2321 Scores Tabulation.pdf

This is a scores tabulation document for Kenosha County, Wisconsin related to Proposal #2321 for Old Settlers Park Beer Garden Concessions Operation. Three bidders submitted proposals: 1 of Us Brewing Co. from Mount Pleasant, WI; Petrifying Springs Beer Garden, LLC from Kenosha, WI; and Beer Garden Partners, LLC from Salem, WI. The evaluation process assessed proposals across multiple technical criteria including Company Profile (20 points), Staff Qualifications (20 points), Business Plan (25 points), Improvements (25 points), and Menu (20 points), for a total technical score of 100 points.

The scoring results show Petrifying Springs Beer Garden, LLC received the highest combined score of 111.33 points, significantly outperforming the other bidders with a technical score of 101.33 points and a cost score of 10.00 points. Beer Garden Partners, LLC scored 90.86 points total with a technical score of 87.67 and cost score of 3.19 points, while 1 of Us Brewing Co. scored 80.40 points total with a technical score of 77.00 and cost score of 3.40 points. Cost proposals ranged from $78,415.00 to $245,750.75, with Petrifying Springs Beer Garden, LLC proposing the highest cost at $245,750.75, which corresponded to the highest cost score allocation within the 10-point cost evaluation category.