Tabulation of Bids - LA ERFO FW BOCH 2016-2(1).pdf

Tabulation of Bids Report Date: 08/01/19

1 out of 3

Project No: LA ERFO FW BOCH 2016-2(1)

Project Name: Removal & Replacement of the Pearl River Boardwalk

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Solcitation No: 693C73-19-B-000025

Division: Eastern Federal Lands

State: LA County: Saint Tammany

Federal Land: Bogue Chitto National Wildlife Refuge Opened at: Sterling, VA

Opened by: Shirley Anderson

Date: 07/30/19

I certify that this Bid Tabulation accurately reflects the offers received for this solicitation.

Signed: _______________________________

Title: _______________________________

Date: _______________________________

Contract Awarded to: ____________________ Award Date: ____________________

Contractor Comment Bid Amount Responsive

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $362,430.00 2510 Hwy 53 Perkinston, MS 39573

Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $519,600.76 28601 Sundance Road Pass Christian, MS 38571

Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $563,284.00 116 Marlin Drive Slidell, LA 70461

Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $1,084,800.00 3721 N. Carnation Street Franklin Park, IL 60131

Engineer's Estimate $835,000.00

Shirley A. Anderson

Contract Specialist

07/30/2019

Gill's Crane & Dozer Services, Inc. 11/21/2019

Mistake in Bid

Contractor has math error at item No. A0200 Pay Item No. 55701-2000 (Bid Total is $755,125.00)

2 out of 3

Project No: LA ERFO FW BOCH 2016-2(1)

Project Name: Removal & Replacement of the Pearl River Boardwalk

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

A0100 15101-0000 MOBILIZATION

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC Lump Sum $10,000.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC Lump Sum $70,000.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. Lump Sum $50,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. Lump Sum $100,000.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $70,400.00

A0120 15201-0000 CONSTRUCTION SURVEY AND STAKING

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC Lump Sum $900.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC Lump Sum $23,000.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. Lump Sum $20,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. Lump Sum $20,000.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $18,000.00

A0140 20304-2000 REMOVAL OF BRIDGE (BOARDWALKS)

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC Lump Sum $85,000.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC Lump Sum $149,400.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. Lump Sum $50,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. Lump Sum $135,000.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $50,000.00

A0160 55101-2300 TREATED TIMBER PILE, IN PLACE

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $21.15 $84,600.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $51.52 $206,080.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $15.00 $60,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $25.00 $100,000.00 Engineer's Estimate 4,000 LNFT $45.00 $180,000.00

A0180 55601-1300 BRIDGE RAILING, TIMBER

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $44.50 $84,550.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $24.15 $45,885.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $65.00 $123,500.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $150.00 $285,000.00 Engineer's Estimate 1,900 LNFT $120.00 $228,000.00

A0200 55701-2000 STRUCTURAL TIMBER AND LUMBER, TREATED

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $3,020.00 $84,560.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $8.42 $235.76 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $8,928.00 $249,984.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $15,000.00 $420,000.00 Engineer's Estimate 28 MFBM $9,000.00 $252,000.00

3 out of 3

Project No: LA ERFO FW BOCH 2016-2(1)

Project Name: Removal & Replacement of the Pearl River Boardwalk

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

A0220 63502-3900 TEMPORARY TRAFFIC CONTROL, CONSTRUCTION SIGN (BOARDWALK CLOSED)

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $70.00 $280.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $100.00 $400.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $500.00 $2,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $100.00 $400.00 Engineer's Estimate 4 EACH $350.00 $1,400.00

A0240 63503-0300 TEMPORARY TRAFFIC CONTROL, BARRICADE TYPE 3

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $6.00 $240.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $15.00 $600.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $20.00 $800.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $100.00 $4,000.00 Engineer's Estimate 40 LNFT $30.00 $1,200.00

A0260 63701-0000 FIELD OFFICE

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $12,000.00 $12,000.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $22,000.00 $22,000.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $5,000.00 $5,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $20,000.00 $20,000.00 Engineer's Estimate 1 EACH $30,000.00 $30,000.00

A0280 64603-0000 FIXTURE (REMOVE AND RESET SIGN)

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $75.00 $150.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $500.00 $1,000.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $500.00 $1,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $100.00 $200.00 Engineer's Estimate 2 EACH $1,000.00 $2,000.00

A0300 64620-0000 REMOVE AND RESET (SIGN)

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $75.00 $150.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $500.00 $1,000.00 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $500.00 $1,000.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $100.00 $200.00 Engineer's Estimate 2 EACH $1,000.00 $2,000.00

Total Schedule - All Items

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $362,430.00 Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $519,600.76 Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $563,284.00 Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $1,084,800.00 Engineer's Estimate $835,000.00

Bid Error Report

1 out of 2

Project No: LA ERFO FW BOCH 2016-2(1)

Project Name: Removal & Replacement of the Pearl River Boardwalk

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Bid Item Check Pass

Bidder Line Item Number Bidder's Extension Computed Extension

Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC A0200 $235,760.00 $235.76

Bid Error Report

2 out of 2

Project No: LA ERFO FW BOCH 2016-2(1)

Project Name: Removal & Replacement of the Pearl River Boardwalk

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Bid Total Check Pass

Bidder Bidder's Bid Amount Computed Bid Amount Error

Gill's Crane & Dozer Service, Inc. $563,284.00 $563,284.00

Kovillic Construction Co., Inc. $1,084,800.00 $1,084,800.00

Gray Falcon Construction, LLC $362,430.00 $362,430.00

Greco Roofing & Construction, LLC $755,125.00 $519,600.76 X

The apparent low bidder is 56.60% below the engineer's estimate.