MSSP San Diego Bundling CDF_Redacted.pdf
PDF 575 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- N00002426R4439414
About this file
This is a Class Determination and Findings (CD&F) document from the Department of the Navy authorizing substantial bundling of fleet maintenance and repair requirements for DDG-51 class ships homeported in San Diego, California. The determination approves consolidation of Fleet Maintenance Availabilities and Incremental Selected Restricted Availabilities (ISRAs) into Single Award Indefinite Delivery Indefinite Quantity Multi-Ship Sustainment Partnership (MSSP) contracts with a cumulative estimated value above the substantial bundling threshold. The Navy plans to award up to three Facilitized Lot contracts (for ships scheduled to complete ISRAs, with estimated combined value redacted) and up to three Non-Facilitized Lot contracts (for Fleet Maintenance Availabilities only, worth approximately redacted amount) in the San Diego homeport. The contracts consist of three one-year ordering periods beginning in Fiscal Year 2027 and will be performed at government facilities (Fleet Maintenance Availabilities) and contractor-provided facilities (ISRAs).
The determination identifies robust market competition with three Other-Than-Small Businesses qualified for Facilitized Lots and one Other-Than-Small Business plus six Small Businesses qualified for Non-Facilitized Lots. The Navy set aside the Non-Facilitized Lot (representing 85,000 Man-Days or 22% of scope) exclusively for small businesses and requires Facilitized Lot awardees to subcontract at least 15% of their scope to small business Master Ship Repair Agreement (MSRA) holders and 25% to small businesses overall. Award fee incentives and penalties are tied to these subcontracting requirements. Primary benefits of bundling include long-term contractor-vessel relationships enabling enhanced preparation and cost avoidance, increased competitive pressure from consolidated awards, elimination of recurring mobilization costs, improved supply chain relationships, and administrative efficiencies through pre-priced task menus rather than individual competitive selections. The CD&F authority expires December 31, 2027.
View the file
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
D&F Number: 14
SOURCE SELECTION INFORMATION – SEE FAR 2.101 and FAR 3.104 award up to three (3) Facilitized Lot contracts in each homeport. The number will be determined at contract award based on the number of acceptable proposals received.
Non-Facilitized Lot includes Fleet Maintenance Availabilities only, to be completed on specific DDG-51 class ships that are not scheduled to complete ISRAs over the MSSP period of performance. The scope of this contract includes all efforts necessary to support continuous coordination, planning and preparation between contractor and government to complete Fleet Maintenance Availabilities including, but not limited to, IAPA support, inspections and assessments, engineering and design support, specification and other government furnished information reviews, and material procurement and logistics support.
Unless otherwise specified in a Delivery Order Solicitation, all delivery orders will be performed at the Government’s facility. The Navy intends to award up to three (3) Non- Facilitized Lot contracts in each homeport. The number will be determined at contract award based on the number of acceptable proposals received.
The Single Award IDIQs are planned for Fiscal Year (FY) 2027 and will consist of three (3) one (1) year ordering periods with a cumulative estimated value of
3. Identification of Statutory/Regulatory Authority
This Determination and Findings is executed pursuant to the requirements of FAR 7.107-1(b)(3) and 7.107-2 (CD 2026-O0020 Rev. 1), and 15 U.S.C. § 644(e).
4. Justification of Determination
FAR 7.107-1 states that before conducting an acquisition that is a consolidation of requirements with an estimated total dollar value exceeding $2 million and a substantial bundling of requirements with an estimated dollar value exceeding $8 million or more for the Department of War, the agency shall make a written determination that the bundling is necessary and justified in accordance with 15 U.S.C. 644(e) after ensuring that:
Market research has been conducted;
Any alternative contracting approaches that would involve a lesser degree of consolidation have been identified;
The determination is coordinated with the agency's Office of Small Disadvantaged
Business Utilization or the Office of Small Business Programs;
Any negative impact by the acquisition strategy on contracting with small business concerns has been identified; and Steps are taken to include small business concerns in the acquisition strategy.
FAR 7.107-2 states that the agency shall quantify the specific benefits identified through the use of market research and other techniques to explain how their impact would substantial. Such benefits may include, but are not limited to:
Cost savings;
Price reduction;
Quality improvements that will save time or improve or enhance performance or efficiency;
Reduction in acquisition cycle times, or Better terms and conditions.
FAR 7.107-2 also states that, for a contract with a cumulative estimated value above the substantial bunding threshold, the agency must document in its strategy:
The specific benefits anticipated to be derived from substantial bundling;
An assessment of the specific barriers to participation by small business concerns as contractors that result from substantial bundling;
Actions designed to maximize small business participation as contractors, including provisions that encourage small business teaming;
Actions designed to maximize small business participation as subcontractors (including suppliers) at any tier under the contract, or order, that may be awarded to meet the requirements;
The determination that the anticipated benefits of the proposed bundled contract or order justify its use; and Alternative strategies that would reduce or minimize the scope of the bundling, and the rationale for not choosing those alternatives.
Results of Market Research
As discussed in detail below, market research indicates that there is robust competition for the contemplated contracts. Due to the bundling of the requirements, there will be impacts on small businesses’ ability to bid for Fleet Maintenance Availabilities designated for the Facilitized Lots.
While the current IDIQ-MAC strategy may maintain an increased level of competition and have some benefits in comparison to the MSSP contracts, these benefits are outweighed by the substantial benefits of bundling.
a. Industry Days - The Navy held multiple industry days to provide an overview and solicit actionable feedback on the Navy’s MSSP acquisition strategy. These industry days were on 15 August 2025, 22 August 2025 and 28 May 2026.
b. Sources Sought Notice - The Navy also released a Sources Sought Notice on 23 Jan 2026 to determine industry capability and bid interest and solicit actionable feedback on the Navy’s MSSP acquisition strategy.
Market research revealed a strong and diverse pool of contractors, including a broad range of large and small businesses with varying levels of capability, capacity and facilities, interested in competing for MSSP requirements in the in San Diego, CA homeport. This diverse mix of contractors demonstrated extensive experience with both ISRAs and Fleet Maintenance
Availabilities across various surface ship classes. Many respondents currently perform the Navy’s non-nuclear ship repair requirements under existing IDIQ-MAC contracts, reflecting a well-established local industrial base with proven capabilities to meet technical and management requirements.
PAE Maritime received the following responses to the DDG-51 San Diego MSSP market research:
i. Facilitized Lot: Three (3) Other-Than-Small Businesses responded with the demonstrated capability, capacity and facilities to complete the requirements expected to be included within the DDG-51 MSSP Facilitized Lot
ii. Non- Facilitized Lot: An additional one (1) Other-Than-Small Business and six (6) Small Businesses responded with the demonstrated capability, capacity and facilities to complete the requirements expected to be included within the DDG-51 MSSP Non- Facilitized Lot.
Table 1: Qualified Respondents for the San Diego Facilitized and Non-Facilitized Lots
c. Program History.
The Navy’s non-nuclear surface ship modernization and maintenance/repair contracting strategy implements a suite of contracts to maximize competition and the use of fixed pricing. This approach leverages multiple types of contracts, right sized to best complete each type of ship availability, reflecting the specifics of the work and the industrial base in each port. This approach improves cost control, schedule adherence and quality of workmanship while maintaining an appropriate level of flexibility and responsiveness to the Fleet.
Prior to the implementation of this strategy, the Navy implemented the cost-reimbursable type Multi-Ship, Multi-Option (MSMO) contract strategy from FY2006 through FY2018 to plan and execute non-nuclear surface ship maintenance, modernization and repair. Each MSMO contract was waterfront shipyard facilities necessary to complete CNO Availabilities. However, San Diego’s small business industrial base has historically completed approximately 80% of the Fleet Maintenance Availabilities executed under the San Diego IDIQ-MACs.
MSSP contractors will be awarded the maintenance responsibility for specific DDG-51 class ships homeported in San Diego, CA. They will be responsible for completing all their vessels’ maintenance, modernization and repair requirements across all their vessels’ scheduled and unscheduled ISRAs and Fleet Maintenance Availabilities. Approximately half of the DDG-51 class ships homeported in San Diego are scheduled to complete ISRAs over the MSSP’s period of performance. Therefore, responsibility to complete these vessels’ ISRA and Fleet Maintenance requirements will be awarded to contractors in the Facilitized Lot. Since San Diego’s small business industrial base lacks the waterfront shipyard facilities necessary to be awarded Facilitized Lot contracts, small businesses will lose the opportunity to compete for these vessels’ Fleet Maintenance Availabilities. These Fleet Maintenance Availabilities have an estimated combined value of .
The remaining half of the DDG-51 class ships do not have scheduled ISRAs over the MSSP’s period of performance. Therefore, responsibility to complete these vessel’s ISRA and Fleet Maintenance requirements will be awarded to contractors in the Non-Facilitized Lot. This Lot, worth approximately , will be set aside for small businesses.
Benefits of Substantial Bundling
The bundling of Fleet Maintenance Availabilities and ISRAs into a series of Single Award IDIQ contracts would result in the following benefits:
a. Long-Term Relationships - The long-term relationship provided by the Single Award IDIQ contracts will allow increased collaboration between the Navy and industry, improving mutual understanding of the material condition of the specific vessels included in the contract. The long-term relationship will allow contractors to better prepare for their projects, completing continuous ship checks and assessments to ensure specifications better reflect each vessel’s material condition (reducing the growth and new work that increases costs during availability execution). The continuous long-term relationship will also facilitate the movement of depot level scope typically completed during CNO Availabilities into Fleet Maintenance Availability windows of opportunity. This movement will reduce time in depot and enable significant cost avoidance on CNO Availability costs that run with time. It will also help minimize the operational availability of highly expensive DDG-51 class ships lost to depot maintenance downtime.
b. Increased Competitive Pressure – The MSSP contracts are highly desirable. They are much larger and provide a much more stable and predictable workload than the individual awards they are intended to replace. Furthermore, the single competition for the MSSP contracts replaces dozens of individual competitions under the IDIQ-MAC strategy. As a result, the value and importance of the MSSP competition is much greater than the individual competitions under the IDIQ-MAC strategy. As a result, the Navy expects that offerors will bid very aggressively on the maintenance task menu, labor and material burden rates, and other pricing factors to win the MSSP contracts.
c. Recurring Footprint Mobilization Cost Avoidance - The principal place of performance for the DDG-51 Fleet Maintenance Availabilities covered under these contracts is San Diego Naval Station. Within the current IDIQ-MAC contract structure, each Fleet Maintenance Availability is solicited and awarded as a separate delivery order with a typical period of performance of one (1) to three (3) months. As each of these short availabilities is awarded separately, contractors typically must mobilize and de-mobilize their on-base footprint for each availability. Awarding a collection of Fleet Maintenance Availabilities to a single contractor over an extended period of performance would allow the awarded contractor to maintain a more permanent on-base footprint and allow the Navy to avoid non-recurring mobilization and de-mobilization costs.
d. Economic Order Quantity Improvements - On-going world-wide supply chain issues have made some material unavailable or highly price erratic. The longer-term relationship provided by the Single Award IDIQ contracts will allow Industry to establish teaming arrangements with Original Equipment Manufacturers (OEMs) and critical suppliers to better ensure the responsive provision of subcontracted labor, technical representatives and material. Furthermore, the long-term relationship will facilitate industrial learning and improvement on repeated tasks and processes; enabling efficiencies that would drive cost savings and schedule improvement.
e. Increased Administrative Efficiencies – The Navy expects that awarding availabilities using the single award IDIQ contract’s competitively pre-priced task menu may, under some circumstances, take less time than the current competitive process within the IDIQ-MACs.
Currently, the Navy requires up to 100 days to run competitive source selections for individual continuous maintenance availabilities. This process awards most Fleet Maintenance Availabilities only 20 days prior to their start. The Navy expects that most Fleet Maintenance Availabilities will be awarded by ordering directly from the pre-priced menu with minimal negotiation. This substantially less time-consuming process will provide more time for pre-award scope definition and post award contractor preparation, improving readiness and on-time delivery.
The financial benefits of the substantial bundling are expected to exceed five percent of the estimated contract value.
Barriers to Participation by Small Business Concerns
The principal barrier to small business participation as prime contractors in the Facilitized Lot is ownership or committed access to a DDG-51 capable pier with laydown and services sufficient to support the completion of ISRAs. As described above, none of the small business shipyards in San Diego have ownership or committed access these piers.
Actions Designed to Maximize Small Business Participation
PAE Maritime intends to take several meaningful steps to maximize small business participation.
a. Small Business Set Aside of Non-Facilitized Lot – Based on market research of the San Diego, CA homeport industrial base, the Navy has a “reasonable expectation of obtaining offers from two or more responsible small business concerns that are competitive in terms of fair market prices, quality, and delivery” for each of the DDG-51 MSSP Non-Facilitized lot awards. Therefore, PAE Maritime intends to set aside the Non-Facilitized Lots, representing 85K Man-Days or about twenty-two percent (22%) of the DDG-51 MSSP scope in San Diego, CA, for small businesses.
b. Small Business Subcontracting Requirement in Facilitized Lot – Historically, under the IDIQ-MAC strategy, small businesses were awarded prime contracts to complete eighty percent (80%) of the Fleet Maintenance Availabilities. These small businesses were required to have Master Ship Repair Agreement (MSRA) level managerial and technical capabilities to be awarded these contracts. On the DDG-51 San Diego MSSP contracts, 80% of the Fleet Maintenance Availabilities represents 129K Man-Days of work. As 85K of these Man-Days are being set aside for small businesses in the Non-Facilitized Lot, the transition from the IDIQ-MAC to the MSSP contract strategy is expected to reduce small business prime contracting opportunities by 44K Man-Days. This 44K Man Days represents fifteen percent (15%) of the 297K Man-Days expected to be awarded under the Facilitized Lot. Therefore, PAE Maritime intends to require Facilitized Lot awardees to subcontract with small business MSRA holders to complete at least fifteen percent (15%) of the scope within the Facilitized Lot.
c. Award Fee and Small Business Subcontracting Performance – PAE Maritime intends to incorporate a five percent (5%) award fee pool in the MSSP contracts to incentivize managerial and technical performance. Within the Facilitized Lot, in order to ensure large business primes subcontract to small businesses in a manner that supports the overall ship repair industrial base, the award fee pool available to be earned will be adjusted to the extent that Facilitized Lot awardees subcontract at least fifteen percent (15%) of their scope to small business MSRA holders and at least twenty-five percent (25%) of their scope to small businesses overall. Failure to meet these small business goals will result in a proportionate reduction of the contractor’s award fee pool.
d. Small Business Subcontracting Plan - Additionally, other-than-small business offerors will be required to submit a preliminary small business subcontracting plan which will be reviewed for overall small business strategy and compliance with PAE Maritime’s small business guidelines. The small business plan will be reviewed to determine that the plan achieves the minimum subcontracting requirements for small business and socio-economic categories and complies with FAR Part 19109.
Alternate Acquisition Strategies
Prior to settling on the proposed contracting strategy, PAE Maritime considered alternative contracting approaches that would have involved a lesser degree of bundling.
a. Any alternative to the MSSP structure would sever the long-term relationship between a contractor and a specific DDG-51 class ship.
b. The principal alternative considered was continuing to compete each Fleet Maintenance Availability and ISRA as separate delivery orders among existing or follow-on IDIQ-MAC contract holders. This approach is the least consolidated approach and provides the strongest recurring order-level price competition. It maximizes the number of opportunities for large and small business firms holding the relevant IDIQ-MAC and permits the Government to select a different contractor for each availability based upon the needs of the immediate work package.
c. A secondary alternative would be an MSSP contract structure wherein contractors would be awarded long-term contracts to complete specific types of work, but not necessarily with long-term continuity on specific DDG-51 class ships.
d. The principal disadvantage to these approaches is that they deprive the Navy of the desired long-term relationship between a contractor and specific DDG-51 class ships that enables enhanced understanding of the vessel’s material condition, long term availability preparation, responsiveness to emergent requirements, and work scope management between ISRAs and Fleet Maintenance Availabilities to minimize growth and new work and maximize operational availability.
e. While these alternative approaches have some merit, they do not provide the same continuity, preparation time, recurring mobilization avoidance, task-menu efficiency, or long-horizon supply-chain benefits as MSSP. PAE Maritime therefore rejected exclusive reliance on the current model or a modified MSSP approach discussed above.
5. CD&F Expiration Date
The authority under this CD&F expires 31 December 2027, which affords sufficient time to award the Single Award IDIQ MSSP contracts for the San Diego homeport.
DETERMINATION
Based on the above facts, I determine that in accordance with FAR 7.107-3(a) and 7.107-2, substantial bundling for the above referenced requirements is necessary and justified because the benefits of the proposed approach would substantially exceed the benefits that would be derived from each of the alternative contracting approaches. I further determine that the anticipated benefits of the proposed bundled contracts justify their use.
APPROVAL BLOCK
CRISTINA M. COVALT Date Executive Director of Acquisition & Contracts Portfolio Acquisition Executive Maritime
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .