DS 27-0008 Q & A RESTART Contract Audit.docx

DOCX document 22 KB Posted

Attached to
Audit services for RESTART contract
Solicitation number
DS 761 270000000008 2
Issued by
Grand Traverse County, Michigan

About this file

This is a Question and Answer document for audit services related to the RESTART contract opportunity in Michigan, involving the state agency EGLE (Environmental Quality) and LTU (Lawrence Technological University). The engagement is an agreed-upon procedures engagement under AT-C Section 215/SSAE No. 19, which differs from a full program compliance audit. The scope encompasses a review of 37 payment requests submitted for the period from September 1, 2022, through June 30, 2026. All invoices and supporting documentation are available in electronic format (PDF, Word, or Excel) and are currently in the possession of EGLE, eliminating the need for on-site testing at subcontractor locations. The work can be completed in a hybrid format, providing flexibility in project execution.

The audit procedures will examine financial status reports, payroll records, bank statements, credit card statements, receipts, travel documentation, and deliverables such as technical assessment reports and training materials to determine whether payment requests are "properly supported." Service level compliance is contractually enforced through penalties: $100 may be assessed for each of the first five non-compliance occurrences in a calendar year, with penalties increasing to $500 beginning with the sixth occurrence and continuing for each subsequent occurrence within the same calendar year. The supporting documentation provided with invoices varies in completeness, with some subcontractor invoices containing detailed information regarding hours, hourly rates, and task descriptions while others lack comprehensive detail.

View the file

Other files

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Q & A DS No. 270000000008 RESTART Contract Audit

1. Please clarify what type of report or service is desired. Is this to be a program compliance audit under AU-C 935, an agreed-upon procedures engagement under AT-C 215, a forensic accounting engagement under Statement on Standards for Forensic Services or some other level of service?

Answer: This would be an agreed-upon procedures engagement under AT-C Section 215/SSAE No. 19.

2. What is the size of the invoice population to be reviewed?

Answer: A total of 37 payment requests.

3. How are the invoices and support stored?

Answer: The invoices are in pdf format. The technical reports are saved in either word or pdf format. The progress reports are saved in either word or excel workbook format.

4. Is all information to be reviewed in the possession of EGLE or of LTU or does the testing involve information at any of the subcontractors or businesses that participated in the program?

Answer: All information to be reviewed is in the possession of EGLE.

5. Can the work be completed in a hybrid format or does it require on-site testing?

Answer: The work can be completed in a hybrid format.

6. Please clarify how the credit due for failing to meet the service level agreements apply to this contract.

Answer: $100 may be assessed for each of the first five occurrences of non-compliance in a given calendar year. $500 may be assessed beginning with the sixth occurrence of non-compliance and on each occurrence thereafter in a given calendar year.

7. How many contract invoices were submitted for the period from September 1, 2022, through June 30, 2026?

Answer: See answer to Question 2.

8. What information (hours, costs, etc.) is included on the contract invoices?

Answer: The invoices were submitted using what the state calls the Financial Status Report/Payment Request. Some subcontractor invoices include hours, hourly rates, task information etc., but not all of them have all that information.

9. How many payments were made for the period from September 1, 2022, through June 30, 2026?

Answer: See answer to Question 2.

10. How is “properly supported” defined in this context?

Answer: Payment requests typically contain/require the following supporting documents among others : contractor generated financial status reports, payroll reports, bank statements as proof of payments to subcontractors, credit card statements, pre-approvals from the State for travel or additional tasks, subcontractor generated invoices, google map snapshots for travel, approved DTMB travel rates for said period, receipts for lodging, meals, local travel, parking etc., Deliverables such as technical assessment reports, follow up HVAC assessment reports with completed questionnaires attached, technical assistance reports, outreach and training materials etc.

11. Are the invoices available electronically or hard copy?

Answer: All invoices and supporting documents are available in electronic format.

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .