L1 Series COR SPEC Rev 11-8-23.docx

DOCX document 3 MB Posted

Attached to
Space Weather Next L1 Series Coronagraph Federal contract opportunity
Solicitation number
80GSFC24R0009
Issued by
National Aeronautics and Space Administration Goddard Space Center

About this file

This is a requirements specification for a space weather Coronagraph instrument to be delivered under solicitation number 80GSFC24R0009. The specification defines performance, interface, environmental test, and verification requirements for an instrument that will capture white light coronal imagery between 3 and 22 solar radii with 70 arcsecond resolution and 10% photometric accuracy. It requires delivery of flight hardware, ground support equipment including emulators and test equipment, and holds the contractor responsible for analyses including radiation hardness assurance, contamination, charging, and displacement damage assessments. Qualification testing, cleanliness standards, and verification methods are also outlined.

View the file

Other files for this federal contract opportunity

Other files attached to Space Weather Next L1 Series Coronagraph, newest first.
File Type Posted
L1 Series COR MAR Rev 11-8-2023.docx DOCX document
L1_Series COR SOW Rev 11-9-23.docx DOCX document
Coronagraph Pre-Solicitation Notice.docx DOCX document
L1 Series COR QASP Rev- 11-8-23.docx DOCX document
L1 Series COR CDRL Rev 11-8-2023.docx DOCX document
L1 Series COR GFP List 11-8-23.docx DOCX document

On GovTribe

Work with this file on GovTribe

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

L1SERIES-COR-REQ-0018, Revision - Effective Date:

Space Weather (SW) Next L1 Series, Code 491.0 L1SERIES-COR-REQ-0018, Revision -

Space Weather (SW) Next L1 Series SW L1 Coronagraph Requirement Specification (CSPEC)

SWO CMO

October 19, 2023

DRAFT

U.S. Department of Commerce (DOC) National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) NOAA Satellite and Information Service (NESDIS)

DOORS EXPORT
Effective Date:

National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) Check https://ipdtdms.gsfc.nasa.gov/frontmenu_dsp.cfm to verify that this is the correct version prior to use.

SW L1 Coronagraph Requirement Specification (CSPEC) Review/Signature/Approval Page

Prepared by:

Mark Edison Systems Engineer

Date

SWO L1 Series NASA GSFC, Code 493

Reviewed by:

Charles “Hudson” Delee Systems Engineer

Date

SWO L1 Series

Approved by:

Timothy Van Sant L1 Series Project Manager

Date

SWO L1 Series

Electronic Approval available on-line at: IPD TDMS - Instruments Project Division TDMS (nasa.gov)

Preface

This document is under SWO Program configuration control. Once this document is approved, SWO approved changes are handled in accordance with Class I and Class II change control requirements as described in the SWO Configuration Management Procedure, and changes to this document shall be made by complete revision.

In this plan, all mandatory actions (i.e., requirements) are denoted by statements containing the term “shall.” The terms “may” or “can” denote discretionary privilege or permission; “should” denotes a good practice and is recommended but not required; “will” denotes expected outcome; and “are/is” denotes descriptive material.

Any questions should be addressed to:

SWO Configuration Management Office

NASA/GSFC

Code 490.0 Greenbelt, MD 20771

Change History Log Change History Log will be provided by CM prior to release

Deviations/Waivers Record

Section # / Rqmt.
Deviation / Waiver #
CCR #
Date Approved
Description
None.
None.
None.
None.
None.

L1SERIES-COR-REQ-0018, Revision -v Check https://ipdtdms.gsfc.nasa.gov/frontmenu_dsp.cfm to verify that this is the correct version prior to use.

Table of TBCs/TBDs/TBRs/TBSs

Item No.
Identifier
Section
Summary
1
CSPEC16
4.3.7
The Coronagraph instrument shall have a 99.9 % (TBR-8) probability of operating continuously on-orbit during nominal observation mode (which excludes non-Coronagraph related Spacecraft Safe Holds, instrument calibrations and storm conditions).
2
CSPEC20
4.3.7
The instrument shall provide a 99% (TBR-10) or greater probability of providing all of the instrument's HAP data during S4 class solar radiation storms or solar flare conditions including class X50, verifying through analysis using the “Worst Week” October 1989 model in CREME96 or equivalent.
3
CSPEC22
4.1.1
The Coronagraph shall capture radial coronal scenes from ≤3 RSun to ≥ 22 RSun (TBR-1).
4
CSPEC26
4.1.2
The Coronagraph shall capture coronal images with spatial resolution ≤ 70.0 arcsec (TBR-2) over the un-occulted field of view.
5
CSPEC29
4.1.3
The Coronagraph shall capture coronal white light imagery with intensity of 1×10-11 BSun to 1×10-8 BSun (TBR-3).
6
CSPEC31
4.1.4
The Coronagraph shall have photometric accuracy for the corona image of ≤ 10% in mean solar brightness (TBR-4)
7
CSPEC33
4.1.5
The Coronagraph shall allow for an unobstructed field of view of no more than 50 deg (TBR-5) half cone angle.
8
CSPEC35
4.1.6
The Coronagraph shall produce an image during nominal operations at a refresh rate of every 15 minutes or less (TBR-6).
9
CSPEC36
4.1.6
The Coronagraph shall produce an image with a latency of 13 minutes after end of image acquisition (TBR-7). Note that the Coronagraph instrument latency is only one component of the end-to-end latency budget.
10
CSPEC43
4.2.2
The Coronagraph instrument volume (length*width*height), including the sensor unit (TBD-1), electronics box (TBD-2), mounts, sensor standoff bracket (if required), instra-instrument harness, thermal blankets, and connectors, for both stowed and operational configurations shall have dimensions that do not exceed a total volume of TBD-3 cm3. These dimensions pertain to both static and dynamic envelopes of the instrument.
11
CSPEC44
4.2.2
The Coronagraph maximum instrument volume during deployment of mechanisms shall have dimensions that do not exceed a total volume of TBD-4 cm3
12
CSPEC48
4.2.4
The Coronagraph instrument shall have a peak (instantaneous) power consumption of less than or equal to TBD-5 for a duration of 60 seconds.
13
CSPEC50
4.2.5
The Coronagraph instrument survival heater power shall not exceed TBD-6 Watts when averaged over any 60-minute period.
14
CSPEC68

The L1 SERIES spacecraft will monitor up to six (TBR) analog instrument health and safety parameters defined by the Coronagraph contractor and command the Coronagraph into safe mode when any of those key values have been exceeded.

15
CSPEC75
4.3.6
The instrument shall meet all performance requirements within 300 seconds (TBR-9) after the spacecraft interface has returned to being within specification following spacecraft maneuvers.
16
CSPEC92
4.4.7
The Coronagraph instrument shall limit any change in operational power current at any time (including initial power turn-on) to no more than 0.2A/µs. (TBR)
17
CSPEC199

The Coronagraph +XCSRF axis is aligned with the instrument line of sight, the +YCRSF axis is perpendicular with the instrument mounting plane and the +ZCSRF axis completes the triad.

18
CSPEC243
6.6
The Coronagraph shall be designed to withstand, without any damage or degradation of performance, when acoustic testing to the equivalent Protoflight [TBR] levels, which are +3 dB over those shown in Figure 9.
19
CSPEC260
6.8.2
The Coronagraph shall be designed to meet all performance requirements after exposure to a maximum depressurization rate of -50mbar/sec (-0.72 psi/sec) experienced during launch and ascent.
20
CSPEC696
10.2.2
The Coronagraph emulator shall comply with NOAA facility and security requirements per [TBD].
21
CSPEC1224
8.3.0-4.0-12
TBD
22
CSPEC1239
8.3.0-4.0-15
Notes:

1. Test methods can be in accordance with the latest version of the Goddard Environmental Verification Specification (GEVS), MIL-STD-461C/462 as approved by the Project prior to commencement of testing

2. Guidelines for defining magnetic requirements are provided in "The Design, Construction and Test of Magnetically Clean Spacecraft - A Practical Guide (Mario H. Acuna)". TBD.

3. Default limit. The limit will be updated when all reveivers, including instruments, if any, have been defined.

4. Default limit. The limit will be updated when all transmitters, including launch vehicle, have been defined.

23
CSPEC1564
12.0-2.0-32
TBD
24
CSPEC1570
12.0-2.0-34
TBR

L1SERIES-COR-REQ-0018, Revision -

Check https://ipdtdms.gsfc.nasa.gov/frontmenu_dsp.cfm to verify that this is the correct version prior to use.

Table of Contents

1Introduction1
1.1General Information1
1.2Scope1
2Applicable Documents2
3Contract Description4
3.1Coronagraph Description4
3.2Ground Support Equipment Description4
4Functional/Performance Requirments5
4.1Coronagraph Performance Requirements5
4.1.1Scene Coverage5
4.1.2Spatial Resolution5
4.1.3Measurement Range5
4.1.4Accuracy5
4.1.5Field of View (FOV)6
4.1.6Refresh Rate and Latency6
4.1.7Detector Well Depth6
4.2Resource Allocations6
4.2.1Mass Allocation6
4.2.2Physical Envelope6
4.2.3Operational Power Allocation6
4.2.4Peak Operational Power6
4.2.5Survival Heater Power7
4.2.6Telemetry7
4.2.7Transient Magnetic Field7
4.2.8Static Magnetic Field7
4.3Coronagraph Operating Modes7
4.3.1Mode Transitions7
4.3.2Deterministic Power on Configuration7
4.3.3Safe Mode7
4.3.3.1Provision of Safe Mode7
4.3.3.2Entry Into Safe Mode8
4.3.4Normal Operational Mode8
4.3.5On-Orbit Operations8
4.3.6Station Keeping8
4.4Power8
4.4.1Voltage Range8
4.4.2Abnormal Voltages8
4.4.3Power Transients9
4.4.4Sudden Removal of Power9
4.4.5Over-Current Protection9
4.4.6Primary Power Return Ground9
4.4.7Turn On Current Transients9
4.5Electrical Grounding9
4.5.1Primary Power DC Isolation9
4.5.2Survival Power Isolation9
4.5.3Internally Generated Secondary to Primary DC Isolation10
4.5.4Internally Generated Secondary Return10
4.5.5Mechanical Contact Resistance10
4.5.6Grounding10
4.5.7Connector DC Resistance11
4.6Signal and Data Interfaces11
4.6.1Passive Analog Telemetry11
4.6.2Data Signal Interface11
4.6.2.1Telemetry Source Packet Format11
4.6.2.2Command Source Packet Format13
4.6.3Clock Signal Interface13
4.6.4Command and Housekeeping telemetry14
4.6.5Commands for Autonomous Functions14
4.6.6Limits and Triggers14
4.6.7On-Board Processor Reset15
4.6.8Micro-switches15
4.7Flight Software15
4.7.1Flight Load Non-volatile Memory15
4.7.2Software Updates15
4.7.3Software Table Updates15
4.7.4Flexibility and Ease of Software Modification16
4.7.5Version Identifiers16
4.7.6Warm Restart16
4.7.7Memory Tests17
4.7.8Memory Dump17
4.7.9Fault Detection and Correction Control17
4.7.10Health and Safety Monitoring17
5Physical Requirements18
5.1Interface and Design Units and Exclusions18
5.2Mass Properties Accuracy18
5.2.1Coronagraph Instrument Mass Accuracy18
5.2.2Center of Mass Location18
5.2.3Center of Mass Accuracy18
5.2.4Determination of Moments and Products of Inertia18
5.3Mounting19
5.3.1Surface Flatness19
5.3.2Method19
5.4Coordinate System and Alignment19
6Environmental Requirements21
6.1Mechanical Factors of Safety21
6.2Quasi-Static Acceleration21
6.3Frequency Requirement22
6.3.1Fundamental Launch Frequencies22
6.4Vibration22
6.4.1Sinusoidal Vibration22
6.4.2Random Vibration23
6.5Shock25
6.6Acoustics26
6.7Transportation27
6.7.1Transportation Cleanliness28
6.8Pressure28
6.8.1Operating Pressure Range28
6.8.2Maximum Depressurization Rate28
6.8.3Launch Vehicle (LV) Environmental Control System (ECS) Impingement28
6.9On-Orbit Dynamic Environment28
6.10Thermal Requirements28
6.10.1Flight Interface Design Temperature Limits29
6.11Charged Particle Radiation Requirements30
6.11.1Definitions30
6.11.2Radiation Hardness Assurance32
6.11.2.1Single-Event Effect Rate Calculations33
6.11.3Destructive Events34
6.11.3.1Single Event Latchups (SELs)34
6.11.3.2Single Event Gate Rupture (SEGRs), Single Event Burnout (SEB)34
6.11.4Charging Environment35
6.11.5Total Ionizing Dose35
6.11.6Displacement Damage Levels38
6.11.7Single Event Effects41
6.11.8Solar Cycle Performance41
6.11.9Solar Particle Event Operations47
6.11.10Solar Flare Survival51
7Contamination Control52
7.1Coronagraph Surface Cleanliness Requirements52
7.2Contamination Generation52
7.2.1Particulate Generation52
7.2.2Molecular Contamination Generation53
7.2.2.1Molecular Material Restrictions54
7.3Vacuum Bakeouts54
7.4Contamination Analyses55
7.5Venting Requirements55
7.6Cleanability and Protection56
7.7Electrostatic Cleanliness56
7.7.1Conductive Surface Ground Path56
7.7.2Conductive Surface Resistivity56
7.7.3Closeout of Gaps and Apertures57
7.7.4Exposed Harness Specific Requirements57
7.7.5Thermal Blankets57
8Design and Construction Requirements58
8.1Electrical58
8.1.1Test Sensors58
8.1.2MGSE Grounding58
8.1.3Connector Specifications58
8.1.3.1Contact Derating58
8.1.3.2Redundant Contact Derating58
8.1.3.3Signal Segregation58
8.1.3.4Test and Flight Signal Isolation59
8.1.4Test Interfaces59
8.1.4.1Facility-Induced Noise59
8.1.4.2Facility-Induced ESD GSE Malfunction59
8.1.4.3Facility-Induced GSE Malfunction59
8.1.5Mitigation of Internal Charging59
8.1.5.1Mitigation Strategies for Internal Charging59
8.1.5.2Floating Conductors60
8.1.5.3Dielectric Structures60
8.2Safety60
8.3Electromagnetic Compatibility60
8.3.1Conducted Emissions61
8.3.1.1Applicability of Conducted Emissions62
8.3.1.2CE101 – Differential Mode Conducted Emissions Limits62
8.3.1.3CE03 – Differential Mode Conducted Emissions Limits62
8.3.1.4Common Mode Bulk Conducted Emissions Limits62
8.3.1.5CETDT - Conducted Emissions, Time Domain, Transients Limits63
8.3.2Conducted Susceptibility64
8.3.2.1Applicability of Conducted Susceptibility64
8.3.2.2CS101 – Conducted Susceptibility Limit64
8.3.2.3CS114 – Conducted Susceptibility Differential Mode Limit65
8.3.2.4CS114 – Conducted Susceptibility, Common Mode, Power and Signal Cables66
8.3.2.5CS06 - Conducted Susceptibility, Transients Limits66
8.3.2.6CS115 - Conducted Susceptibility, Bulk Cable Injection, Impulse Excitation67
8.3.3Radiated Emissions68
8.3.3.1RE102 - Electric Field Emissions Limits68
8.3.4Radiated Susceptibility69
8.3.4.1RS103 - Radiated Susceptibility, Electric Field, Launch Limit69
8.3.4.2RS103 - Radiated Susceptibility, Electric Field, On-orbit Limit70
8.4Identification and Marking70
8.5Workmanship70
8.5.1Connectors70
8.6Reliability and Mission Lifetime71
8.6.1Mission Life71
8.6.2Operating Time71
8.6.3Trouble-Free Time71
8.7Ground Handling71
8.7.1Ground Support Equipment (GSE) Design71
8.7.2Lifting Hardware71
8.7.3Manual Lifting Hardware71
8.7.4GSE Cleanliness72
8.7.5GSE Bakeout72
8.7.6Test Harness72
8.8Interface Documentation72
8.8.1Mechanical Interface72
8.8.2Electrical Interface72
8.8.3Data Interface72
9Mechanical Design Requirements73
9.1Structural Requirements73
9.1.1Component Fatigue73
9.1.2Fracture Control Requirements73
9.2Fastening Systems74
9.2.1Factors of Safety74
9.2.2Supplemental Factor74
9.2.3Ultimate Design Loads74
9.2.4Yield Design Loads74
9.2.5Design Separation Load74
9.2.6Fastener Locking and Retention75
9.2.6.1Thread Engagement75
9.2.6.2Locking Feature Verification75
9.2.6.3Locking Feature Installation75
9.2.6.4Snap Ring and Cotter Pin Use Limitation75
9.2.6.5Snap Ring and Cotter Pin Use76
9.2.6.6Liquid Locking Compounds76
9.2.7Fastened Joints Criteria77
10Logistics79
10.1I&T Deliverables79
10.2Ground Support Equipment79
10.2.1Electrical System Test Equipment79
10.2.2Coronagraph Emulator (CORONAGRAPHE)79
10.3Transportation Equipment80
10.3.1Shipping Container80
11Verification Requirements81
11.1Verification Methods81
11.1.1Inspection81
11.1.2Analysis81
11.1.3Test81
11.1.4Demonstration81
11.2Inspection Requirements81
11.2.1Visual Inspection82
11.2.2Physical Measurement82
11.2.3Documentation Search82
11.3Analysis Requirements82
11.4Test Requirements82
11.4.1Definitions82
11.4.2Test Factors83
11.4.3Test Restrictions84
11.5Required Tests85
11.5.1Performance Tests86
11.5.2Mass Properties Measurement86
11.5.3Static Loads/Strength Test86
11.5.4Sine Sweep Survey87
11.5.5Sine Vibration88
11.5.6Random Vibration89
11.5.7Acoustic Test89
11.5.8Shock89
11.5.9Thermal Vacuum Bake-out90
11.5.10Thermal Vacuum Test90
11.5.11Magnetics Test92
11.5.12Harness Tests92
11.5.13EMI/EMC Tests92
12Appendix A Abbreviations and Acronyms93

List of Figures

Figure 1 Telemetry Source Packet Definition12
Figure 2 Time Code Format12
Figure 3 Command Source Packet13
Figure 4 Spacecraft Time Message Packet Figure14
Figure 5 Spacecraft Reference System19
Figure 6 Sine Vibration Environment23
Figure 7 Coronagraph Acceptance Random Vibration Environment24
Figure 8 Candidate LV Shock Environment26
Figure 9 L1 SERIES S/C Acceptance Acoustic Envelope27
Figure 10 Allowable Analytical, Flight Operation, Flight Acceptance Test, and Qualification (ProtoFlight or Prototype) Test Temperature Ranges29
Figure 11 Total Ionizing Dose (TID) Dose - Depth Curve37
Figure 12 Displacement Damage Dose (DDD) in Silicon vs. Shielding Thickness Dose-Depth Curve39
Figure 13 Displacement Damage Dose in Gallium Arsenide Dose-Depth Curve41
Figure 14 LET Spectrum of GCR Background43
Figure 15 Solar Background LET Spectrum Background45
Figure 16 Solar Proton Background Spectra47
Figure 17 Peak Solar Particle Event Flux49
Figure 18 Peak Solar Proton Flux51
Figure 19 CE101/CE03 Differential Mode Conducted Emissions Limits62
Figure 20 Common Mode Bulk Conducted Emissions Limit63
Figure 21 Inrush Current Transient Default Limit64
Figure 22 Power Lead Conducted Susceptibility (CS101) Voltage Limit65
Figure 23 Conducted Susceptibility Power Limit (30 Hz to 150 kHz)65
Figure 24 Conducted Susceptibility Transient Waveform66
Figure 25 Common Mode Conducted Susceptibility Calibration Limit67
Figure 26 Conducted Susceptibility, Power Leads, 150 kHz to 50 MHz Limit67
Figure 27 CS115 Default Limit68
Figure 28 Unit Level RE102 Radiated Electric Field Emission Limits69
Figure 29 Thermal Vacuum Profile91

List of Tables

Table 1 Applicable Documents (TBR)2
Table 2 Factors of Safety21
Table 3 Coronagraph Design Limit Loads22
Table 4 Candidate LV Shock Environment25
Table 5 Transportation Loads27
Table 6 Total Ionizing Dose vs. Shielding Thickness35
Table 7 Displacement Damage Dose in Silicon vs. Shielding Thickness38
Table 8 Displacement Damage Dose in Gallium Arsenide vs. Shielding Thickness39
Table 9 LET Spectrum of GCR Background42
Table 10 Solar Background LET Spectrum43
Table 11 Solar Proton Background Flux45
Table 12 Peak Solar Particle Event Flux47
Table 13 Peak Solar Proton Flux49
Table 14 Coronagraph Lifetime Contamination Requirements52
Table 15 Thermal Blanket Area vs. Grounding Tabs57
Table 16 Emission and Susceptibility Requirements60
Table 17 RS103 Radiated Susceptibility Levels (Launch)69
Table 18 Test Factors and Durations83
Table 19 Thermal Vacuum Test Parameters90

L1SERIES-COR-REQ-0018, Revision -x Check https://ipdtdms.gsfc.nasa.gov/frontmenu_dsp.cfm to verify that this is the correct version prior to use.

Introduction General Information Scope This specification describes the performance and electrical, mechanical, environmental, and verification testing requirements for a space-qualified Coronagraph Instrument for the Space Weather Next Lagrange 1 (L1 Series) Series Mission.

Applicable Documents CSPEC6: The following documents and drawings in effect on the day this specification was signed shall apply to the fabrication and to the electrical, mechanical, and environmental requirements of the Coronagraph to the extent specified herein. In the event of conflict between this specification and any referenced document, this specification will govern, except for the L1 Series Coronagraph Statement of Work (L1SERIES-COR-SOW-0006), in which case the Statement of Work takes precedence.

The following is a list of the applicable specifications and publications.

Table 1 Applicable Documents (TBR)

Document Number
Title
L1SERIES-STIS-SOW-0004
L1 Series Solar Wind Plasma Sensor (SWiPS) Statement of Work (SOW)
L1SERIES-STIS-REQ-0014
L1 Series Solar Wind Plasma Sensor (SWiPS) Contract Deliverables Requirements List (CDRL)
TIA-422 Revision B
Electrical Characteristics of Balanced Voltage Digital Interface Circuits
TIA-644 Revision A
Electrical Characteristics of Low Voltage Differential Signaling (LVDS) Interface Circuits
NFPA 70
National Fire Protection Association National Electric Code
NASA-STD-5001B
Structural Design And Test Factors Of Safety For Spaceflight Hardware
NASA-STD-8719.24
NASA Expendable Launch Vehicle Payload Safety Requirements
NASA-STD-6016
Standard Materials and Processes Requirements for Spacecraft
NASA-HDBK-7005
Dynamic Environment Criteria
NASA-STD-7001
Payload Vibroacoustic Test Criteria
IEST-STD-CC-1246E
Product Cleanliness Levels And Contamination Control Program
ASTM E-595-07
Standard Test Method for Total Mass Loss and Collected Volatile Condensable Materials from Outgassing in a Vacuum Environment
MIL-DTL-5541
Chemical Conversion Coatings on Aluminum and Aluminum Alloys
MIL-A-8625F
Anodic Coatings for Aluminum and Aluminum Alloys
EEE-INST-002
Instructions for EEE Parts Selection, Screening, Qualification, and Derating
MIL-STD-461G
Military Standard, Electromagnetic Emission And Susceptibility Requirements For The Control Of Electromagnetic Interference (EMI)
GSFC-STD-7000B
General Environmental Verification Standard (GEVS)
NASA-STD-5019A
Fracture Control Requirements for Spaceflight Hardware
NASA-STD-5020B
Requirements for Threaded Fastening Systems in Spaceflight Hardware
NASA-STD-5017B
Design and Development Requirements for Mechanisms
NASA-HDBK-4002B
Mitigating In-Space Charging Effects—A Guideline
FAA AC 20-71
Federal Aviation Administration Advisory Circular (AC) 20-71, “Dual Locking Devices on Fasteners".
NASM 33540
Safety Wiring, Safety Cabling, Cotter Pinning, General Practices for
SAE AS567
Safety Cable, Safety Wire, Key Washers, and Cotter Pins for Propulsion Systems, General Practices for Use of
MSFC-STD-3029A
Guidelines for the Selection of Metallic Materials for Stress Corrosion Cracking Resistance in Sodium Chloride Environments
MIL-STD-462, Notice 4
Electromagnetic Interference Characteristics, Measurement of, 1 May 1970
ISO 14644-1:2015
Part 1: Classification of air cleanliness by particle concentration
ISO 14644-3: 2005
Cleanrooms and associated controlled environments -- Part 3: Test methods
CCSDS 133.0-B-2
Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, June 2020
CCSDS 301.0-B-4
Time Code Formats. Blue Book. November 2010

Contract Description Coronagraph Description The Coronagraph instrument consists of a telescope module, an electronics box and the associated interconnecting cables up to the spacecraft provided interface.

The Coronagraph contract includes the delivery of One (1) Engineering Development Unit (EDU) with representative spacecraft mechanical and electrical interfaces. Three (3) Flight Units, plus parts for 3 additional flight units to be procured concurrently, plus parts for a robust sparing philosophy; and a flight spare instrument philosophy to mitigate risk of issues identified late in the launch integration flow.

Ground Support Equipment Description The Coronagraph contract includes the delivery of (2) sets of the Electrical System Test Equipment (ESTE), (4) Coronagraph Emulators, (1) Flight Software Development Environment (FSDE), and (1) One Ground Processing Development System (GPDS). Additionally, Mechanical Ground Support Equipment (MGSE) such as lifting fixtures/handles, shipping containers, purge carts, drill templates, test fixtures, non-flight protective covers, etc. are included in the delivery. Electrical Ground Support Equipment includes, but is not limited to, test cables and break-out boxes.

The Coronagraph delivery includes the ground support equipment required to power and operate the Coronagraph at the vendor’s and spacecraft contractor’s facilities. The delivery also includes a standalone emulator that will interface to a spacecraft simulator for the purposes of interface testing, operations product development, and training.

Ground Support Equipment is necessary to operate the instrument during spacecraft testing. Supplying this equipment is considered part of the delivery for the instrument. More information is provided in the Contract Data Requirement List (CDRL).

Functional/Performance Requirments This section defines the functional and performance requirements for the Space Weather Next Lagrange 1 Series Coronagraph.

The requirements in this Specification pertain to the Coronagraph ‘system’, which may include all instrument hardware, software, and ground processing algorithms. The Coronagraph contractor is not responsible for the operational ground system, but certain specifications may require ground processing after collection but before data distribution, which the contractor is responsible for defining and developing.

Coronagraph Performance Requirements Scene Coverage CSPEC22: The Coronagraph shall capture radial coronal scenes from ≤ 3 RSun to ≥ 22 RSun (TBR-1).

CSPEC23: The Coronagraph shall capture the radial coronal scene with a ≥ 290° coverage satisfying all spatial and photometric requirements.

Rationale: The inner field of view represents a geometric cutoff, not a photometric cutoff, and does not account for spacecraft motions. The spatial range for the field of view ensures that a CME travelling at ~3000 km/s can have sufficient observations (with the cadence given in Section 4.1.6) to fit model parameters. The specification ensures at least three images for each CME observed, giving sufficient margin for determining the CME properties necessary for prediction. Note that the external occulter (EO) will vignette the coronal scene (reduce the A1 aperture that can view the coronal scene) and add to the image noise from the diffracted straylight. The angular scene coverage of 290° allows use of pylon(s) to support the occulter. The EO pylon(s) will vignette the coronal scene (reduce the A1 aperture that can view the coronal scene) and add to the image noise from the diffracted straylight off of the EO pylon edge and reflected straylight off of the aft face of the pylon(s). The impact of the EO pylon(s) on the vignetting and straylight will decrease with the polar angle from the center of any EO pylon(s). Therefore, it is recognized the spatial and photometric requirements will have localized effects near these instrument features.

Spatial Resolution CSPEC26: The Coronagraph shall capture coronal images with spatial resolution ≤ 70.0 arcsec (TBR-2) over the un-occulted field of view.

Rationale: The image spatial resolution is defined as the average of the optical spatial resolution in the sagittal and tangential planes of the optical system. The instrument spatial resolution applies to an image acquired under nominal pointing conditions (with no boresight jitter or pointed windowed stability during the averaged image acquisition time). The spatial resolution is defined as the distance, in arcsec, between two point-sources of equal brightness located at infinity. The relative intensity between the peaks of the imaged sources (100% intensity) and the intensity at the mid-point between the peaks is 90% or less.

Measurement Range CSPEC29: The Coronagraph shall capture coronal white light imagery with intensity of 1×10-11 BSun to 1×10-8 BSun (TBR-3).

Rationale: The coronagraph’s dynamic range shall be such that the expected signal of the F + K corona, the residual straylight, and the CME all as modulated by the vignetting will be covered over the entire field of view. Bsun (or B0) is the surface brightness of the solar disk, which is an extended source. It is equivalent to the observed flux density per solid angle.

Accuracy CSPEC31: The Coronagraph shall have photometric accuracy for the corona image of ≤ 10% in mean solar brightness (TBR-4).

Rationale: Setting absolute photometric accuracy, i.e. calibration, on the observed scene allows for determination of CME mass. Much of the image noise in the K corona image is shot noise with a Poisson distribution for the electrons collected at each pixel based on the total brightness of the instrumental straylight, the coronal scene, vignetting, and the detector dark current. The estimation error over a block of pixels dominated by Poisson statistical noise can be reduced by averaging over this block of pixels if the source brightness is not varying greatly over this pixel block.

Unobstructed Field of View (UFOV) CSPEC33: The Coronagraph shall allow for an unobstructed field of view of no more than 50 deg (TBR-5) half cone angle.

Rationale: Allows for glint or other interference of spacecraft structures at angles larger than this.

Refresh Rate and Latency CSPEC35: The Coronagraph shall produce an image during nominal operations at a refresh rate of every 15 minutes or less (TBR-6).

CSPEC36: The Coronagraph shall produce an image with a latency of 13 minutes after end of image acquisition (TBR-7).

Rationale: The specifications ensure at least three images for each CME observed, giving sufficient margin for determining the CME properties necessary for prediction. Note that the Coronagraph instrument latency is only one component of the end-to-end latency budget. Total system data latency— from image acquisition completion at the spacecraft to SWPC’s generation of corresponding Level 3 data products—is 15 minutes; the 13 minutes allocated for the instrument includes data processing time (on-board, on the ground, or a combination) and data transfer with rates specified in Section 4.2.6. The latency value is set by the SWPC forecasters’ time needed for analyzing the images and by the cadence of the center’s real-time operational models.

Detector Well Depth CSPEC38: The Coronagraph instrument exposure time shall be such that total brightness measurement in electrons does not exceed 95% full well of detector.

Rationale: Ensure observations fit with refresh rate and latency requirements.

Operations during Storm conditions CSPEC39: The coronagraph shall provide data during a S4 (solar radiation) storm event.

Rationale: To fulfill its mission of providing the observational data needed for the SWPC Forecast Office to issue solar storm warnings and watches, the SWFO Program must be able to make observations during the most intense reasonably expected solar radiation storms and solar flares. Severe space weather of all types can occur at the same time. Previous non-operational missions such as ACE and SOHO have been significantly degraded and unable to make observations at times during the most intense solar storms and flares.

The solar radiation storm intensity scale goes from S1 to S5 (https://www.swpc.noaa.gov/noaascales-explanation). A solar storm of intensity S5 has never been observed, but is believed to be physically possible. A solar storm intensity of S4 includes storms where the 10 MeV integral proton fluxes reach at least 1x104 proton flux units (PFU) but do not reach 1x105 PFU.

Resource Allocations Mass Allocation CSPEC41: The Coronagraph instrument, including the imaging module, power supply box, intra-instrument harness, and thermal blankets, shall have a combined mass of ≤ 29.0 kg (includes margin).

CSPEC42: The Coronagraph instrument mass margin shall comply with GSFC-STD-1000H Rule 1.06.

Physical Envelope CSPEC43: The Coronagraph instrument volume (length*width*height), including the sensor unit (TBD-1), electronics box (TBD-2), mounts, sensor standoff bracket (if required), instra-instrument harness, thermal blankets, and connectors, for both stowed and operational configurations shall have dimensions that do not exceed a total volume of TBD-3 cm3. These dimensions pertain to both static and dynamic envelopes of the instrument.

CSPEC44: The Coronagraph maximum instrument volume during deployment of mechanisms shall have dimensions that do not exceed a total volume of TBD-4 cm3 Operational Power Allocation CSPEC46: The Coronagraph instrument average operational power shall not exceed 29 Watts when averaged over any 15-minute period.

Peak Operational Power CSPEC48: The Coronagraph instrument shall have a peak (instantaneous) power consumption of less than or equal to TBD-5 for a duration of 60 seconds.

Survival Heater Power CSPEC50: The Coronagraph instrument survival heater power shall not exceed TBD-6 Watts when averaged over any 60-minute period.

Telemetry CSPEC52: The Coronagraph instrument total data rate, including all overhead associated with Consultative Committee for Space Data Systems (CCSDS) packetization by the instrument at the spacecraft interface, shall not exceed 140 kbps averaged over 5 seconds.

Transient Magnetic Field CSPEC54: The Coronagraph instrument shall limit varying magnetic field less than 5 Hz to less than 4 nT zero-to-peak in any axis 1 meter from any face of the unit for any operating mode and changing configurations.

Static Magnetic Field CSPEC56: The Coronagraph instrument shall limit the static magnetic field to less than 40 nT in any axis 1 meter from any face of the unit for any operating mode.

Coronagraph Operating Modes Mode Transitions CSPEC59: The Coronagraph instrument shall transition from the current mode to any other mode without causing damage to itself.

Deterministic Power on Configuration CSPEC61: The Coronagraph instrument shall initialize into a predetermined configuration.

Safe Mode Provision of Safe Mode CSPEC64: The Coronagraph instrument shall provide a Safe Mode. Safe mode is an operating mode of the instrument during which all non-essential subsystems are shut down and only essential functions are active. Safe mode represents a configuration in which the instrument is thermally, mechanically, and optically “safe” without receiving commands from the Spacecraft.

CSPEC65: The Coronagraph instrument shall be capable of remaining in a safe configuration for at least 168 hours without ground intervention.

Entry Into Safe Mode CSPEC67: The Coronagraph instrument shall enter Safe Mode upon detection of internal faults that can cause damage to the instrument.

The L1 SERIES spacecraft will monitor up to six (TBR) analog instrument health and safety parameters defined by the Coronagraph contractor and command the Coronagraph into safe mode when any of those key values have been exceeded.

Normal Operational Mode CSPEC70: In normal operational mode, the Coronagraph instrument shall be in a fully functional configuration in which designed measurements are made in accordance with the performance requirements listed in section 4.1 of this document and are available to be sent to the spacecraft for downlink.

On-Orbit Operations CSPEC72: The Coronagraph instrument shall operate normally, within specification, while flying aboard a 3-axis stabilized spacecraft with orbital limit constraints as stated in this specification.

Station Keeping CSPEC74: The Coronagraph instrument shall continuously operate during all spacecraft maneuvers.

CSPEC75: The instrument shall meet all performance requirements within 300 seconds (TBR-9) after the spacecraft interface has returned to being within specification following spacecraft maneuvers.

Instrument Data Availability CSPEC16: The Coronagraph instrument shall have a 99.9 % (TBR-8) probability of operating continuously on-orbit during nominal observation mode (which excludes non-Coronagraph related Spacecraft Safe Holds, instrument calibrations and storm conditions).

CSPEC17: The Coronagraph Instrument shall limit on-orbit calibrations to no more than four (4) calibrations per year with each calibration lasting no more than 30 minutes.

CSPEC18: The Coronagraph instrument shall be capable of maintaining nominal observation mode without ground interaction for a minimum of four days.

CSPEC19: The instrument shall ensure there are no gaps in HAP data due to planned instrument events during NWS-declared Critical Space Weather Days.

Rationale: Once a Critical Space Weather Day is declared by NWS it is expected that any pre-planned instrument activities (e.g., calibration maneuvers) will have the flexibility to be re-scheduled without impacting instrument performance. The expected cadence and duration of NWS-declared Critical Space Weather Days is (TBR).

CSPEC20: The instrument shall provide a 99% (TBR-10) or greater probability of providing all of the instrument's HAP data during S4 class solar radiation storms or solar flare conditions including class X50, verifying through analysis using the “Worst Week” October 1989 model in CREME96 or equivalent.

Rationale: the CREME96 model includes the October 1989 solar particle event worst week model that conservatively bounds the single event effects environment in S4 and X50 solar events. It is expected that the probability of occurrence of outages as well as Bit Error Rates (BER) due to SEE will be used in the analysis that verifies this probability (CSPEC323 and CSPEC328 have been deleted and are being replaced with this requirement). Further definition of the worst week model can be found here: https://creme.isde.vanderbilt.edu/CREME-MC/help/solar-energetic-particle-environment.

Power The spacecraft will provide a power feed to the Coronagraph Instrument operational electronics.

The spacecraft will provide a power feed for the Coronagraph Instrument survival heaters.

Voltage Range CSPEC80: The Coronagraph instrument shall operate over the bus voltage range of 30 +/-4 VDC at the primary power inputs during all normal mission phases and for all expected load conditions (except when turned off).

Abnormal Voltages CSPEC82: The Coronagraph instrument shall survive without performance degradation after indefinite exposure to an anomalous voltage range of 0 to +40 VDC.

Power Transients The Coronagraph instrument shall meet its performance requirements in the presence of transients specified in MIL-STD-461F, Figure CS115-1 and Figure CS116-2.

Sudden Removal of Power CSPEC86: The Coronagraph instrument shall meet its performance requirements without degradation after exposure to an abrupt, unannounced removal of power.

Over-Current Protection The Coronagraph instrument does not use non-resetting over-current protection (i.e., fuses) internal to the unit Primary Power Return Ground CSPEC90: The Coronagraph instrument shall provide a dedicated Primary Power return in the same connector as the primary power.

Turn On Current Transients CSPEC92: The Coronagraph instrument shall limit any change in operational power current at any time (including initial power turn-on) to no more than 0.2A/µs. (TBR) Electrical Grounding Primary Power DC Isolation CSPEC95: The Coronagraph primary power interfaces, primary power and primary power returns, shall be isolated from the unit chassis by a DC resistance of greater than or equal to 10 Megaohms.

Survival Power Isolation CSPEC97: The Coronagraph survival heater power interfaces shall be isolated from the unit chassis by a DC resistance of greater than or equal to 10 Megaohms.

Rationale: Returning the instrument survival heater power returns to the spacecraft single point ground and isolating the survival heater power returns from the instrument chassis helps control common mode noise current and minimize magnetic field effects due to ground loops.

Internally Generated Secondary to Primary DC Isolation CSPEC99: Secondary power inputs shall be isolated from primary power by a DC resistance of greater than 10 Megaohms.

Rationale: Isolating the instrument secondary power returns from the instrument primary power returns helps control common mode noise currents and minimizes magnetic field effects due to ground loops.

Internally Generated Secondary Return CSPEC101: The Coronagraph shall reference its secondary returns (power and signal grounds) to the unit chassis ground.

Rationale: NASA-HDBK-4001 ELECTRICAL GROUNDING ARCHITECTURE FOR UNMANNED SPACECRAFT Mechanical Contact Resistance CSPEC103: The DC resistance of the mechanical contact between two conductive mating mechanical surfaces (internal to the unit) shall be less than or equal to 2.5 mΩ DC resistance.

Rationale: Low resistance contacts are essential for maintaining a zero potential ground.

Grounding CSPEC105: The DC resistance between the Mag Electronics Unit chassis and the observatory chassis shall be ≤ 2.5 milliohms.

Rationale: Low resistance contact between instrument chassis to spacecraft structure is essential for maintaining a zero potential ground.

CSPEC106: The Coronagraph shall provide a ground lug for a grounding strap to be attached from the Coronagraph Electronics Unit chassis for connection to the spacecraft conductive structure.

Rationale: This provides a method/location for tying the instrument ground to the spacecraft conductive structure.

CSPEC107: The grounding lug location on the Cornagraph Electronics Unit chassis or the tie points in contact with the ground strap shall be defined in the MICD. The ground lug contact area must remain free of any material finish that may affect the reliability of the ground connection and will be shown in the MICD.

Connector DC Resistance CSPEC109: Coronagraph connector backshells shall be electrically connected to Electronics Unit chassis with a DC resistance ≤ 2.5 mΩ.

Rationale: Low resistance contact between instrument chassis to spacecraft structure is essential for maintaining a zero potential ground.

Signal and Data Interfaces Passive Analog Telemetry CSPEC112: The Coronagraph shall utilize no more than three analog signals to monitor critical temperature points when the Coronagraph is powered off.

Rationale: Common best practices for on-orbit operations deems that the Spacecraft will be able to monitor health and safety of the instrument if the instrument is in any configuration other than the normal operational configuration, e.g. safe or survival mode. Six signals is also deemed reasonable given the complexity of the instrument.

Data Signal Interface CSPEC114: The Coronagraph Instrument shall interface for data transfer to or from the spacecraft by SpaceWire (ECSS-E-ST-50-12C-rev.1) data bus.

Rationale: SpaceWire is the preferred standard high-rate data interface.

The spacecraft will provide two data signal interface feeds to the Coronagraph Electronics Unit for command and telemetry. The spacecraft will also provide an interface line for a Pulse Per Second (PPS).

Telemetry Source Packet Format CSPEC117: The Coronagraph shall transfer all data to the spacecraft using the CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Section 4.1 Protocol Data Unit definition shown in the Telemetry Source Packet Definition Figure 1.

Rationale: Use of CCSDS standards simplifies command and telemetry data handling system and interface design.

Figure 1 Telemetry Source Packet Definition CSPEC120: The Coronagraph telemetry Source packets shall be variable length with a maximum data zone of 8192 octets including Secondary Header.

Rationale: CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2003 CSPEC121: The Coronagraph shall set the telemetry source packet Secondary Header Flag to the value 1.

Rationale: CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2003 CSPEC122: The Coronagraph shall set the Telemetry Source Packet Sequence Flags to the value of 11.

Note: Segmentation services are not permitted.

Rationale: CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2003 CSPEC123: The Coronagraph shall set the Telemetry Source Packet Time Code per CCSDS 301.B-4 Time Code Formats, Day Segmented format in the Time Code Format Figure 2.

Rationale: CCSDS is a data format interface standard developed by NASA to create commonality to simplify data processing and routing.

Figure 2 Time Code Format Note: The P-Field is implied and not included in the actual time message.

The Spacecraft will maintain a continuous time system on-board that can be related to UTC time on the ground.

Command Source Packet Format CSPEC130: The Coronagraph shall receive all data from the spacecraft formatted per CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Section 4.1 Protocol Data Unit definition shown in the Command Source Packet Definition Figure 3.

Rationale: CCSDS is a data format interface standard developed by NASA to create commonality to simplify data processing and routing.

INSERT FIGURE

Figure 3 Command Source Packet CSPEC133: The Coronagraph command Source packets shall be variable length with a maximum data zone of 8192 octets.

Rationale: CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2003 CSPEC134: The Coronagraph shall receive Command Source Packet with Secondary Header Flag set to the value 0.

Rationale: CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2003 CSPEC135: The Coronagraph shall receive Command Source Packet with the Sequence Flags set to the value of 11.

Note: Segmentation services are not permitted.

Rationale: CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2003 Clock Signal Interface CSPEC137: The Coronagraph shall receive a Pulse Per Second (PPS) time pulse from spacecraft clock line by the interface defined in CSPEC114.

Rationale: TBD to allow for flexibility The Spacecraft will maintain Spacecraft time correlation to within +/- 0.95 sec of UTC and will provide the Coronagraph a 1 PPS with a time code message.

The spacecraft will provide a clock interface feed to the Coronagraph Electronics Unit.

CSPEC140: The Coronagraph shall receive from the spacecraft a time code message on the data line as defined in Spacecraft Time Message Packet Figure 4. The time code message is the time applicable to receipt of the 1 PPS.

Rationale: CCSDS 133.0-B-1 Space Packet Protocol, Blue Book, Issue 1, September 2003

Figure 4 Spacecraft Time Message Packet Figure Command and Housekeeping telemetry CSPEC144: The Coronagraph instrument shall provide command and housekeeping telemetry functions in all powered modes.

Rationale: Housekeeping telemetry are data required to monitor instrument operation, health, and safety. Command functions may be required to maintain the health and safety of the instrument.

Commands for Autonomous Functions CSPEC146: The Coronagraph shall execute commands to individually enable and disable each autonomous function.

Rationale: Allows flexibility to maintain the health and safety of the instrument during on-orbit operations.

Limits and Triggers CSPEC148: The Coronagraph autonomous limits and triggers shall be changeable by command.

Rationale: Allows flexibility to maintain the health and safety of the instrument during on-orbit operations.

On-Board Processor Reset CSPEC150: The Coronagraph On-Board Processor shall be reset by command.

Rationale: Common best practices dictate this capability for on-orbit anomaly troubleshooting, e.g. to terminate hung processes.

CSPEC151: An autonomous power-on reset occurrence shall be unambiguously identifiable via telemetry.

Note: This does not imply real-time telemetry as the reset is occurring.

Rationale: Common best practices dictate this capability for on-orbit anomaly troubleshooting Micro-switches CSPEC153: Micro-switches shall be used for information only and not used to initiate on-board autonomous activity or as an on-board interlock.

Rationale: Common best practices dictate this capability for on-orbit anomaly troubleshooting. Micro-switches are not reliable enough for autonomous actions.

Flight Software Flight Load Non-volatile Memory CSPEC156: The Coronagraph flight software image shall be contained in its entirety in non-volatile memory.

Rationale: Allows for power-cycling without loss of the stored flight software image.

Software Updates CSPEC158: The flight software modules shall be reprogrammable.

Rationale: Provides flexibility should operational changes be required following an anomaly, as the instrument ages, etc.

Software Table Updates CSPEC160: Instrument configuration data (e.g. Table Loads or Configuration Parameters) shall be reprogrammable during integration and test phases and on-orbit without computer restart.

Rationale: Common best practices dictate this capability to avoid unnecessary power cycles of the instrument.

CSPEC161: Modified instrument configuration data (e.g. Table Loads or Configuration Parameters) shall be committed to operational use by ground command.

Rationale: Common best practice to ensure “a person in the loop” before making a configuration change.

Flexibility and Ease of Software Modification CSPEC163: The Coronagraph flight software shall be deterministic in terms of scheduling and prioritization of critical processing tasks to ensure their timely completion.

Rationale: To ensure that a critical task gets executed in the intended timeframe.

CSPEC164: Instrument configuration data (e.g. Table Loads or Configuration Parameters) shall be referenced such that data can be loaded and dumped by the ground without reference to memory address.

Rationale: Common best practices dictates this capability for ease of operation and to reduce risk of loading to the wrong memory address.

CSPEC165: The definition of instrument commands within the ground database (excluding memory diagnostic/load commands) shall not be dependent on physical memory addresses within the flight software.

Rationale: To avoid the need to rebuild the command and telemetry database every time the flight software is recompiled; modifying the code results in address changes leading to command changes and then re-testing commands.

Version Identifiers CSPEC167: The Coronagraph software and firmware versions shall each have an internal identifier (embedded in the executive program) that can be included in the instrument engineering data.

Rationale: Common best practice to ensure that knowledge of version is always accessible.

CSPEC168: This software identifier shall be configuration management controlled.

Rationale: Common best practice.

Warm Restart CSPEC170: The Coronagraph flight software shall provide a restart by command with preservation of instrument configuration data and memory tables.

Memory Tests CSPEC172: The Coronagraph flight software shall provide a mechanism to verify the contents of all memory areas.

Rationale: Common best practice.

Memory Dump CSPEC174: The Coronagraph flight software, and associated on-board computer hardware, shall provide the capability to dump any memory location.

Rationale: Common best practice.

CSPEC175: The flight software memory dump capability shall not disturb normal operations and instrument data processing.

Rationale: Common best practice.

Fault Detection and Correction Control CSPEC177: If applicable, Coronagraph shall provide the capability to enable and disable any internal Fault Detection and Correction (FDC) features.

Rationale: Allows flexibility in the on-orbit operations.

Health and Safety Monitoring CSPEC179: The Coronagraph flight software shall provide health and safety monitoring, including memory checksum and watchdog timer.

Rationale: Common best practice for maintaining health and safety of the instrument.

Physical Requirements Interface and Design Units and Exclusions CSPEC182: The contractor shall use metric units to design the instrument and for developing interfaces with the spacecraft including any drawings, documents, models, except for the following cases:

· Heritage Component or unit: Components or units that has been previously qualified, or of similar design heritage, may be specified in English units where use of metric equivalents would lead to additional cost to the program.

· Fasteners: Although bolt patterns will be defined using metric dimensioning, use of English fasteners (with hole dimensioning and tolerancing) is permitted.

· Angular Measurement: Angular measurement may be expressed in degree of arc or in an appropriate subdivision of degree of arc such as second of arc (arc-sec) when advantageous to application.

Mass Properties Accuracy…

This is the start of the file's text. The full file is on GovTribe.

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .