Addendum 1 Questions and Responses .pdf

PDF 130 KB Posted

Attached to
GEMM 1 Audits
Solicitation number
RFP FAAA 2027000088 2
Issued by
Denver County, Denver City, Colorado

About this file

This is an Addendum containing questions and responses from vendors regarding Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) RFP 2027*88 for Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Energy Management for Manufacturing (GEMM) Audits. The solicitation seeks third-party auditors to conduct comprehensive greenhouse gas emissions and energy management audits at four Colorado manufacturing facilities: two cement plants, one steel mill, and one additional cement facility. The audit scope includes evaluation of GHG control technologies and energy best management practices, verification of emission reduction potential for identified technologies, and feasibility assessments for carbon capture, utilization, and storage. Auditors must review five years of historical emissions and energy data, with production and operational data reviewed for a minimum 12-month period. The lead auditor must hold current certification as a Lead Auditor from an accredited professional certification body in Quality, GHG, or Energy Management Systems, such as IRCA or ANAB-accredited certifications in ISO 9000, 14000, or 50001 series. Vendors may propose on individual audits, specific facility types (cement or steel only), or all four facilities, with final assignments made based on qualified auditor expertise and conflict of interest considerations. Minimum qualifications may be satisfied collectively by prime contractors and subcontractors, including certified lead auditors and industry specialists.

Pricing should be estimated on a facility-specific basis using time and materials approach, though fixed fee is acceptable, with cost estimates typically ranging from $50,000 to $100,000 per facility but not serving as absolute limits. Periodic invoicing and milestone payments are permissible. No federal funds will be used for this work. The evaluation criteria total 125 points, weighted as follows: Organizational Summary (20 points), Minimum Requirements (40 points), Experience and Qualifications (40 points), Budget (15 points), and References (10 points). Auditors will work directly with facilities to gather information and conduct site visits, though the number and duration of site visits are not prescribed and should follow standard industry practice. Economic analyses must use the federal Interagency Working Group's February 2021 Social Cost of GHG values at a 2.5% discount rate. CDPHE will review submitted audit reports and may request additional information within 45 days if reports are found incomplete, with auditors expected to build time for follow-up responses into initial cost estimates.

View the file

Other files

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Addendum 1

COLORADO DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH AND ENVIRONMENT

SOLICITATION QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

Solicitation #: RFP 2027*88 Solicitation Name: Greenhouse Gas Emissions and Energy Management for Manufacturing (GEMM) 1 Audits

Vendor Question #1: For third-party scope related to GHG emissions, please confirm:

a. DNV understands that the selected auditor will validate/verify the underlying GHG emissions inventory and calculations which will serve as the basis for evaluating GHG BAECT opportunities?

b. Whether this is emissions verification (e.g. verification of baseline GHG emissions) within a specified reporting period and/or emissions reduction verification for each facility in scope?

CDPHE Answer #1:

a. Validating underlying GHG emissions is not a requirement of these audits. Reported GHG emissions are required to follow EPA Part 98 methodologies, are reported as accurate and complete by facilities, and would be subject to enforcement if information is found to be falsified or misleading. The main purpose of the audits is to evaluate GHG control technologies and strategies and energy best management practices.

b. The scope does not include emissions verification of baseline emissions but does include verification of emission reduction potential of the identified and evaluated technologies.

Vendor Question #2: Since the RFP covers assurance and feasibility assessments for the four facilities in scope, there is a potential conflict of interest. DNV will ensure that teams working on assurance and feasibility assessment will be separate with a firewall and as part of the workplan, we will issue a conflict of interest mitigation plan. Is this acceptable by the contracting entity?

CDPHE Answer #2: Yes, as long as the minimum requirements are met for the lead auditor and audit team performing each audit, that would be acceptable. The plan laid out to mitigate conflict of interest would be acceptable. We may also select multiple auditors through this solicitation based on requisite experience and to avoid potential conflicts of interest, so it may be that one auditor is not assigned to all four facilities.

Vendor Question #3: The audit reports including findings and assessments for the facilities are defined as deliverables for the RFP. Please clarify:

a. Will these deliverables be shared with parties outside of the contracting entities?

b. In addition to the audit report, is the contracting entity seeking an opinion statement (on the accuracy/reliability) of the information evaluated as part of the GHG Emissions third-party scope? If yes, will this opinion be shared in the public domain?

CDPHE Answer #3:

a. Yes, audit reports will be public documents. As outlined in the draft Statement of Work, confidential business information must be submitted in a separate document that will not be made public. Confidential information must be flagged and redacted or removed from the final public facing report.

b. We are not seeking an opinion statement, though it should be evident that information presented in the report and findings must be accurate and reliable. Auditors must also make recommendations for strategies that are feasible and cost effective, if identified.

Vendor Question #4: Please clarify for each facility, regulatory standards, protocols, or calculation methodologies that are currently used by the facilities to quantify and report their GHG emissions?

CDPHE Answer #4: Each facility reports GHG emissions following EPA Part 98 requirements and methodologies. Our state GHG reporting regulation, Colorado AQCC Regulation 22, incorporates Part 98 by reference. All facilities report combustion emissions under Subpart C. Additionally, the three cement facilities report cement production emissions under Subpart H, and the steel mill reports under Subparts Q and TT for steel production and their industrial waste landfill.

Vendor Question #5: For each facility: Please identify the historical period of emissions, energy, production, and operational data the auditor will be expected to review?

CDPHE Answer #5: Emissions and energy data will need to be compiled for the last five years when putting together the Audit Plan. Production and operational data need to be reviewed, at a minimum, for the most recent 12-month period that will establish the intensity rate, though a longer period will likely be beneficial to evaluate trends and rule out discrepancies.

Vendor Question #6: Can CDPHE provide facility-specific information describing key manufacturing processes, major equipment, production capacity, operating profile, and relevant GHG-emitting and energy-consuming processes for each of the four facilities? Please see attached excel file for facility information request.

CDPHE Answer #6: Please use the following links to access the Audit Plans from the previous 2022 audits, which contain the majority of the requested information. Equipment lists should be very similar, if not the same, as they were in 2022. One exception is a brand new rail mill operating at the steel mill. For the last question on the Excel file, the verification scope may include renewable energy if that presents a viable solution to reducing onsite emissions/energy consumption. RECs do not have to be evaluated.

● GCC 2022 Audit Plan

● Cemex 2022 Audit Plan

● Amrize (formerly Holcim) 2022 Audit Plan

● Rocky Mountain Steel Mills (formerly Evraz) 2022 Audit Plan

Vendor Question #7: Eligibility through a multidisciplinary team — RFP Sections V.B–C Can the minimum qualifications be satisfied collectively by the prime contractor and subcontractors, including the certified lead auditor and cement/steel industry specialists? From a different perspective, must the prime contractor directly employ the qualified third-party auditor and independently satisfy each organizational experience requirement?

CDPHE Answer #7: The minimum qualification can be satisfied collectively by the prime contractor and subcontractors, as long as the composition of the audit team as a whole meets all the requirements.

Vendor Question #8: Acceptable lead auditor certifications — RFP Sections I.A and V.B.1 Please identify the lead auditor certifications and accrediting or certification bodies for this opportunity, or at least provide examples of certifications.

CDPHE Answer #8: The lead auditor must hold a current certification as a Lead Auditor from an accredited professional certification body in Quality, GHG, or Energy Management Systems. Examples include:

● International Registration of Certified Auditors (IRCA) Lead Auditor certification in ISO 9000, 14000 or 50000 series.

● Lead Auditor certification from an organization accredited by the ANSI National Accreditation Board (ANAB) in ISO 9000, 14000 or 50000 series.

Vendor Question #9: Industry-specific proposals and assignments — RFP Sections I.B, V.D, and VII.A Can we propose on individual audits or must we bid on all proposed sites? How will individual facility assignments be made among the prequalified contractors, and will facility-specific scope and pricing be finalized before assignment?

https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=35982335 https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=35989330 https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=36005710 https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=36004176

CDPHE Answer #9: You may propose on individual audits, or just cement or just steel, more broadly.

Individual assignments will be made according to the qualified pool of auditors, and where experience and expertise best fit. This could be satisfied by one auditor if they are the most qualified in all aspects of the audit and associated industries, or multiple to fill any gaps and avoid conflicts of interest. Facility-specific pricing should be estimated up front, but scope and pricing will be finalized after assignments are made.

Vendor Question #10: Information available for proposal development — RFP Sections V.D and VI.B, Budget Narrative Can APCD provide facility-specific information sufficient to develop comparable cost estimates, such as emission-unit lists, historical emissions and energy data, prior audit reports, or existing control or energy saving systems? If not, what common assumptions should offerors use (ie, # of days expected, # of auditors expected)?

CDPHE Answer #10: Please see the links in #6 above to previous Audit Plans for idea of scope.

Additionally, the 2022 full Audit Reports are accessible through the links below. Note that these are provided for reference, though are not necessarily indicative of the exact current operating conditions of each facility, nor necessarily the exact same methods another auditor may use.

● GCC 2022 Audit Report

● Cemex 2022 Audit Report

● Amrize (formerly Holcim) 2022 Audit Report

● Rocky Mountain Steel Mills (formerly Evraz) 2022 Audit Report

Vendor Question #11: Facility cooperation and data gaps — Exhibit C, Section III, PA #1 and PA #2 What responsibilities will facilities have for providing timely records? Where unit-level emissions or energy data are incomplete, is the auditor expected to develop engineering estimates, conduct temporary metering or testing, or identify the limitation for APCD resolution? Will we be working directly with the facility or will we be working through APCD on the audits?

CDPHE Answer #11: Ultimately, facilities are responsible for submitting the audit report by the end of 2027, so they are incentivized to provide timely responses and records to meet their compliance obligations. If unit-level data are incomplete, auditors may use their judgement on the best path forward. That may be engineering estimates, gap filling through interpolation/extrapolation, looking at historical trends, or potentially flagging and presenting to APCD for resolution. Temporary metering or testing is not an expectation. Auditors will be working directly with facilities to gather information, records, coordinate site visits, and anything else necessary for the complete audit. Auditors may consult with APCD to seek clarification on processes and methods or for conflict resolution if there is disagreement or unresponsiveness from the facility.

Vendor Question #12: Expected fieldwork and audit depth — Exhibit C, Section III, PA #1–2 Does APCD prescribe a minimum number or duration of site visits, an audit standard, or a required level of engineering detail?

CDPHE Answer #12: This is not prescribed, and should be done in accordance with standard industry practice and existing audit protocols. See #8 above for example audit protocols and the previous Audit Reports in #10 for an idea of expected engineering detail.

Vendor Question #13: Energy audit scope for certified facilities — Exhibit C, PA #1, Sub-Activity 1.b.i, and PA #2, Sub-Activity 1.b.viii–ix Which facilities are expected to qualify for the limited energy audit scope through ENERGY STAR or ISO 50001? Please clarify the required verification work and how the scope and compensation would be adjusted if a facility plans to obtain certification but does not achieve it within the required period.

CDPHE Answer #13: CC Rio Grande is currently the only facility certified to the federal industrial ENERGY STAR standard, and no facilities are formally certified to ISO 50001 to our knowledge.

https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=35987474 https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=35989075 https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=36004622 https://oitco.hylandcloud.com/POP/DocPop/DocPop.aspx?docid=36003758

Verification of relevant standards will include provision of the most recent certification that demonstrates the standard they are certified to. Scope and price should be adjusted accordingly for limited scope audits that do not require the Energy BMP Analysis. If a facility plans to obtain certification and provides the information required under AQCC Regulation 27, Part C, Section I.B.1.c.(i), the auditor will treat the requirement as satisfied. If the facility does not then achieve certification within 12 months after the audit date, that is a compliance issue that CDPHE will handle on a facility by facility basis and will not affect the original audit scope or pricing.

Vendor Question #14: Carbon capture feasibility assessment — Exhibit C, PA #2, Sub-Activity 1.a.iii What level of detail is expected for the required carbon capture, storage, or utilization feasibility assessment? Should it include capture-system screening only, or also transportation, storage or utilization availability, permitting, infrastructure, and commercial arrangements? Are desktop assessments and published cost data acceptable where site-specific engineering or vendor information is unavailable?

CDPHE Answer #14: You may refer to the CCUS assessments that were performed in the 2022 audits, though those demonstrate the minimum level of expected detail. With technology developments over the past five years, a more thorough assessment is preferred. Capture-system screening, site-specific storage or utilization options, offsite transportation and storage, permitting, and infrastructure, should all be considered to the extent they are applicable. However, no onsite testing for site-specific capture tech or storage feasibility is expected. A desktop assessment using published cost data on technology and storage/utilization options is acceptable where site-specific engineering or vendor information is unavailable.

Vendor Question #15: Economic analysis assumptions — Exhibit C, PA #2, Sub-Activities 1.a.v–vii and 1.b.iv–vi Will APCD provide common assumptions or templates for the social cost of GHGs including assumptions on discount rates, equipment lifetimes, energy-price forecasts, and treatment of grants and tax credits?

CDPHE Answer #15: We currently rely on the federal Interagency Working Group’s February 2021 Technical Support Document on the Social Cost of GHGs. Values using the 2.5% discount rate must be used and converted from 2020 dollars in the document to present day value.

Contractors are expected to use industry-standard best practices when it comes to cost benefit analysis. These are generally reflected in documents like the EPA Air Pollution Cost Control Manual or the Chemical Engineering Plant Cost Index. APCD can provide a set of standard assumptions, acknowledging that some discount rates and equipment lifetimes may vary site to site and equipment to equipment. For energy price forecasts, contractors can utilize the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) forecasts, filtered down to industrial application in Colorado when possible.

Alternatives can be proposed and will be considered on a case-by-case basis. Contractors are also expected to have an understanding of applicable state and federal incentives, including tax credits and grants. Contractors should be able to provide an assessment of whether incentives are guaranteed or issued on a competitive basis and provide rationale for their inclusion or exclusion from cost benefit analyses.

Vendor Question #16: Competitiveness assessment — Exhibit C, PA #2, Sub-Activities 1.a.vii and 1.b.vi What data and evidence are expected to assess impacts on a facility’s domestic and international competitiveness? Will facilities be required to provide relevant financial and market information, and what approach should auditors use if that information is unavailable?

CDPHE Answer #16: We expect facilities to provide sufficient justification for any claims that their competitiveness in the marketplace will be affected by recommendations from the audit. Auditors can evaluate the information provided by facilities to assess the validity of such claims, and detail final decisions in the audit report.

https://bidenwhitehouse.archives.gov/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/TechnicalSupportDocument_SocialCostofCarbonMethaneNitrousOxide.pdf

Vendor Question #17: Quantification of community co-benefits — Exhibit C, PA #2, Sub-Activities 1.a.viii and 1.b.vii Does the required co-benefits analysis consist of estimating changes in emissions of non GHG air pollutants? If so should it also include dispersion modeling, exposure or health-impact assessment?

Will APCD provide a preferred methodology and relevant community data?

CDPHE Answer #17: Co-benefits are defined in Regulation 27 as “additional benefits associated with the reduction of harmful air pollutants to local communities, including localized air quality benefits.”

So the analysis would consist of expected changes in non-GHG air pollutants resulting from the measure or strategy, including Criteria pollutants and HAPs. Dispersion modeling and health-impact assessments are not required as part of the analysis, rather a simple quantification of the net change.

APCD can provide a preferred methodology to auditors if outstanding questions remain.

Vendor Question #18: Public communication and language requirements — Exhibit C, PA #2, Sub- Activities 1.e–f, and PA #3 Will APCD identify the geographic community boundary and the two languages required for each plain-language summary? Beyond preparing translated summaries and responding to written comments, should the contractor budget for public meetings, presentations, interpretation, or other community engagement?

CDPHE Answer #18: APCD can provide the community boundary and top two languages in surrounding communities. No outreach is expected as part of this solicitation outside of the audit process, so it is not necessary to budget for public meetings, presentations, interpretation, or other community engagement activities.

Vendor Question #19: Review, revisions, and additional analyses — Exhibit C, PA #3, Section IV, and Section VII.B What level of effort should offerors assume for APCD review, public comments, and report revisions?

Please confirm the March 1, 2028 supplement deadline, because the PA #3 deliverable fields are blank, and clarify how requests for new analyses beyond the approved audit scope will be authorized and compensated.

CDPHE Answer #19: PA #3 will likely be amended to remove the requirement of public comment response and a required supplement. Instead, APCD intends to review the submitted audit report, and within 45 days, request additional information if the audit report is found to be incomplete. We would allow auditors sufficient time to gather any additional requested information and provide responses. If every aspect of the audit requirements were met initially, any information requests or additional back and forth would be expected to be minimal. Time for potential follow-up responses and information gathering should be built into the initial cost estimate.

Vendor Question #20: Pricing and payment structure — RFP Section IV.B; Exhibit C, Section VII.A Is there a preference for time and materials or fixed fee costs? Are the stated $50,000–$100,000 per-facility estimates intended as limits? Please reconcile payment “upon completion” in the RFP with the periodic invoicing provisions in Exhibit C and confirm whether milestone payments are permitted.

CDPHE Answer #20: The preference is for time and materials, though there is flexibility there. The stated cost estimates are not intended as limits, though most audits should fall within this range depending on scope and complexity. Periodic invoicing and milestone payments will also be allowable.

Vendor Question #21: Exhibit B, Addendum 2 (Federal Provisions), applies only if any part of the Purchase Order is funded with federal funds. Please confirm whether federal funds will be used for this work. If so, please identify the federal award and the applicable certifications.

CDPHE Answer #21: Federal funds will not be used for this work.

Vendor Question #22: Section VII.C lists the evaluation factors without relative weights, please confirm.

CDPHE Answer #22:

Section I. Organizational Summary 20 points Section II. Minimum Requirements 40 Points Section III. Experience and Qualifications 40 points Section IV. Budget 15 points Section V. References 10 points Total Points Awarded to Proposal 125 points

Vendor Question #23: Please confirm whether there is a page limit, font or format requirement, or a required section order.

CDPHE Answer #23: No, there are no formatting requirements.

Vendor Question #24: Section V.B.1.a requires staff with a valid lead auditor certification from "a professional certification body." Please confirm whether the State accepts any accredited certification body, or whether specific certifications or certification bodies are required.

CDPHE Answer #24: Preferred certification bodies are listed in #8 above, though we will review and evaluate other certifications and certification bodies outside of those listed.

Vendor Question #25: Exhibit C, PA #1, item 1.c permits supplementary third-party audit data from audits within the prior three years. Please confirm whether data from an audit conducted by a different contractor under AQCC Regulation 27, Part C may be used in the 2027 audit, and what third-party verification the State will accept.

CDPHE Answer #25: The previous audits required by Regulation 27 were performed in 2022, and are outside of the acceptable 3-year window referenced in Exhibit C, PA #1, 1.c. That provision allows for data to be used from audits only within 3 years prior to the start of the planned audit, which would not fall under Regulation 27, Part C since those audits are required every 5 years. If audits were conducted by a third party at a facility for other reasons where there is data overlap with the Regulation 27 audits, then it may be reviewed and used on a supplementary basis if it falls within the allowable timeframe. Third party verification would consist of the original audit being performed by an accredited third party and being reviewed and accepted by the qualified third party auditor conducting the Regulation 27 audit.

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .