RFR-2004-OCA-001A.doc

DOC document 66 KB Posted

Attached to
Mediators and Experts for The Massachusetts Municipal-Industry Wireless Collaborative for Resolution
Solicitation number
S15421-vCurrent
Issued by
Massachusetts

About this file

This document is a Request for Response (RFR) from the Massachusetts Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation (OCABR) to establish a pool of pre-qualified mediators and experts to resolve disputes between municipalities and wireless carriers related to the siting of wireless telecommunication facilities. The RFR seeks to qualify mediators with experience in land use, zoning law, and the wireless industry, as well as experts in various fields such as radio frequency engineering, land use, zoning, and environmental impacts. The OCABR will provide administrative services for the program, and mediators and experts will be selected on a rolling enrollment basis. The initial contract term is three years with two optional two-year renewals.

The RFR is a fee-for-service contract, where the parties requesting mediation will pay the mediator and expert fees directly. There is no maximum or minimum obligation amount, and no federal funds will be used. Bidders must submit proposed fee schedules, including a flat fee for the first four hours and an hourly rate for additional time. The OCABR reserves the right to limit the number of contractors in a particular geographic region based on capacity. The RFR also encourages participation from Minority and Women-owned Business Enterprises (M/WBEs).

View the file

Other files

File Type Posted
scf2001.doc DOC document
c_tc.doc DOC document
S15421-vCurrent_OD.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
Summary_015421.html HTML file
RFR-2004-OCA-001-Updated-10.7.2004.doc DOC document
nirel.doc DOC document
w-9.doc DOC document

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation

Request for Response for Mediators and Experts for

The Massachusetts Municipal-Industry Wireless Collaborative for Resolution of Certain Wireless Facility Siting Disputes

Procuring Department: Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation

Address: 10 Park Plaza, Suite 5170, Boston, MA 02116

Telephone #: 617-973-8708 Fax #: 617-973-8799

RFR File Name/Title: Mediators and Experts for the Massachusetts

Municipal-Industry Wireless Collaborative for Resolution of Certain Wireless Facility Siting Disputes

RFR File Number: RFR-2004-OCA-001

Procurement Team Leader/RFR Contact Person: Daniela Messina

Procurement Management Team (PMT)/Category: Professional Services

REQUIRED AND OPTIONAL RFR SPECIFICATIONS

In general, most of the required contractual stipulations are referenced in the Standard

Contract Form and the Commonwealth Terms and Conditions (either version). However, the following RFR provisions must appear in all Commonwealth competitive procurements conducted under 801 CMR 21.00:

REQUIRED RFR PROVISIONS

The terms of 801 CMR 21.00: Procurement of Commodities and Services (and 808 CMR

1.00: Compliance, Reporting and Auditing for Human and Social Services, if applicable) are incorporated by reference into this RFR. Words used in this RFR shall have the meanings defined in 801 CMR 21.00 (and 808 CMR 1.00, if applicable). Additional definitions may also be identified in this RFR. Unless otherwise specified in this RFR, all communications, responses, and documentation must be in English, all measurements must be provided in feet, inches, and pounds and all cost proposals or figures in U.S.

currency. All responses must be submitted in accordance with the specific terms of this

RFR. No electronic responses may be submitted in response to this RFR.

Bidder Communication. Bidders are prohibited from communicating directly with any employee of the procuring department except as specified in this RFR, and no other individual Commonwealth employee or representative is authorized to provide any information or respond to any question or inquiry concerning this RFR. Bidders may contact Daniela Messina in the event this RFR is incomplete or the bidder is having trouble obtaining any required attachments electronically through Comm-

PASS.

Reasonable Accommodation. Bidders with disabilities or hardships that seek reasonable accommodation, which may include the receipt of RFR information in an alternative format, must communicate such requests in writing to the contact person. Requests for accommodation will be addressed on a case by case basis. A bidder requesting accommodation must submit a written statement, which describes the bidder’s disability and the requested accommodation to the contact person for the RFR. The PMT reserves the right to reject unreasonable requests.

Public Records. All responses and information submitted in response to this RFR are subject to the Massachusetts Public Records Law, M.G.L., Chapter 66, Section 10, and to

Chapter 4, Section 7, Subsection 26. Any statements in submitted responses that are inconsistent with these statutes shall be disregarded.

Best Value Selection and Negotiation. The PMT may select the response(s), which demonstrates the best value, overall, including proposed alternatives that will achieve the procurement goals of the department. The PMT and a selected bidder, or a contractor, may negotiate a change in any element of contract performance or cost identified in the original RFR or the selected bidder’s or contractor’s response which results in lower costs or a more cost effective or better value than was presented in the selected bidder’s or contractor’s original response.

Costs. Costs, which are not specifically identified in the bidder’s response, and accepted by a department as part of a contract, will not be compensated under any contract awarded pursuant to this RFR. The Commonwealth will not be responsible for any costs or expenses incurred by bidders responding to this RFR.

Comm-PASS. If this RFR has been distributed electronically using the Comm-PASS system, RFR attachments that are referenced will be found either as a separate .pdf file along with the RFR, or are found in the "Forms and Information" section at:

(http://www.comm-pass.com/comm-pass/forms.html). Bidders are solely responsible for obtaining and completing required attachments that are identified in this RFR and for checking Comm-PASS for any addenda or modifications that are subsequently made to this RFR or attachments. The Commonwealth and its subdivisions accept no liability and will provide no accommodation to bidders who fail to check for amended RFRs and submit inadequate or incorrect responses. Bidders are advised to check the "last change" field on the summary page of RFRs for which they intend to submit a response to ensure that they have the most recent RFR files. Bidders may not alter (manually or electronically) the RFR language or any RFR component files. Modifications to the body of the RFR, specifications, terms and conditions, or which change the intent of this RFR are prohibited and may disqualify a response.

Northern Ireland Notice and Certification. All bidders must complete the Northern Ireland

Notice and Certification form to satisfy M.G.L. c.7 section 22C, which states that no state agency may procure commodities or services from any bidder employing ten (10) or more employees in an office or other facility located in Northern Ireland unless the bidder certifies through the notice and certification form that if it employs ten or more employees in Northern Ireland, a) the bidder does not discriminate in employment, compensation or the terms, conditions and privileges of employment on account of religious or political belief, b) the bidder promotes religious tolerance within the workplace and the eradication of any manifestations of religious and other illegal discrimination and, c) the bidder is not engaged in the manufacture, distribution or sale of firearms, munitions, including rubber or plastic bullets, tear gas, armored vehicles or military aircraft for use or deployment in any activity in Northern Ireland.

Subcontracting Policies. Prior approval of the department is required for any subcontracted service of the contract. Contractors are responsible for the satisfactory performance and adequate oversight of its subcontractors. Subcontractors are required to meet the same state and federal financial and program reporting requirements and are held to the same reimbursable cost standards as contractors.

Affirmative Market Program. Massachusetts Executive Order 390 established a policy to promote the award of state contracts in a manner that develops and strengthens Minority and Women Business Enterprises (M/WBEs). As a result, M/WBEs are strongly encouraged to submit responses to this RFR, either as prime vendors, as joint venture partners, or as subcontractors.

Non-M/WBE bidders are strongly encouraged to develop creative initiatives to help foster new business relationships with M/WBEs within the primary industries affected by this RFR. The highest number of points will be awarded for responses that clearly illustrate how the proposed business relationship(s) will result in the development and growth of M/WBEs within these primary industries. A lesser number of points will be awarded for traditional subcontracting relationships. The least number of points will be awarded for ancillary uses of M/WBEs.

In order to satisfy this section, the bidder must submit: the names, addresses, phone numbers and contact persons of each M/WBE firm; a description of each business relationship to be established; and the actual dollar amounts, or percentages, to be awarded to each M/WBE firm. MBE and WBE firms must submit a copy of their

SOMWBA certification letter for the current period. A directory of SOMWBA certified firms is available via the Internet at www.magnet.state.ma.us/somwba.

A Minority Business Enterprise (MBE) or a Woman Business Enterprises (WBE) is defined as a business that has been certified as such by the State Office of Minority and

Women Business Assistance (SOMWBA). Minority and women-owned firms that are not currently SOMWBA-certified but would like to be considered as an M/WBE for this

RFR should apply for certification. A fast track application is available, and will be considered for the purposes of this RFR. For further information on SOMWBA certification contact the State Office of Minority and Women Business Assistance at

(617) 727-8692 or via the Internet at www.magnet.state.ma.us/somwba.

Information Technology - Clarification of Language in Section 11, Indemnification of the

Commonwealth Terms and Conditions. Required for the following object codes within the “Expenditure Classification Handbook” as issued by the Office of the Comptroller:

E08 - Telecommunication Services, Voice

EE8 - Telecommunication Services, Data

E09 - Software purchases

H03 - IT consulting & Maintenance

J08 - IT Cabling/installation & maintenance

K01 - IT equipment purchases

L01 - IT TELP

L21 - IT Rental or Lease

L41 - IT Technical Support

Pursuant to Section 11, Indemnification of the Commonwealth Terms and Conditions, the term “other damages” shall include, but shall not be limited to, the reasonable costs the

Commonwealth incurs to repair, return, replace or seek cover (purchase of comparable substitute commodities and services) under a Contract. “Other damages” shall not include damages to the Commonwealth as a result of third party claims, provided, however, that the foregoing in no way limits the Commonwealth’s right of recovery for personal injury or property damages or patent and copyright infringement under Section

11, nor the Commonwealth’s ability to join the Contractor as a third party defendant.

Further, the term “other damages” shall not include, and in no event shall the Contractor be liable for damages for the Commonwealth’s use of Contractor provided products or services, loss of Commonwealth records, or data (or other intangible property), loss of use of equipment, lost revenue, lost savings or lost profits of the Commonwealth. In no event shall “other damages” exceed the greater of $100,000, or two times the value of the product or service (as defined in the Contract Scope of Work) that is the subject of the claim. Section 11. sets forth the Contractor’s entire liability under a Contract. Nothing in this section shall limit the Commonwealth’s ability to negotiate higher limitations of liability in a particular Contract, provided that any such limitation must specifically reference Section 11 of the Commonwealth Terms and Conditions.

OPTIONAL RFR PROVISIONS

Estimated Provisions. The Commonwealth makes no guarantee that any commodities or services will be purchased from any contract resulting from this RFR. Any estimates or past procurement volumes referenced in this RFR are included only for the convenience of bidders, and are not to be relied upon as any indication of future purchase levels.

Alternatives. A response which fails to meet any material term or condition of the RFR, including the submission of required attachments, may lose points or be deemed unresponsive and disqualified. Unless otherwise specified, bidders may submit responses proposing alternatives, which provide equivalent, better, or more cost-effective performance than achievable under the stated RFR specifications. These alternatives may include related commodities or services that may be available to enhance performance during the period of the contract. The response should describe how any alternative achieves substantially equivalent or better performance to that of the RFR specifications.

The department will determine if a proposed alternative method of performance achieves substantially equivalent or better performance. The goal of this RFR is to provide the best value of commodities and services to achieve the procurement goals of the department. Bidders that propose discounts, uncharged commodities and services or other benefits in addition to the RFR specifications may receive a preference or additional points under this RFR as specified.

Contract Expansion. If additional funds become available during the contract duration period, the department reserves the right to increase the maximum obligation to some or all contracts executed as a result of this RFR or to execute contracts with contractors not funded in the initial selection process, subject to available funding, satisfactory contract performance and service or commodity need.

Environmentally Preferable Products and Services. The department and contractor(s) may negotiate during the contract term to permit the substitution or addition of

Environmentally Preferable Products (EPPs) when such products become available at a competitive cost and satisfy the department’s performance needs. Unless otherwise specified in the RFR, during evaluation of responses, an EPP may be considered best value even when the price is greater than that of a non-EPP (recommended not to exceed

10% in price). Bidders are encouraged to submit information to identify any and all environmental attributes of the product or services being procured, even when such attributes are not being required.

1. Overview and Purpose of this Request:

The Massachusetts Municipal-Industry Wireless Collaborative has agreed that a process should be put in place to facilitate the settlement of certain disputes between municipalities and wireless carriers related to the siting of wireless telecommunication facilities whereby the disputes may be submitted to voluntary state-certified mediation. The Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation (OCABR) will provide the daily administrative services for the program, and is seeking to qualify a pool of mediators to mediate and conciliate cases, and if requested by the parties, to render non-binding decisions. In addition, the OCABR is seeking to qualify a pool of experts that may be used as necessary by the mediator to provide expertise with regard to certain matters.

2. Acquisition Method:

The acquisition method for the RFR is “Fee for Service.”

3. Number Of Contracts Needed:

We are seeking to qualify a pool of mediators and experts adequate for the number of cases handled each year. This is a “Rolling Enrollment” RFR, which means that after the initial award process (Summer of 2003), bidders may submit responses at any time during the life of the procurement. On a quarterly or as-needed basis, the OCABR will evaluate these responses utilizing the same criteria used in the initial award process. The OCABR reserves the right to limit the number of contractors in a particular geographical region, and has the sole discretion in determining adequate capacity.

4. Departments that May Contract under this RFR:

The Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation will use this contract exclusively.

5. Anticipated Duration of Contract:

The initial duration of this contract will be three (3) years. There will be two (2) renewal options of two (2) years each option. Contractors added after the initial selection period will join the existing contractors in the remainder of their terms.

6. Anticipated Expenditures, Funding or Compensation for Expected Duration:

The anticipated expenditures relating to the procurement shall be determined by the bidder’s fee schedule, the actual number of mediations requested and held each year and contributions of the parties. The contract will not have a maximum or minimum obligation amount, as it is a “Fee for Service” contract. The parties requesting mediation will pay the mediation fees and expert fees as necessary; these fees will be paid directly to the mediators and experts. There will be no federal funds used in this contract.

7. Contract Performance and Specifications: Scope of Contract:

This RFR will establish a list of pre-qualified mediators that will be available to mediate disputes between municipalities and wireless carriers. The Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation (OCABR) will provide the centralized administration of the Massachusetts Municipal-Industry Wireless Collaborative mediation cases, including, but not limited to, scheduling hearings with pre-qualified mediators, sending appropriate notices and decisions to the parties, and other administrative duties. Mediators will resolve disputes between municipalities and wireless carriers by issuing a final, typed-written non-binding determination.

This RFR will also establish a list of pre-qualified experts that will be available to both parties as necessary. During consultation with the parties, the mediator may select an appropriate expert based on the needs and specific matters in dispute. If an expert is needed, the parties shall share the cost of the expert fees equally.

A. Mediator Appointment: The OCABR will provide the parties with a list of pre-qualified mediators by county, with each county roster listing mediators in numerical order. The parties shall choose a mediator within 10 days from receiving the list. If the parties do not agree on a mediator, the OCABR shall assign a mediator for the parties. All mediation hearings must take place within a 50-mile radius of the property in dispute, unless the parties agree otherwise.

Mediator appointments when the parties do not agree shall be selected in numerical order from the applicable county roster. In the event that the first mediator is not available, that mediator will relinquish his or her appointment, and the next numerically listed mediator will be appointed. If a conflict exists based on information provided on the Mediator Disclosure Form at the time OCABR assigns a mediator to a case, either party has the option to request another mediator.

B. Mediator Compensation: Mediators will be compensated directly by both parties. Bidders must submit a proposed fee schedule. The parties will each be responsible for paying fees directly to the mediator. The fee for service shall consist of a four-hour time period including preparation for hearing, actual hearing time and the preparation of an agreement document or execution of a typed-written, non-binding determination (if parties request this).

An oral hearing should last no longer than 4 hours. If the mediator determines that additional hearing time is necessary to obtain sufficient evidence to render a decision, the mediator may extend the hearing time with the agreement of the parties. The mediator is authorized to charge an additional fee per hour if the preparation, hearing and agreement or decision completion extends beyond 4 hours. The total additional fee will be shared equally by both parties and paid directly to the mediator.

C. Mediator Duties: Mediators shall seek to have the parties agree to a resolution of the matter and reduce the parties’ agreement to writing; if requested by the parties the mediator shall issue a typed-written, non-binding decision with findings of fact which provide a basis for their decisions. Mediation shall be conducted in a manner which allows for a full and fair proceeding, even if a party is not represented by counsel. Mediators shall ensure the personal objectivity and impartiality of the mediation process, and may not have any personal interest in the outcome of the hearing, nor hold any prejudice or bias toward any party or participant.

D. Mediator Qualifications:

1. Mediation Experience: at least one (1) of the following:

A. Minimum of 3 years of professional experience; or

B. Affiliation with and accountability to a dispute resolution organization in existence for at least 3 years; or

C. Present or past Appointment to mediate or conciliate by a judicial or governmental body.

2. Demonstrated ability in the following areas:

A. Land use and zoning law

B. General understanding of the wireless industry

3. Adherence to the Model Standards of Conduct for Mediators prepared by a joint committee composed of two delegates each from the American Arbitration Association, the American Bar Association and the Association for Conflict Resolution. The OCABR reserves the right to remove a mediator from the established list due to unsatisfactory performance.

E. Expert Appointment:

Subject to agreement of the parties, the mediator may select an appropriate expert based on the needs and specific matters in dispute. If a conflict exists based on information provided on the Expert Disclosure Form at the time the mediator selects an expert, either party has the option to request another expert.

F. Expert Compensation:

Experts will be compensated directly by both parties. Bidders must submit a proposed fee schedule. The parties will each be responsible for paying the fee directly to the expert.

G. Expert Duties:

Experts shall be objective and impartial in the mediation process, and may not have any personal interest in the outcome of the hearing, nor hold any prejudice or bias toward any party or participant.

H. Expert Qualifications:

1. Expert Experience: at least one (1) of the following:

(A) Radio frequency engineers

(B) Land use

(C) Zoning

(D) Environment

(E) Public Health

(F) Civil Engineering

(G) Planning

(H) Design/architecture

(I) Noise expert

(J) Other related areas

8. Evaluation Criteria

The Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation will qualify bidders for inclusion on the mediator or expert roster based upon the following criteria:

a. The bidder’s qualification and experience as a mediator or expert;

b. The bidder’s ability to provide the services outlined in Section 7 “Scope of Services;”

c. The fee for service cost schedule for the first four hours and the hourly rate for any additional hours proposed by the bidder;

d. The availability of the bidder to provide mediation or expert services;

e. Completion of all required attachments; and

f. The quality of the bidder’s response.

9. Instructions for Submission of Responses:

Bidders applying for inclusion on the list of mediators or experts for the Massachusetts Municipal-Industry Wireless Collaborative must submit the following:

· A resume detailing his/her mediation or expert background and experience;

· A proposed fee schedule including a flat fee for the first four hours and an hourly rate for additional hours; there is to be no charge for travel time;

· A description of the geographic region in which he/she may be available for hearings, which may be satisfied by completing the “County Checklist” attached to this RFR;

· An estimate of the number of mediation cases for which he/she would be willing to serve during a calendar year; and

· An estimate of the number of cases for which the expert would be willing to serve during a calendar year.

DEADLINE FOR WRITTEN INQUIRES:

Bidders should submit any written questions to Daniela Messina via email (Daniela.Messina@state.ma.us) no later than Monday, July 21st at 4:00pm.

Responses will be posted by Friday, July 25th at 4:00PM via email.

Responses must be sent to:

Daniela Messina, Deputy General Counsel

Office of Consumer Affairs and Business Regulation

10 Park Plaza

Boston, MA 02116

Phone: (617) 973-8708

Fax: (617) 973-8799

This is a “Rolling Enrollment” RFR, which means that after the initial award process

(Summer of 2003), bidders may submit responses at any time during the life of the procurement. To be considered for the initial award process, the deadline for responses is Friday, August 1, 2003 at 4:00PM.

A bidders conference will not be offered.

After the initial award (Summer of 2003), written questions for “Rolling

Enrollment” bidders may be submitted by e-mail (Daniela.Messina@state.ma.us), facsimile, or regular mail. The bidder is responsible for verifying receipt of the fax and e-mail.

10. RFR Attachments

All Bidders will be required to complete execute and return the following documents:

1. Commonwealth Terms and Conditions.

2. Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification (W-9)

3. Commonwealth Standard Contract Form

4. Northern Ireland Notice and Certification

PAGE

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .