forms C developed by the TMC panels, plus any additional Criterion Forms, into an integrated report for that proposal. The package of these reports for all proposals is the input for the next phase, Categorization.
1872.44 Categorization.
(a) Just as the assessment process distills the distinctive strengths and weaknesses of each proposal into the concise, critical representations in the Criterion Forms, the categorization process condenses the contents of these Forms into a summary of the select ability of each proposed investigation. In doing so, the categorization process continues to focus on the scientific and technical merits, implementation feasibility, management approach, cost realism, and comprehensive risk assessment of each proposal individually. The objective of the categorization process is to derive a portfolio of consolidated merit-risk characterizations that will be subjected during the recommendation and selection processes to additional programmatic criteria.
(b) The categorization process is a critical gateway to selection. A proposal that categorizes poorly has virtually no chance of selection; conversely, a proposal that emerges from this process with a category rating in the top range is considered highly eligible to be selected for implementation. The Agency will devote years and very substantial resources to achieving the investigation’s represented results and to overcoming any unforeseen technical or management problems. As a result, the Categorization process determining these ratings must be conducted by a Headquarters committee of government employees that combines appropriate scientific, technical, and project management expertise with breadth and experience. Only government employees may be appointed to the Categorization Committee. IPA personnel may also be appointed provided they are free of both actual or perceived bias and statutory restrictions as provided in NFS CG 1872.14 and NFS CG 1872.15. The OGC must be consulted in any areas of uncertainty.
(c) The authority to appoint the Categorization Committee is vested in the MDAA, who may delegate it to the Directorate AL (see NFS CG 1872.14(a)(3)). These appointments must be made well in advance of the committee’s meeting in order to ensure availability and adequate preparation time. One committee member must be appointed Chair by the MDAA or Directorate AL and must have the authority and responsibility of conducting the categorization review.
(d) The sponsoring Division Program AL (see NFS CG 1872.14(a)(2)) will brief the committee on the AO and Assessment phase and present the Assessment results for each proposal. The division program AL may be assisted by other division staff involved in the Assessment phase. The TAM must be present in the categorization meeting to answer any questions about the TMC reviews.
(e) In a situation where the number of proposal Forms A, B, and C (plus any other special Forms) to be categorized exceeds what members of a single committee can reasonably be expected to absorb and retain, the Categorization Committee can be divided into two or more panels to spread the effort among more staff members. In these cases, proposals must be gathered in the same panel to ensure that the competitive outcome between them is not affected by any inter-panel standards inconsistencies. In addition, the potential for inconsistent standards in separate Categorization panels can be further mitigated by crosschecking in the subsequent Validation phase and possible leveling action. In what follows, the Committee Chair must be understood as the Panel Chair if there is more than one panel of the Committee.
(f) The appointed members must be provided with the Criterion Forms, with a description of the solicitation and evaluation process to date, and with clear instructions about how the categorization process is to be conducted, no less than seven calendar days before their meeting. This must include a list of all participating institutions for review by members for potential conflicts of interest. It must be clearly understood that all materials provided are competition-sensitive and must be protected while in use and returned for disposition to the Directorate AL.
(g) Before the meeting begins, participants must ensure compliance with ethics requirements (see NFS CG 1872.15, NFS CG 1872.16, and NFS CG 1872.17);
provisions regarding observers in NFS CG 1872.41(e) also apply.
(h) The Categorization meeting must include—
(1) A briefing, usually by the Division Program AL, on the course of solicitation and evaluation, beginning with characteristics of the solicitation, through a survey of the proposals received, and continuing with the conduct of the assessment process and an overview of its results;
(2) A presentation of each proposal’s evaluation, given generally by the Division Program AL, followed by discussion moderated by the Committee Chair that results in a categorization (see NFS CG 1872.43(d)) via a poll of members. A consensus is not required, but if a tie, or even a very close vote, persists after adequate discussion and several polls, the Chair may defer the decision for a proposal to be revisited at the end of the meeting. If a deadlock tie persists after this reconsideration, the Chair may break the tie by assigning the Categorization;
and
(3) After the reviews for all proposal evaluations (or for all of the ones allocated to that panel if there is more than one panel) have been considered, the Chair will lead the panel in a crosscutting review of its proposals to ensure consistent standards have been applied. Any departure from equitable treatment must be corrected before adjournment of the Committee or panel.
(4) The report of the Categorization Committee Chair consists, at a minimum, of a table of the final categorizations for each of the proposals. When a strong majority is not achieved for a given categorization, the manner in which that categorization was assigned must be documented. It is good practice to include a brief categorization rationale for each proposal.
This must be limited to the most influential points raised during the discussions to include how the Committee balanced strong conflicting strengths and weaknesses. This rationale must not simply restate the documented assessment findings on the criterion forms.
(i) During this process, Categorization Committee members are not permitted access to any of the proposals. This is to eliminate any possibility of re-reviewing the proposals, which could be perceived as inequitable. In rare circumstances involving confusion or contradictions in Assessment findings for a proposal, the Chair can recess the Categorization Committee while the Division Program AL (only) consults the underlying proposal to resolve the issue for the Committee.
(j) If the Committee encounters a serious inconsistency in the assessment record, or other flaw that prevents a clear and supportable categorization from being assigned based on that record, the Committee Chair can guide the Committee in documenting the issue needing resolution and require the Division Program AL to reconvene the Criterion A/B panel or Criterion C panel to respond with a formal clarification that will enable the categorization to be completed by the Committee.
(k) A meritorious investigation is defined as one that has high overall intrinsic scientific, exploration, and/or technology merit and acceptable risk per the Criteria and objectives of the AO; categorizations are assigned according to the following definitions:
Category I – Well conceived, meritorious, and feasible investigations pertinent to the goals of the program and the AO's objectives and offered by a competent investigator from an institution capable of supplying the necessary support to ensure that any essential flight hardware or other support can be delivered on time and that data can be properly reduced, analyzed, interpreted, and published in a reasonable time. Investigations in Category I are recommended for acceptance and normally will be displaced only by other Category I investigations.
Category II – Well conceived, meritorious, and feasible investigations that are recommended for acceptance, but at a lower priority than Category I, whatever the reason.
Category III – Meritorious investigations that require further development. Category III investigations may be funded for further development and may be reconsidered at a later time for the same or other opportunities.
Category IV – Proposed investigations which are recommended for rejection for the particular opportunity under consideration, whatever the reason.
(l) Products of the Categorization process.
The record of the meeting, which is input to the validation and accommodation phases, consists of the following elements:
(1) Meeting sign-in sheet, with a list of participating institutions, serving as conflict of interest-free self-certification by participants;
(2) Table of categorizations for each investigation, including results of the final and preceding (if any) poll results;
(3) A brief narrative Categorization Rationale for each of the categorizations;
and
(4) Detailed minutes of the meeting, to be reviewed and approved by the Division Program AL and the Committee Chair.
(5) Categorization Report (see NFS CG 1872.44(h)(4))
1872.45 Validation.
(a) The Validation phase is a procedure review intended as an independent check on the quality, balance, and integrity of the evaluation process to this point, including its…
This is the start of the file's text. The full file is on GovTribe.
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .