2318 Scores Tabulation.pdf

This is a scores tabulation document for Kenosha County, Wisconsin related to the Public Safety Building Fuel Tank Replacement Project Design. The document presents evaluation results for three bidding firms: Endpoint Solutions, Clark Dietz, and Kueny Architects. The project scope included technical evaluation across three categories: Company Profile (25 points), Staff Qualifications (25 points), and Proposal Solutions (30 points), for a combined technical score of 100 points. Endpoint Solutions achieved a technical score of 67.67, Clark Dietz scored 70.33, and Kueny Architects scored 67.67.

The cost evaluation component weighted at 20 points was based on lump sum proposals, with calculations adjusted for scope compliance. Endpoint Solutions submitted a lump sum cost of $43,300, Clark Dietz submitted $70,995, and Kueny Architects submitted $27,500. After adjustment of Clark Dietz's proposal to exclude $17,960 in additional services exceeding scope (resulting in a calculated cost of $53,035 for scoring purposes), the cost scores were 12.70, 10.37, and 20.00 points respectively. Clark Dietz received the highest total proposal score of 80.70 points, followed by Endpoint Solutions at 80.37 points and Kueny Architects at 87.67 points.