Tabulation of Bids - AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3) 11(1).pdf

Tabulation of Bids Report Date: 07/26/19

1 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Contractor Responsive?

Engineer's Estimate

Construction Solutions Group, LLC

GC Works, Inc.

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving

Base Schedule A

$2,200,000.00

$2,842,677.48

$3,512,746.40

$2,531,659.00

Base Schedule B

$1,220,000.00

$1,601,299.51

$2,870,103.78

$1,738,042.00

2 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Solcitation No: 693C73-19-B-000026

Division: Eastern Federal Lands

State: AZ County: Pima

Federal Land: Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge Opened at: Sterling, Va

Opened by: Shirley Anderson

Date: 07/25/19

I certify that this Bid Tabulation accurately reflects the offers received for this solicitation.

Signed: _______________________________

Title: _______________________________

Date: _______________________________

Contract Awarded to: ____________________ Award Date: ____________________

Contractor Comment Bid Amount Responsive

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $2,531,659.00 5624 N. 54th Avenue Glendale Arizona 85301

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $2,842,677.48 5512 Elk Valley Estates Dr St. Louis Missouri 63128

GC Works, Inc. $3,512,746.40 5933 NE Win Sivers Dr. Ste 205 Portland Oregon 97220

Engineer's Estimate $2,200,000.00

Shirley A. Anderson

Contract Specialist

07/25/2019

SWP Contracting & Paving 9/5/2019 Stormwater Plans, LLC

3 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

A0010 15101-0000 MOBILIZATION

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $720,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $381,694.31 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $1,007,262.83 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $248,990.00

A0020 15201-0000 CONSTRUCTION SURVEY AND STAKING

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $155,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $22,050.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $28,704.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $55,000.00

A0030 15401-0000 CONTRACTOR TESTING

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $85,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $14,700.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $28,704.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $54,000.00

A0040 15705-1400 SOIL EROSION CONTROL, FIBER ROLL

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $5.00 $7,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $22.05 $30,870.00 GC Works, Inc. $5.74 $8,036.00 Engineer's Estimate 1,400 LNFT $8.00 $11,200.00

A0050 15720-0000 STORM WATER POLLUTION PREVENTION PLAN

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $15,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $7,350.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $7,176.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $10,000.00

A0060 20103-0000 CLEARING AND GRUBBING

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $0.60 $13,800.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $2.57 $59,110.00 GC Works, Inc. $1.25 $28,750.00 Engineer's Estimate 23,000 SQYD $12.00 $276,000.00

4 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

A0070 20301-2400 REMOVAL OF SIGN

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $85.00 $765.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $183.75 $1,653.75 GC Works, Inc. $93.29 $839.61 Engineer's Estimate 9 EACH $150.00 $1,350.00

A0080 20301-3400 REMOVAL OF WHEELSTOP

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $105.00 $1,260.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $142.59 $1,711.08 GC Works, Inc. $114.82 $1,377.84 Engineer's Estimate 12 EACH $40.00 $480.00

A0090 20401-0000 ROADWAY EXCAVATION

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $15.00 $15,900.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $35.87 $38,022.20 GC Works, Inc. $18.72 $19,843.20 Engineer's Estimate 1,060 CUYD $45.00 $47,700.00

A0100 30101-4000 AGGREGATE BASE GRADING C OR D

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $60.00 $180,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $88.45 $265,350.00 GC Works, Inc. $81.12 $243,360.00 Engineer's Estimate 3,000 TON $45.00 $135,000.00

A0120 30303-3000 ROADWAY RECONDITIONING

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $1.40 $1,134.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $9.80 $7,938.00 GC Works, Inc. $2.50 $2,025.00 Engineer's Estimate 810 SQYD $3.00 $2,430.00

A0130 30402-1000 FULL DEPTH RECLAMATION, METHOD 1 (4-INCHES)

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $2.00 $50,400.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $4.81 $121,212.00 GC Works, Inc. $3.12 $78,624.00 Engineer's Estimate 25,200 SQYD $4.00 $100,800.00

5 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

A0140 40101-0600 ASPHALT CONCRETE PAVEMENT, GYRATORY MIX, 1/2-INCH NOMINAL MAXIMUM SIZE AGGREGATE, 0.3 TO <3

MILLION ESAL (PG 70-10) (ROUGHNESS TYPE III B OR TYPE IV)

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $130.00 $910,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $241.08 $1,687,560.00 GC Works, Inc. $243.36 $1,703,520.00 Engineer's Estimate 7,000 TON $160.00 $1,120,000.00

A0170 40601-0000 FOG SEAL

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $675.00 $10,125.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $2,131.50 $31,972.50 GC Works, Inc. $936.00 $14,040.00 Engineer's Estimate 15 TON $700.00 $10,500.00

A0180 41101-1000 PRIME COAT, METHOD 1

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $675.00 $10,125.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $2,572.50 $38,587.50 GC Works, Inc. $936.00 $14,040.00 Engineer's Estimate 15 TON $1,000.00 $15,000.00

A0190 41201-0000 TACK COAT

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $675.00 $10,125.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $2,572.50 $38,587.50 GC Works, Inc. $936.00 $14,040.00 Engineer's Estimate 15 TON $700.00 $10,500.00

A0200 50101-2600 MINOR CONCRETE PAVEMENT, PLAIN, 6-INCH DEPTH (COLORED CONCRETE)

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $2,250.00 $33,750.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $302.92 $4,543.80 GC Works, Inc. $14.35 $215.25 Engineer's Estimate 15 SQYD $100.00 $1,500.00

A0210 60901-0000 CURB, CONCRETE

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $250.00 $17,500.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $53.92 $3,774.40 GC Works, Inc. $71.76 $5,023.20 Engineer's Estimate 70 LNFT $50.00 $3,500.00

6 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

A0220 60915-1000 WHEELSTOP, CONCRETE

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $125.00 $3,125.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $170.64 $4,266.00 GC Works, Inc. $140.65 $3,516.25 Engineer's Estimate 25 EACH $120.00 $3,000.00

A0230 61501-0200 SIDEWALK, COLORED CONCRETE

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $400.00 $74,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $128.70 $23,809.50 GC Works, Inc. $717.60 $132,756.00 Engineer's Estimate 185 SQYD $130.00 $24,050.00

A0240 61509-0000 DETECTABLE WARNING PANELS

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $5,000.00 $10,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $926.22 $1,852.44 GC Works, Inc. $143.52 $287.04 Engineer's Estimate 2 SQYD $400.00 $800.00

A0250 63302-0000 SIGN SYSTEM

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $130.00 $9,100.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $147.00 $10,290.00 GC Works, Inc. $146.39 $10,247.30 Engineer's Estimate 70 SQFT $60.00 $4,200.00

A0260 63316-1000 REMOVE AND RESET SIGN

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $450.00 $900.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $367.50 $735.00 GC Works, Inc. $502.32 $1,004.64 Engineer's Estimate 2 EACH $400.00 $800.00

A0270 63401-0300 PAVEMENT MARKINGS, TYPE B, SOLID

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $0.80 $21,600.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $0.74 $19,980.00 GC Works, Inc. $4.31 $116,370.00 Engineer's Estimate 27,000 LNFT $0.25 $6,750.00

7 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

A0280 63405-0850 PAVEMENT MARKINGS, TYPE B, ACCESSIBILITY SYMBOL

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $350.00 $1,050.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $1,102.50 $3,307.50 GC Works, Inc. $574.08 $1,722.24 Engineer's Estimate 3 EACH $150.00 $450.00

A0290 63501-0000 TEMPORARY TRAFFIC CONTROL

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $50,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $14,700.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $29,780.40 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $36,000.00

A0300 63701-0000 FIELD OFFICE

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $125,000.00 $125,000.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $7,050.00 $7,050.00 GC Works, Inc. $11,481.60 $11,481.60 Engineer's Estimate 1 EACH $20,000.00 $20,000.00

Total Schedule - All Items

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $2,531,659.00 Construction Solutions Group, LLC $2,842,677.48 GC Works, Inc. $3,512,746.40 Engineer's Estimate $2,200,000.00

8 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: B

Schedule Type: Base

Solcitation No: 693C73-19-B-000026

Division: Eastern Federal Lands

State: AZ County: Pima

Federal Land: Buenos Aires National Wildlife Refuge Opened at: Sterling, Va

Opened by: Shirley Anderson

Date: 07/25/19

I certify that this Bid Tabulation accurately reflects the offers received for this solicitation.

Signed: _______________________________

Title: _______________________________

Date: _______________________________

Contract Awarded to: ____________________ Award Date: ____________________

Contractor Comment Bid Amount Responsive

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $1,601,299.51 5512 Elk Valley Estates Dr St. Louis Missouri 63128

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $1,738,042.00 5624 N. 54th Avenue Glendale Arizona 85301

GC Works, Inc. $2,870,103.78 5933 NE Win Sivers Dr. Ste 205 Portland Oregon 97220

Engineer's Estimate $1,220,000.00

Shirley A. Anderson

Contract Specialist

07/25/2019

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting & Paving 09/05/2019

9 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: B

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

B0010 15101-0000 MOBILIZATION

Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $28,953.41 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $270,000.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $1,007,262.83 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $144,560.00

B0020 15201-0000 CONSTRUCTION SURVEY AND STAKING

Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $2,940.00 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $150,000.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $28,704.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $77,000.00

B0030 15401-0000 CONTRACTOR TESTING

Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $7,350.00 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $50,000.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $28,704.00 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $34,000.00

B0040 15705-1400 SOIL EROSION CONTROL, FIBER ROLL

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $8.40 $11,760.00 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $5.00 $7,000.00 GC Works, Inc. $5.74 $8,036.00 Engineer's Estimate 1,400 LNFT $8.00 $11,200.00

B0050 20103-0000 CLEARING AND GRUBBING

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $10.36 $4,869.20 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $0.60 $282.00 GC Works, Inc. $1.25 $587.50 Engineer's Estimate 470 SQYD $12.00 $5,640.00

B0060 20301-2400 REMOVAL OF SIGN

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $183.65 $1,101.90 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $85.00 $510.00 GC Works, Inc. $93.29 $559.74 Engineer's Estimate 6 EACH $150.00 $900.00

10 out of 10

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: B

Schedule Type: Base

Line Item Pay Item No. Description Quantity Unit Unit Price Amount

Number

B0080 30110-0000 AGGREGATE SURFACE COURSE

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $62.92 $1,195,480.00 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $58.00 $1,102,000.00 GC Works, Inc. $81.12 $1,541,280.00 Engineer's Estimate 19,000 TON $35.00 $665,000.00

B0090 30303-3000 ROADWAY RECONDITIONING

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $3.68 $334,880.00 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $1.40 $127,400.00 GC Works, Inc. $2.50 $227,500.00 Engineer's Estimate 91,000 SQYD $3.00 $273,000.00

B0100 63302-0000 SIGN SYSTEM

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $147.00 $6,615.00 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $130.00 $5,850.00 GC Works, Inc. $146.39 $6,587.55 Engineer's Estimate 45 SQFT $60.00 $2,700.00

B0110 63501-0000 TEMPORARY TRAFFIC CONTROL

Construction Solutions Group, LLC Lump Sum $7,350.00 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving Lump Sum $25,000.00 GC Works, Inc. Lump Sum $20,882.16 Engineer's Estimate ALL LPSM Lump Sum $6,000.00

Total Schedule - All Items

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $1,601,299.51 Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $1,738,042.00 GC Works, Inc. $2,870,103.78 Engineer's Estimate $1,220,000.00

Bid Error Report

1 out of 4

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Bid Item Check Pass

Bidder Line Item Number Bidder's Extension Computed Extension

GC Works, Inc. A0040 $8,037.12 $8,036.00

GC Works, Inc. A0270 $116,251.20 $116,370.00

GC Works, Inc. A0200 $215.28 $215.25

GC Works, Inc. A0220 $3,516.24 $3,516.25

GC Works, Inc. A0070 $839.59 $839.61

GC Works, Inc. A0060 $28,704.00 $28,750.00

GC Works, Inc. A0120 $2,021.76 $2,025.00

GC Works, Inc. A0080 $1,377.79 $1,377.84

GC Works, Inc. A0250 $10,247.33 $10,247.30

2 out of 4

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: A

Schedule Type: Base

Bid Total Check Pass

Bidder Bidder's Bid Amount Computed Bid Amount Error

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $2,842,677.48 $2,842,677.48

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $2,531,659.00 $2,531,659.00

GC Works, Inc. $3,512,579.46 $3,512,746.40 X

The apparent low bidder is 15.08% above the engineer's estimate.

3 out of 4

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: B

Schedule Type: Base

Bid Item Check Pass

Bidder Line Item Number Bidder's Extension Computed Extension

GC Works, Inc. B0060 $559.73 $559.74

GC Works, Inc. B0040 $8,037.12 $8,036.00

GC Works, Inc. B0090 $227,136.00 $227,500.00

GC Works, Inc. B0100 $6,587.57 $6,587.55

GC Works, Inc. B0050 $586.56 $587.50

4 out of 4

Project No: AZ FTFW BUAI 10(3), 11(1)

Project Name: Rehabilitation of Refuge Entrance Road, Pronghorn Tour Loop Road, and Visitor Center

Parking Area, and construction of new Overflow Parking Area

Schedule: B

Schedule Type: Base

Bid Total Check Pass

Bidder Bidder's Bid Amount Computed Bid Amount Error

Construction Solutions Group, LLC $1,601,299.51 $1,601,299.51

Stormwater Plans, LLC dba SWP Contracting and Paving $1,738,042.00 $1,738,042.00

GC Works, Inc. $2,869,739.42 $2,870,103.78 X

The apparent low bidder is 31.25% above the engineer's estimate.