Enclosure3_Eval Criteria - ANL Furnace_v3.docx
DOCX document 54 KB Posted
- Attached to
- Custom R&D Industrial Furnace
- Solicitation number
- 7-S176-Q-00012-00
- Issued by
-
Department of Energy Office of Science
About this file
This file contains evaluation criteria for a Best Value solicitation for a custom R&D industrial furnace. The evaluation will utilize an adjectival scale for the Technical Proposal, which is weighted as more important than both the Price Proposal and Business Management Proposal, with the latter two evaluated on a pass/fail basis. Technical acceptability criteria require offerors to demonstrate compliance with all Statement of Work requirements, including performance specifications for a fuel-flexible furnace capable of testing natural gas and hydrogen blends from 0-100% H2 in both direct-fired and indirect-fired burner configurations. Mandatory documentation includes a completed Technical Proposal with supporting evidence addressing each SOW requirement, Country of Origin information per FAR 52.225-1 (Buy American-Supplies), delivery lead times and milestones (FOB Destination, Lemont, IL 60439), completed ANL-70B Representations and Certifications, and any proposed exceptions or deviations. Offers lacking adequate supporting documentation or failing to meet mandatory requirements will be deemed technically unacceptable.
The Argonne National Laboratory solicitation (7-S176-Q-00012-00) has been modified through multiple addendums, with the award decision to be made on Best Value among responsible, technically acceptable offerors. Offerors must submit all required proposal components including Technical, Business/Management, and Price Proposals as detailed in the Request for Proposal Document, along with one signed copy of all related addendums. The furnace must comply with all applicable codes and safety requirements, with the contracting officer available to address questions regarding submission requirements and evaluation criteria.
View the file
Other files
| File | Type | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| RFP 7-S176-Q-00012-00 - FP Best Value.docx | DOCX document | |
| Addendum and Acknowledgement Doc 002.doc | DOC document | |
| Addendum and Acknowledgement Doc 001.doc | DOC document | |
| SOW.docx | DOCX document | |
| Appendix D8C-12-DEC-2023.PDF | ||
| ANL-70B Reps and Certs Long-29-SEP-2026.PDF | ||
| Appendix A-71COM-15-OCT-2026.PDF | ||
| ANL-70 Request for Quotation.doc | DOC document | |
| ANL-366H (on-site high risk)-23-OCT-2026.PDF |
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
Attachment 2 – Technical Evaluation ANL-830 March 10, 2025 Enclosure No. 3 Evaluation Criteria November 4, 2026 I. Evaluation will be conducted in accordance with the Argonne National Laboratory (ANL) approved Procurement policies based on the Evaluation Criteria set forth below:
II. Overall Relative Importance of Proposal Parts
The Technical Proposal is of greater importance than the Price Proposal and Business Management Proposal. While the Price Proposal and Business Management Proposal may not be the controlling factor for the award, they will be a significant part of ANL’s selection decision. ANL shall select for an award based on the principles of best value tradeoffs. The best value is expected to result from selection of the highest technical acceptable proposal with the lowest evaluated proposed cost. It may be in the best interest of ANL to consider award to other than the Offeror with the lowest evaluated proposed cost if the perceived technical advantages of a higher evaluated proposed cost proposal merit the additional higher proposed cost.
III. Evaluation Criteria
ANL will use the following technical evaluation criteria, listed in Descending order of importance, to evaluate the merit of the Desirable Requirements:
CRITERION 1 – Technical Approach Basis for Evaluation: ANL will consider the Offeror’s demonstrated capability to design, manufacture, and support industrial furnaces for Research and Development (R&D) purposes. The Offeror’s proposal must comply with the technical specifications outlined in the Statement of Work.
Offeror to Provide for Evaluation:
· Preliminary design description and supporting calculations to demonstrate feasibility according to the Statement of Work.
· Project schedule detailing design, procurement, fabrication, delivery, onsite installation (if applicable), and commissioning.
· Business structure: Description of Offeror organization including number of employees, and departments relevant to this contract.
· Manufacturing facility description and capabilities
· Identification of major subcontractors and their responsibilities
· Scope of supply with descriptions: including furnace, spare parts, documentation, operators manual, service manual, warranty, product support, etc.
· Identification of required ANL facility preparation and ANL-furnished installation tools (if applicable)
· Personnel Qualifications: Key personnel roles, relevant experience, and anticipated project involvement.
· Identification of technical and schedule risks, proposed mitigation measures, and any requested exceptions or deviations from the Statement of Work, including their expected effects on performance, safety, reliability, and delivery.
· Method for providing furnace support to customers, including spare parts sales, customer service/maintenance manual(s), warranty claims, service department.
CRITERION 2 – Environment, Safety, and Health Basis for Evaluation: ANL will consider the Offeror’s attention to furnace safety features and compliance with relevant codes and standards per technical specifications in the Statement of Work
Offeror to Provide for Evaluation:
· A list of applicable codes and standards, including editions. Include a justification for applying each code and a description of how compliance will be demonstrated. The list may include a subset of the codes and standards proposed in the Statement of Work.
· A preliminary hazard assessment addressing hazards associated with the proposed furnace and its intended operating conditions.
· Identification of required facility protective measures, including ventilation, exhaust, utilities, guarding, confined space permit, etc.
CRITERION 3 – Quality Assurance Basis for Evaluation: ANL will evaluate the adequacy of the Offeror’s Quality Assurance (QA) Program and proposed project-specific quality controls to ensure that the furnace conforms to the Statement of Work, approved drawings, and applicable requirements. The evaluation will consider the effectiveness of design controls, procurement and subcontractor controls, manufacturing inspections, testing, documentation, and corrective-action processes. This may include the evaluation of quality through assessment of necessary organization, experience, accounting and operational controls, and technical skills, or the ability to obtain them (including, as appropriate, such elements as production control procedures, property control systems, quality assurance measures, and safety programs applicable to materials to be produced or services to be performed by the prospective contractor and subcontractors).
Offeror to Provide for Evaluation:
· Quality Management System documentation or manual (table of contents acceptable).
· Relevant ISO certifications such as ISO 9001 or calibration standards, if held, including their scope and current status.
· A preliminary project-specific quality plan identifying inspections, tests, acceptance criteria for key gateways, records, and proposed ANL witness or hold points.
· Controls for material identification and traceability
· Procedures for identifying, documenting, resolving, and preventing recurrence of nonconformances.
CRITERION 4 – Record of Past Performance Basis for Evaluation: Consideration will be given to demonstrated successful design, fabrication, delivery, commissioning, and operation of industrial furnaces. Additional consideration may be given to experience in furnaces for laboratory R&D environments at similar scales, however experience supplying furnaces of similar technical complexity to industrial processes will also receive favorable consideration. ANL may contact client references.
Offeror to Provide for Evaluation:
A list of three (3) completed contracts in the past five (5) years that have been awarded to the Offeror of similar technical complexity, operating conditions, and scale. Fewer than three (3) completed contracts with high similarity to the proposed contract will be evaluated more favorably than a greater quantity of lesser technical similarity. An additional two (2) contracts (for a total of five (5) completed contracts) may be submitted for consideration if each contract demonstrates capability in distinct technical capacities relevant to the proposed furnace. Subcontractor experience may also be considered if the Offeror’s role demonstrates experience of relevant technical complexity, operating conditions, and scale of the proposed furnace. The list should provide the following information for each contract:
· Contract Title
· Date of Award
· Client’s Name and Address
· Telephone/E-mail for Client
· Maximum continuous firing rate and temperature
· Purpose of the device provided under the contract
· Provisions for specialized instrumentation
· In-house design and analysis performed by the Offeror under the contract
· Optical access details, if applicable
· Explanation of similar technical elements to the proposed furnace
· Planned versus actual delivery and commissioning dates with explanation for significant variances
· Evidence of commissioning results, and successful deployment image1.png
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .