Bid Notice-Carmen-Smith 13th Part 12D Report Consulting.pdf

PDF 332 KB Posted

Attached to
Carmen-Smith 13th Part 12D Report Consulting
Solicitation number
26-197-Q
Issued by
Lane County, Oregon

About this file

This Request for Proposals (RFP) document is issued by the Eugene Water & Electric Board (EWEB), an Oregon utility, seeking qualified consultant firms to perform independent safety inspection and review services for the Carmen-Smith Hydroelectric Project pursuant to 18 CFR Part 12, Subpart D requirements. The project involves comprehensive assessment of two hydroelectric developments—the Carmen Development (including Carmen Diversion Dam, Smith Dam, and associated structures) and the Trail Bridge Development (including Trail Bridge Dam and appurtenant structures)—located approximately 70 miles east of Eugene on the upper McKenzie River. The scope of work encompasses twelve major tasks including pre-inspection preparation reporting, field inspections, potential failure mode analysis, Level 2 risk analysis, comprehensive assessment reporting, hydrologic and seismic hazard assessments, life-loss consequence studies with inundation mapping, project management, and responses to Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) comments. The RFP closing date is December 8, 2026, at 2:00 PM PST, with a mandatory pre-proposal conference scheduled for November 24, 2026, at 11:00 AM PST via Microsoft Teams. The contract period runs from the award date (anticipated February 4, 2027) through January 31, 2030, with potential extension for up to five years from original execution if needed. Electronic submission via the OregonBuys website is required; emailed proposals will not be accepted.

EWEB's estimate for the work is $1,350,000. Minimum qualifications require proposers to have been in business for at least seven years providing similar engineering services, maintain appropriate professional licenses from the Oregon State Board of Examiners for Engineering and Land Surveying, be listed on FERC's Previously Approved Independent Consultants list as of September 18, 2026, and have successfully completed a minimum of three Comprehensive Assessments Part 12 Safety Inspection Reports accepted by FERC within the last seven years. The evaluation process follows a three-step qualifications-based selection methodology: Step One reviews minimum requirements on a pass/fail basis; Step Two evaluates written proposals on project understanding and approach (25 points), staff and resources (15 points), key staff qualifications and experience (25 points), and past performance and references (20 points), with optional interviews; Step Three evaluates pricing (15 points) totaling 100 possible points. Pricing proposals must be submitted within 24 hours of shortlist notification and should not be included with initial submissions. EWEB reserves the right to waive informalities, cancel the RFP, or reject any or all proposals. Proposers are encouraged to use Minority, Women, and Emerging Small Businesses (MWESB) and Disadvantaged Business Enterprises as subcontractors.

View the file

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Rev 07/01/24

RFP 26-197-Q 09/24

Eugene Water & Electric Board

REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS

for

Carmen-Smith 13th Part 12D Report

A&E RFP No.: 26-197-Q Closing Date: Tuesday, December 8, 2026 Time: 2:00 PM PST

Description: The Eugene Water & Electric Board (EWEB) is seeking proposals from qualified consultant firms to perform independent safety inspection and review services for the Carmen Smith Hydroelectric Project pursuant to the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 18, Part 12 Subpart D (Part 12D) requirements.

Purchasing Contact: Sandra Hahn (541) 685-7163 sandra.hahn@eweb.org

Pre-Proposal Conference: YES Mandatory Date: November 24, 2026 Time: 11:00 AM Location: Online, Microsoft Teams

This is a COMPETITIVE SEALED PROCUREMENT.

ELECTRONIC PROPOSALS SUBMITTED VIA THE OREGONBUYS BID SITE ARE REQUIRED. Emailed submittals will not be accepted.

To ensure your submission is received prior to the closing date and time, it is recommended that you begin the submittal process on the OregonBuys website at least 72-hours prior to the closing date and time listed above.

SINGLE POINT OF CONTACT: There will be only one point of contact for the entire Request for Proposal process. The contact point is the EWEB Purchasing Office, and the contact person is the Purchasing Contact listed above, unless otherwise stated. Any questions or issues that may arise regarding the specifications, the bidding process, and/or the award process shall be directed to the Purchasing Contact listed above. EWEB’s official response to any questions or requests will be in writing via the Addendum process.

FOR MORE INFORMATION please refer to Part 1 “Instructions to Proposers”

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Section Description

Legal Advertisement

1 Instructions to Proposers

2 Scope of Work

3 Minimum Qualifications and Requirements

4 Evaluation Process & Proposer Selection

5 Evaluation Criteria

6 Proposal Form

EXHIBITS

Sample Contract

LEGAL ADVERTISEMENT

RFP #26-197-Q

Carmen-Smith 13th Part 12D Report

The Eugene Water & Electric Board (EWEB) is seeking proposals from qualified firms to perform independent inspection, review, and assessment services for the Carmen-Smith Hydroelectric Project pursuant to 18 CFR Part 12, subpart D requirements.

Proposals shall be submitted on the State of Oregon – OregonBuys website (https://oregonbuys.gov/bso/), before, 2:00 pm, Tuesday, December 8, 2026. (Emailed responses will not be accepted.) Proposals will not be accepted after this hour and date.

RFP documents may be obtained by downloading the RFP documents from the State of Oregon's bid site ("OregonBuys"): https://oregonbuys.gov/bso/. (On OregonBuys home page, search under “Bid Solicitation” for “EWEB” or bid # S-P00140-00018370. For navigation help, please call 1-855-800-5046.)

A mandatory Pre-Proposal Conference will be held at 11:00 AM PST, November 24, 2026, Online via Microsoft Teams. The purpose of the conference is to discuss the work to be performed with the prospective Proposers and allow them to ask questions concerning the RFP. Attendance by at least one employee of the primary consultant is mandatory. Please RSVP beforehand to Sandra Hahn: sandra.hahn@eweb.org.

All proposals shall be submitted as set forth in Section 1 - Instructions to Proposers. EWEB is not responsible for proposals submitted in any manner, format or to any delivery point other than as required by the Solicitation Document.

No proposal may be withdrawn after the hour set for the opening thereof until the elapse of thirty (30) days from the date and time set for opening.

EWEB reserves the right to waive any or all informalities and irregularities (EWEB Rule 3-0470) and may cancel the Request for Proposals or reject any or all proposals pursuant to EWEB Rule 3-0640.

Date: November 5, 2026

Sandra Hahn, Purchasing Contact

1. INSTRUCTIONS TO PROPOSERS

All proposals and contracts are subject to the provisions and requirements of the Oregon Revised Statutes 279A and 279B and EWEB Public Contracting Rules Divisions 1, 2, 3 and 6.

INFORMATION OF RECORD

The official source of information for this project until the Intent to Award is posted is located at the State of Oregon's bid site, located at https://oregonbuys.gov/bso/. IT IS THE SOLE RESPONSIBILITY OF THE PROPOSER TO

CHECK THE WEBSITE ON A TIMELY BASIS.

PROPOSAL PREPARATION

1.1 PROPOSAL FORMAT AND COST

Proposals shall be typewritten or prepared in ink and shall be submitted electronically, per Section 1.8 below. Proposals shall conform to the requirements of the Request for Proposals. All necessary attachments shall be submitted with the proposal and in the required format.

Proposer is responsible for all costs incurred in connection with its Proposal, including, but not limited to, the costs to prepare and submit the Proposal, costs of samples and other supporting materials, costs to participate in demonstrations, and costs associated with protests.

1.2 CONFORMANCE TO SOLICITATION REQUIREMENTS

Proposals shall conform to the requirements of the Request for Proposals. All necessary attachments shall be submitted with the proposal and in the required format.

1.3 PROTEST OF SPECIFICATIONS / REQUIREMENTS

A Proposer who believes that the procurement process is contrary to law, or that the solicitation is unnecessarily restrictive in that specifications limit competition arbitrarily, without reasonably promoting the fulfillment of the procurement needs of EWEB, or that the solicitation document is legally flawed in that it contains terms or conditions that are contrary to law, or that the solicitation improperly specifies a brand name as defined in ORS 279B.200, may submit a protest via email to sandra.hahn@eweb.org. Insert the following in the subject header:

RFP SPECIFICATION PROTEST, RFP # 26-197-Q

To be considered, protests shall be received no less than 5 business days before close (EW-3-0700(2)).

Protest of specifications shall include the reason for protest, any and all evidence and documented factual information that supports Proposer’s protest, and any proposed changes to the requirements. The EWEB Purchasing department shall promptly respond to each written protest, and where appropriate, issue all revisions, substitutions, or clarifications via Addenda to all Proposers. Proposers must exhaust all administrative remedies before seeking judicial review.

1.4 PROPOSER'S PROPOSED TERMS AND CONDITIONS Rule 3-0230(7)(b)

Proposers may include in the Cover Letter of their response, proposed revisions to the contractual terms and conditions in the Sample Contract (Exhibit 1) and the Scope of Work included in this RFP document.

(Proposer may show proposed changes by using Word Track Changes tool OR providing proposed revisions in cover letter.) Proposers may not protest or request to change the entire terms and conditions of the solicitation. For example, you may not seek to replace EWEB’s terms and conditions in whole with your company’s terms and conditions, standard contract, master services agreement, etc.

Terms included with Proposer’s proposal documents will not be considered unless they are listed in the Cover Letter as requested terms to negotiate.

EWEB reserves the right to negotiate the proposed terms and/or conditions with Proposer, and either accept or reject the proposed terms and/or conditions. REQUESTS FOR REVISION OF EWEB CONTRACTUAL

TERMS AND CONDITIONS MAY BE MADE AT TIME OF PROPOSAL SUBMISSION. THERE MAY BE NO

OPPORTUNITY TO DO SO AT A LATER DATE.

NO PROPOSED TERMS OR CONDITIONS SHALL BECOME A PART OF THE AWARDED CONTRACT UNLESS

ACCEPTED BY EWEB AND INCORPORATED INTO THE CONTRACT IN WRITING.

1.5 SIGNATURE ON PROPOSAL

Proposals shall be signed by an authorized representative of the Proposer. Signature on a proposal certifies that the proposal is made without connection with any person, firm or corporation making a proposal for the same goods and/or services and is in all respects fair and made without collusion or fraud. Signature on a proposal also certifies that the Proposer has read, fully understands and agrees with all solicitation requirements, terms and conditions. No consideration will be given to any claim resulting from proposing without fully comprehending all requirements of the Request for Proposals.

Proposers shall only enter information within the proposal document where it is requested or required.

Proposers shall NOT make any alterations to the original solicitation document. Any proposal that has been altered may be rejected.

1.6 CANCELLATION, REJECTION, DELAY OF RFP

Pursuant to Rule 3-0640, EWEB may cancel, reject in whole or in any part any proposals, if EWEB determines it is in the best interest of EWEB to do so.

1.7 PRE-PROPOSAL CONFERENCE

A mandatory Pre-Proposal Conference will be held on November 24, 2026 at 11:00 AM, PST, online via Microsoft Teams. The purpose of the conference is to discuss the work to be performed with the prospective Proposers and allow them to ask questions concerning the RFP. Attendance by at least one employee of the primary consultant is mandatory. Subconsultants are encouraged to attend, but their attendance is not mandatory.

Please RSVP the Purchasing Contract

1.8 PROPOSAL SUBMISSION

(a) OregonBuys Electronic Response

Please be sure to combine all documents into one pdf file before attempting to submit your bid into the OregonBuys bid site.

In order to submit an electronic proposal on the OregonBuys website, Proposer must be registered with OregonBuys and able to submit an electronic proposal. For instructions to register on OregonBuys, visit the following site: OrBuysSupplierRegistrationSteps.pdf (oregon.gov)

If you experience any issues registering, please contact OregonBuys at:

Phone: 1-855-800-5046 Email: support.oregonbuys@das.oregon.gov

When Proposer is submitting their proposal electronically, Proposer should follow the procedures outlined in any of the following:

https://www.oregon.gov/das/ORBuys/Documents/OregonBuys%20Vendor%20Formal%20Solicitation%20R esponse.pdf for electronic submission.

A video presentation on submitting an electronic proposal may be found at: Supplier - Submitting a Quote - Overview (periscopeholdings.com)

Terminology specific to the OregonBuys system may be found at:

https://www.oregon.gov/das/ORBuys/Documents/Phase1TerminologyCrosswalk.pdf

Proposals received in a manner other than through the OregonBuys website and/or after the closing date and time will not be considered and will be rejected. EWEB is not responsible for proposals submitted in any manner format or to any delivery point other than as required by the Solicitation document.

(b) REQUIRED PROPOSAL PACKAGE Complete, sign, and return the following documents as RFP response. Failing to include these documents could lead to rejection of proposal.

Cover Sheet, with:

Contractual Acceptance: Statement accepting ALL terms and conditions contained in this solicitation and the Sample Contract (Exhibit 1). Statement may also include request for negotiation of proposed terms and conditions as allowed per Section 1.4.

Termination for Default: Proposers shall indicate if they have had a contract terminated for default in the last five years. Termination for default is defined as notice to stop performance that was delivered to the Proposer due to the Proposer’s non-performance or poor performance and the issue of performance was either (a) not litigated due to inaction on the part of the Proposer, or (b) litigated and determined that the Proposer was in default.

NOTE: If a Proposer has had a contract terminated for default in this period, then the Proposer shall submit full details including the other party’s name, address and phone number. EWEB will evaluate the facts and may, at its sole discretion, reject the proposal on the grounds of Proposer’s past performance.

Proposal Form (Section 6) Response to Minimum Requirements (Section 3) Response to All Evaluation Criteria (Section 5) All Addenda Acknowledged

IMPORTANT NOTE RE PRICING – DO NOT submit pricing proposal with your submission. All Proposers should be prepared to submit their pricing within 24 hours of formal invitation to submit pricing, shortly after shortlist notification.)

(c) RESPONSIVENESS / RESPONSIBILTIY

A “Responsive” proposal is a proposal that substantially complies with the Request for Proposals instructions and requirements.

A “Responsible” Proposer can demonstrate ability to meet the requirements of the Scope of Work, has the appropriate experience, is legally qualified to do the Work, has the required certifications required, has a satisfactory record of integrity and can meet the other requirements described in

ORS 279B.110(2).

1.9 ADDENDA

Any VERBAL communication cannot and shall not be construed as approval of the acceptability of any deviation to any requirement. All changes to requirements and/or the solicitation documents will be made in the form of Addenda. The Proposer is responsible for ensuring that all Addenda have been downloaded and are acknowledged in their RFP Response. Proposer may sign each issued Addendum and include with response or acknowledge in the space provided on the Proposal Form.

All Addenda can be obtained electronically at the State of Oregon's bid site ("Oregon Buys"):

https://oregonbuys.gov/bso/.

1.10 PROPOSAL MODIFICATION

If a Proposer wishes to make modifications to a submitted Proposal, Proposer must do so through OregonBuys prior to the Proposal Due Date and Time stated on the Cover Page for this RFP.

1.11 PROPOSAL WITHDRAWALS:

If a Proposer wishes to withdraw a submitted Proposal, Proposer must do so through OregonBuys, using the “Withdraw Quote” button prior to the Proposal Due Date and Time stated on the Cover Page for this RFP.

1.12 EXCEPTIONS

Any exceptions to the requirements of this solicitation MUST be submitted in accordance with Item 1.3

PROTEST OF SPECIFICATIONS / REQUIREMENTS. Exceptions submitted with your proposal, or in any manner other than the process provided herein, may cause your proposal to be ruled non-Responsive and rejected.

1.13 PROPOSAL OPENING: Unless otherwise provided by Law or Rule, proposals received in response to this

Request for Proposals shall be opened at the scheduled closing date and time at the EWEB Purchasing department located at 4200 Roosevelt Blvd, Eugene, Oregon 97402. Enquiring Proposers shall be informed only of the names of Proposers submitting proposals. No other information shall be available at that time.

Award decisions will NOT be made at the opening.

1.14 ALTERNATE PROPOSALS

Proposers may submit more than one proposal. All proposals must comply with the requirements of the RFP except that additional proposals may incorporate, by reference, repetitive information which is provided in the complete proposal.

1.15 PROPRIETARY DATA/PUBLIC RECORD

This Request for Proposal, together with copies of all documents pertaining to the award of a contract, shall be kept by EWEB and made a part of a file or record which shall be open to public inspection. If a proposal contains any information that is considered a trade secret under ORS 192.345(2), each sheet of such information shall be marked with the following legend:

"This data constitutes a trade secret under ORS 192.345(2) and shall not be disclosed except in accordance with the Oregon Public Records Law, ORS Chapter 192."

The Oregon Public Records Law exempts from disclosures only bona fide trade secrets, and the exemption from disclosure applies only "unless the public interest requires disclosure in the particular instance" ORS 192.345(2). Therefore, non-disclosure of documents or any portion of a document submitted as part of a proposal may depend upon official or judicial determinations made pursuant to the Public Records Law.

The above restriction may not include cost or price information, which shall be open to public inspection.

1.16 SOCIAL EQUITY

EWEB supports the use of Minority, Women, Emerging Small Businesses (M/W/ESB), local businesses, Disadvantaged Business Enterprises and Qualified Rehabilitation Facilities (QRF). EWEB encourages the awarded offeror to use the following voluntary practices to promote open competitive opportunities for disadvantaged businesses as applicable:

a. Access lists of certified minority, women, emerging small business or disadvantaged business enterprises from the Oregon State Office of Minority, Women and Emerging Small Business (OMWESB) by visiting their website at:

b. Visit the Oregon State Qualified Rehabilitation Facilities Program website to search for Qualified Rehabilitation Facilities from whom to procure products or services.

SCHEDULE OF EVENTS

1.17 The schedule of events set out herein represent Eugene Water & Electric Board’s best estimate of the schedule that will be followed.

Request for Proposal released November 5, 2026

Mandatory Pre-Proposal Conference November 24, 2026

Last day for EWEB to receive questions from Proposers December 1, 2026

Last day EWEB will post Addenda on Bid Site December 3, 2026

Closing date (last day to submit proposals to EWEB) December 8, 2026

Responses evaluated (2 week) December 17, 2026

EWEB-optional Interview presentations held Week of January 5 - 7

Pricing evaluated January 12, 2027

Intent to Award announcement posted on bid site January 12, 2027

Board approval February 2, 2027

Contract award February 4, 2027

ANTICIPATED PROJECT SCHEDULE:

Task 1 – CA Pre-Inspection Preparation Report Q4 2027

Task 2 – CA Field Inspection Q2 to Q3 2028

Task 3 – CA Potential Failure Mode Analysis Q2 to Q3 2028

Task 4 – CA Level 2 Risk Analysis Q2 to Q3 2028

Task 3 – Comprehensive Assessment Report (CAR) Q4 2028

Task 6 – Comprehensive Assessment Report Presentation & Review Meeting Q1 2029

Task 7 – Hydrologic Hazard Assessment Q4 2027

Task 8 – Seismic Hazard Assessment Q3 to Q4 2027

Task 9 – Life Loss Consequences Study & Inundation Mapping Q3 to Q4 2027

Task 10 – Project Management 2027 to 2030

Task 11 – Extra Workshop Time Virtual Q3 2028

Task 12 – Response to FERC Comments Allowance Q4 2029 to Q1 2030

2. SCOPE OF WORK

2.1 BACKGROUND /OBJECTIVES

The Eugene Water & Electric Board (EWEB), founded in 1911, is Oregon’s largest customer-owned utility and provides electricity and water services to more than 86,000 customers. EWEB owns, operates, and maintains the Carmen-Smith Hydroelectric Project (FERC No. P-2242) under a single federal license on the upper McKenzie River, a major tributary of the Willamette River in western Oregon. The Project is located approximately 70 miles east of the Eugene metropolitan area. Completed in 1963, the Project consists of two major components: the Carmen Development and the Trail Bridge Development.

More detailed Project information is provided in the 2023 Supporting Technical Information Document (STID), which is in the process of being updated by the end of 2026. This document is available upon request and execution of a Critical Energy Infrastructure Information (CEII) General Non-Disclosure Agreement.

The two developments include three embankment dams, two of which are classified as high hazard, gated spillway structures, water conveyance facilities, two powerhouses, emergency access roads, fish-spawning facilities, and other appurtenant structures, as summarized below.

Carmen Development

Carmen Diversion Dam, Spillway, and Reservoir Carmen Diversion Tunnel Smith Dam, Spillway, and Reservoir Power Intake Structure, Tunnel, and Penstock Carmen Powerhouse

Trail Bridge Development

Trail Bridge Dam, Reservoir, and Spillway Emergency Spillway (formerly known as the saddle dike section) Trail Bridge Powerhouse

The Carmen Powerhouse is the Project’s primary generating facility. The two generating units housed in the powerhouse provide peaking power to meet EWEB customer demand and supplement baseload power obtained from other sources. The Trail Bridge Development functions as a re-regulating dam and reservoir, regulating releases to the McKenzie River downstream of the Project in accordance with applicable regulatory requirements. The Trail Bridge Powerhouse also generates electricity to help meet EWEB’s system demands.

The Carmen-Smith Project is located at the upper end of the McKenzie River drainage system. Carmen Diversion Dam impounds water from the McKenzie River and Icecap Spring in Carmen Diversion Reservoir. Water is conveyed from Carmen Diversion Reservoir through the Carmen Diversion Tunnel to Smith Reservoir. Smith Dam is the Project’s largest dam and impounds the primary water storage reservoir, which receives flows from the Smith River and diverted water from Carmen Diversion Reservoir. Water is conveyed from Smith Reservoir through the Power Intake Structure, Tunnel, and Penstock to the Carmen Powerhouse for power generation.

This Scope of Work (SOW) describes the tasks required to complete the Comprehensive Assessment (CA) for the Carmen-Smith Hydroelectric Project (FERC No. P-2242), informed by the findings and outcomes of the 2023 Part 12D Periodic Inspection.

The CA will be divided into two inspection and reporting deliverables for submission to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC). Where applicable, separate deliverables will be prepared for each development:

Trail Bridge Development: Trail Bridge Dam and its appurtenant structures.

Carmen Development: Smith Dam, Carmen Diversion Dam, and their respective appurtenant structures.

Based on the current requirements of the Part 12D Safety Inspection Program, the Dam Safety Performance Monitoring Program, and the operational needs of the Project, the anticipated scope includes the following tasks:

1. Task 1 – CA Pre-Inspection Preparation Report

2. Task 2 – CA Field Inspection

3. Task 3 – CA Potential Failure Mode Analysis

4. Task 4 – CA Level 2 Risk Analysis

5. Task 5 – Comprehensive Assessment Report (CAR)

6. Task 6 – Comprehensive Assessment Report Presentation and Review Meeting

7. Task 7 – Hydrologic Hazard Assessment

8. Task 8 – Seismic Hazard Assessment

9. Task 9 – Life Loss Consequences Study and Inundation Mapping

10. Task 10 – Project Management

11. Task 11 – Additional Virtual Workshop Time

12. Task 12 – Response to FERC Comments Allowance

2.2 LENGTH OF CONTRACT

The contract for this project (“Contract”) will start from the date of award, approximately February 4, 2027 and expire on January 31, 2030. The contract may be extended with a formal amendment executed by both parties, for a maximum duration of 5 years from original contract execution date, if needed. All major tasks are scheduled to be completed late 2028 to early 2029. The work performed after is only intended to address comments and questions that may be raised by FERC after the delivery of the report.

2.3 LOCATION OF WORK

The location the work to be performed, completed and managed is at Contractor’s business location and EWEB facilities Carmen-Smith Project 59727 Hwy 126 McKenzie Bridge, OR 97413.

EWEB WILL NOT provide workspace for the Consultant. The Consultant must provide its own workspace.

2.4 ENGINEERS ESTIMATE

The EWEB estimate for this Work is $1,350,000.

2.5 SCOPE OF WORK

General Requirements (Workshop Schedule)

For the Carmen Development, the Consultant shall assume a total of 15 days over three weeks for the field inspection, PFMA, and L2RA activities. The first week, including the field inspection and PFMA, shall be conducted in person. The second and third weeks, covering the L2RA, shall be conducted virtually. EWEB will provide the in-person workshop location and coordinate arrangements in advance to facilitate travel planning.

The PFMA and L2RA activities for Smith Dam and Carmen Diversion Dam are anticipated to be conducted separately for efficiency; however, the reporting deliverables shall be combined into a single report for the Carmen Development. EWEB would like the Consultant to consider whether Carmen Diversion Dam should be included in the CA, considering its low-hazard classification, and help facilitate discussion with FERC concurrence, if applicable.

For the Trail Bridge Development, the Consultant shall assume a total of 10 days over two weeks for the field inspection, PFMA, and L2RA activities. The first week, including the field inspection and PFMA, shall be conducted in person, and the second week, covering the L2RA, shall be conducted virtually. EWEB will provide the in-person workshop location and coordinate arrangements in advance.

Task 1 – CA Pre-Inspection Preparation Report

The Consultant shall develop a Part 12D Inspection Plan for submission to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC), including the proposed Independent Consultant (IC) Team and the proposed personnel fulfilling the applicable FERC-required roles for the Comprehensive Assessment (CA). The team shall include the following roles and technical disciplines, at a minimum:

Facilitator Independent Consultant

Geotechnical and Seismic Subject Matter Expert (SME) Geology SME Structural SME

Hydrology and Hydraulics SME Mechanical and Controls SME Recorder

The Consultant shall prepare a CA Pre-Inspection Preparation Report (CA-PIPR) to document the available Project information and support preparation for the field inspection, Potential Failure Mode Analysis (PFMA), and Level 2 Risk Analysis (L2RA) workshops. The CA-PIPR shall be developed generally in accordance with the outline provided in Appendix E of Chapter 16 of the FERC Engineering Guidelines.

The Consultant shall submit a draft CA-PIPR to EWEB for review and incorporate one round of revisions based on consolidated comments from EWEB. The Consultant shall then submit the final CA-PIPR to EWEB for submission to FERC at least 60 days before the scheduled start of the field inspection. Although FERC requires submission of the CA-PIPR at least 30 days before the inspection, the 60-day submittal target provides additional time for the Consultant to address any FERC comments received by EWEB before acceptance of the CA-PIPR.

The CA-PIPR shall include preliminary versions of much of the content that will be incorporated into the Comprehensive Assessment Report (CAR), including:

Section 2 – Description of Project Features and Operations Section 3 – Review and Evaluation of Design Basis and Construction Section 4 – Review and Evaluation of Previous Analyses Section 5 – Project Status Portions of Section 6 – Field Inspection and Interpretation of Monitoring Data Section 8 – Review and Evaluation of Dam and Public Safety Programs

As part of preparing the CA-PIPR, the Consultant shall provide a list of any recommended studies for EWEB to consider completing in preparation for the CA. The Consultant shall review the available Project records and develop a preliminary evaluation of the design basis and construction history. This review shall address site geology, seismic and foundation conditions, hydrology and hydraulics, seepage, static and flood stability analyses of the embankments and spillways, and the overall design and construction of the Project.

The Consultant shall also summarize previous modifications to the Project structures and operations;

outstanding recommendations from previous Part 12D reports; ongoing and completed studies; and applicable operations, maintenance, and dam safety programs. In addition, the Consultant shall review previous field inspection observations, interpretations of available monitoring data, and the existing dam and public safety programs.

Deliverables

1. Carmen Development CA-PIPR – Draft and Final

2. Trail Bridge Development CA-PIPR – Draft and Final

Task 2 – CA Field Inspection

The Independent Consultant (IC) Team shall conduct a physical field inspection of the Project facilities to evaluate existing conditions. Before the inspection, the IC Team shall develop a thorough understanding of the Project through review of available records and completion of the pre-inspection activities documented in the CA Pre-Inspection Preparation Report (CA-PIPR).

The Consultant shall assume that the field inspections will require two separate mobilizations, one for the Carmen Development and one for the Trail Bridge Development, to support separate inspection and reporting deliverables for FERC. EWEB is open to coordinating or streamlining the inspections, where practicable, provided that the time between each field inspection and its associated Potential Failure Mode Analysis (PFMA) and Level 2 Risk Analysis (L2RA) workshops is minimized. Each development’s field inspection is assumed to require one 10-hour day.

The Consultant shall document inspection observations using site-specific checklists, field notes, photographs, and sketches, as appropriate. The Consultant shall determine whether rope-access inspections are needed for the spillways. If required, these inspections shall be completed by the IC and relevant subject matter experts (SMEs) before the main IC Team inspection, or sufficient additional time shall be included in the field inspection schedule.

The following structures and areas shall be inspected by the IC Team.

Carmen Development

Carmen Diversion Dam embankment Carmen Diversion Spillway and sluiceway

Carmen Diversion Overflow Spillway Carmen Diversion Tunnel Intake Structure Smith Dam embankment

Smith Dam debris boom Smith Dam spillway Smith Dam intake tower Smith Dam power tunnel and penstock (non-entry inspection) Carmen Powerhouse Reservoir rim

Trail Bridge Development

Trail Bridge Dam embankment Trail Bridge Dam debris boom Trail Bridge service spillway Saddle dike and emergency spillway Outlet works (non-entry inspection) Trail Bridge Powerhouse Reservoir rim

A desktop assessment of each reservoir rim shall be conducted using readily available aerial imagery and the best available topographic data to identify potential vulnerabilities, including landslides and seiche hazards. It is assumed that FERC will require boat-based reservoir rim inspections at Smith Reservoir and Trail Bridge Reservoir but not at Carmen Diversion Reservoir. EWEB will provide vessel support; however, seating capacity is limited. EWEB will also provide access to the intake tower.

FERC may require remotely operated vehicle (ROV) inspections of the intake tower and intake structures before the field inspection. If the Consultant determines that an ROV inspection is necessary or FERC requires one, EWEB will procure the inspection.

The Consultant shall review instrumentation data and dam safety surveillance reports, including the underlying data. In accordance with the FERC guidelines, review of plots included in the Dam Safety Surveillance and Monitoring Reports (DSSMRs) alone is insufficient. The review shall evaluate:

Expected behavior for each instrument and the characteristics of unexpected behavior.

Historical readings and ongoing trends that may indicate adverse performance.

Whether established thresholds, automated alarms, and other monitoring triggers provide sufficient time for appropriate follow-up actions before substantial progression of a potential failure mode.

Relationships between instrument readings and environmental or operational factors, including reservoir elevation, precipitation, air and water temperatures, and Project operations.

The new Smith Dam spillway may be under construction as early as 2029, shortly after completion of the CA.

EWEB seeks the Consultant’s recommendation on whether the CA should evaluate existing conditions, anticipated conditions following completion of the new spillway, or a combination of both, subject to FERC requirements. The Consultant shall support discussions with EWEB and FERC to determine the appropriate approach.

A similar determination is needed for the Trail Bridge Development, where modifications to the Trail Bridge Dam and spillway, including work associated with the trap-and-haul facility, may also be underway as early as 2029.

Task 3 – CA Potential Failure Mode Analysis

In accordance with Chapter 17 of the FERC Engineering Guidelines, the PFMA workshop shall be conducted after completion of the field inspection.

For the Carmen Development, the Consultant shall assume a one-day, 10-hour inspection as described in Task 2, immediately followed by four days of in-person PFMA workshops. The inspection and PFMA workshops shall be scheduled consecutively, requiring a total of five business days (one full week) of in-person attendance. EWEB will provide the workshop location and coordinate arrangements in advance to facilitate travel planning.

For the Trail Bridge Development, the Consultant shall assume a one-day, 10-hour inspection as described in Task 2, immediately followed by four days of in-person PFMA workshops. The inspection and PFMA workshops shall be scheduled consecutively, requiring a total of five business days (one full week) of in-person attendance.

EWEB will provide the workshop location and coordinate arrangements in advance to facilitate travel planning.

The PFMA process shall extend beyond reviewing the previous PFMA report. For each Project feature, the PFMA shall begin with a brainstorming session to identify ways the feature could fail under various loading conditions.

During this initial brainstorming, the PFMA team, including the facilitator and other participants, shall not refer to previous PFMA reports or prepared lists of common potential failure modes (PFMs).

Before the workshop, PFMA team members shall review background information and prepare a preliminary list of candidate PFMs. After brainstorming is complete for each Project feature, the team may consult previous PFMA reports and prepared lists of common PFMs to identify overlooked failure modes and address gaps in the brainstorming results.

The team shall develop a list of candidate PFMs for subsequent evaluation and screening. For each candidate PFM, the team shall complete the description, evaluation, and screening process.

For PFMs previously identified and documented in earlier PFMA reports, the team may use existing documentation as a starting point. The team shall collectively review the documentation, evaluate each component of the PFM description, make necessary updates, and screen the PFM. For newly identified candidate PFMs, the team shall develop the description and complete the evaluation and screening process.

Task 4 – CA Level 2 Risk Analysis, Including Facilitator and Recorder

In accordance with Chapter 18 of the FERC Engineering Guidelines, the L2RA shall be conducted after completion of the PFMA described in Task 3. The L2RA shall include the following activities:

Additional PFM screening: The SMEs and facilitator shall evaluate the candidate PFMs to determine which are significant and should be carried forward into the L2RA.

Failure likelihood and consequence estimates: For credible PFMs selected for risk analysis, the team shall review, revise, and expand the factors identified during the PFMA that make each PFM more or less likely to occur. Relevant analysis results shall be incorporated, where applicable, and key factors shall be identified.

Confidence estimates: The team shall estimate confidence in the failure likelihood and consequence assessments for each PFM.

Potential risk reduction measures and management actions: The team shall identify potential measures, including changes to dam safety inspection types or frequencies, improvements to surveillance and monitoring, improvements to the Emergency Action Plan (EAP), and follow-up studies.

Potential interim and permanent risk reduction measures shall be identified where practicable.

Risk portrayal: The team shall document risk estimates and plot them on the established risk matrices.

The Consultant shall assume that the L2RA workshops for both developments will be conducted through virtual sessions. The Carmen Development L2RA shall require 10 eight-hour days, and the Trail Bridge Development L2RA shall require five eight-hour days.

The Consultant shall provide platforms that support live document sharing and editing and shall conduct virtual sessions using a collaborative video conferencing application, such as Microsoft Teams.

Task 5 – Comprehensive Assessment Report

Based on the document review, field inspection, and PFMA and L2RA workshops, the Consultant shall prepare Comprehensive Assessment Reports (CARs) generally in accordance with Chapter 16 of the FERC Engineering Guidelines and the outline provided in Appendix 16-D.

Each draft CAR shall be submitted in Word and PDF to aid in the review process. Each final CAR shall be submitted in Word and as a searchable PDF that supports printing and copying of high-resolution text and graphics. Relevant FERC correspondence, including the FERC inspection reminder letter and the Part 12D Inspection Plan and IC Team approval letters, shall be included in separate appendices.

Separate CARs shall be prepared for the Carmen and Trail Bridge Developments.

The CA-PIPRs shall serve as the basis for the CARs. This task shall include revising and finalizing the sections prepared for the CA-PIPRs and adding the following content:

Section 1 – Findings and Recommendations Sections 6.2.1, 6.2.3, and 6.2.4 – Field Inspection Observations Section 7 – PFMA and Risk Analysis

The CAR shall include the combined PFMA and L2RA report as Appendix I. This report shall describe each PFM considered, identify key adverse and favorable factors, recommend visual surveillance or monitoring, describe potential failure consequences, and document identified risk reduction measures and management actions.

Relevant drawings and photographs shall be included for each PFM where available.

The PFMA and L2RA report shall also include a statement regarding the adequacy of Project documentation and the overall quality of the PFMA data. The presentation developed for the PFMA workshop shall be appended to the report.

The report shall document the results of the L2RA, including:

PFMs considered in the risk analysis.

Failure likelihood and consequence estimates, including the rationale for each estimate.

Confidence ratings and the rationale supporting those ratings.

Additional information that could improve confidence ratings, where applicable.

Identified risk reduction measures and management actions.

Risk estimates and their portrayal.

Following the PFMA and L2RA workshops, the Consultant shall prepare and submit a combined draft PFMA and L2RA report, formatted for Section 1 of the STID, to EWEB for review. EWEB will consolidate comments from its reviewers into a single PDF or Microsoft Word document.

The Consultant shall prepare a comment resolution table documenting proposed responses to each EWEB comment. The ICs and Consultant staff shall participate in a video conference with EWEB to discuss comments on the draft report. Following resolution of comments, the Consultant shall issue the final PFMA and L2RA report for submission to FERC at least three weeks before the applicable FERC submittal deadline.

Deliverables

1. Carmen Development CAR – Draft and Final.

2. Trail Bridge Development CAR – Draft and Final.

Task 6 – Comprehensive Assessment Report Presentation and Review Meeting

The Consultant shall prepare for and attend a virtual CA review meeting with FERC to present the CA findings and recommendations. Members of the IC Team shall participate in the meeting.

The presentation shall include a summary of the CA, time for questions from FERC and EWEB, a summary of follow-up activities, and final remarks and conclusions.

The meeting shall be held within 45 days after submission of the CAR to FERC. The Consultant shall submit the presentation to EWEB at least 10 days before the meeting. EWEB will coordinate the meeting date and virtual meeting arrangements with FERC and the Consultant.

Each CA review meeting is anticipated to last approximately three hours. In addition, the ICs shall attend a separate two-hour virtual presentation-planning meeting with EWEB for each development before the corresponding CA review meeting.

Deliverables

1. Carmen Development presentation slides – Draft and Final.

2. Trail Bridge Development presentation slides – Draft and Final.

Task 7 – Hydrologic Hazard Assessment

To support the L2RA, the Consultant shall conduct a Hydrologic Hazard Assessment (HHA) to establish curves relating reservoir elevation to annual exceedance probability based on historical inflow volumes and reservoir water-surface elevations.

The analysis should use historical reservoir water-level data recorded at subdaily intervals, preferably hourly, and a period of record of at least 30 years. An HHA was previously completed by R2 Consultants in 2018 for the Part 12D Inspection.

The Consultant shall review available USGS streamflow gages within the watershed and, if necessary, supplement these data with streamflow records from adjacent watersheds. The Consultant shall evaluate whether EWEB and USGS data are sufficient for the analysis or whether rainfall-runoff modeling is needed.

The Consultant shall conduct a probabilistic HHA using the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) Risk Management Center tools Best Fit and Reservoir Frequency Analysis (RMC-BestFit and RMC-RFA). The analysis shall produce inflow-volume curves and stage-frequency curves relating reservoir inflow volumes and water-surface elevations to annual exceedance probability (AEP).

The Consultant shall document the HHA approach and findings in a technical memorandum to be included as an appendix to the CAR.

EWEB will provide spillway rating curves and reservoir stage-storage curves. The Consultant shall develop a hydrologic hazard curve representing typical Project operations for use during the L2RA workshop using RMC- BestFit and RMC-RFA.

Task 8 – Seismic Hazard Assessment

Probabilistic seismic loading estimates are required to support the risk analysis. EWEB will provide the site-specific Seismic Hazard Assessment (SHA) prepared by LCI in 2024 and accepted by FERC.

The Consultant shall review the LCI (2024) assessment and compare its results with published USGS seismic hazard curves. The resulting seismic hazard information shall be incorporated into the critical load estimation tables used during the L2RA. The Consultant shall review the existing seismic analyses and identify any data gaps that need to be addressed to support the risk assessment.

Task 9 – Life Loss Consequences Study and Inundation Mapping

Consequence analysis is a key component of the risk analysis and, together with the HHA and SHA, supports development of the risk analysis frequency-consequence (f-N) matrix. Potential adverse consequences include loss of the reservoir, loss of human life, and environmental and economic impacts.

In accordance with Chapter 18 of the FERC Engineering Guidelines, life safety shall be the primary consideration in the risk analysis. Economic and environmental consequences shall also be evaluated to help prioritize dam safety actions. FERC requires consequence estimates to be developed before the PFMA and L2RA workshops.

The Consultant shall conduct consequence analyses to estimate potential loss of human life and environmental and economic impacts. Potential loss of life depends on the population at risk (PAR) within the dam-break inundation area, flood severity, and available warning time.

The Consultant shall use LifeSim, the USACE Risk Management Center’s life-loss and direct-damage estimation software, or an equivalent industry-standard tool. LifeSim simulates warning and evacuation processes to estimate potential loss of life and economic and environmental damages resulting from flooding.

Hydraulic Data and Failure Scenarios

The Consultant shall use LifeSim to import hydraulic results from the existing HEC-RAS modeling, assuming the existing dam failure analysis is compatible with LifeSim.

The imported results shall be used to evaluate flood and sunny-day embankment breach scenarios. The provided HEC-RAS model shall also be used to evaluate inundation and life-loss consequences for flood and sunny-day breaches of the spillway and gates.

Breach geometries shall represent a reasonable range of conditions associated with the relevant PFMs. The following scenarios shall be evaluated where they have potential life-safety consequences:

1. Flood without breach, to establish incremental consequences excluding lives at risk from the flood alone.

2. Flood breach of the spillway.

3. Flood breach of the embankment.

4. Sunny-day spillway breach.

5. Sunny-day embankment breach.

Impact Area

Consequence estimates for the L2RA shall represent the best reasonable estimates rather than worst-case scenarios. The initial reservoir elevation shall be established in coordination with the IC, facilitator, consequences SME, and EWEB to develop a reasonable scenario.

The Consultant shall evaluate downstream catchments and other features that could affect inundation areas.

The extent of the inundation analysis shall be coordinated with EWEB and is not anticipated to extend beyond the downstream limit of the existing dam failure analysis.

Flood Loading Scenarios

Several potential failure modes (PFM) associated with the PMF flood loading. Some of these PFMs may be taken to risk estimation, and some will be screened out.

To be screened out, the annual exceedance probability (AEP) should be clearly greater than 10^-7. If the recurrence interval associated with the PMF is sufficiently low (perhaps on the order of 100,000 years, i.e. the flood loading likelihood is around 3x10-4 or 10-5), consultant will review the event trees associated with the flood PFMs to evaluate if the other nodes are likely to push the overall PFM likelihood below the 10^-7 threshold. If it appears likely the flood load scenarios will be screened out during the workshop, consultant will not prepare any consequences associated with the flood loading at this time.

Structure Inventory

The Consultant shall use Version 2 of the USACE National Structure Inventory as the initial building inventory.

The inventory shall be reviewed against other available sources, such as Geographic Names Information System (GNIS) data, Microsoft building layers, aerial imagery, and other relevant datasets, to verify that structures are appropriately represented and located.

Inundation Mapping

Using the hydraulic models and results developed for the life-loss and consequence analyses Trail Bridge and Carmen developments, the Consultant shall prepare inundation maps in ESRI shapefile format for the sunny-day and PMF Trail Bridge dam-failure scenarios evaluated. Consultants shall also prepare inundation maps in ESRI shapefile format for the sunny-day and PMF for both developments Trail Bridge and Carmen (Smith/Carmen Diversion) dam-failure scenarios evaluated.

The Consultant shall coordinate with EWEB and FERC to develop color 11-by-17-inch inundation maps incorporating the best available National Agriculture Imagery Program (NAIP) color aerial imagery. Maps shall generally be prepared at a scale of one inch to 1,000 feet, except in rural areas with minimal development.

The maps shall show sunny-day and PMF dam-failure inundation boundaries and identify dam-breach information at critical locations, including:

Distance from the dam.

Flood-wave arrival time.

Time to peak.

Peak discharge.

Maximum flow depth.

Maximum flow velocity.

The maps shall also show maximum flood depths using color-coded hazard ratings and identify roads, highways, and other critical infrastructure affected by the dam-breach flood wave, including major roads expected to be overtopped.

Each map shall include the required Project information, graphic scale, north arrow, breach assumptions and routing methods, confidentiality and proprietary statement, and data sources. Mapping shall be developed using ESRI ArcMap 10.8.2 and formatted for use in the EAP documents.

Dam Failure Inundation Mapping Technical Memorandum

Following completion of the dam-failure and routing analyses, the Consultant shall prepare a Dam Failure Inundation Mapping Report summarizing the hydraulic analyses performed under this task. The Consultant shall also provide the electronic files developed for the engineering analyses, inundation mapping, and computer models.

The report shall generally follow this organization:

1. Introduction

2. Project Description

3. Potential Downstream Inundation Areas

4. HEC-RAS Analysis

5. Results

6. Inundation Mapping

7. Conclusions

8. References

9. Appendices

The Consultant shall submit a draft report electronically to EWEB for review and comment and incorporate EWEB’s comments into the final report. The final deliverables shall include the report, electronic files, PDFs of the inundation maps, supporting calculations, and hydraulic and hydrologic models.

The report shall include reservoir capacity tables, other relevant dam and reservoir data, tabulated hydraulic data for each cross section or critical structure location, and abbreviated computer-model output or as requested by FERC for review. The report shall satisfy applicable FERC documentation requirements and be suitable for inclusion in or as supporting documentation for the EAP.

Task 10 – Project Management

The Consultant shall assume a total project duration of 24 months. In the lead-up to key project milestones, biweekly meetings are anticipated to support timely progress and effective communication between the Consultant and EWEB.

The Consultant shall prepare and distribute meeting agendas at least 24 hours before each biweekly meeting and provide meeting notes to the project team within 48 hours after each meeting.

Shortly after the kickoff meeting, the Consultant shall provide a Gantt-style project schedule identifying key milestones and deliverables. The Consultant shall update and distribute the schedule to the project team as appropriate throughout the project.

Task 11 – Additional Virtual Workshop Time Allowance

Additional two weeks of workshop time may be required depending on project-specific circumstances.

Consultant shall include internal staff and SME required for PFMA/L2RA workshop (week for each development).

Potential causes include FERC requirements for the IC Team’s review of spillway and fish-passage facilities at either development, changes to FERC guidelines, or additional time needed to develop and evaluate PFMs.

EWEB may authorize this optional task when additional workshop time is warranted.

This is the start of the file's text. The full file is on GovTribe.

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .