8_DASPS-1667-21_TotalScoring_FinalRanking_07302021.pdf

This is a final scoring and ranking summary for a Construction Manager/General Contractor (CM/GC) services solicitation (DASPS-1667-21) issued for the Renovation of the North Valley Complex. The evaluation document presents proposal scores from four evaluators across nine competing contractors: Andersen Construction, Bremik Construction, Lease Crutcher Lewis LLC, Hoffman Construction Company, Balfour Beatty Construction LLC dba Howard S. Wright, JE Dunn Construction, Pence Construction, Perlo Construction, and Swinerton Builders. The evaluation process included two scoring components: Proposal and Interview (PI and CP) worth a combined base score, and an Interview component valued at up to 25 points. The final ranking identified Lease Crutcher Lewis LLC as the highest-ranked proposer with 107.45 total points, followed by Balfour Beatty Construction LLC in second place with 98.87 points, and Andersen Construction in third place with 90.43 points. The scoring summary was finalized on July 30, 2021.

The evaluation methodology employed four independent evaluators who assessed interview performance on a 25-point scale. Lease Crutcher Lewis LLC achieved the highest interview average score of 20.25 points, while Balfour Beatty Construction LLC scored 22.00 interview points. The proposal and interview scoring indicates that the selected contractor demonstrated superior qualifications in both written proposal quality and oral presentation capabilities relative to competing firms. The document does not contain pricing information, funding sources, or contract term details; however, the CM/GC delivery method typically involves a cost-plus or guaranteed maximum price arrangement developed during the preconstruction phase.