General_Decision_MA190006_4Jan19_MA6.pdf

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̂-)#!.!">*&$"<&F+#Z!#&;#+>!(>)+"*&&-"<!#&>?!&HP&)*&$D$)%$/%!&$>&FFFG<+%GE+D7F?<7E+D(+">#$(>*G&&&&&1+<)M)($>)+"&,-./!#&&&&&]-/%)($>)+"&'$>!&&&&&&&&&&&5&&&&&&&&&&&&&5375879534&&_&H, J559UN553&357537953̀&&:A2AHIJ'H&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&\$>!*&&&&&&&&&&[#)"E!*&&'#!<E)"E0&&&&&&&&@a2::&2GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGV&T=G3=&&&&&&&&36G93b$b/&&&&&&@a2::&X3GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGV&TTG5T&&&&&&&&3UG=5b$b/&&&&&&@a2::&X9GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGV&T3G54&&&&&&&&3UG6Ub$b/&&&&&&@a2::&@3GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGV&T5G98&&&&&&&&38G=Tb$b/&&&&&&@a2::&@9GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGV&94G96&&&&&&&&38G̀Ub$b/&&&&&&@a2::&'GGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGGV&98GT5&&&&&&&&3TG65b$b/&&@a2::J[J@2AJP,:0&&&@a2::&20&&a!$<&'#!<E!.$"K&P;!#$>+#K&a!D!#.$"K&a)(!"*!<&A-E&&&P;!#$>+#&+D!#&3555&C]G&

!"#$$ %&' ()**+,- ./)*012*3 $/+4)*5$/+66 %0*7) ./)*012*3 897+9))*3 86),1*+,+093 !:+); <)64)*3 !:+); =01)3 >+66 ?60,)*3 ./)*012* @@3 =0+91)909,) 897+9))*3 "+,)9A)4 %201 ./)*012*B !"#$$ %C' !)*1+;+)4 <)64)*B !"#$$ !&' =01)3 (*07 %0*7) ./)*012*3 $1)D0*43 #AA+A1091 >+66 ?60,)*3 <)64)*B !"#$$ !C' %201 ./)*012* !"#$$ (' $:2*)E093 (),-:0943 F24E093 $,2DE093 !22-3 =)AAE093 ?2*1)*5G09+12*3 .+6)*B @H!8HI@J8 ?#K' L#44 12 M2N*6O F01)P ./)*012* LH!!!. "+,)9A)5!)*1+;+,01+29P Q&BRS "+,)9A)4 IN7 ./)*012* 2T)* &SSS M? L#AA+79)4 0A =0A1)*P LU$!V 6+,)9A)4 =0A1)* 2; I2D+97 J)AA)6A L=.IJP Q&BRSW "+,)9A)4 %201 ./)*012* L#AA+79)4 0A 6)04 X201 ,0/10+9P U$!V 6+,)9A)4 X201 2/)*012* Q&BSSW 897+9))* LY=8( 094 I09-)*E09 )942*A)E)91 2* 6+,)9A)4 )97+9))* LU$!VP Q&BRS .+6)* LY=8( 094 I09-)*E09 )942*A)E)91 LU$!VP Q&BRSW #66 ,60AA+;+,01+29A LI09-)*E09 )942*A)E)91 296OP U$!V Q&BCRW (),-:094 2* =01) L#% D+1: "+;)X201E09 )942*A)E)91 LU$!VP Q&BRSW #66 ,60AA+;+,01+29A L6+;)X201E09 )942*A)E)91 296O LU$!VP Q&BCRW <)64)* L#%$ ,)*1+;+,01+29P QSBRS >..IH.I8$ #??"@!#%"8 I. #%.J8 !F#>I$' 0B ?#@( M."@(#K$' H)D K)0*ZA (0O3 =0*1+9 "N1:)* [+973 G*BZA %+*1:40O3 =)E2*+06 (0O3 V224 >*+40O3 @94)/)94)9,) (0O3 "0X2* (0O3 J)1)*09AZ (0O3 I:09-A7+T+97 (0O 094 !:*+A1E0A (0O XB J#!#I@.H' 8+7:1 /)*,)91 L\]P 2; 1:) A1*0+7:1 1+E) *01)3 EN61+/6+)4 XO 1:) 12106 :2N*A D2*-)4B ̂̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂ <8"(8F$ ̂ F),)+T) *01) /*)A,*+X)4 ;2* ,*0;1 /)*;2*E+97 2/)*01+29 12 D:+,: D)64+97 +A +9,+4)9106B ________________________________________________________________ H21)' 8̀),N1+T) .*4)* L8.P &abSc3 8A10X6+A:+97 ?0+4 $+,- ")0T) ;2* >)4)*06 !291*0,12*A 0//6+)A 12 066 ,291*0,1A ANXd),1 12 1:) (0T+Â%0,29 #,1 ;2* D:+,: 1:) ,291*0,1 +A 0D0*4)4 L094 09O A26+,+101+29 D0A +AAN)4P 29 2* 0;1)* G09N0*O &3 CS&bB @; 1:+A ,291*0,1 +A ,2T)*)4 XO 1:) 8.3 1:) ,291*0,12* ENA1 /*2T+4) )E/62O))A D+1: & :2N* 2; /0+4 A+,- 6)0T) ;2* )T)*O aS :2N*A 1:)O D2*-3 N/ 12 Rc :2N*A 2; /0+4 A+,- 6)0T) )0,: O)0*B 8E/62O))A ENA1 X) /)*E+11)4 12 NA) /0+4 A+,- 6)0T) ;2* 1:)+* 2D9 +669)AA3 +9dN*O 2* 21:)* :)061:̂*)601)4 9))4A3 +9,6N4+97 /*)T)91+T) ,0*)W 12 0AA+A1 0 ;0E+6O E)EX)* L2* /)*A29 D:2 +A 6+-) ;0E+6O 12 1:) )E/62O))P D:2 +A +663 +9dN*)43 2* :0A 21:)* :)061:̂*)601)4 9))4A3 +9,6N4+97 /*)T)91+T) ,0*)W 2* ;2* *)0A29A *)AN61+97 ;*2E3 2* 12 0AA+A1 0 ;0E+6O E)EX)* L2* /)*A29 D:2 +A 6+-) ;0E+6O 12 1:) )E/62O))P D:2 +A 0 T+,1+E 2;3 42E)A1+, T+26)9,)3 A)̀N06 0AA0N613 2* A106-+97B #44+1+2906 +9;2*E01+29 29 ,291*0,12* *)eN+*)E)91A 094 D2*-)* /*21),1+29A N94)* 1:) 8. +A 0T0+60X6) 01 DDDB426B72T5D:4572T,291*0,1AB U96+A1)4 ,60AA+;+,01+29A 9))4)4 ;2* D2*- 921 +9,6N4)4 D+1:+9 1:) A,2/) 2; 1:) ,60AA+;+,01+29A 6+A1)4 E0O X) 044)4 0;1)* 0D0*4 296O 0A /*2T+4)4 +9 1:) 60X2* A10940*4A ,291*0,1 ,60NA)A LCf!>F RBR L0P L&P L++PPB ̂̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂^̂ I:) X24O 2; )0,: D07) 4)1)*E+901+29 6+A1A 1:) ,60AA+;+,01+29

!"#$ %&#' (&)#(* (#* +&#,&&!#-./!"#(.#,&#0'&+ 121!%#-.'#(*&#31(&"#(40&5)6#.-#3.!)('/3(1.!#1!#(*&# '& #3.+&'&"#,4#(*&#$ %&#"&(&'71! (1.!8#9*&#32 ))1-13 (1.!)# '&#21)(&"#1!# 20* ,&(13 2#.'"&'#.-#:1"&!(1-1&'):#(* (#1!"13 (&#$*&(*&'#(*&#0 '(13/2 '#' (&#1)# #/!1.!#' (&#53/''&!(#/!1.!#!&%.(1 (&"#' (&#-.'#2.3 26;# #)/'+&4#' (&#5$&1%*(&"# +&' %&#' (&6#.'# #/!1.!# +&' %&#' (&#5$&1%*(&"#/!1.!# +&' %&#' (&68##<!1.!#= (&#>"&!(1-1&')##?#-./'#2&((&'#32 ))1-13 (1.!# ,,'&+1 (1.!#1"&!(1-1&'#&!32.)&"#1!#".((&"#21!&)#,&%1!!1!%#$1(*#3* ' 3(&')#.(*&'#(* !#:@<:#.'#:<?AB:#"&!.(&)#(* (#(*&#/!1.!#32 ))1-13 (1.!# !"#' (&#$&'&#0'&+ 121!%#-.'#(* (#32 ))1-13 (1.!#1!#(*&#)/'+&48#CD 702&E#FG<HIJKLMIIN#IOPIJPQIJR8#FG<H#1)# !# ,,'&+1 (1.!#1"&!(1-1&'#.-#(*&#/!1.!#$*13*#0'&+ 12&"#1!#(*&#)/'+&4#-.'#(*1)#32 ))1-13 (1.!;#$*13*#1!#(*1)#&D 702&#$./2"#,&#F2/7,&')8#IJKL#1!"13 (&)#(*&#2.3 2#/!1.!#!/7,&'#.'#"1)('13(#3./!312#!/7,&'#$*&'&# 00213 ,2&;#18&8;#F2/7,&')#G.3 2#IJKL8#9*&#!&D(#!/7,&';#IIN#1!#(*&#&D 702&;#1)# !#1!(&'! 2#!/7,&'#/)&"#1!#0'.3&))1!%#(*&#$ %&#"&(&'71! (1.!8#IOPIJPQIJR#1)#(*&#&--&3(1+&#" (&#.-#(*&#7.)(#3/''&!(#!&%.(1 (&"#' (&;#$*13*#1!#(*1)#&D 702&#1)#S/24#J;#QIJR8##<!1.!#0'&+ 121!%#$ %&#' (&)# '&#/0" (&"#(.#'&-2&3(# 22#' (&#3* !%&)#1!#(*&#3.22&3(1+&#, '% 1!1!%# %'&&7&!(#5TU?6#%.+&'!1!%#(*1)#32 ))1-13 (1.!# !"#' (&8##@/'+&4#= (&#>"&!(1-1&')##T2 ))1-13 (1.!)#21)(&"#/!"&'#(*&#:@<:#1"&!(1-1&'#1!"13 (&#(* (#!.#.!&#' (&#0'&+ 12&"#-.'#(*1)#32 ))1-13 (1.!#1!#(*&#)/'+&4# !"#(*&#0/,21)*&"#' (&#1)#"&'1+&"#,4#3.70/(1!%# #$&1%*(&"# +&' %&#' (&#, )&"#.!# 22#(*&#' (&)#'&0.'(&"#1!#(*&#)/'+&4#-.'#(* (#32 ))1-13 (1.!8##?)#(*1)#$&1%*(&"# +&' %&#' (&#1!32/"&)# 22#' (&)#'&0.'(&"#1!#(*&#)/'+&4;#1(#7 4#1!32/"&#,.(*#/!1.!# !"#!.!M/!1.!#' (&)8#CD 702&E#@<G?QIJQMIIO#NPJVPQIJR8#@<#1!"13 (&)#(*&#' (&)# '&#)/'+&4#' (&)#, )&"#.!# #$&1%*(&"# +&' %&#3 23/2 (1.!#.-#' (&)# !"# '&#!.(#7 W.'1(4#' (&)8#G?#1!"13 (&)#(*&#@( (&#.-#G./1)1 ! 8#QIJQ#1)#(*&#4& '#.-#)/'+&4#.!#$*13*#(*&)&#32 ))1-13 (1.!)# !"#' (&)# '&#, )&"8#9*&#!&D(#!/7,&';#IIO#1!#(*&#&D 702&;#1)# !#1!(&'! 2#!/7,&'#/)&"#1!#0'."/31!%#(*&#$ %&#"&(&'71! (1.!8#NPJVPQIJR#1!"13 (&)#(*&#)/'+&4#3.702&(1.!#" (&#-.'#(*&#32 ))1-13 (1.!)# !"#' (&)#/!"&'#(* (#1"&!(1-1&'8##@/'+&4#$ %&#' (&)# '&#!.(#/0" (&"# !"#'&7 1!#1!#&--&3(#/!(12# #!&$#)/'+&4#1)#3.!"/3(&"8##<!1.!#?+&' %&#= (&#>"&!(1-1&')##T2 ))1-13 (1.!5)6#21)(&"#/!"&'#(*&#<?AB#1"&!(1-1&'#1!"13 (&#(* (#!.#)1!%2&#7 W.'1(4#' (&#0'&+ 12&"#-.'#(*.)&#32 ))1-13 (1.!)X#*.$&+&';#JIIY#.-#(*&#" ( #'&0.'(&"#-.'#(*&#32 ))1-13 (1.!)#$ )#/!1.!#" ( 8#CZ?HFGCE#<?ABM[\MIIJI#ILPQKPQIJR8#<?AB#1!"13 (&)#(* (#(*&#' (&#1)# #$&1%*(&"#/!1.!# +&' %&#' (&8#[\#1!"13 (&)#(*&#)( (&8#9*&#!&D(#!/7,&';#IIJI#1!#(*&#&D 702&;#1)# !#1!(&'! 2#!/7,&'#/)&"#1!#0'."/31!%#(*&#$ %&#"&(&'71! (1.!8#ILPQKPQIJR#1!"13 (&)#(*&#)/'+&4#3.702&(1.!#" (&#-.'#(*&#32 ))1-13 (1.!)# !"#' (&)#/!"&'#(* (#1"&!(1-1&'8##?#<?AB#' (&#$122#,&#/0" (&"#.!3&# #4& ';#/)/ 224#1!#S !/ '4#.-#& 3*#4& ';#(.#'&-2&3(# #$&1%*(&"# +&' %&#.-#(*&#3/''&!(#!&%.(1 (&"PTU?#' (&#.-#(*&#/!1.!#2.3 2)#-'.7#$*13*#(*&#' (&#1)#, )&"8##

!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! "#$% &%'%()*+#'*,+ #--%#./ -(,0%// 123 456 789:9 ;99< 5< =<=7=5> ?9@=6=A< =< 789 B5779:C '8=6 @5< ;9D E 5< 9F=67=<G HI;>=689? J5G9 ?979:B=<57=A< E 5 6I:K9L I<?9:>L=<G 5 J5G9 ?979:B=<57=A< E 5 "5G9 5<? 4AI: &=K=6=A< >9779: 6977=<G MA:78 5 HA6=7=A< A< 5 J5G9 ?979:B=<57=A< B5779: E 5 @A<MA:B5<@9 N5??=7=A<5> @>566=M=@57=A< 5<? :5793 :I>=<G ,< 6I:K9L :9>579? B5779:6O =<=7=5> @A<75@7O =<@>I?=<G :9PI9676 MA: 6IBB5:=96 AM 6I:K9L6O 68AI>? ;9 J=78 789 "5G9 5<? 4AI: (9G=A<5> ,MM=@9 MA: 789 5:95 =< J8=@8 789 6I:K9L J56 @A<?I@79? ;9@5I69 78A69 (9G=A<5> ,MM=@96 85K9 :96HA<6=;=>=7L MA: 789 &5K=6!Q5@A< 6I:K9L H:AG:5B2 *M 789 :96HA<69 M:AB 78=6 =<=7=5> @A<75@7 =6 <A7 657=6M5@7A:LO 789< 789 H:A@966 ?96@:=;9? =< R23 5<? S23 68AI>? ;9 MA>>AJ9?2 "=78 :9G5:? 7A 5<L A789: B5779: <A7 L97 :=H9 MA: 789 MA:B5> H:A@966 ?96@:=;9? 89:9O =<=7=5> @A<75@7 68AI>? ;9 J=78 789 Q:5<@8 AM 0A<67:I@7=A< "5G9 &979:B=<57=A<62 ":=79 7AD Q:5<@8 AM 0A<67:I@7=A< "5G9 &979:B=<57=A<6 "5G9 5<? 4AI: &=K=6=A< T2/2 &9H5:7B9<7 AM .5;A: RUU 0A<67=7I7=A< #K9<I9O +2"2 "568=<G7A<O &0 RUR1U R23 *M 789 5<6J9: 7A 789 PI967=A< =< 123 =6 L96O 789< 5< =<79:9679? H5:7L N78A69 5MM9@79? ;L 789 5@7=A<3 @5< :9PI967 :9K=9J 5<? :9@A<6=?9:57=A< M:AB 789 "5G9 5<? 4AI: #?B=<=67:57A: N/99 RV 0W( -5:7 12X 5<? RV 0W( -5:7 Y32 ":=79 7AD "5G9 5<? 4AI: #?B=<=67:57A: T2/2 &9H5:7B9<7 AM .5;A: RUU 0A<67=7I7=A< #K9<I9O +2"2 "568=<G7A<O &0 RUR1U '89 :9PI967 68AI>? ;9 5@@ABH5<=9? ;L 5 MI>> 67579B9<7 AM 789 =<79:9679? H5:7LZ6 HA6=7=A< 5<? ;L 5<L =<MA:B57=A< NJ5G9 H5LB9<7 ?575O H:A[9@7 ?96@:=H7=A<O 5:95 H:5@7=@9 B579:=5>O 97@23 7857 789 :9PI967A: @A<6=?9:6 :9>9K5<7 7A 789 =66I92 S23 *M 789 ?9@=6=A< AM 789 #?B=<=67:57A: =6 <A7 M5KA:5;>9O 5< =<79:9679? H5:7L B5L 5HH95> ?=:9@7>L 7A 789 #?B=<=67:57=K9 (9K=9J QA5:? NMA:B9:>L 789 "5G9 #HH95>6 QA5:?32 ":=79 7AD #?B=<=67:57=K9 (9K=9J QA5:? T2/2 &9H5:7B9<7 AM .5;A: RUU 0A<67=7I7=A< #K9<I9O +2"2 "568=<G7A<O &0 RUR1U \23 #>> ?9@=6=A<6 ;L 789 #?B=<=67:57=K9 (9K=9J QA5:? 5:9 M=<5>2 ]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]]] %+& ,W $%+%(#. &%0*/*,+