35585_ScoreMatrix_WC.pdf

This is an evaluation score matrix for a Request for Proposals (RFP) issued by the State of Oregon for the US26 at Cornelius Pass Road Bike/Pedestrian Crossing project (RFP Number 35585). The evaluation involved three consulting engineering firms competing for the contract: David Evans and Associates, Jacobs Engineering Group, and KPFF Consulting Engineers. The evaluation team consisted of three independent evaluators who scored each proposal on a standardized scoring system. KPFF Consulting Engineers achieved the highest overall average score of 112 points across the three evaluators and was ranked first, followed by Jacobs Engineering Group with an average score of 106 points ranked second, and David Evans and Associates with an average score of 106 points ranked third. Individual evaluator scores ranged from a low of 98 points to a high of 118 points, with a scoring range of 4 to 10 points across evaluators.

The final proposal scores remained consistent with the evaluation summary scores, with no cost adjustment applied to the final rankings. KPFF Consulting Engineers maintained its first-place ranking with a final score of 112, while both Jacobs Engineering Group and David Evans and Associates retained their respective rankings with final scores of 106 points each. The evaluation matrix utilized a standardized format with gray-highlighted data entry fields for summary, proposal, interview, and reference score worksheets, as indicated by the document version dated October 20, 2016.