Attachment C_Contractor Evaluation.xlsx

XLSX spreadsheet 34 KB Posted Oct 20, 2022

Attached to: Environmental Planning and Consulting Services for Various Projects Located Throughout the Northeastern United States
Solicitation number: W912WJ23R0002
Issued by: Department of the Army Corps of Engineers Engineering District New England

View the file

Other files

File	Type	Posted
Amendment 0003.pdf	PDF	Nov 21, 2022
Amendment 0002.pdf	PDF	Nov 17, 2022
Amendment 0002 - Attachment D (Updated).xlsx	XLSX spreadsheet	Nov 17, 2022
Amendment 0001_Attachment E.xlsx	XLSX spreadsheet	Nov 4, 2022
Amendment 0001.pdf	PDF	Nov 4, 2022
Attachment_D_Binding_Rates_Table.xlsx	XLSX spreadsheet	Oct 19, 2022
Sample_Task_Order.pdf	PDF	Oct 19, 2022
W912WJ23R0002.pdf	PDF	Oct 19, 2022
Attachment_A_PPQ.pdf	PDF	Oct 19, 2022
Attachment_B_Joint_Venture_Requirements.pdf	PDF	Oct 19, 2022

On GovTribe

Work with this file

Download the original file
Contacts named in this file
Similar government files
Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Try for free Login

Text version

The file's text, extracted by GovTribe without its formatting.

Final

Technical Expertise

Table 1 - NEPA Documents

Resources Affected by the Project

Project Name

Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)

Project Location (State)

Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)

Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?

Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)

Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)

Date of FONSI or ROD, or last NEPA document

For EISs, Number of Staff from the team listed in the published List of Preparers

Upland Forest, Grassland, Shrub

Estuary/Marine

Freshwater Wetland

Salt Marsh

Rivers/Streams

Eelgrass

Disciplines Provided by the Offeror's Team (from list provided)

Number of EIS Scoping Meetings Led by the Offeror's Team

Number of Public Meetings Led by the Team

For EISs, Number of Public Comments Received (>100, <100, <50)

Ecological Model Applied? (provide the name)

List any statistical analyses performed

Project 1

Project 2

Project 3

Project 4

Project 5

Project 6

Project 7

Project 8

Project 9

Project 10

Project 11

Project 12

Project 13

Table 2 - Biological Assessments
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)	Federal Endangered Species Addressed
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3
Project 4
Project 5

Table 3 - Essential Fish Habitat Assessments
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3

Table 4 - National Historic Preservation Act Surveys or Documents
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Type of Document (Eligibility Detemination, SAR, Phase 1, 2, or 3 Survey, Remoate Sesnin Surveeys, HABS/HAER)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3
Project 4
Project 5
Project 6
Project 7
Project 8
Project 9
Project 10
Project 11
Project 12
Project 13
Project 14
Project 15

Table 5 - Coastal Modeling Studies
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3
Project 4
Project 5

Table 6 - Ecological Risk Assessment
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. environmental remediation, flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3

Table 7 - Wetland Delineation
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. environmental remediation, flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3

Table 8 - Mitigation, Monitoring, and Adaptive Management Plan
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)	Primary Habitat(s)
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3

Table 9 - Clean Air Act Emissions Studies
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)
Project 1
Project 2
Project 3

Table 10. Personnel Qualifications
Staff Member Name	Anticipated Role in Supporting Work under the Contract	Discipline	Highest Degree	Office/Work Location	Years of Experience with the Prime Contractor	Years of Experience in the profession	Years of Experience working on Northeast Civil Works Water Resources Projects	Years of Experience working on USACE Civil Works Water Resources Projects	Years of Experience working on Military Construction and/or Environmental Master Plans	Number of EISs for which the Staff Member was the Lead Author	Number of EAs or cultural resources reports for which the Staff Member was the Lead Author

Acronyms
AER	Aquatic Ecosystem Restoration
CSRM	Coastal Storm Risk Management
EA	Environmental Assessment
EIS	Environmental Impact Statement
FRM	Flood Risk Management
HABS	Historic American Buildings Survey
HAER	Historic American Engineering Record
NEPA	National Environmental Policy Act
ROD	Record of Decision

Sheet1

Technical Expertise
Table 1 - NEPA Documents	Resources Affected by the Project

tc={1E64DC3C-445C-4E45-B2B6-9A72652CA2CC}: [Threaded comment]

Your version of Excel allows you to read this threaded comment; however, any edits to it will get removed if the file is opened in a newer version of Excel. Learn more: https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?linkid=870924

Comment:

Not trying to be difficult but I think we are slicing the bologna way to thin asking for this amount of detailed information that should otherwise be left to the contractor to provide when describing their NEPA experience. If all the offereors fill this out they are all going to look the same leaving little room to ifferentiate one contractors capabilites over another. Presenting this information in a matrix of thier own making speaks t thier abiltiy to present complex information in a clear and understandible format.

Project Name Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation) Project Location (State) Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA) Was this a USACE Civil Works Project? Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation) tc={939B8AA7-EE83-430B-A4CE-9D1DCC91446B}: [Threaded comment]

Comment:

Should we have an acronym list?

Reply:

Good idea. Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan) Date of FONSI or ROD, or last NEPA document For EISs, Number of Staff from the team listed in the published List of Preparers tc={F2285E40-6A47-4E7E-BD2B-3E6ED38BE1FD}: [Threaded comment]

Comment:

Prime or propsed team? It would seem valuable to know since the prime is responsible for the deliverable and is the POC even though the l;ions share of the work may done by the sub.

Upland Forest, Grassland, Shrub

Estuary/Marine

Freshwater Wetland

Salt Marsh

Rivers/Streams

Eelgrass

Disciplines Provided by the Offeror's Team (from list provided)

Number of EIS Scoping Meetings Led by the Offeror's Team

Number of Public Meetings Led by the Team

For EISs, Number of Public Comments Received (>100, <100, <50)

Ecological Model Applied? (provide the name)

List any statistical analyses performed

New Haven

Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA): Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA):

Add example projects if it helps you.

tc={939B8AA7-EE83-430B-A4CE-9D1DCC91446B}: [Threaded comment]

Comment:

Should we have an acronym list?

Reply:

Good idea.

Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA): Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA):

Add things if you feel they are missing. Suggest deletions as appropriate.

Navigation

EIS

Yes

Providence River

Navigation

EIS

Yes

2001

Yes

>100

Town Pond

Ecosystem Restoration

Yes

2000

Yes

HEP

Sagamore Marsh

Ecosystem Restoration

Yes

2000

Yes

HEP

Table 2 - Biological Assessments
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)	Federal Endangered Species Addressed

Table 3 - Essential Fish Habitat Assessments
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)

Table 4 - National Historic Preservation Act Surveys or Documents
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Type of Document (Eligibility Detemination, SAR, Phase 1, 2, or 3 Survey, Remoate Sesnin Surveeys, HABS/HAER)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)

Table 5 - Coastal Modeling Studies
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)

Table 6 - Ecological Risk Assessment
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. environmental remediation, flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)

Table 7 - Wetland Delineation
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. environmental remediation, flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)

Table 8 - Mitigation, Monitoring, and Adaptive Management Plan
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Type of NEPA Document (EIS or EA)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)	Primary Habitat(s)

Table 9 - Clean Air Act Emissions Studies
Project Name	Primary Purpose (e.g. flood risk reduction, transportation, ecosystem restoration, navigation)	Project Location (State)	Was this a USACE Civil Works Project?	Was this a Water Resources Project (i.e. CSRM, FRM, AER, Navigation)	Was this a Military Project (e.g. military construction or master plan)

Personnel Qualifications

Staff Member Name

tc={677EF741-7072-4386-8B9A-7DF0CF053EDC}: [Threaded comment]

Comment:

Identify thier affiliation Prime or Sub. and thier role in the contract. Just because they are on the list doesn;t mean the will be working on task orders.

tc={F2285E40-6A47-4E7E-BD2B-3E6ED38BE1FD}: [Threaded comment]

Comment:

Prime or propsed team? It would seem valuable to know since the prime is responsible for the deliverable and is the POC even though the l;ions share of the work may done by the sub.	Discipline	Highest Degree	Office/Work Location	Years of Experience with the Prime Contractor	Years of Experience in the profession	Years of Experience working on Northeast Civil Works Water Resources Projects	Years of Experience working on USACE Civil Works Water Resources Projects	Years of Experience working on Military Construction and/or Environmental Master Plans	Number of EISs for which the Staff Member was the Lead Author	Number of EAs for which the Staff Member was the Lead Author
	Larry Oliver

Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA): Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA):

Add yourself if it helps you.

tc={1E64DC3C-445C-4E45-B2B6-9A72652CA2CC}: [Threaded comment]

Comment:

Sheet2 Potential contract tasks Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA): Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA):

What tasks are we most likely to award?	How would we evaluate capability	How would we evaluate capability	How would we evaluate capability	How would we evaluate capability
	EIS	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	EA	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	BA	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	EFH assessment	Number (up to 10)
	Feasibility study?	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	Cultural resources assessment	Number (up to 10)
	Ecological risk assessment	Number (up to 10)
	Public meeting facilitation and logistics	Number (up to 10)
	EIS Public comment responses	Number (up to 10)
	Wetland delineation	Number (up to 10)
	Field survey - e.g. bat, bird, benthic, fish	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	Ecological benefits modeling	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	Coastal hydraulic modeling	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	Mitigation plan design and implementation	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	Monitoring plan design and implementation	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	Clean Air Act assessment	Number (up to 10) and relevance
	Report preparation	measured by the overall quality of the proposal
	Critical Line Items for a Cost Comparison

Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA): Oliver, Lawrence R CIV USARMY CENAE (USA):

What are the primary disciplines we would use most frequently?

Project manager

Wetland ecologist

Marine/estuarine ecologist

Wildlife biologist

Fish biologist

GIS specialist

Coastal engineer

Graphics specialist

Facilitator

Field technician

Indicate the number of (X) prepared over the last ten years and provide information on the 10 most relevant in the matrix

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated Oct 20, 2022.