Appendix A Evaluation Forms.pdf
PDF 161 KB Posted
- Attached to
- NCC WTP - Collection System Optimization
- Solicitation number
- RFP FAAA 2027000097 2
- Issued by
- Grand County, Colorado
About this file
This document consists of evaluation forms for Integrated Project Delivery (IPD) General Contractor/Construction Manager (GC/CM) services issued by the State of Colorado Office of the State Architect, State Buildings Program. The evaluation forms are designed to assess and rank qualified firms competing for state construction projects through a qualifications-based selection process combined with sealed fee proposals. The forms establish standardized criteria and scoring methodologies for evaluating multiple firms across various project delivery aspects, though specific project details, response dates, due dates, site visit information, and award timelines are not included in this appendix.
The evaluation process employs a weighted scoring system with ratings from 0 (not provided) to 5 (excellent) across six primary categories: qualifications of the firm(s), qualifications of management team members, project management approach, prior project experience/success, equity/diversity/inclusion practices, and claims/litigation history. The ranking methodology incorporates a 60/40 split between qualifications (40 points maximum) and sealed proposal fees (60 points maximum), with qualifications scores determined as a percentage of the highest scoring firm's qualifications and proposal scores based on the lowest submitted fee being equivalent to the maximum 60 points available. All evaluators' scores are averaged to determine each firm's final qualifications score, which is then combined with the proposal score to establish cumulative rankings, with the highest-scoring firm identified as most qualified and advantageous to the state. Pricing terms, set-asides, incumbents, funding sources, and contract duration information are not specified in these evaluation forms.
View the file
Other files
Show all 19
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
IPD-GMP-App-A (R1)
STATE OF COLORADO
OFFICE OF THE STATE ARCHITECT
STATE BUILDINGS PROGRAM
APPENDIX A: EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS FORM:
INTEGRATED PROJECT DELIVERY
Name of Firm:____________________________________________________________________ Name of Project: _________________________________________________________________ Evaluator No:_______________________________________ Date:______________________________________________
RFP REFERENCE MINIMUM REQUIREMENTS Y ____ N ____
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT AND ATTESTATION INCLUDED: Y ____ N ____
If the minimum requirements have not been met, specify the reason(s):
INSTRUCTIONS:
1. Weights are to be assigned prior to evaluation and are to be consistent on all evaluation forms.
2. Use only whole numbers.
3. Rating: 0 = not provided, 1 = Unacceptable, 2 = Poor, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
4. Total score includes the sum total of all criteria.
5. A passing score (as a percentage of the total points available) is to be established by the state prior to evaluation.
1. QUALIFICATIONS OF THE FIRM(S) Weight X Rating = Score ◻ Overall qualifications 5 x =
◻ Organizational structure/lines of authority 2 X =
◻ Subcontractor selection and management 3 X
◻ Colorado workforce 1 X
◻ Safety/employee support 3 X
2. QUALIFICATIONS OF MANAGEMENT TEAM MEMBERS Weight X Rating = Score
◻ Qualifications and relevant experience of superintendent 5 X =
◻ Qualifications and relevant experience of in-house staff 5 X
◻ Location/Access 2
3. PROJECT MANAGEMENT APPROACH Weight X Rating = Score ◻ Approach to successful CM/GC Services
Cost Effectiveness 5 X =
Schedule effectiveness 10 X
Quality effectiveness 10 X
◻ Competitively Bid/Self Performed Work 5
4. PRIOR PROJECT EXPERIENCE/SUCCESS Weight X Rating = Score ◻ Project #1 8 X =
Timeliness
Disruption
Budget Considerations
Quality
Acceptability/Punchlist
Compliance ◻ Project #2 8 X =
Timeliness
Disruption
Budget Considerations
Quality
Acceptability/Punchlist
Compliance ◻ Project #3 8 X =
Timeliness
Disruption
Budget Considerations
Quality
Acceptability/Punchlist
Compliance
5. EQUITY, DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION Weight X Rating = Score ◻ Hiring and Promotion Practices 5 X =
◻ Subcontracting Practices 5 X =
6. MISCELLANEOUS Weight X Rating = Score
◻ Claims/litigation history 5 X =
Total Score: _________
STATE BUILDINGS PROGRAM
APPENDIX A1: EVALUATION OF QUALIFICATIONS FORM:
INTEGRATED PROJECT DELIVERY
Name of Firm:____________________________________________________________________ Name of Project: _________________________________________________________________ Evaluator No:_______________________________________ Date:______________________________________________
INSTRUCTIONS:
1. Weights are to be assigned prior to evaluation and are to be consistent on all evaluation forms.
2. Use only whole numbers.
3. Rating: 0 = not provided, 1 = Unacceptable, 2 = Poor, 3 = Fair, 4 = Good, 5 = Excellent
4. Total score includes the sum total of all criteria.
5. A passing score (as a percentage of the total points available) is to be established by the state prior to evaluation.
1. QUALIFICATIONS OF THE FIRM(S) Weight
Rating
Score
5 x =
2. QUALIFICATIONS OF MANAGEMENT TEAM
MEMBERS
10 X =
3. PROJECT MANAGEMENT APPROACH
10 X =
4. PRIOR PROJECT EXPERIENCE/SUCCESS
5 X =
5. EQUITY, DIVERSITY AND INCLUSION
5 X =
Total Score: _________
STATE BUILDINGS PROGRAM
APPENDIX A2: QUALIFICATIONS AND PROPOSAL RANKING
MATRIX: INTEGRATED PROJECT DELIVERY
INSTRUCTIONS/EXAMPLE:
1. QUALIFICATIONS Example uses the 60% / Fee 40% split. Insert total score from each evaluator's SUBMITTAL review.
2. Add all evaluators’ total scores and divide by the number of evaluators to determine the average score for each firm’s qualifications.
3. The maximum score for qualifications on the evaluation form is equivalent to 40 points and is equivalent to the maximum points available for qualifications. Therefore, each firm’s score is determined as a percentage of the maximum points available. To score each average qualification score, use the example formula.
4. Assume the highest score is 600.
SCORING OF QUALIFICATIONS
FIRM B: 600 X 40 points = 40 points
FIRM C: 500 X 40 points = 33.33 points
FIRM A: 400 X 40 points = 26.66 points
5. Determine score for each firm’s sealed proposal with the lowest fee being equivalent to a maximum score of 60 points. To score each proposal, use the example formula.
6. Assume the lowest Proposal was $100,000.
SCORING OF PROPOSALS
FIRM A: $100,000 X 60 points = 60 points $100,000
FIRM B: $100,000 X 60 points = 48 points $125,000
FIRM C: $100,000 X 60 points = 39.99 points $150,000
7. Add the average qualification score to the Proposal score to determine cumulative qualifications and fee score.
8. Numerically rank all firms with the highest scoring firm being the most qualified and advantageous to the state.
FIRM
QUALIFICATIONS
AVE.
QUALS
SCORE
PROPOS
AL
PROPO
SAL
RANK
EVAL
#1
EVA
L #2
EVA
L #3
EVA
L #4
EVA
L #5
EVA
L #6
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .