354-RFB-27-12 Addendum 1 with attachments.pdf
PDF 404 KB Posted
- Attached to
- Powder Activated Carbon
- Solicitation number
- 354-RFB-27-12
- Issued by
- Wake County, Charlotte City, North Carolina
About this file
This Addendum 1 document, issued by the Town of Cary, North Carolina on November 2, 2026, clarifies the bid specifications and answers 21 submitted questions for Request for Bids 354-RFB-27-12 for Powder Activated Carbon supply to the Cary/Apex Water Treatment Facility. The Town seeks approximately 400,000 pounds of powder activated carbon (PAC) for a four-month fixed-price contract period anticipated to begin in November 2026 with no extension options. Bidders must be established in chemical manufacturing and/or procurement for a minimum of five years and must be eligible to submit multiple products on separate bid forms, each with a required one-pound sample submitted by November 9, 2026 at 11:00 a.m. ET to Ryan Lambert at the Cary/Apex WTF Laboratory. Bids are due November 9, 2026 at 11:00 a.m. ET via the North Carolina eVP website, with virtual bid opening at 11:00 a.m. ET. Award is anticipated November 16, 2026, and the Town will evaluate bids based on responsive, responsible bidders using performance evaluation criteria including jar testing for removal of taste and odor compounds.
The current supplier price is $1.045 per pound, and the Town used approximately 1,238,500 pounds of PAC from January through September 2026, with the current product being Watercarb 1000 D by Donau. All bidders must hold their price for 60 days from bid submission, after which the contract price remains fixed for the four-month duration. Bidders must submit certified laboratory data demonstrating at least 50% removal of PFOA and PFOS, an affidavit certifying material compliance, a letter of product commitment, and at least three municipal water utility references. The material must be domestically produced from domestic raw materials, meet AWWA Standard B-600-24 and NSF Standard 60, and deliveries of approximately 40,000-pound tanker loads are typically required at either the Cary/Apex Water Treatment Facility (1400 Wimberly Road, Apex) or the Raw Water Pump Station (9651 US64, Apex). Pricing includes all transportation and freight on an FOB destination basis, with payment Net 30 from receipt of invoice or acceptance of goods, and North Carolina sales tax listed separately. Distributors not directly manufacturing the product are eligible to bid if they disclose the manufacturer, provide a letter of product commitment from the manufacturer, and use contracted bulk tanker companies for delivery.
View the file
Other files
| File | Type | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| 354-27-12 Powder Activated Carbon.pdf |
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
TOWN O f CARY 316 North Academy Street • Cary, NC 27513 • PO Box 8005 • Cary, NC 27512-8005 tel 919-469-4030 • fax 919-460-4935 • www.townofcary.org
November 2, 2026 354-RFB-27-12 Request for Bids for
Powder Activated Carbon
ADDENDUM 1
Please note that this addendum is to clarify the bid and answer questions submitted during the “RFB Questions” open period. All other terms and conditions given in the RFB are in full force and effect.
QUESTION & ANSWER
1) Q: Will you please share the previous bid tabulation?
A: The bid tabulation from the most recent Powder Activated Carbon Bid is attached as “Bid Tabulation 354-RFB-25-08.”
2) What is the current supplier price?
A: The current price is $1.045 per pound.
3) How much Powder Activated Carbon has the Town used in pounds this year up to this point?
A: The Town used approximately 1,238,500 pounds of Powder Activated Carbon from January through September of 2026.
4) What is the Town’s current PAC product?
A: The Town’s current product is Watercarb 1000 D by Donau.
5) Does the Town currently test or monitor for PFAS contaminants?
A: Yes
6) What are the four-month contract dates for PAC?
A: The contract will begin once awarded and end four months after. The Town anticipates awarding the project in November.
7) Is there a possibility for any contract extensions?
A: No. The Town intends to issue a future Request for Bids.
8) What is the town’s typical delivery size of PAC? What is your minimum tanker delivery?
A: While there is no official minimum, deliveries are typically full-size tanker trucks that contain approximately 40,000 pounds of product.
9) Could you please advise on the below requirement you all need product performance from a certified lab on Geosmin, MIB,TOC and perfluorinated compounds such as PFOA and PFOS? Does this have to be with City of Cary water?
“Bidder shall submit technical information demonstrating the performance of their product in the removal of the organic compounds responsible for taste and odor (Geosmin, MIB, etc.), TOC, and perfluorinated compounds such as PFOA and
PFOS.”
A: The intent of this request is to evaluate the ability of the product to meet the Town’s treatment needs, particularly with regards to PFAS compounds. It is expected that vendors will choose products to submit for bid that are proven to remove PFAS compounds.
For the purposes of this bid, while it is mandatory to provide laboratory data for the carbon product being submitted, testing IS NOT required to be performed using the specific sample of material submitted or performed on Cary’s water.
Examples of acceptable documentation would include, but are not limited to, internal test data obtained during product development, data from a similar project, or data from pilot testing. This documentation must show the product provided at least 50% PFAS removal in that testing. The Town recognizes that the characteristics of Cary’s water source are unique and that actual field performance may differ.
If data is available, but was not performed by a certified testing laboratory, it may be acceptable, provided the name of the laboratory and testing method used are listed.
If laboratory testing was done in-house, please note that on the submission.
10) Are we allowed to submit bids for multiple products?
A: Yes. Each product must be submitted on a separate, signed bid form. Forms may be submitted together as a single packet in the bid portal. A sample must be submitted for each product bid.
11) Which four months are typically the highest usage months?
A: Usage is highly dependent on demand as well as levels of taste and odor compounds in the source water. Water demand is generally highest in the summer, while taste and odor compounds tend to be at their highest when the lake turns over in the fall and spring.
12) Could you please provide the performance results from the previous contract period?
A: Performance results from the previous bid are attached (“Watercarb vs. TRA performance evaluation”, “Carbon Evaluation Information”). Please note that the evaluation process for this bid will be as stated in the specifications and not as shown in the previous bid evaluation.
13) Same-organization delivery (Minimum Specifications §6.c.i). Section 6.c.i states the "CONTRACTOR, Manufacturer, and Dispatch should be within the same organization or company." Is a bidder that is a distributor/procurement company — not the manufacturer — eligible if (a) the manufacturer is disclosed on the proposal form, (b) the manufacturer's letter of product commitment required by §10 is enclosed, and (c) deliveries are made by the manufacturer's or a contracted bulk-tanker's dispatch? Is this clause a mandatory eligibility requirement or a preference?
A: Yes, a bidder who is a distributor and not the direct manufacturer is eligible to bid.
It is mandatory to disclose the name of the product and manufacturer and provide the letter of product commitment. The bidder’s use of contracted bulk tanker companies for delivery is acceptable.
14) Five-year establishment (Minimum Specifications §1.d). Section 1.d limits bids to bidders "established in the business of chemical manufacturing and/or procurement, and delivery for five years or more." How should a bidder document the five years, and does chemical procurement-and-delivery experience (as distinct from manufacturing) satisfy the requirement on its own?
A: There are no specific requirements for how this must be documented. Examples of acceptable items include, but are not limited to, dated reference lists and published company history information. Bidders are not required to manufacture the product being bid, so chemical procurement and delivery experience would satisfy the experience requirement.
15) Municipal references (Minimum Specifications §11 and Attachment 1). The three references must be large municipal water utilities "for which the MATERIAL being bid is or has been supplied by the bidder." If the bidder is a distributor, may the references be utilities supplied with the same manufacturer's material through other channels, or must the bidder itself have been the supplier of record to each utility?
A: The intent of the municipal references is to both confirm the quality of the material supplied and the performance of the supplier. If bidder is a distributor and unable to provide three references for the product bid that was also supplied by the distributor, references may be split between utilities using the same product through other channels and utilities served by the distributor for projects similar in scope, even if the material supplied was different. This must be clearly noted on the references list.
16) Contract term and committed volume (§1.b, §10, Instructions §13). The estimate is approximately 400,000 pounds during a four-month period. (a) Is 400,000 pounds the total contract quantity, or the estimated usage per four-month period if the contract is extended? (b) What contract end date should the §10 letter of product commitment state? (c) Instructions §13 describes a fixed-price contract period of four months with pricing fixed for the first 60 days — please confirm the initial contract term and how extension periods are exercised.
A: 400,000 pounds is the estimated total quantity used during the four-month contract period. There will not be extensions to this contract. It will end at the conclusion of the four-month period. All bidders are required to hold their price for 60 days from the bid. This is to provide adequate time for bid evaluation and award.
For the bidder awarded the contract, their bid price shall become the contract price and shall remain fixed for the duration of the contract.
17) Delivery split between service points (Minimum Specifications §6.m). Deliveries go to the Cary/Apex Water Treatment Facility (1400 Wimberly Road, Apex) and the Raw Water Pump Station (9651 US64, Apex). Is there an expected split of the 400,000 pounds between the two points, and what is the typical tanker load size and delivery frequency the Town expects?
A: There is not an expected split between the two locations. It will be dependent on the characteristics of the water source and the facility’s process control needs.
Delivery location will be provided for each order. The delivery frequency will depend on usage but may be as frequent as weekly. Tanker load size was addressed in a previous question.
18) One-pound sample (§4.c). The sample must be received by the bid due time (November 9, 11:00 AM ET) at the Cary/Apex WTF Laboratory, 1400 Wimberly Rd, Apex, NC 27523. Please confirm: (a) to whose attention the sample should be addressed, (b) how the sample package should be marked/identified with the bid number, and (c) whether the sample must come from the same product lot as the certified laboratory data submitted with the bid.
A: The sample should be sent to the attention of Ryan Lambert, the CAWTF manager. The sample should be identified with the name of the product and the bid number. This identification should be on both the shipping container and the container holding the product. The sample DOES NOT have to come from the same product lot as the laboratory data submitted with the bid.
19) PFAS laboratory data (§3.c and §4.b.i). Bids must include certified independent laboratory data on removal of perfluorinated compounds, and products showing less than 50% removal of PFOA and PFOS are removed from consideration. (a) Does the manufacturer's existing certified laboratory data for the exact product satisfy this requirement, or must the data be commissioned by the bidder? (b) Are there specific test conditions (influent concentrations, contact time, carbon dose) the Town wants the data reported under?
A: Yes, manufacturer’s existing laboratory data for the exact product will satisfy this requirement. There are no specific test conditions the Town would like for the reported data.
20) Bid opening time (Proposal Form vs. Instructions §7). The proposal form states bids will be opened at 11:00 AM ET on November 9, while Instructions §7.a lists the virtual Webex opening at 2:00 PM ET. Which time is correct for bidders who wish to attend?
A: The correct time for the bid opening is November 9 at 11:00 am.
21) What is the process for exceptions to the specifications?
A: Any exceptions taken to the specifications and/or Terms and Conditions must be noted in the designated spot on the bid form. A product with exceptions may be submitted and may be evaluated; however, the Town reserves the right to reject products that do not meet the specifications as written if, in its estimation, rejection is in the best interest of the Town.
BID TABULATION
354-RFB-25-08
Powder Activated Carbon Opened: February 14, 2025 at 11:30 AM ET
This is the bid tabulation ONLY for Powder Activated Carbon as per the Specifications, Terms and Conditions listed in the request for bid number 354-RFB-25-08.
Joining on the Webex were:
Kathryn McMillan, Town of Cary Ryan Lambert, Town of Cary Betsy Drake, Town of Cary Audrey Foster, Town of Cary Austin Conley, Arq Purification
Bidders
Addendum Acknowledged
Sample Received
Memo & Affidavit Product/Manufacturer
Price Per Dry Pound Line Total
Brenntag Mid-South NA NA NA No Bid - -
Carbon Activated Corp Y Y Y RUWA-PL 1500 $1.1925 $1,908,000
Carbon Activated Corp Y Y Y COL-PL900 $1.1175 $1,788,000
Carbon Activated Corp Y Y Y COL-PL700 $1.0625 $1,700,000
Arq Purification Y Y Y CarbPure TRA $1.10 $1,760,000
Arq Purification Y Y Y CarbPure QRA $1.85 $2,960,000
Norit Y Y Y NORIT PAC20BF $1.25 $2,000,000
Norit Y Y Y Hydrodarco B $1.50 $2,400,000
Donau Carbon Y Y Y Watercarb 1000(D) $1.045 $1,672,770
Donau Carbon Y Y Y Watercarb 1000 $1.104 $1,988,002
*Please note that during the live bid opening only one bid was read aloud for Carbon Activated Corp & Donau Carbon, however, both bidders submitted multiple products as part of their bid packages. The items that were missed during the live reading have been accounted for on the above bid tab.
Hi Austin, My apologies, I misinterpreted the information provided to me on the two products. You’re correct that the QRA was the one identified to have PFAS compounds and was eliminated from consideration.
Regarding your original question on additional insight into Cary’s evaluation, one of the primary factors that determined Watercarb 1000D over CarbPure TRA was the performance of the products at the 15ppm dosage for removal of MIB, Geosmin, and PFAS. The water treatment facility uses a baseline dose of 15 ppm carbon for removal of those compounds, with minor temporary adjustments if levels increase in the lake beyond what our treatment process can adequately remove. This dose is used the majority of the time and is the heaviest influence on total cost. As you can see from the table below, Watercarb 1000D outperformed for the removal of PFAS, MIB, & Geosmin at this dosage.
The daily cost of carbon based on an average day flow of 20 MGD at the 15 ppm dose would be as follows:
0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%
Performance for Key Parameters at 15 ppm Dose
Total PFAS MIB Geosmin
Product Bid Price Total Cost 2- CarbPure TRA 1.10 $2,752.20 7- WaterCarb 1000D 1.045 $2,614.59
Carbon Evaluation Additional Information
Each carbon sample was jar tested. Jars were spiked to get a 100 ng/L concentration of MIB/Geosmin. Testing for MIB, Geosmin, TOC, and Turbidity were performed by staff and were tested at three different concentrations, 15 ppm, 25 ppm, and 35 ppm. Samples were sent to an outside lab for PFAS testing, which was only performed for the 15 ppm concentration.
Prior to 2018, the Cary/Apex Water Treatment Facility used PAC for removal of taste and odor compounds. The levels of these compounds change throughout the year, depending on conditions in Jordan Lake. In 2018, we also began using PAC for removal of PFAS. We use a consistent daily dose of PAC for PFAS removal and increase above that dose as needed to address higher concentrations of MIB and Geosmin in the lake.
We selected the MIB-Geosmin removal variable as the basis for a cost assessment, since our dose increases above baseline in response to those concentrations. Lab staff used the results from the 15 ppm, 25 ppm, and 35 ppm dosages to create a curve for each carbon sample. The slope of the curve was used to determine the dosage required to meet 9 ppm.
The figure on the next page shows the curves for each carbon.
We have an established dose for PFAS removal and, since PFAS testing is both expensive and takes at least two weeks for results, we only evaluated PFAS removal at 15 ppm. This aligns with the dose used for the full-scale process. Carbons were evaluated to see how they performed in comparison to our current supplier. While there is no regulation for PFAS at this time, CAWTF’s finished water is meeting proposed future EPA MCLs using the current carbon. The PFAS removal chart is included on the next page.
The recommended product performed comparably with our current carbon in all categories. It was not the top remover of PFAS among the suppliers, but performed similarly to our current carbon, so we expect to be able to continue to produce finished water below the proposed MCLs with the same dosage. The supplier also met all requirements of the bid, including providing performance information, test results showing whether the product contained PFAS (it did not), and is a fully domestic product.
Carbon 1 = CarbPure QRA Carbon 6 = Watercarb-1000
Carbon 2 = CarbPure TRA Carbon 7 = Watercarb-1000D
Carbon 3 = COL-PL700 Carbon 8 = Hydodarco BP-1072
Carbon 4 = COL-PL900 Carbon 9 = PAC 20BF P-1059
Carbon 5 = RUWA – PL1500 Carbon 10 = Current Carbon
| 354-RFB-27-12 Addendum 1 |
| Bid Tab 354-RFB-25-08 |
| Watercarb vs. TRA performance evaluation |
| Carbon Evaluation Information |
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .