1-RFP Q2701 Student Information System Score Sheet.docx

DOCX document 2 MB Posted

Attached to
Tooele Technical College- Student Information System
Solicitation number
RA27-139
Issued by
Tooele County, Utah

About this file

This document is a scoring sheet for the Student Information System Request for Proposal (RFP Q2701) issued by Tooele Technical College in Utah. The scoring sheet establishes the evaluation criteria and point allocations for assessing vendor proposals submitted in response to this solicitation. Questions regarding the solicitation must be submitted through the U3P portal no later than November 30, 2026, at 2:00 PM, with proposals due by December 18, 2026, at 2:00 PM. The scoring sheet provides a structured framework for evaluating competing proposals based on predetermined criteria and weighted point values to ensure consistent and objective assessment of all submissions.

The scoring sheet contains the evaluation methodology that will be applied by Tooele Technical College's evaluation committee to rank and compare proposals. The specific scoring criteria, point distributions, and evaluation standards are outlined in the document to guide vendors in understanding how their proposals will be assessed. This procurement is being conducted directly by Tooele Technical College rather than through the Utah Division of Purchasing, and vendors are responsible for reviewing all solicitation documents to ensure compliance with requirements.

View the file

Other files

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

RFP Evaluation Score Sheet Solicitation Title: Student Information System (SIS) RFP Reference Number: Q27001 / RFP #Q2701 Issuing Office: Tooele Technical College - Fiscal Services Department Evaluation Summary Table

Evaluation Category
RFP Section Reference
Maximum Points
Evaluated Score
A. General & Section 5 Functionality
Section 3 (Minimum & General Requirements)
50
B. Cost
Section 3 (Evaluation Criteria - Cost)
25
C. Project Management & Support
Section 3 (Project Mgt & Support)
20
D. References
Section 3 (References)
5

TOTAL POSSIBLE SCORE

Detailed Scoring Breakdown A. Functionality & Minimum/General Requirements (50 Points Max) Evaluates how effectively the proposed SaaS solution fulfills the College's functional, technical, and operational requirements, with emphasis on supporting open-entry, non-term, flexible pacing workflows.

Sub-Category / Criteria Area
Key Requirements & Description
Max Points
Score
1. SaaS, Platform & Minimum Technical Requirements
· 100% SaaS delivery (no on-premises dependency), high availability, scalability, disaster recovery

· Mobile-ready, Chrome browser accessible across iOS, Android, Windows, Mac

· API/Web services integration (functional Canvas API required)

· SAML 2.0 Single Sign-On (SSO) and Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)

· Support for Utah GDPA, FERPA compliance, audit logging, and data encryption

2. Flexible Scheduling & Open-Entry Academic Model
· Dynamic support for course-based, open-entry, non-term scheduling

· Individual course start/end dates and flexible student pacing calculation

· Multi-occupancy room scheduling (different courses/schedules in same physical space)

· Multiple program structures (full-time, part-time, AM/PM, hybrid) and calendars

3. Student Experience & Self-Service Portal
· Intuitive portal for schedule building, progress tracking, and document uploads

· Student self-service scheduling without required staff intervention

· Real-time course availability, prerequisites, completion timeline projections

· Online payments, account balances, and automated notification/alerts

4. Academic Records, Registration & Progression
· Comprehensive academic history, transcript generation, and attendance tracking

· Transfer credit, competency recognition, course retakes/extensions

· Prerequisite enforcement, student flags/notes, detailed audit logs

· Digital/physical student ID credential generation and management

5. Catalog, Program & Financials Management
· Program and course versioning, effective dating, completion rule definitions

· Variable pricing/tuition based on course start dates, payment plans, online payments

· Full Accounts Receivable (AR), invoicing, sponsor billing hierarchies, 1098-T generation

· General Ledger mapping and export capabilities

6. CRM, Admissions & Communications
· Online admissions portal, dynamic application forms, requirement tracking

· Recruitment pipelines, prospect tracking, intake forms, automated lifecycle communications

· Multi-channel messaging (email, SMS, system alerts), case management, advising tools

7. Reporting, Analytics & Embedded AI Capabilities
· Ad hoc and standard reports (IPEDS, National Student Clearinghouse, state/federal)

· Export formats (Excel, PDF, CSV) and scheduled report delivery

· Embedded AI / Copilot features for conversational data querying and workflow automation

8. Trial Period Availability & Validation
· Confirmation of readiness to participate in up to 90-day trial testing

· Validation of open-entry model, user interface, mobility, and integrations

Section A Total

B. Cost Evaluation (25 Points Max) Evaluated independently based on the Total Cost of Ownership (TCO) submitted in a separate file.

Cost Assessment Area
Evaluation Focus
Max Points
Score
5-Year Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)
· Itemized Base Bid: implementation, licensing, remote setup, remote training, conversion

· Licensing clarity (model specified, firm price per additional license for 5 years)

· Overall 5-Year TCO competitiveness relative to other responsive proposals

· Post-year-5 annual escalation percentage limit

Section B Total

C. Project Management & Support (20 Points Max) Evaluates the offeror’s methodology, timeline, implementation plan, and ongoing support services.

Criteria Area
Evaluation Focus
Max Points
Score
1. Implementation, Migration & Installation Schedule
· Detailed outline from kick-off to go-live with clear key milestones

· Data conversion plan from NorthStar (student records, GL fee schedule, schedules)

· Regular coordination meeting structure (bi-weekly minimum, weekly preferred)

· Acceptance testing process adhering to Attachment C checklist

2. Training Program & Materials
· Customized training outline and schedule for Faculty, Financial Aid, Student Services, Finance

· Execution timing (scheduled within 30 days post-acceptance testing)

· User guides (PDF format), recorded sessions for College knowledge base

3. Ongoing Technical Support & Maintenance Coverage
· Support hours coverage (at minimum 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM MST, Mon–Fri)

· Multi-channel support (phone, chat, email) and response time SLAs

· System uptime guarantees, patch/upgrade release management free of charge

· Clear definition of included vs. excluded support/maintenance services

Section C Total

D. References (5 Points Max) Evaluates the offeror's past performance and client satisfaction in comparable environments.

Criteria Area
Evaluation Focus
Max Points
Score
Client References Performance
· Minimum three (3) references provided with contact details

· Relevance to scope, size, and flexible academic model of Tooele Tech

· Timely response and positive feedback from reference contacts Note: Failure to submit references or unresponsiveness results in 0 points.

Section D Total

Evaluator Authorization & Notes Evaluator Name: _____________________________________________________________ Evaluator Signature: __________________________________________________________ Date: _______________________________________________________________________

Evaluator Comments / Justification:

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .