Amendment #1 - Q&A - RFP PMAA 2027_0007.pdf

PDF 208 KB Posted

Attached to
CPW On-Call Water Resource Engineering Services
Solicitation number
RFP PMAA 20270000000000000007 2
Issued by
Colorado

About this file

This Amendment #1 document provides Questions and Answers clarifications for RFP PMAA 2027_0007, issued by Colorado Parks and Wildlife (CPW), for on-call water resources engineering services related to water rights and water court matters. CPW seeks qualified vendors to provide comprehensive water resources engineering support statewide across all Colorado water divisions, including services related to water rights applications, water court litigation, hydrological analysis, and engineering valuations. The solicitation anticipates awarding multiple on-call contracts to ensure statewide geographic coverage and conflict-free representation. CPW holds water rights in every water division across the state and has significant ongoing water court involvement, currently participating as an opposer in 39 active cases while prosecuting 10 applications; historically, CPW files approximately 40 applications over five-year periods, predominantly diligence applications. The contract term is five years, with task orders to be directly assigned to selected contractors based on conflict clearance, technical specialty, geographic familiarity, and availability rather than through formal competition among awardees.

Pricing is based on billable hourly rates organized by labor category and personnel role, with support staff listed by category rather than individually named; reimbursable expenses beyond hourly rates include mileage at Colorado State Controller rates, travel time, field expenses, and specialized costs, either at billable unit rates or cost-plus markup as specified. Key Personnel must be named with resumes provided for evaluation purposes, and CPW approval is required for key personnel assignments on individual task orders; a Colorado Professional Engineer license is not required, but personnel performing expert witness duties must possess sufficient qualifications and preferably prior water court expert witness experience. The RFP does not specify an anticipated number of awarded contractors, minimum work guarantees, or concentrated need in particular technical disciplines or geographic areas. Conflicts of interest disclosures are limited to major, actual conflicts such as existing client relationships precluding work in specific drainage basins or water divisions; matter-by-matter conflict resolution occurs at the task order stage, and ethical screens may be accepted depending on specific circumstances. Annual rate adjustments are contractor-requested and state-discretionary, based on Chained CPI data submitted before November 1st. No federal funding is anticipated, and work is expected to be performed in Colorado with potential out-of-state work allowed upon written notice.

View the file

Other files

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Amendment #1 - Questions & Answers (Q&A)

RFP PMAA 2027*0007

CPW On-Call Water Resources Engineering

A. The following questions, and the answer to each, were received:

1. Could CPW share details on its existing portfolio of water rights and areas of water operations in the State so that Offerors can check for conflicts?

Does CPW have a larger list of other water rights and operations that could be shared?

i. CPW is one of the largest water rights users in the state. There are water rights in active use in every single water division including direct flow, storage and groundwater rights. We do not have a single list of water rights that can be shared. To learn about operations, please look at the CPW website to see where there are state wildlife areas, state parks, and hatcheries. Not every property will have water rights operations that Offerors may provide assistance on. Each task order we will conduct a specific conflicts check before entering any task orders. However, the question here is to help the State understand the major conflicts (such as Offeror can’t work for CPW in a water division because they have a major client involved in everything in that specific division or they can’t work on a particular major drainage basin because of a big client).

Please focus on actual conflicts not potential conflicts. The State needs to know if Offeror's current clients prevent them from taking other work in certain areas so that CPW can ensure it has vendors to fill those gaps.

2. Since the nature of on-call services solicitation acknowledges the potential for conflicts, will the nature of the type of work also be taken into consideration? For example, a conflict may exist in working on a water right, however a conflict may not exist in the same location designing a diversion structure.

i. CPW will consider the nature of the conflict rather than the category of work, and the responsibility will rest with the contractor to determine whether it can represent CPW without a conflict on any given assignment. At the solicitation stage, CPW is only looking for

Offerors to disclose major, actual conflicts—such as existing client relationships that preclude them from working in a specific drainage basin or water division—so that CPW can award multiple contracts to ensure statewide coverage. Selected firms must conduct a project-specific conflict check prior to entering into any task order and confirm whether its existing client obligations allow it to represent CPW’s interests on that specific matter regardless of the category of work. If the contractor determines it has a conflict, CPW will assign the task order to another contracted vendor.

3. For the engineering valuation work, are you looking for a Certified General

Appraiser in water rights? Since USPAP is a part of appraiser licensure, are you seeking a professional knowledgeable in the awareness of ethics, scope, record keeping, and competency components included in a valuation, are you seeking a 15-hr USPAP certification, or are you seeking an Appraiser?

i. CPW is not looking for a certified appraiser or specific appraisal certification. The contractor may be asked to provide engineering or other assistance in support of an official appraisal. Please indicate whether the Offeror has any appraiser certifications for future reference, but the work contemplated at this time does not need specialized certifications of any kind.

4. To assist in the determination and proper communication of potential conflicts of interest, will you please provide more details regarding the locations of potential projects under this RFP? This can be accomplished by way of a list and map of all CPW regions, properties, and facilities within the statewide service area.

i. See response to question 1.

5. Does CPW anticipate assigning work primarily based on geographic region, technical specialty, availability or a combination of these factors?

i. CPW anticipates assigning work based on a combination of these three factors alongside a conflict of interest clearance. Because

CPW intends to award multiple on-call contracts to achieve statewide coverage across all CPW regions and Colorado Water

Divisions, individual task orders will be matched to the best suited firm based on 1) conflict of interest clearance, 2) technical specialty and qualifications, 3) geographic region and basin familiarity, and 4) availability and responsiveness.

6. Will individual task order generally be competed among the selected on-call consultants, or does CPW anticipate directly assigning work based on qualifications, expertise, availability, conflicts, or other considerations?

i. CPW anticipates directly assigning individual task orders rather than running a formal competition among selected on-call Offers for every project. Individual task orders will be matched to the best suited firm based on 1) conflict of interest clearance, 2) technical specialty and qualifications, 3) geographic region and basin familiarity, and 4) availability and responsiveness. See #5 above.

The task order framework is specifically designed to streamline the allocation of work to the most qualified, unconflicted, and available firm without delaying critical project or litigation schedules.

7. Are there particular technical disciplines, geographic areas, or types of water-resources assignments where CPW currently anticipates the greatest need for outside consultant support?

i. Due to the breadth and depth of CPW’s water rights portfolio, no— there are no single technical disciplines, geographic areas, or assignment types where CPW anticipates a concentrated need.

CPW holds water rights in every water division across the state and is seeking qualified vendors capable of supporting the full range of services outlined in the solicitation as project and water court needs arise.

8. If available, please provide the relative weighting, point values, or scoring matrix for each evaluation criterion in Sections 3.5 through 3.7. For the price scoring, please describe how hourly rates will be compared across

Offerors with different staffing structures (for example, by labor category, weighted average, or a hypothetical task order).

i. Proposals will be evaluated by the Evaluation Committee using the evaluation criteria outlined in sections 3.2-3.7. The evaluators will consider whether the submittal requirements in section 2.0 the solicitation have been addressed and they will review the capabilities of the Offeror as it relates to the Scope of Work aspect or any other aspect determined relevant to the evaluation criteria.

ii. Pricing will be evaluated based on the relative value against the services offered through the firm resume and level of qualifications of the firm personnel.

9. Does CPW have an ideal anticipated number of awarded Offerors?

i. No. The number of awarded Offerors will depend on the amount of proposals submitted and which of those proposals are determined to be able to provide the needed services at best value to the State.

10. Can CPW share, within the 5-year term of the on-call contract, the anticipated number of applications where CPW will be the Applicant, and the anticipated number of applications where CPW will be an Opposer?

i. The number of applications where CPW serves as the Applicant varies significantly from year to year and cannot be precisely forecasted. In some years, CPW may not file any applications, while in other years it may file several or more. The volume of applications where CPW acts as an Opposer is more consistent and predictable, as it is common for CPW to file Statements of

Opposition (SOPs) to applications published in the monthly water court resume. For context regarding current workload, CPW is presently participating as an opposer in 39 active cases and is prosecuting 10 applications. In the last 5 years, CPW has filed approximately 40 applications, most of which were diligence applications.

11. Has CPW operated under any on-call water resources engineering contracts related to water rights and water court in the past? If so, can

CPW share the anticipated annual expenditure or the historical volume of projects under any prior engineering contract(s)?

i. No, CPW has not operated under any on-call water resources engineering contracts related to water rights and water court in the past.

12. Please clarify what CPW considers a conflict of interest for purposes of the Section 2.3 disclosure. For example, is a conflict limited to current representation of a party adverse to CPW in a pending water court case, or does it extend to any client work in a water division where CPW holds water rights, or to representation of other water users who may oppose

CPW in the future?

i. At this stage, CPW is only looking for Offerors to disclose major, actual conflicts—such as existing client relationships or exclusivities that preclude the firm from working in a specific drainage basin or water division. These conflicts would include instances where a current Offeror client is actively opposing a CPW application or where a current Offeror client has such broad interests or activities that the Offeror cannot take on any other clients in a specific drainage or water division. This allows CPW to award multiple contracts to ensure adequate statewide coverage. General representation of other water users within a division where CPW holds water rights does not automatically constitute a disqualifying conflict unless it prevents the firm from representing CPW's interests.

13. Section 3.3 states firms will be compared in areas where no conflict is indicated. Does disclosure of a conflict in a particular water basin exclude the Offeror from consideration only for that basin, or does it also affect the

Offeror’s overall consideration in that Water Division or state-wide? Will

CPW accept internal ethical screens, or matter-by-matter conflict resolution at the task order stage, as a means of addressing potential conflicts?

i. Disclosing a conflict in a specific drainage basin only limits an

Offeror’s consideration for that particular basin—it does not disqualify or negatively impact the firm's overall consideration for unaffected basins within the same Water Division or elsewhere statewide. CPW is utilizing this disclosure process specifically to award multiple contracts and ensure complete, conflict-free coverage across all regions of the state. CPW will rely on matter-by-matter conflict resolution at the task order stage. Prior to entering into any individual task order, the selected firm will be responsible for conducting a project-specific conflict check to verify whether it can represent CPW’s interests without a conflict. CPW may accept ethical screens, depending on the specific matter needs. If Offeror has an ethical screen process, please explain how the process operates generally.

14. Section 2.5 requires a list of all billable personnel. May Offerors list support staff by labor category, with Key Personnel named individually? If staff join or leave the firm during the contract term, may new staff be billed at the rate of the applicable labor category? We note that Section 4.B.i.d of the Model Main Task Order Contract prohibits including work in a Task

Order for which an applicable rate is not provided. Also, what approval process, if any, applies to substituting Key Personnel?

i. Yes, Offerors may list support staff by labor category or role and only provide individually named personnel for the key personnel roles. The rate sheet should include all roles that will be contributing to the proposed services and the associated rates for each role. Names are not needed for any staff role on the rate sheet. The rates for each provided staff role shall not change unless done so through the instructions outlined in RFP section 4.4

Annual Rate Adjustments. If the list of staff roles changes, a formal amendment to the contract is required to modify the list of roles on the rate sheet. Providing key personnel names and CV/resumes as part of the proposal is for evaluation. Upon issuance of a task order

CPW will confirm the finalized Statement of Work with the consultant, including which staff roles will contribute and the number of hours each staff role will commit to completing that task order. For key personnel, CPW will approve upon issuance of a task order whether the proposed key personnel can complete the assigned personnel role for that task order. (See “Amendment #1

RFP PMAA 2027*0007 - CPW On-Call Water Resources

Engineering” posted with this amendment #1 Q&A for updated language)

15. Does CPW require that personnel performing engineering analyses, or signing engineering reports and expert disclosures, hold a Colorado

Professional Engineer license? Are there other minimum qualifications

CPW expects for Key Personnel serving as water court experts?

i. A Colorado Professional Engineer license is not required. The contractor must be sufficiently qualified however to perform expert witness duties in order to ensure any preliminary materials are developed with a proper standard of care. The primary preferred qualification is prior experience serving as a water court expert witness.

https://osc.colorado.gov/financial-operations/fiscal-rules-procedures/travel-fiscal-rule/mileage-reimbursement-rate

16. For project examples: (a) Does “total cost of the project” refer to the

Offeror’s fee or the client’s total project cost? (b) May examples include projects completed by current Key Personnel while employed at a prior firm or public agency, if clearly identified as such? (c) May examples involving confidential settlement or litigation matters be described without identifying the client?

i. “Total cost of the project” refers to the Offeror’s total consultant fee working on the project, not the client’s total project cost.

ii. Yes, the examples can include projects completed by Key

Personnel while employed at a prior firm or public agency as long as they are identified as such. Total cost for such prior work is not necessary or relevant.

iii. Client name is not included as part of the details required to be shared in the project examples.

17. Section 4.3 indicates payment will be based on billable hours. Are reimbursable expenses (for example, mileage, lodging, per diem, field equipment, laboratory analysis, data purchases, or specialized software) billable under task orders? If so, at what rates (for example, State travel reimbursement rates), and should they be shown on the rate sheet? If not, should hourly rates be fully loaded to include these costs?

i. Other reimbursable expenses in addition to the personnel hourly rates shall be provided at a billable unit rate or noted as “at cost” for reimbursements that can vary in cost. Any expenses that include a markup shall include the associated percentage markup. Mileage will be reimbursed based on the current “State of Colorado” rates posted by the State of Colorado Office of the State Controller as the following link: https://osc.colorado.gov/financial-operations/fiscal-rules-procedures/travel-fiscal-rule/mileage-reimbursement-rate

(See “Amendment #1 RFP PMAA 2027*0007 - CPW On-Call Water

Resources Engineering” posted with this amendment #1 Q&A for updated language) https://osc.colorado.gov/financial-operations/fiscal-rules-procedures/travel-fiscal-rule/mileage-reimbursement-rate https://osc.colorado.gov/financial-operations/fiscal-rules-procedures/travel-fiscal-rule/mileage-reimbursement-rate https://osc.colorado.gov/financial-operations/fiscal-rules-procedures/travel-fiscal-rule/mileage-reimbursement-rate

ii. Staff time spent performing authorized project work—including necessary site inspections and required travel time—is billed at contracted hourly rates.

18. May Offerors propose separate hourly rates for expert witness services

(deposition and trial testimony) on the rate sheet? Will the rates established under this contract apply to any separate agreement with the

Attorney General’s Office referenced in Exhibit A Section 1.7?

i. Yes. Offerors may include separate hourly rate tiers for expert witness services (such as deposition and trial testimony) on the solicitation rate sheet, as those services may be utilized by CPW under this contract.

ii. No. When expert witness or trial-related services are contracted directly through the Colorado Attorney General’s Office under a separate agreement, that contracting process is entirely independent of this CPW procurement. Rates and terms for AGO contracts are established directly with the AGO at that time and are not governed by the rate sheet submitted under this solicitation.

19. RFP Section 4.4 states that annual rate adjustments will be based on an average of the prior 12 months of Chained CPI published before

November 1, while Section 5.C of the Model Main Task Order Contract describes rate adjustments as the State’s option, based on the percent change in Chained CPI during the most recent 12-month period. Please clarify which provision governs, and whether the Contractor may request an annual adjustment or whether adjustments are made solely at the

State’s discretion.

i. Contractors shall submit rate adjustments and the State, at its discretion, shall have the option to modify the Contractor’s billing rates established in Exhibit A. Rate adjustment requests must be submitted before November 1st of each year. The Model Main Task

Order Contract States, “the average percentage will be calculated from the most recent 12-month period for which data is available at a time reasonably in advance of the renewal date.” The RFP section 4.4 establishes November 1 as the request deadline to ensure time reasonably in advance of the renewal date, which is expected to be January 1 of each year.

20. What is the award process for selected offerors providing Task Orders for each Project Type? Can CPW provide the selection criteria for awarding

Task Orders to selected Offerors?

i. CPW will directly assign individual task orders to contracted firms.

This streamlined framework is specifically designed to efficiently route assignments to the most qualified, unconflicted, and available firm without delaying critical project or water court litigation schedules. CPW will match and directly assign individual task orders to the best-suited firm based on the following four criteria:

1. Conflict of Interest Clearance: Confirmation that the firm has no existing client obligations or conflicts precluding it from representing CPW’s interests on the specific matter.

2. Technical Specialty and Qualifications: Alignment of the firm’s specific engineering, hydrological, or water rights expertise with the technical demands of the project.

3. Geographic Region and Basin Familiarity: Prior experience and working knowledge within the specific drainage basin, water division, or CPW region involved.

4. Availability and Responsiveness: Capacity to mobilize quickly and meet project or court-mandated deadlines.

21. Regarding the separate agreement with the Attorney General’s Office for trial-related work: Is that agreement expected to be a separate procurement or a direct award to the firm already engaged on the matter?

Would the firm continue to perform advisory work for CPW under this contract concurrently?

i. Typically the AGO will enter into a separate contract for expert duties during the water court phase of a project. Ideally the same firm that provided the preliminary analyses in support of a water court action would be selected by the AGO to perform expert witness duties, but this is not required. A firm that is awarded a separate AGO contract may continue to provide services under this contract.

22. The Model Main Task Order Contract lists Exhibit E, Federal Provisions, first in the order of precedence, but Exhibit E is not included in the posted document. Does CPW anticipate that task orders may be funded in whole or in part with federal funds? If so, please provide Exhibit E. Please also confirm how the out-of-state performance notice in Section 6.C, which does not apply when Contract Funds include federal funds, will be administered.

i. Federal funding will not be utilized for this work. Any reference to

Exhibit E in the Model Main Task Order Contract can be disregarded and Federal Provisions will not apply. Section 6.C will apply through the entire duration of the contract due to no Federal

Funds being utilized.

23. The Model Main Task Order Contract 6.A requires monthly progress reports. Can CPW provide additional detail on the contents of the report and means by which it can be submitted, such as an email?

i. Reporting content and format will be agreed upon and included in the specific Statement of Work for each Task order. Separate monthly reports for the main Contract will not be required automatically, but reports may be requested by CPW.

24. Please confirm which items count toward the 15-page limit. Specifically, are the conflicts of interest disclosure, personnel list, rate sheet, project examples, contract redlines, and any Request for Confidentiality excluded, as are the cover page, cover letter, resumes, and Submission Form? Are there font size, margin, or page size requirements?

i. RFP section 2.1 states: Proposals shall be no longer than 15 pages in length. The page limit will not include a cover page, cover letter, resumes or the required submission form. Any information besides a cover page, cover letter, resumes or the required submission form will count towards the page limit. See RFP section 5.6 for instructions regarding submission of a Request for Confidentiality.

The “written request” will not count towards the page limit. The second proposal reflecting redacted information will not count towards the page limit. DNR asks Offerors to follow the page limit instructions in section 2.1 for the proposal that will be reviewed by the evaluation committee and ensure the second proposal submitted with redacted information is identical to the original proposal, only with the requested redactions.

25. Submission Form Question 8 asks Offerors to affirm that 100% of the work will be performed within Colorado, while Section 4.6 allows out-of-state work with written notice. Will a “No” response to Question 8 (for example, due to a remote staff member or out-of-state subcontractor) render a proposal non-responsive? Additionally, could CPW specify what form the written notice should be in (for example, a form that is submitted for approval or an email letter)?

i. The RFP does not state anywhere that a proposal is non-responsive if a “No” response is provided to Submission Form question 8 noting that work is being completed outside of the State of Colorado. Submission Form Question 8 helps DNR identify if

Contractors are out-of-state so that DNR can fulfill the requirement of notifying the Colorado Department of Personnel & Administration so the information can be posted on the Colorado Department of

Personnel & Administration’s website as noted in section 4.6. The response to Submission Form question 8 serves as the written notice.

26. Question 9 does not include Yes/No response blanks; please confirm how

Offerors should respond.

i. Submission Form question 9 has been corrected to include the

Yes/No response blanks.

27. Section 3.Y of the Model Main Task Order Contract excludes from Work

Product only pre-existing material “used, without modification,” while

Section 15.C provides that the Contractor retains ownership of pre-existing materials. If an Offeror’s pre-existing tool, model, spreadsheet, or template is modified or adapted for a task order, does the State own the modified tool in its entirety, or only the task order-specific modifications, with the Contractor retaining ownership of the underlying pre-existing material?

i. If an Offeror's pre-existing tool, model, spreadsheet, or template is protected under copyright or other legal means as proprietary or a trade secret, the pre-existing tool, model, spreadsheet, or template is owned by Offeror and will remain the property of the Offeror even if modified or adapted for a task order. The State owns exclusive right to any input data provided by the State and the product or output of the tool, model, spreadsheet, or template, adapted or not, that is the result of a task order. If the modified Work Product delivered to the State as part of work completed for this Contract required sufficient modification to the pre-existing tool, model, spreadsheet, or template such that the material no longer rationally resembles the pre-existing tool, model, spreadsheet, or template, the modified Work Product shall be the exclusive property of the

State. The Contractor retains the exclusive rights, title, and ownership to any and all preexisting materials owned or licensed to

Contractor including, but not limited to, all pre-existing software, licensed products, associated source code, machine code, text images, audio and/or video, and third-party materials, delivered by

Contractor under the Contract, whether incorporated in a

Deliverable or necessary to use a Deliverable (collectively, “Contractor Property”). Contractor must notify the State whether

Contractor Property that will be used or modified to satisfy a task order holds some copyright or other legal protection as proprietary or a trade secret. Contractor will bear all costs of protecting

Contractor Property related to any CORA request for the material.

See RFP section 5.6 for instructions on requesting confidentiality.

28. Will the top candidate interviews scheduled for January 4 to 6, 2027 be held in person or virtually? If in person, at what location?

i. Please note that the Top Candidate Interview dates are subject to change or could potentially not occur at all and can vary depending on the amount of proposals received (see RFP section 3.1, paragraphs 5 & 6). The interview format is undecided and if the

Evaluation Team determines that interviews are necessary for the evaluation, then the format and timing will be decided at that time.

29. Will awards be made separately for each Task Order Project Type, so that an Offeror could be selected for some types and not others? If an Offeror does not propose on every Task Order Project Type, will that affect its evaluation or eligibility for the types on which it does propose?

i. Contractors will be awarded based on the submitted proposal and the resulting Statement of Work attached to the Main Task Order

Contract will indicate the Task Order Project Types that the

Contractor demonstrated they could provide best value to CPW.

CPW, at its sole discretion, will select the Contractors for Task

Orders based on the need of that specific project and Contractor’s capabilities. The Department does not guarantee a minimum amount of work to be assigned pursuant to the contract.

ii. Proposals will be evaluated according to the criteria outlined in RFP section 3. Section 3.4 specifies: “Firms will be evaluated for each indicated “Task Order Project Type” according to the criteria in sections 3.5 & 3.6.”

B. All other terms and conditions of RFP PMAA 2027*0007 - CPW On-Call Water

Resources Engineering remain the same.

Amendment #1 - Questions & Answers (Q&A)
RFP PMAA 2027*0007
CPW On-Call Water Resources Engineering

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .