RFP 70CMSW23R00000009 Attachment 6- OFTP Individual Scoring Worksheet.pdf

Source Evaluation Plan Attachment 2.B

TECHNICAL EVALUATION BOARD INDIVIDUAL WORKSHEET Sample_________________________

.223 REMINGTON DUTY AMMUNITION (62-64 GRAIN) Raters Name_____________________

Date___________________________

Quality Management System 3.3 Pass / Fail

Sample Size 3.4.1 Pass / Fail

Documentation 3.5

Missing any documentation = 0

Supplied all required documentation = 2

Packaging 3.6

Missing any packaging requirements = 0

Met all packaging requirements = 2

Cartridge 3.7 Pass / Fail

Pressure 3.8 Pass / Fail

Bullet Push 3.9 Pass / Fail

Velocity 3.10

Standard Deviation > 30 fps = Fail

> 10 fps, ≤ 30 fps = 0

≤ 10 fps = 1

Precision Grouping - Test Barrel 3.11.1

Extreme Spread > 1.25" = Fail

> 1", ≤ 1.25" = 0 T

> 0.75", ≤ 1" = 1

≤ 0.75" = 2 O

Evidence of keyholing Pass / Fail

Page 1 Total

RFP 70CMSW23R00000009/ ATTACHMENT 6

Comments

Ba si c Co m pl ia nc e

ScoreGuidance SOW Section

M aj or R eq ui re m en ts

/7

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Page 1 of 4

Raters Name_____________________ Sample_________________________

Terminal Ballistics 3.12

Bare Gelatin

Penetration 3.12.1.1 < 12" = Fail

5 shot ave. > 18" = Fail

≥ 12", < 14" = 0 T

≥ 14", ≤ 16" = 3 O

≥ 16", ≤ 18" = 0 T

All shots ≥ 12" = 2 O

Shot exit gel block = Fail

Bullet Expansion 3.12.1.2 < 190% = Fail

≥ 190%, < 210% = 0 T

≥ 210%, < 230% = 1

≥ 230% = 2 O

Retained Bullet Mass 3.12.1.3 < 90% = Fail

≥ 90%, < 95% = 0 T

≥ 95% = 1 O

Heavy Clothing

Penetration 3.12.2.1 < 12" = Fail

5 shot ave. > 18" = Fail

≥ 12", < 14" = 0 T

≥ 14", ≤ 16" = 3 O

≥ 16", ≤ 18" = 0 T

All shots ≥ 12" = 2 O

Shot exit gel block = Fail

Bullet Expansion 3.12.2.2 < 190% = Fail

≥ 190%, < 210% = 0 T

≥ 210%, < 230% = 1

≥ 230% = 2 O

Retained Bullet Mass 3.12.2.3 < 90% = Fail

≥ 90%, < 95% = 0 T

≥ 95% = 1 O

Page 2 Total

M aj or R eq ui re m en ts

/16

Guidance SOW Section Rating CommentsScore

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Page 2 of 4

Terminal Ballistics (continued) 3.12

Steel

Penetration 3.12.3.1 < 12" = Fail

5 shot ave. > 18" = Fail

≥ 12", < 14" = 0 T

≥ 14", ≤ 16" = 3 O

≥ 16", ≤ 18" = 0 T

All shots ≥ 12" = 2 O

Shot exit gel block = Fail

Bullet Expansion 3.12.3.2 < 170% = Fail

≥ 170%, < 190% = 0 T

≥ 190%, < 200% = 1

≥ 200% = 2 O

Retained Bullet Mass 3.12.3.3 < 90% = Fail

≥ 90%, < 95% = 0 T

≥ 95% = 1 O

Laminated Glass

Penetration 3.12.4.1 < 12" = Fail

5 shot ave. > 18" = Fail

≥ 12", < 14" = 0 T

≥ 14", ≤ 16" =3 O

≥ 16", ≤ 18" = 0 T

All shots ≥ 12" = 2 O

Shot exit gel block = Fail

Bullet Expansion 3.12.4.2 < 130% = Fail

≥ 130%, < 160% = 0 T

≥ 160%, < 170% = 1

≥ 170% = 2 O

Retained Bullet Mass 3.12.4.3 < 50% = Fail

≥ 50%, < 70% = 0 T

≥ 70% = 1 O

Penetration Standard Deviation 3.12.5 > 2.5" = Fail

≤ 2.5", > 1.25" = 0 T

≤ 1.25" =2 O

Page 3 Total

M aj or R eq ui re m en ts

Guidance SOW Section Rating Comments

/18

Score

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Page 3 of 4

Function 3.13

Type 1 or Type 3 malfunctions Two (2) or more Type 1 Malfunctions = Fail

One (1) Type 1 Malfunctions = 0 T

Zero (0) Type 1 Malfunctions = 1 O

Two (2) or more Type 3 Malfunctions = Fail

One (1) Type 3 Malfunctions = 0 T

Zero (0) Type 3 Malfunctions = 1 O

Type 2 malfunctions One (1) Type 2 Malfunctions = Fail

Evidence of keyholing Pass / Fail

Environmental Conditioning 3.14

High Temperature 3.14.1 See Function above

Low Temperature 3.14.2 See Function above

Salt Water Immersion 3.14.3 See Function above

Evidence of keyholing 3.14.1/2/3 Pass / Fail

Visible Muzzle Plume 3.15 One (1) or more = 0

Zero (0) = 1 O

Luminous Ejecta 3.16 One (1) or more = 0

Zero (0) = 1 O

Page 4 Total

OVERALL TOTAL SCORE

Rating Score Key Outstanding = 35 - 51 points (no Failures) Sample_______________________________ Very Good = 18 - 34 points (no Failures) Sample Rating_________________________ Acceptable = 0 - 17 points (no Failures) Raters Name__________________________ Unacceptable = One or more Failures (unawardable) Raters Signature_______________________

Definitions T = Threshold (see SOW Section 3.1.1) O = Objective (see SOW Section 3.1.1) Failure - A failure is defined as any “FAIL” grade received for any of the Government’s “PASS/FAIL” tests outlined in the SOW.

One (1) failure constitutes an Unacceptable rating for Factor 1. The proposal is not eligible for award.

M aj or R eq ui re m en ts

M in or R eq

Guidance SOW Section Rating

/10

/51

Score Comments

FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Page 4 of 4

Sheet1