Scoring Summary

This is a Scoring Summary document evaluating multiple consulting firms for a contract opportunity. The evaluation compared eleven bidders across scoring metrics including best value scores, average questionnaire ratings, total bid hourly rates, and price scores. The firms evaluated were Krevolin & Horst, LLC; Littler Mendelson PC; Seyfarth Shaw LLP; Consilio, LLC; Morris, Manning & Martin, LLP; Church Church Hittle + Antrim; Title IX Solutions, LLC; Grand River Solutions; The NCHERM Group, LLC (TNG Consulting); Jamet Inc; and DCJ Global Management Solutions, LLC.

The scoring analysis reveals that Krevolin & Horst, LLC achieved the highest best value score of 585.45 with an average questionnaire rating of 569.03 and an hourly rate of $475.00, resulting in a price score of 16.42. The lowest-priced bidder, DCJ Global Management Solutions, LLC, submitted an hourly rate of $78.00 with a price score of 100.00, but received the lowest average questionnaire rating of 136.13 and best value score of 311.61. Littler Mendelson PC and Seyfarth Shaw LLP tied for the second-highest best value scores at 565.99, with hourly rates of $295.00 and $485.00 respectively. A notation indicates an adjusted price for Krevolin & Horst, LLC to reflect a corrected hourly rate.