Attachment_C_-_Asbestos_Survey_and_Paint_Sampling_Report.pdf

100 Portage Street Houghton, MI 49931

906-482-4810 • 800-562-7684 • Fax: 906-482-9799

Offices also in:

Iron Mountain

Ishpeming Marinette

Sault Ste Marie

U.P. Engineers & Architects, Inc. www.UPEA.com

[U28-17435] July 26, 2017

Ms. Debra K. Brinn, Contract Specialist USDA Forest Service Huron Shores Ranger Station 5761 N. Skeel Oscoda, MI 48750-1595

RE: ASBESTOS SURVEY AND LEAD & CADMIUM CONTAINING PAINT SAMPLING –

MONDEAUX RECREATION SITE LOCATED AT W7969 PARK RD., WESTBORO, WI

54490

Dear Debra K. Brinn:

Thank you for selecting U.P. Engineers & Architects, Inc. (UPEA) to conduct the asbestos survey and lead & cadmium containing paint sampling. As authorized, UPEA completed the survey and sampling on July 11th, 2017. UPEA has enclosed an asbestos survey, and a lead and cadmium containing paint sampling report, which includes procedures and methodologies, analytical laboratory results, and applicable conclusions and recommendations.

If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at (906) 482-4810 or erbjorn@upea.com. We appreciate the opportunity to be of service.

Sincerely, U.P. ENGINEERS & ARCHITECTS, INC.

Emmett Bjorn WI Asbestos Inspector License: AII-234953 WI Lead Risk Assessor License: LRA-234953

Cc: TSPurdy/UPEA w/enclosures

12569R19B0005 Attachment C - Asbestos Survey and Paint Sampling Report 79 Pages

MONDEAUX SITE RECREATION

BUILDINGS LOCATED AT

W7969 PARK RD.

WESTBORO, WI 54490

ASBESTOS SURVEY & LEAD

AND CADMIUM CONTAINING PAINT

SAMPLING REPORT

Prepared for:

USDA Forest Service Huron Shores Ranger Station

5761 N. Skeel Oscodo, MI 48750-1595

Prepared By:

U.P. ENGINEERS & ARCHITECTS, INC.

100 Portage Street Houghton, Michigan 49931

July 2017

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

I. PURPOSE AND SCOPE

II. ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL SURVEY

III. LEAD AND CADMIUM CONTAINING PAINT SAMPLING

IV. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATION

V. LIMITATIONS

LIST OF APPENDICES

APPENDIX A INSPECTOR ACCREDITATION

APPENDIX B BUILDING FLOOR PLANS

APPENDIX C ANALYTICAL RESULTS - ASBESTOS

APPENDIX D LABORATORY ACCREDITATION

APPENDIX E ANALYTICAL RESULTS – LEAD & CADMIUM CONTAINING PAINT

APPENDIX F MOLD TESTING – LIVING QUARTERS BUILDING

1 UPEA

I. PURPOSE AND SCOPE

The purpose of this project was to conduct an asbestos survey and lead & cadmium containing paint sampling at the buildings located at W7969 Park Rd., Westboro, WI 54490. The survey and sampling will identify asbestos containing material (ACM), presumed ACM (PACM), and lead and cadmium containing paint throughout the building. The survey and sampling should be referred to by staff and personnel during demolition operations. Material or items not comprised of ACM or PACM may be removed, repaired or replaced by general maintenance staff or contractors. However, ACM or PACM items must be handled and disposed of by properly trained personnel.

Lead and cadmium containing paint may be disposed of as demolition debris, if the proper procedures are followed.

The scope of this project includes:

1. Building walk through

2. Identification of suspect ACM

3. Collection and analysis of bulk samples of suspect ACM

4. Collection of suspect Lead & Cadmium Containing Paint Samples

5. Quantification of ACM and PACM

6. Assess current condition of ACM and PACM, and identify the potential for disturbance of ACM and PACM.

II. ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL SURVEY

An asbestos survey was conducted for the buildings located at W7969 Park Rd., Westboro, WI 54490. The asbestos survey was performed by Emmett Bjorn; a State of Wisconsin licensed Asbestos Inspector (License # AII-234953) on July 11, 2017.

The asbestos survey consisted of five phases: 1) conduct a visual inspection of the building; 2) identify homogeneous areas; 3) sample selected suspect ACM from different homogeneous areas; 4) quantify ACM and PACM; 5) assess current conditions of sampled suspect ACM and the potential for disturbance of the ACM identified.

Prior to collecting any samples, a sampling strategy was developed based on the layout of the building and the construction periods associated with each section of the building.

Based on the sampling strategy, the building was divided into different homogeneous areas, from which samples would be collected. A homogeneous area can be described as one or more areas of material that are similar in appearance and that have the same construction/installation date and function. Bulk samples of identified suspect asbestos containing material (ACM) were collected in individual containers and sent to a National Voluntary Lab Accreditation Program (NVLAP)/American Industrial Hygiene Association (AIHA) accredited laboratory for analysis. The number of samples collected from each homogeneous area may vary depending on the professional judgment of the inspector and the type of material present.

2 UPEA

A. SAMPLING STRATEGY

In planning the asbestos survey, the approach was taken to test and catalog all visible areas of the building presumed to be asbestos containing. The building is scheduled to be renovated, so any materials presumed to be asbestos containing must be removed prior to any construction.

The asbestos survey was conducted according to AHERA guidelines utilizing a minimum number of samples collected from each homogeneous area. The number of samples collected depends on the category that the suspect asbestos containing building material (ACBM) falls under and the amount of suspect material present. The following table outlines the AHERA sampling Guidelines:

Bulk Sampling Requirements Type of Material Samples Required

Friable Surfacing Material:

Area ≤ 1,000 sq. feet 3 Area > 1,000 sq. feet but ≤ 5,000 sq. feet 5 Area > 5,000 sq. feet 7 Thermal System Insulation (TSI) TSI not assumed to be ACBM 3 Patched TSI not assumed to be ACBM (if patched section < 6 linear or sq. feet)

Miscellaneous Materials Each insulated mechanical system not assumed to be ACBM where cement or plaster is used on fittings such as tees, elbows, or valves

Samples in a manner sufficient to determine if material is or is not ACBM*

Friable Miscellaneous Material not Assumed to be ACBM

Samples in a manner sufficient to determine if material is or is not ACBM*

Nonfriable Suspected ACBM not assumed to be ACSM

Samples in a manner sufficient to determine if material is or is not ACBM*

* EPA recommends that three samples be taken to meet this requirement.

Miscellaneous materials require sufficient sampling, which requires at least one sample per homogeneous material, with three samples typically collected. The number of samples collected is determined by the building inspector, typically based on observations such as quantity, condition, and friability of material present.

B. SUSPECT ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIAL

Forty Six (46) samples (29-Lodge, 14-Living Quarters, 3-Garage) of suspect ACM were collected from the building and analyzed by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM). Table 1 shows any confirmed ACMs. Table 2 presents the sample analysis results. The confirmed ACMs, if any, are reported in bold text.

Appendix B contains a copy of the building floor plans. Copies of the analytical results are included in Appendix C. Appendix D contains a copy of the laboratory accreditation.

3 UPEA

This asbestos survey was completed with limited destructive testing. Therefore, hidden materials may be discovered in walls or ceilings that contain asbestos. If such materials are encountered, all work shall stop immediately until proper testing is conducted to determine the content of the material.

TABLE 1

CONFIRMED ASBESTOS CONTAINING MATERIALS

FLOOR LOCATION MATERIAL QUANTITY FRIABLE

Lodge - Roof Chimney

Penetration Black Tar/Caulk 12 LF No

III. LEAD AND CADMIUM CONTAINING PAINT SAMPLING

Six (6) samples (3-Lodge, 2-Living Quarters, 1-Garage) of suspect lead and cadmium containing paint from the building were collected and submitted for analysis by an accredited laboratory. The following tables (Table 3 & Table 4) present the sample analysis results. The confirmed lead-containing and cadmium-containing paint samples are reported in bold text. Copies of the lead and cadmium analytical results are included in Appendix E.

IV. CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS

Asbestos:

The results of the asbestos survey conducted on 7/11/2017 for the buildings located at W7969 Park Rd., Westboro, WI 54490 indicate that the building DOES contain asbestos at the Lodge Chimney Roof Penetration. Of the tested materials, asbestos WAS found in one (1) sample collected from the site.

Material or items not comprised of ACM or PACM may be removed, repaired or replaced by general maintenance staff or contractors. However, ACM or PACM items must be handled and disposed of by properly trained personnel. Subcontractors and employees working in the building should be instructed to report any hidden suspect ACM immediately upon discovery.

Lead and Cadmium-Containing Paint:

The results of the lead and cadmium-containing paint sampling conducted on 7/11/2017, indicate that the building sampled DOES contain lead containing paint. Of the tested materials, lead containing paint was identified in the Lodge Windows, Lodge Exterior Trims, Garage Windows, Living Quarters Interior Trims & Living Quarters Interior Walls.

Of the tested materials, cadmium containing paint was NOT identified in any samples.

Since lead paint is present, air monitoring and or proper personal protective equipment will be required during demolition, dependent upon worse-case scenario.

4 UPEA

V. LIMITATIONS

Identification and testing of PACM was conducted by a trained professional licensed in the State of Wisconsin. Professional judgment was used in the selection of materials to be tested and the number of samples of each homogeneous material tested.

This report documents testing of ACM or PACM based on sampling strategies and priorities as described herein, and on the dates and at locations identified in this report.

Modifications to the building or its interior through renovations, remodeling, building additions or changes to fixtures, facilities or furnishings that occur subsequent to the date of this report may add or remove ACM or PACM not identified in this report.

This report was completed to aid the building Owner, general contractors, and potential asbestos abatement contractors in locating ACM. Under no circumstances should this report be utilized as a bidding document or as a project specification document.

This report was completed with limited destructive testing. Therefore, materials may be discovered in walls or ceilings that contain asbestos. If such materials are encountered, all work shall stop immediately until proper testing may be conducted to determine the content of the material.

SAMPLE LOCATION

SAMPLE

NUMBER

MATERIAL

(CLASSIFICATION) DESCRIPTION OF MATERIAL

ESTIMATED

QUANTITY

FRIABLE

YES / NO

ASBESTOS

CONTENT

Drywall White ~1000 SF NO None

Roofing Underlayment Black ~2500 SF NO None

Lodge 28 Roof Penetration Tar Black, Bituminous ~15 LF NO None

Ceiling Plaster White ~1000 SF

Wall Plaster White ~1000 SF NO None

Lodge 23 Drywall White ~1000 SF NO None

Drywall White ~1000 SF NO None

Lodge 21 Ceiling Plaster White ~1000 SF NO None

Grout Brown, between 6"x6" tiles 100 SF NO None

Lodge 19 Ceiling Tile 2'x2', White, Kit. #1 only 200 SF NO None

Baseboard Trim Vinyl, White 60 LF NO None

Lodge 17 Floor Tile 6"x6", Brown 100 SF NO None

Glue Tan, behind wood base board in Open

Space & Kit. #2 100 LF NO None

Lodge 15 Floor Tile 8"x8", grey, ceramic 400 SF NO None

NO None

Lodge 26 Roofing Shingles Brown ~2500 SF NO None

NO None

Lodge 13 Gypcrete Red, in Kit. #1 & Kit. #2 400 SF NO None

NO

Caulk

Caulk White, around windows of Kit. #1 &

Mech. Rm.

50 LF NO

Clear, vertical seams between column

& wall

50 LF NO7

Lodge 11

Lodge 12

Lodge 25

Lodge 27

Lodge 14

Lodge 16

Lodge 18

Lodge 20

Lodge 22

Lodge 24

Lodge

Lodge

Lodge

Lodge

None

Caulk White, around window sashes 20 LF None

Floor Underlayment

Lodge

Living Quarters

Lodge

None

Lodge 1 Caulk Brown, corner of chimney & wall 40 LF

TABLE 2 ‐ PG. 1 OF 2

SUMMARY OF ASBESTOS ANALYTICAL RESULTS

W7969 PARK RD.

WESTBORO, WI 54490

NO None

500 SF NO6

Lodge 2 Door Stop Cushion Grey, on inside of chimney door 5 LF NO

Lodge

Lodge

NO None

Caulk Dark Brown, outside of Open Space &

Mech. Rm.

200 LF

None

Lodge 3 Grout Grey, on floor near chimney 12 SF

Grout Light Grey, 2nd Layer outside of chimney 100 SF NO None

None

NO None

Grout Grey, on outside of chimney between bricks

100 SF NO

Black

None

Caulk White/Grey, around window sashes

(original) 200 LF NO None

Caulk Tan, in crawl space along block border 80 LF NO None

Chimney Penetration Tar on

Roof Black, Bituminous ~12 LF NO 1.25% CHRYSOTILE

Caulk Tan, outside of Restroom & shower windows and outside wall trim

200 LF

NOTE: Material containing less than 1 percent asbestos is not classified as ABM Asbestos Containing Material.

Living Quarters 38 Wall Plaster White 2500 SF NO None

Living Quarters 39 Wall Plaster White, on chimney 100 SF NO None

NO None

Living Quarters 37 Ceiling Tile & Drywall White 150 SF NO None

Garage 43 Caulk White, on window sashes 80 LF NO None

Living Quarters 32 Caulk White, around tub/shower 25 LF NO None

Living Quarters 33 Drywall White 2000 SF NO None

Living Quarters 34 Ceiling Tile & Plaster

Living Quarters 41 Roofing Shingles Tan 800 SF NO None

Living Quarters 42 Roofing Underlayment Black 800 SF NO None

WESTBORO, WI 54490

Living Quarters 40 Grout Trowled surface, grey, over rigid insulation near ground 100 SF NO None

12"x12" Ceiling Tile 100 SF NO None

Living Quarters 35 Caulk White, @ electrical conduit penetration in kit. Ceiling 1 LF NO None

Living Quarters 36 Wall Plaster White 2500 SF

TABLE 2 ‐ PG. 2 OF 2

SUMMARY OF ASBESTOS ANALYTICAL RESULTS

None

Roofing Underlayment

Floor Tile 12"x12", under carpeting 100 SF NO

Caulk Chimney Penetration Tar, Black 12 LF NO

Roofing Shingles Tan 800 SF45 NO

Garage

Garage

46 Black 800 SF NO None

W7969 PARK RD.

Living Quarters

Living Quarters None

None44

TABLE 3

SUMMARY OF LEAD‐CONTAINING PAINT ANALYTICAL RESULTS

LOCATION

SAMPLE

NUMBER

SAMPLE

DESCRIPTION COLOR

TOTAL

LEAD

(mg/kg)

LEAD

CONC

(% by wt)

LODGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐1 WINDOWS BROWN 1380 0.138

LODGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐2 WALLS TAN <29.6 <0.00296

LODGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐3 SOFFIT, FASCIA

& TRIM

BROWN 67.9 0.00679

GARAGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐4 WINDOWS BROWN 1010 0.101

LIVING QTRS –

INTERIOR

L‐5 BASEBOARD &

TRIM

WHITE/PEACH 416 0.0416

LIVING QTRS –

INTERIOR

L‐6 WALLS BEIGE 220 0.022

NOTE: BOLD INDICATES LEAD CONCENTRATION ABOVE ACTION LIMIT

TABLE 4

SUMMARY OF CADMIUM‐CONTAINING PAINT ANALYTICAL RESULTS

LOCATION

SAMPLE

NUMBER

SAMPLE

DESCRIPTION COLOR

TOTAL

CADMIUM

(mg/kg)

CADMIUM

CONC

(% by wt)

LODGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐1 WINDOWS BROWN <5.87 <0.000587

LODGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐2 WALLS TAN <5.92 <0.000592

LODGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐3 SOFFIT, FASCIA

& TRIM

BROWN <6.58 <0.000658

GARAGE –

EXTERIOR

L‐4 WINDOWS BROWN <6.14 <0.000614

LIVING QTRS –

INTERIOR

L‐5 BASEBOARD &

TRIM

WHITE/PEACH <5.94 <0.000594

LIVING QTRS –

INTERIOR

L‐6 WALLS BEIGE <6.12 <0.000612

NOTE: BOLD INDICATES CADMIUM CONCENTRATION ABOVE ACTION LIMIT

APPENDIX A

INSPECTOR ACCREDIATION

APPENDIX B

BUILDING FLOOR PLANS

& SAMPLE LOCATIONS

APPENDIX C

ANALYTICAL RESULTS ‐ ASBESTOS

APPENDIX E

ANALYTICAL RESULTS – LEAD & CADMIUM

CONTAINING PAINT

APPENDIX F

MOLD TESTING – LIVING QUARTERS

BUILDING

100 Portage Street Houghton, MI 49931

906-482-4810 • 800-562-7684 • Fax: 906-482-9799

Offices also in:

Iron Mountain

Ishpeming Marinette

Sault Ste Marie

U.P. Engineers & Architects, Inc. www.UPEA.com

[U28-17435] July 26, 2017

Ms. Debra K. Brinn, Contract Specialist USDA Forest Service Huron Shores Ranger Station 5761 N. Skeel Oscoda, MI 48750-1595

RE: LIMITED MOLD SAMPLING IN LIVING QUARTERS BUILDING AT THE MONDEAUX

RECREATION SITE

Dear Debra K. Brinn, A mold sample was taken from the Living Quarters Building on the kitchen ceiling near the chimney on July 11th, 2017. The inside of the building had a strong moldy odor before it was aired out by keeping the doors open for about 15 minutes. The sample was taken from a dark brown stain (~1 SF) in the white ceiling tile.

The results show that a “low” amount of Ascospores is present in the brown ceiling tile.

Ascospores fungal is a common fungal that is commonly found in interior damp locations and even outdoors. Ascospores may cause allergic reactions to certain individuals, so care should be taken when working around and removing the stained/moldy ceiling tile. Also, the cause of the mold, which is most likely water penetrating the chimney flashing on the roof should be addressed immediately to stop any further damage.

If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at (906) 482-4810 or erbjorn@upea.com. We appreciate the opportunity to be of service.

Sincerely, U.P. ENGINEERS & ARCHITECTS, INC.

Emmett Bjorn Engineer

Cc: TSPurdy/UPEA