00010599 Eval Matrix for release.xlsx

XLSX spreadsheet 71 KB Posted

Attached to
SOUTHWEST CORVALLIS AREA PLAN, TGM 2B-22 Key #21725
Solicitation number
S-73000-00010599
Issued by
Benton County, Oregon

About this file

This document is an evaluation matrix for a state and local contract opportunity issued by the Oregon Department of Transportation (ODOT) and the City of Corvallis to procure consulting services for the Southwest Corvallis Area Plan project. The objective is to refine land uses, provide an orderly plan for local street networks and alternative transportation options, and create a sense of community for the Southwest Corvallis area. Key deliverables include draft and revised memoranda, public event materials, a draft Southwest Area Plan, and a final Southwest Area Plan. The needed services include transportation planning, public outreach, policy and plan development, and adoption. Proposals will be evaluated based on the qualifications and experience of key staff, project approach, work samples, and clarity of the proposal. The contract is anticipated to start in September 2024 and be completed by March 2026.

The total not-to-exceed amount for the contract is $85,000, which includes $81,000 for non-contingency tasks and a $4,000 fixed fee. The contract has a 3% Disadvantaged Business Enterprise (DBE) participation goal, and proposers must submit a Committed DBE Breakdown and Certification Form-AE during negotiations if a DBE goal greater than 0% is assigned. The procurement does not identify any incumbent contractors or funding sources beyond state and federal transportation funds.

View the file

Other files

File Type Posted
00010599 ITA.docx DOCX document
00010599 Final Mini~1.docx DOCX document
00010599 Final Sample WOC.docx DOCX document
00010599 Mini RFP Att A Cover Sheet.doc DOC document
Public Notice of Intent to Award Through Permissive Cooperative - signed.pdf PDF

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Summary Scores

RFP Number: Project Name: ____________________
EVALUATION SCORE SUMMARY
Enter data only in gray highlighted fields on Summary, Proposal, Interview and Reference Score worksheets as applicable.
SOP Evaluation Summary ScoresNumber of Proposal evaluators:6
Evaluation Team
Score
Firmevaluator 1evaluator 2evaluator 3evaluator 4evaluator 6TotalAverageRank
3J Consulting9318619611001841459771
First Forty Feet743803783813633376633
Kittleson931842912962792443742
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Firm Name0404040404004
Statistics
High Score93869610084
Low Score74180178181163
Range196181921
Interview Evaluation Summary ScoresNumber of interview evaluators:1
Evaluation Team
Score
Firmname1name2name3name4name5TotalAverageRank
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Statistics
High Score00000
Low ScoreERROR:#NUM!1ERROR:#NUM!1ERROR:#NUM!1ERROR:#NUM!1ERROR:#NUM!
RangeERROR:#NUM!ERROR:#NUM!ERROR:#NUM!ERROR:#NUM!ERROR:#NUM!
References Summary ScoresNumber of references scored:1
References
Score
Firmreference1reference2reference3reference4reference5TotalAverageRank
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001
Firm Name0101010101001

FINAL SCORES (with COST SCORES if applicable)

ProposalInterviewEnterReferencesFinal Scores
FirmAverageAverageCost ScoresTotalRank
firm 177101001771
firm 263301001633
firm 374201001742
firm 4040100104
firm 5040100104
firm 6040100104

Ver 10/20/16

Proposal Detail Scores

RFP Number: Project Name: ____________________
SOP SCORE DETAILS RFP 00010599 Southwest Corvallis Area Plan
Proposal Evaluation Detail ScoresEnter actual number of evaluators:6
Evaluation Team
Maximum
Scoreevaluator 1evaluator 2evaluator 3evaluator 4evaluator 5evaluator 6
13J Consulting
2.2.1Specific Experience of Key Staff40383540403733
2.2.2Project Approach30302530302325
2.2.3Work Samples20151816201318
2.2.4Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10108101088
Total10093869610081840%
Scoring Deduction Points000000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)938696100818490
2First Forty Feet
Specific Experience of Key Staff40313130342026
Project Approach30142323201513
Work Samples20201818201316
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10987758
TOTAL1007480788153630%
Scoring Deduction Points000000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)74807881536372
3Kittleson
Specific Experience of Key Staff40363835383533
Project Approach30302528282822
Work Samples20181418201517
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements1097101097
TOTAL1009384919687790%
Scoring Deduction Points000000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)93849196877988
4Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
5Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
6Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
7Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
8Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
9Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
10Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
11Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
12Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
13Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
14Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
15Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
16Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
17Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000
18Firm Name
Specific Experience of Key Staff40
Project Approach30
Work Samples20
Clarity of Proposal and Conformity with Requirements10
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!
ERROR:#REF!ERROR:#REF!Scoring Deductions
TOTALERROR:#REF!000000%
Scoring Deduction Points00000
TOTAL (incl. Scoring Deductions)00000

Interview Detail Scores

RFP Number: Project Name: ____________________
INTERVIEW SCORE DETAILS
Enter actual number of interview evaluators:1
Evaluation Team
Maximum
Scoreevaluator 1evaluator 2evaluator 3evaluator 4evaluator 5
Firm Name
Eval criterion/question 10
Eval criterion/question 20
Eval criterion/question 30
Eval criterion/question 40
Eval criterion/question 50
Eval criterion/question 60
Eval criterion/question 70
Eval criterion/question 80
Eval criterion/question 90
TOTAL000000
Firm Name
Eval criterion/question 10
Eval criterion/question 20
Eval criterion/question 30
Eval criterion/question 40
Eval criterion/question 50
Eval criterion/question 60
Eval criterion/question 70
Eval criterion/question 80
Eval criterion/question 90
TOTAL000000
Firm Name
Eval criterion/question 10
Eval criterion/question 20
Eval criterion/question 30
Eval criterion/question 40
Eval criterion/question 50
Eval criterion/question 60
Eval criterion/question 70
Eval criterion/question 80
Eval criterion/question 90
TOTAL000000
Firm Name
Eval criterion/question 10
Eval criterion/question 20
Eval criterion/question 30
Eval criterion/question 40
Eval criterion/question 50
Eval criterion/question 60
Eval criterion/question 70
Eval criterion/question 80
Eval criterion/question 90
TOTAL000000
Firm Name
Eval criterion/question 10
Eval criterion/question 20
Eval criterion/question 30
Eval criterion/question 40
Eval criterion/question 50
Eval criterion/question 60
Eval criterion/question 70
Eval criterion/question 80
Eval criterion/question 90
TOTAL000000
Firm Name
Eval criterion/question 10
Eval criterion/question 20
Eval criterion/question 30
Eval criterion/question 40
Eval criterion/question 50
Eval criterion/question 60
Eval criterion/question 70
Eval criterion/question 80
Eval criterion/question 90
TOTAL000000

References Detail Scores

RFP Number: Project Name: ____________________
References Evaluation Detail Scores
Enter actual number of references scored:1
Reference Scores
Maximum
Scorereference 1reference 2reference 3reference 4reference 5
1Firm Name
Criterion/Question 10
Criterion/Question 20
Criterion/Question 30
Criterion/Question 40
Criterion/Question 50
Criterion/Question 60
Criterion/Question 70
Criterion/Question 80
Criterion/Question 90
TOTAL000000
2Firm Name
Criterion/Question 10
Criterion/Question 20
Criterion/Question 30
Criterion/Question 40
Criterion/Question 50
Criterion/Question 60
Criterion/Question 70
Criterion/Question 80
Criterion/Question 90
TOTAL000000
3Firm Name
Criterion/Question 10
Criterion/Question 20
Criterion/Question 30
Criterion/Question 40
Criterion/Question 50
Criterion/Question 60
Criterion/Question 70
Criterion/Question 80
Criterion/Question 90
TOTAL000000
4Firm Name
Criterion/Question 10
Criterion/Question 20
Criterion/Question 30
Criterion/Question 40
Criterion/Question 50
Criterion/Question 60
Criterion/Question 70
Criterion/Question 80
Criterion/Question 90
TOTAL000000
5Firm Name
Criterion/Question 10
Criterion/Question 20
Criterion/Question 30
Criterion/Question 40
Criterion/Question 50
Criterion/Question 60
Criterion/Question 70
Criterion/Question 80
Criterion/Question 90
TOTAL000000
6Firm Name
Criterion/Question 10
Criterion/Question 20
Criterion/Question 30
Criterion/Question 40
Criterion/Question 50
Criterion/Question 60
Criterion/Question 70
Criterion/Question 80
Criterion/Question 90
TOTAL000000

&"Arial,Bold"&12REFERENCES SCORE DETAIL RFP xxx (PCMS xxx) &"Arial,Bold Italic"[insert project name]

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .