A16_Sole_Source_J_A_pdf_sr_1.pdf

PDF 217 KB Posted

Attached to
BISC REPAIR BOCA CHITA SHORELINE EROSION
Solicitation number
140PS126C0002
Issued by

About this file

This is a Justification and Approval (J&A) for Other Than Full and Open Competition for a sole source contract award by the National Park Service (NPS).

The NPS seeks to award a sole source contract to Houser Walker Architecture, LLC for Architect/Engineering (A/E) design services to advance the Biscayne National Park shoreline stabilization project from 35% schematic design to 100% construction documents. The project involves approximately 333 linear feet of shoreline stabilization along the northeastern shoreline of Boca Chita Key using rock revetment and native vegetation plantings to address erosion caused by storm surges and tidal events. Houser Walker Architecture previously completed a 35% design under Task Order 140P5424F0004 (awarded December 20, 2023 for $199,035.31) and is designated as the "Designer of Record." The sole source award is justified as a logical follow-on acquisition under FAR 16.505(b)(2)(i), as all IDIQ awardees were given fair opportunity to compete for the original 35% design task order. The CO determined that only Houser Walker Architecture can responsibly advance the designs due to FAR Clause 52.236-23 responsibility requirements, legal risks under the Spearin Doctrine, design interpretation concerns, and the impracticality of having multiple designers of record. The original IDIQ contract ceiling has been reached, preventing use of the original contract vehicle. The CO identified four other qualified A/E firms capable of providing such services but determined that competitive solicitation poses significant risk to the government, including potential redesign costs up to $199,035.31 and litigation exposure. Price fairness will be determined using FAR 13.106-1 price analysis techniques. The justification was signed by Contracting Officer Cole Johnson on December 3, 2025, and approved by Chief of Contracting Office Stacey Rickard on December 9, 2025.

View the file

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

IN REPLY REFER TO: Cole Johnson, Contracting Officer, Cole_Johnson@NPS.Gov

1. Identifications:

a. Agency: National Park Service

b. Contracting Office: Contracting Operations - Strategic

2. Description of the action being approved:

The National Park Service (NPS) shall be soliciting Houser Walker Architecture, LLC under sole source authority as prescribed in FAR 6.302-1. This written justification provides approval for limiting competition to a single source, as authorized by the Federal Acquisition Regulations

(FAR).

3. Description of supplies and services:

Biscayne National Park proposes implementing a shoreline stabilization project along the northeastern shoreline of Boca Chita Key to restore coastal habitats and address persistent erosion and degradation caused primarily by storm surges and tidal events. The project area encompasses approximately 333 linear feet of shoreline along the northern edge of the island. Stabilization is necessary to prevent further shoreline loss and to protect critical infrastructure.

In 2024, an Architect/Engineering (A/E) firm developed a 35% schematic design and Class B construction estimate, which included a sheet pile seawall with a riprap revetment. However, the

National Park Service (NPS) was unable to secure a Coastal Barrier Resources Act (CBRA) consistency determination from the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (USFWS) for that design.

Following consultation with USFWS, NPS obtained approval for a revised hybrid approach utilizing rock revetment and native vegetation plantings. The A/E subsequently revised the schematic design to remove the sheet pile wall and incorporate additional mangrove planting.

These revised drawings are included in Appendix A of the Statement of Work.

This project seeks to take the current design from 35% to 100%, resulting in a final set of

Construction Documents (CD’s) deliverable to the NPS for use in a follow-on construction project at the Park.

4. Authority:

41 U.S.C. 253(c)(1): Only one responsible source and no other supplies or services will satisfy agency requirements.

United States Department of the Interior

NATIONAL PARK SERVICE

Business Services Directorate

CONOPS Strategic mailto:Cole_Johnson@NPS.Gov

5. The description of unique qualifications or the unique nature of the acquisition:

NPS Task Order 140P5424F0004 was awarded to Houser Walker Architecture, LLC under NPS

IDIQ Contract 140P2022D0013 on 12/20/2023 with a completion date of 5/31/2024. The Task

Order was awarded in the amount of $199,035.31 and the Scope stated the contractor shall

“provide a VA of the preliminary alternatives up to 4, 35% design documents for the project.”

The project was completed commensurate with the Contracting Officer’s (CO) prescribed Period of Performance and 35% design documents were provided to the NPS.

It is the CO’s determination that, as Houser Walker Architecture, LLC was the “designer of record” for the 35% documents, House Walker Architecture LLC is the Only Responsible Source able to take the designs from 35% to 100% completion. The CO has made this determination based on the following rationale:

FAR 16.505(b)(2)(i) Exceptions to the fair opportunity process states:

The contracting officer shall give every awardee a fair opportunity to be considered for a delivery order or task order exceeding the micro-purchase threshold unless one of the following statutory exceptions applies:

(C) The order must be issued on a sole-source basis in the interest of economy and efficiency because it is a logical follow-on to an order already issued under the contract, provided that all awardees were given a fair opportunity to be considered for the original order.

Task Order 140P5424F0004 was established using FAR 16.505 Fair Opportunity ordering procedures for A&E Contracts. The government solicited the original 35% design requirement with full intent to establish 100% designs at a later date and would have scoped the original requirement for 100% designs if not for the required USFWS consultation requirement at the 35% design threshold.

This order must be issued on a sole-source basis in the interest of economy and efficiency because it is a logical follow-on to an order already issued under the contract and all (IDIQ) awardees were given a fair opportunity to be considered for the original order in accordance with

FAR 16.505 Fair Opportunity processes.

Upon attempting to reserve a follow-on Task Order under IDIQ 140P2022D0013, the CO discovered the IDIQ Task Order limitation ceiling had been met, therefore, the CO could not reserve a proper follow-on Task Order using the original contract vehicle awarded to Houser

Walker Architecture, LLC. This scenario presents a unique challenge to the acquisition, where the

FAR clearly states that a logical follow-on contract “must” be issued, but the IDIQ can no longer be used.

6. Efforts to obtain competition:

Competition requirements for A&E Services are very briefly laid out in FAR 36.601-1

“Competition” which states that the procedures of FAR SubPart 36.601 “constitute a competitive procedure.” The procedures that follow within the SubPart are commensurate with how the original IDIQ (and subsequent Task Order) were established. Therefore, it is the CO’s determination that since the original Task Order for 35% designs was awarded from an IDIQ that followed all procedures of the SubPart, that competition requirements were met at the time the

IDIQ was established.

For this 100% design follow-on requirement, competition is not being sought due to the requirement’s nature as a logical follow-on to the 35% design Task Order.

7. Determination that costs will be fair & reasonable:

As with all A&E Design Contracts awarded by the NPS, the CO will determine costs to be fair and reasonable via Price Analysis Techniques found in FAR 13.106-1. Determining Price Fair and Reasonable may include evaluation of the contractor’s “Other Than Certified Cost and

Pricing Data” and may include negotiations. Under no circumstance will a contract be awarded where the price cannot be determined “Fair and Reasonable.”

8. Description of the market research conducted:

A formal Market Research Report was not prepared for this effort because the value of the requirement is estimated to be under the Simplified Acquisition Threshold (SAT).

As this requirement is for the procurement of A&E Design services, the requirements to synopsize, solicit, and select a contractor are unique to the procedures prescribed under FAR

36.6.

The Park cited Houser Walker Architects as the most qualified contractor and “Designer of

Record” due to the firm receiving the 35% Task Order award at the outset of the requirement. The

CO accessed the NPS Denver Service Center (DSC) Hub where the NPS keeps it’s Multiple

Award A&E Multiple Award Task Order Contracts (MATOCs) within their respective Regional

“pools.” The CO found that the original Task Order was awarded under the “SER Small”

MATOC pool. The CO was able to identify the following A&E firms with IDIQ’s listed under the SER Small pool:

Croft & Associates

Duvall Decker Architects PA

Houser Walker Architecture (Designer of Record)

Walker Architects

Liollio Architecture PC

The CO’s research indicates that there are four (4) other IDIQ firms, as stated above, capable of providing A&E design services for the Southeast Region. As Houser Walker Architecture was determined to be the Designer of Record, this JOFOC was established to ensure a sole source award could be made to the firm without the express use of their (now defunct) IDIQ vehicle in order to complete the designs.

9. Other facts supporting other than full & open competition:

a. Reason why documents suitable for full & open competition have not been developed:

As indicated above, this requirement meets the definition of a logical follow-on. Full & Open

Competition would not be appropriate, given the nature of the requirement.

b. Data, estimated costs or other rationale as to the extent or harm to the Government:

Responsibility Conflicts

FAR Clause 52.236-23 “Responsibility of the Architect-Engineer Contractor” was incorporated into the base IDIQ for Houser Walker Architecture, LLC. Part (a) of the clause states the following regarding the Contractor’s responsibility for designs:

(a) The contractor shall be responsible for the professional quality, technical accuracy, and the coordination of all designs, drawings, specifications, and other services furnished by the Contractor under this contract. The Contractor shall, without additional compensation, correct or revise any errors or deficiencies in its designs, drawings, specifications, and other services.

A logical follow-on order for 100% design must be issued on a sole-source basis to ensure that responsibility of the original designer for the 35% portion is maintained by the government.

If this requirement were competed and a different design firm received the award, they would either be required to take full responsibility for the professional quality, technical accuracy, and the coordination of all designs, drawings, specifications, and other services furnished by the original designer of record at 35% – or - the government would lose it’s ability to seek design flaw restitution during the design phase, as the 35% design would be seen by the new contractor as nothing more than “Government Furnished Information (GFI).”

Any design corrections or changes required against the 35% designs, as GFI, would require the government to pay for the corrections instead of the Designer of Record. Such action would cause significant risk to the government. The cost for re-design or correction has the potential to equate to the full 35% design value of $199,035.31 in added costs to the government. Pursuing such risks, for the sake of obtaining competition, is not in the best interest of the government nor would it be considered a prudent use of taxpayer dollars.

Design Interpretations

Within the professional industry that makes up Architecture and Engineering, no single A&E firm is exactly alike regarding unique approaches to construction designs. Houser Walker

Architecture has already provided the government with an acceptable and functional 35% design for this effort after completing an approximately $200K Task Order.

While this requirement could be awarded to any of the other NPS MATOC A&E firms, Houser Walker Architecture developed the 35% portion in-house, utilizing their own knowledge, experience, expertise, and qualified A&E team. Incorporation of a different A&E firm, with their own knowledge, experience, expertise, and team would open up the government for re-interpretation and even full “revision” to the currently accepted 35% design, as the new firm’s approach will have methods differing from that of the original

Designer of Record.

Legal Risks

Through online and internal research efforts, the CO has been unable to successfully identify any 35% design contracts brought to 100% design completion by a firm other than the original Designer of Record. While there are undoubtedly circumstantial instances where a different design firm was awarded a contract to complete an otherwise “partial” design effort, such instances are not considered to be the norm or even a “common commercial practice;”

especially where government A&E contracts “with follow-on construction” are concerned.

In addition, Spearin Doctrine prohibits the “Designer of Record” from even participating in the construction of their own designs when awarding construction contracts outside of the

Design-Build procedures. This doctrine is relevant to the CO’s sole source decision because such prohibitions exist to protect contractors from liability for defects in construction when they are required to build according to plans and specifications prepared by the owner (in this case, the government). Should the government award a competitive contract for this effort, and the Designer of Record does not receive the award, it is unclear, legally, where the government (or construction contractor) would seek restitution for design flaws, during the construction phase. If competed, the risk of the project being tied up in litigation is high and the governments ability to issue warranty calls in accordance with FAR 36.609-2 “Redesign

Responsibility for Design Errors or Deficiencies” for design flaws, is greatly diminished.

A logical follow-on order for 100% designs must be issued on a sole source basis to minimize the risk of litigation and conflict between the construction contractor, the government, and the designer of record. Having multiple “designers of record” significantly complicates and, therefore, increases risk to the government regarding legal matters.

10. Interested Sources:

None indicated.

11. Actions to remove barriers to competition in the future for similar acquisitions:

None. Future acquisitions found under similar circumstances will be awarded as proper logical follow-on contracts in accordance with FAR prescriptions and regulations.

12. Technical Certifications:

a. I do hereby recommend an exception to competition be granted in accordance with the above and within the authority of FAR 6.302-1.

b. I certify that the supporting data under my cognizance, which are included in this justification, are accurate and complete to the best of my knowledge and belief.

13. Approvals & Signatures:

Contracting Officer:

Chief of the Contracting Office (CCO):

Text1: COLE JOHNSON
2025-12-03T09:13:16-0700
Cole Johnson
2025-12-09T11:52:17-0800
STACEY RICKARD

Text4: STACEY RICKARD

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .