Schedule B - Pricing Comparison RFP 26-1634.pdf

This is a Schedule B Pricing Comparison document for RFP 260000001634, a culvert rehabilitation and drainage restoration project issued by the State of Michigan. The project is structured as an as-needed contract covering seven geographic regions: Bay Region, Grand Region, Metro Region, North Region, Southwest Region, Superior Region, and University Region. The pricing comparison evaluates two bidders—Corby Energy Services, Inc. and Upper Peninsula Rubber Co Inc dba Tunnel Vision Pipeline Services—across all regional service areas to determine the most cost-effective contractor for the state's culvert rehabilitation and drainage restoration needs.

Corby Energy Services, Inc. submitted a total contract estimate of $4,356,188.95, with regional pricing ranging from $562,665.00 to $901,318.50. Upper Peninsula Rubber Co Inc dba Tunnel Vision Pipeline Services submitted a higher total estimate of $6,624,065.25, with regional pricing ranging from $826,080.75 to $1,106,580.75. The pricing comparison indicates significant cost variations between the two bidders across different regions, with Corby Energy Services offering substantially lower pricing in all regions, particularly in the Superior Region where their bid was $74,762.25 lower than their competitor. This document supports Michigan's Intent to Award decision by presenting the comparative analysis necessary for contractor selection.