1-RFP Golf Course Draft Clean.pdf
PDF 510 KB Posted
- Solicitation number
- US.254140
- Issued by
- Mount Aetna CDP, Pennsylvania
About this file
This is a Request for Proposals (RFP) issued by Middletown Township, Bucks County, Pennsylvania, for a comprehensive Middletown Country Club Feasibility Study and Long-Term Operating Plan. The Township seeks qualified consulting services to evaluate the municipally owned Country Club, which comprises a golf course, clubhouse, dining facilities, banquet and event spaces, golf shop, and former swimming pool located at 420 North Bellevue Avenue, Langhorne, Pennsylvania. The RFP was issued September 15, 2026, with a deadline for written questions on October 1, 2026. An optional pre-proposal meeting and site visit is scheduled for October 15, 2026, at 10:00 AM. Proposals are due October 23, 2026, at 12:00 PM via PennBid, with Township responses and addenda issued by October 30, 2026, at 12:00 PM. Consultant interviews are anticipated October 26–30, 2026, with selection of the preferred consultant by November 9, 2026, and notice to proceed by November 10, 2026. The anticipated project completion date is October 12, 2027, spanning approximately thirteen months. Proposals should be submitted to Monica Tierney, Interim Director of Parks and Recreation, at mtierney@middletownbucks.org.
The cost proposal should include a lump sum fee, hourly billing rates, estimated hours by task and staff member, reimbursable expenses, optional services, and a total not-to-exceed fee. The Township reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, negotiate scope and terms with the highest-ranked proposer, and select based on the evaluation criteria weighted as follows: Firm Qualifications and Experience (20 points), Municipal Golf and Recreation Experience (20 points), Project Understanding and Technical Approach (20 points), Project Team Qualifications (15 points), Community Engagement Strategy (10 points), Similar Project Experience and References (10 points), and Cost Proposal (5 points). The current management agreement with Agro Golf expires at the end of 2028. The consultant must obtain commercial general liability insurance ($1,000,000 per occurrence, $2,000,000 aggregate), professional liability insurance ($2,000,000 per claim, $2,000,000 aggregate), automobile liability insurance ($1,000,000 combined single limit), workers' compensation insurance per Pennsylvania requirements, and employer's liability insurance ($500,000 per accident). The Township requires disclosure of all conflicts of interest, current or prior relationships with Middletown Township or Country Club, and compliance with Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law provisions. Proposals remain valid for ninety days following the submission deadline, and no proposal preparation costs will be reimbursed by the Township.
View the file
Other files
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
MIDDLETOWN TOWNSHIP
BUCKS COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
MIDDLETOWN COUNTRY CLUB
FEASIBILITY STUDY AND LONG-TERM OPERATING PLAN
420 N. Bellevue Avenue • Langhorne, Pennsylvania 19047
ANTICIPATED RFP & PROJECT TIMELINE
MILESTONE ANTICIPATED DATE
RFP Issued September 15, 2026
Deadline for Written Questions October 1, 2026
Township Responses / Addendum October 30, 2026, 12;00 PM
Optional Pre-Proposal Meeting / Site Visit October 15, 2026, 10:00 AM
Proposals Due October 23, 12:00 PM
Proposal Evaluation / Interviews October 26-30, 2026
Selection of Preferred Consultant November 9, 2026
Notice to Proceed / Project Kick-Off November 10, 2026
Anticipated Start January 5, 2027
Draft Feasibility Study August 4, 2027
Township Review / Final Community Input August 10, 2027
Final Feasibility Study September 1, 2027
Final Presentations – Boards September 2027
Anticipated Project Completion October 12, 2027
TOWNSHIP CONTACT PROPOSAL SUBMISSION
Name / Title: Monica Tierney, Interim Director of parks and recreation
Email: mtierney@middletownbucks.org
Submission Location / Method:
PennBid
TOWNSHIP VISION AND PROJECT OBJECTIVES
Township Vision
Middletown Township envisions Middletown Country Club as a vibrant, financially sustainable, and well-maintained community asset that builds upon the property's more than 100-year history while meeting the recreational, social, and economic needs of the community for generations to come.
The Township recognizes that Middletown Country Club is more than a golf course. The property includes a historic golf course, clubhouse, dining facilities, banquet and event spaces, and other recreational and community amenities that collectively create a destination that serves golfers and non-golfers alike.
The Township's vision is for Middletown Country Club to be a community hub, a place where residents and visitors can play golf, participate in youth and recreational programs, attend community events, gather for meals and social activities, and utilize the facility for weddings, banquets, celebrations, and other functions.
At the same time, the Township recognizes its responsibility as the owner of the property to ensure that the Country Club is operated in a financially responsible manner. The long-term goal is for the facility to generate sufficient revenue to support its ongoing operations, maintenance, and capital improvement needs while reducing reliance on
Township resources and, where financially feasible, providing a positive financial return to the Township.
The Township is not seeking to predetermine how this vision should be achieved. Rather, the purpose of this study is to determine the operating structure, investments, programming, and business strategies necessary to achieve these goals and to identify whether those objectives are best accomplished through private management, direct
Township operation, or another appropriate operating model.
The Township seeks a long-term strategy that balances financial sustainability, community benefit, responsible stewardship, quality recreation, and preservation of the property's historic character.
Project Objectives
The purpose of the Middletown Country Club Feasibility Study is to provide the Township with the information and analysis necessary to make informed decisions regarding the future operation and investment in the property.
The selected consultant shall evaluate the Country Club with consideration of the following objectives:
1. Determine the Most Appropriate Operating Model
Evaluate the advantages, disadvantages, risks, costs, and opportunities associated with the principal operating alternatives available to the Township, including:
• Continued operation through a private management company;
• Direct operation by Middletown Township; and
• Other appropriate public-private operating or management models.
The analysis shall identify which model provides the strongest opportunity to achieve the Township's financial, operational, recreational, and community objectives.
2. Establish Long-Term Financial Sustainability
Determine how Middletown Country Club can operate as a financially sustainable enterprise capable of supporting its ongoing operations and maintenance.
The consultant shall identify:
• Current financial performance;
• Revenue opportunities;
• Cost-control opportunities;
• Operational efficiencies;
• Appropriate pricing and revenue strategies;
• Potential new or expanded revenue sources; and
• Long-term financial projections.
The study should identify a realistic path toward reducing or eliminating the need for Township financial support of ongoing operations.
3. Support Capital Improvements and Asset Stewardship
Develop a comprehensive understanding of the Country Club's current and future capital needs.
The consultant shall identify the investments necessary to preserve, maintain, and improve the property and shall establish priorities and anticipated costs for those investments.
The study should identify how capital improvements can be funded under each potential operating model and how the Township can ensure that necessary capital investment occurs consistently over time.
4. Maximize the Use of Existing Facilities
Evaluate whether the Country Club's existing buildings, facilities, and amenities are being used to their full potential.
Attention shall be given to:
• Banquet and event facilities;
• Restaurant and food and beverage operations;
• Golf shop;
• Clubhouse;
• Community gathering spaces;
• Junior and youth programming; and
• Other opportunities to increase utilization of the property.
The consultant shall identify opportunities to increase both community use and financial performance.
5. Evaluate the Former Swimming Pool
Assess the condition, potential costs, and future options for the former swimming pool, which has been closed and unused for several years.
The consultant shall evaluate whether the pool should be:
• Rehabilitated;
• Repurposed;
• Removed;
• Replaced with another recreational or community amenity; or
• Otherwise addressed as part of the property's long-term plan.
Any recommendation shall consider cost, liability, community benefit, operational requirements, revenue potential, and applicable restrictions on the property.
6. Strengthen the Country Club as a Community Hub
Review historic uses and identify opportunities for Middletown Country Club to serve a broader segment of the community, including golfers and non-golfers.
Potential opportunities may include:
• Youth and junior golf;
• Community programming;
• Senior programming;
• Recreation and wellness activities;
• Community events;
• Dining and social opportunities;
• Weddings and private events;
• Educational programming;
• Partnerships with local schools and organizations; and
• Other activities that are compatible with the property's recreational purpose.
The consultant shall consider how expanded community use can complement, rather than detract from, the financial performance of the facility.
7. Preserve and Build Upon the Property's Historic Character
Recognize and incorporate the historic significance of Middletown Country Club and its golf course into the long-term strategy.
The consultant shall consider opportunities to preserve the character and legacy of the property while making appropriate improvements necessary to ensure its continued viability and competitiveness.
8. Improve Golf Course Performance and Participation
Evaluate the golf course operation and identify opportunities to improve participation, customer experience, utilization, and financial performance.
The analysis should be considered as appropriate:
• Green fees;
• Membership opportunities;
• Tee-time utilization;
• Outings and tournaments;
• Junior golf;
• Instruction;
• League play;
• Marketing;
• Course improvements;
• Customer experience; and
• Opportunities to attract new and returning golfers.
9. Evaluate Food, Beverage, Banquet, and Event Operations
Determine whether the Country Club's food, beverage, banquet, and event operations are being effectively utilized and whether these operations can become stronger contributors to the overall financial performance of the facility.
The consultant shall evaluate opportunities to improve:
• Revenue;
• Utilization;
• Customer experience;
• Marketing;
• Event programming;
• Staffing;
• Food and beverage operations; and
• Facility investment.
10. Establish a Sustainable Capital Funding Strategy
The Township seeks to avoid a cycle in which necessary capital improvements are deferred until they become significant financial burdens.
• The consultant shall develop a long-term capital funding strategy that considers:
• Annual capital reserves;
• Operating revenues;
• Management agreements;
• Township contributions, if necessary;
• Financing;
• Grants or other outside funding opportunities;
• Capital requirements assigned to a future operator; and
• Other appropriate funding mechanisms.
The strategy should provide the Township with a realistic understanding of the annual financial resources that must be dedicated to maintaining the property over time.
11. Protect the Township's Long-Term Interests
Evaluate each operating model from the perspective of the Township as property owner.
The consultant shall identify:
• Financial risks;
• Operational risks;
• Capital risks;
• Contractual risks;
• Liability considerations;
• Staffing considerations;
• Utility needs assessment;
• Market risks; and
• Other factors that could affect the Township's long-term interests.
The study should identify appropriate safeguards, performance measures, and accountability mechanisms for any recommended operating structure.
12. Incorporate Community Input
Engage residents, golfers, Country Club users, abutting property owners, community organizations, businesses, and other stakeholders in the study process.
The consultant shall use community input to better understand:
• Current perceptions of the Country Club;
• Community priorities;
• Desired recreational and community uses;
• Areas for improvement;
• Potential new programs or amenities; and
• Expectations for the property's future.
• Community input shall inform, but not replace, the consultant's professional, financial, and operational analysis.
13. Develop Measurable Performance Standards
The consultant shall recommend measurable performance standards that the
Township can use to evaluate the success of the Country Club under the recommended operating model.
Potential measures may include:
• Revenue;
• Operating margin;
• Capital investment;
• Golf rounds;
• Facility utilization;
• Banquet and event bookings;
• Customer satisfaction;
• Community programming;
• Junior and youth participation;
• Maintenance standards; and
• Financial contribution to the Township.
The consultant should recommend an appropriate framework for ongoing reporting and accountability.
14. Provide a Practical Path Forward
The final study shall provide the Township with more than an assessment of existing conditions. It should provide a practical roadmap for implementation.
The consultant shall identify:
• The recommended operating model;
• Immediate actions;
• Short-term priorities;
• Long-term priorities;
• Required investments;
• Financial requirements;
• Potential procurement steps;
• Contractual considerations;
• Staffing requirements;
• Community engagement considerations; and
• Recommended performance measures.
The Township's objective is to conclude the study with a clear understanding of where Middletown Country Club is today, where it should be in the future, what it will take to get there, and how the Township can measure whether it is successful.
Guiding Principles
In developing its recommendations, the consultant shall consider the following guiding principles:
Community Benefit – The Country Club should provide meaningful recreational, social, and community benefits to Middletown Township and the surrounding region.
Financial Responsibility – The facility should operate in a manner that supports its ongoing expenses and works toward funding its own capital needs.
Long-Term Stewardship – The Township should protect and responsibly maintain the property for future generations.
Quality and Customer Experience – Golfers, residents, guests, event customers, and other users should have access to a high-quality facility and positive experience.
Accessibility and Inclusion – Opportunities should be considered to make the facility welcoming and useful to a broad range of residents and users.
Historic Preservation – The property's unique history and character should be recognized and incorporated into its future.
Accountability – Any future operating structure should establish clear expectations, measurable performance standards, financial transparency, and appropriate Township oversight.
Sustainability – The recommended strategy should be financially and operationally sustainable over the long term rather than focused solely on short-term financial results.
Objective Analysis – Recommendations should be based on reliable data, sound financial analysis, market conditions, community input, and professional judgment rather than a predetermined operating outcome.
SECTION 1. BACKGROUND
The Township of Middletown, Bucks County, Pennsylvania, is soliciting proposals from qualified consulting firms to perform a comprehensive operational, financial, and strategic feasibility study for the municipally owned Middletown Country Club located at
420 North Bellevue Avenue, Langhorne, Pennsylvania.
Middletown Country Club has been an important recreational asset in Bucks County for over one hundred years. Originally established in 1901 and relocated to its current site in 1913, the golf course was designed by noted Scottish golf architect Alexander Findlay.
Throughout its history, the course has hosted numerous professional golfers, including
World Golf Hall of Fame members Ben Hogan, Gary Player, Johnny Miller, Henry Picard, Leo Diegel, Vic Ghezzi, and George Fazio. Today, the course remains one of Bucks
County's most recognizable public golf facilities while continuing to preserve its historic character.
Since 1987, Middletown Township has owned the property and has contracted with a private management company for the operation of the golf course, clubhouse, restaurant, banquet facilities, golf shop, and related amenities. The current management agreement is approaching expiration, providing the Township with the opportunity to evaluate the long-term future of the facility.
The Township seeks an independent, objective assessment of the Country Club's current operations and future potential. Specifically, the Township desires a comprehensive evaluation of whether continued third-party management, a new management operator, or direct municipal operation would provide the greatest long-term benefit to Township residents and taxpayers.
The Township's vision is for Middletown Country Club to be a premier community recreation asset that is financially sustainable, adequately funded for future capital improvements, responsive to community needs, and capable of generating positive financial returns that support both the facility and the Township.
The study shall recognize that the property is municipally owned parkland and that existing deed restrictions and applicable Pennsylvania law require the property to continue to be utilized for recreational purposes, specifically as a golf course.
Accordingly, the purpose of this study is not to evaluate alternative land uses, but rather to identify the most effective ownership, operational, management, programming, and investment strategies to maximize the public benefit and financial performance of the facility while preserving its historic and recreational purpose.
SECTION 2. REQUIREMENTS
General Requirements
The Township of Middletown seeks proposals from qualified consulting firms with demonstrated experience in municipal golf course operations, golf facility management, financial analysis, strategic planning, public recreation, and capital asset planning.
The selected consultant shall conduct an independent and objective evaluation of
Middletown Country Club and provide recommendations that will assist the Township in determining the most effective long-term operational, financial, and management strategy for the facility.
The Township reserves the right to reject any or all proposals and to select the proposal that it determines to be in the best interest of the Township.
The consultant is encouraged to add to, modify, or clarify any portion of the Scope of
Work that, in its professional opinion, will enhance the quality and usefulness of the final study. Any proposed modifications shall be clearly identified and explained in the proposal. At a minimum, however, the consultant's proposal shall address each of the work elements identified below.
Scope of Work
The consultant shall complete a comprehensive study addressing the following components.
1. Existing Conditions Assessment
The consultant shall perform a comprehensive review of the current operation and condition of Middletown Country Club, including, but not limited to:
• Golf course operations
• Golf course maintenance practices
• Clubhouse operations
• Food and beverage services
• Banquet and catering operations
• Golf shop operations
• Staffing and organizational structure
• Membership programs
• Public play operations
• Marketing and branding
• Technology systems
• Customer service practices
• Existing contracts and operational procedures
The consultant shall identify operational strengths, deficiencies, opportunities, and risks.
2. Financial Analysis
The consultant shall perform a comprehensive financial review of the Country Club utilizing available historical operating and financial information.
The analysis shall include, at a minimum:
• Operating revenues and expenditure
• Historical financial performance
• Revenue sources and trends
• Labor costs
• Maintenance costs
• Capital expenditures
• Equipment replacement costs
• Golf operations
• Food and beverage operations
• Banquet operations
• Membership revenues
• Tournament revenues
• Cash flow analysis
• Benchmark comparisons with similar municipal golf facilities
The consultant shall identify operational efficiencies, opportunities for increased revenue, cost savings, and long-term financial sustainability.
3. Operational Alternatives Analysis
A primary objective of this study is to determine the most appropriate long-term operational model for Middletown Country Club.
The consultant shall evaluate and compare multiple operating scenarios, including:
• Continued operation through a private management company selected through a competitive procurement process.
• Direct operation by Middletown Township.
• Alternative public-private partnership models or other innovative operational structures.
For each operational alternative, the consultant shall evaluate:
• Organizational structure
• Staffing requirements
• Financial implications
• Operational risks
• Required Township oversight
• Advantages and disadvantages
• Transition requirements
• Estimated implementation costs
• Long-term financial performance
The consultant shall provide a recommendation supported by objective analysis and financial projections.
4. Capital Asset and Facility Assessment
The consultant shall assess the condition, functionality, and remaining useful life of all significant physical assets associated with Middletown Country Club.
The assessment shall include, but not be limited to:
• Golf course infrastructure
• Greens, tees, fairways, and bunkers
• Irrigation system
• Drainage system
• Cart paths
• Practice facilities
• Maintenance buildings
• Maintenance equipment fleet
• Clubhouse
• Restaurant and kitchen facilities
• Ballroom, Manor Room, and Windsor Room
• Golf shop
• Parking areas
• Utilities
• Mechanical systems
• Building envelope
• Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) accessibility considerations
The consultant shall prepare a prioritized capital improvement plan identifying immediate, short-term (1-5 years), medium-term (5-10 years), and long-term capital investment needs together with estimated construction costs and recommended funding priorities.
5. Banquet and Event Facilities Assessment
The consultant shall evaluate the existing banquet, catering, restaurant, and event facilities to determine their current utilization, financial performance, market competitiveness, and future opportunities.
The analysis shall include recommendations regarding:
• Weddings
• Corporate events
• Community events
• Private parties
• Funeral luncheons
• Catering services
• Restaurant operations
• Facility improvements
• Revenue enhancement opportunities
The consultant shall specifically evaluate the feasibility of continued, expanded, renovated, or otherwise improved use of the existing banquet and event facilities as supporting amenities of the overall Country Club and recreational complex.
6. Former Pool Facility Assessment
The consultant shall evaluate the existing swimming pool facility, which has been closed for several years, and determine its current condition and future potential.
The evaluation shall include:
• Existing structural condition
• Estimated renovation costs
• Estimated demolition costs
• Alternative recreational uses consistent with the property's deed restrictions
• Potential operational models
• Financial feasibility
• Community demand
• Return on investment
The consultant shall evaluate the feasibility of reopening and operating the existing pool as a recreational amenity associated with the Country Club, including the anticipated capital, operating, staffing, maintenance, insurance, and liability implications. Any alternative use of the pool facility shall be evaluated for consistency with applicable deed restrictions and other legal requirements.
7. Community Needs Assessment
The consultant shall evaluate how Middletown Country Club can better serve
Township residents while maintaining financial sustainability.
The consultant shall solicit public input through stakeholder interviews, surveys, or public meetings and evaluate opportunities to expand community programming, including:
• Junior golf
• Youth instruction
• High school and collegiate partnerships
• Senior programming
• Community events
• Recreational programming
• Walking and wellness opportunities
• Family activities
• Food and beverage programming
Recommendations shall balance community benefit with long-term financial performance.
8. Market and Comparative Analysis
The consultant shall compare Middletown Country Club with comparable municipally owned golf facilities operated under both municipal and private management models.
The analysis shall include:
• Comparable facilities
• Fee structures
• Membership programs
• Revenue generation
• Operational efficiencies
• Capital investment strategies
• Best management practices
Successful municipal golf operations from Pennsylvania and surrounding states should be considered where appropriate.
9. Legal and Governance Considerations
The consultant shall review all available information regarding legal and operational constraints affecting the facility, including existing management agreements, applicable deed restrictions, grant obligations, and public ownership considerations.
The consultant shall acknowledge that Middletown Country Club is municipally owned parkland and that any recommendations shall be consistent with applicable legal restrictions governing the continued recreational use of the property.
The property is subject to restrictions governing dedicated public parkland and its continued recreational use as a golf course. The feasibility study shall therefore focus on management, operational, financial, capital, and recreational strategies that maintain the property's established public park and golf course use. The study shall not assume or recommend conversion of the property to unrelated public use or disposition of the property unless specifically identified as requiring additional legal review and approval.
The consultant may evaluate the continued use, renovation, rehabilitation, and operation of existing supporting amenities, including the banquet facilities and former swimming pool, provided such recommendations are consistent with applicable deed restrictions and do not materially alter or eliminate the established golf course use. The consultant shall identify any recommendations that may require additional legal review, approvals, or other governmental action.
Liability and Risk Analysis
The consultant shall conduct an assessment of significant liability and risk considerations associated with the continued operation and potential future operation of Middletown Country Club. The analysis shall consider, at a minimum:
• General premises and public-use liability
• Golf course-related risks, including play, spectators, golf carts, and course conditions
• Swimming pool and aquatic facility liability, if reopening is considered
• Banquet, catering, restaurant, and special event liability
• Alcohol-related operational risks, where applicable
• Employee and workplace safety considerations
• Maintenance and facility-related risks
• ADA accessibility and related exposure
• Insurance requirements and coverage considerations
• Indemnification and insurance provisions in management, vendor, and operating agreements
• Risk allocation between the Township and any private management company or operating partner
• Potential changes in liability exposure under each operating model evaluated.
• Recommended risk management practices, contractual protections, insurance requirements, and operational controls
The consultant shall identify material liability risks associated with each operational alternative and provide recommendations for mitigating those risks. The analysis should distinguish between risks that may be addressed through operational practices, insurance, contractual provisions, facility improvements, or other measures. Where legal interpretation is required, the consultant shall identify the issue for review by Township counsel rather than providing a legal opinion.
10. Final Report and Presentation
Upon completion of the study, the consultant shall prepare a comprehensive written report that includes:
• Executive Summary
• Existing Conditions Assessment
• Financial Analysis
• Market Analysis
• Operational Alternatives Evaluation
• Capital Improvement Plan
• Utilities needs assessment
• Community Needs Assessment
• Legal governance and Liability considerations
• Implementation Strategy
• Recommended Operational Model
• Ten-Year Financial Pro Forma
• Capital Investment Schedule
The consultant shall present the draft findings to Township staff for review and subsequently present the final report and recommendations to the Middletown
Township Board of Supervisors at a public meeting.
The Township intends to utilize this study as the primary planning document for determining the future management, operation, and investment strategy for
Middletown Country Club following the expiration of the current management agreement. The recommendations should therefore provide a practical, data-driven roadmap that enables the Township to preserve the historic legacy of Middletown
Country Club while ensuring it remains a vibrant, financially sustainable community asset for generations to come.
SECTION 3. COMMUNITY AND STAKEHOLDER ENGAGEMENT
Public participation is an essential component of this study. The selected consultant shall develop and implement a community engagement program designed to gather meaningful input from residents, golf patrons, community organizations, Township advisory boards, and elected officials. The engagement process shall ensure that recommendations reflect both sound business practices and the recreational needs and priorities of the Middletown Township community.
The consultant shall prepare a Community Engagement Plan for Township review at the outset of the project. The plan shall identify the methods of public outreach, proposed meeting schedule, stakeholder groups, and opportunities for public participation throughout the study.
At a minimum, the public engagement program shall include the following:
Stakeholder Interviews
The consultant shall conduct interviews with key stakeholders to obtain insight into the current operation of the facility and opportunities for future improvement. Stakeholders should include, at a minimum:
• Township Manager and appropriate Township staff
• Representatives of the current management company
• Parks and Recreation Board representatives
• Board of Supervisors representatives
• Golf course staff
• Golf professionals
• Regular golfers and members
• Restaurant and banquet users
• Local business representatives
• Youth golf organizations
• Neighbors
• High school or collegiate golf representatives, where applicable
• Other stakeholders identified by the Township
The consultant should conduct approximately fifteen (15) to twenty-five (25) stakeholder interviews.
Public Survey
The consultant shall develop an online public survey, with Township review and approval, to solicit input from residents, golfers, facility users, and other interested parties.
The survey should gather information regarding:
• Current use of Middletown Country Club
• Overall satisfaction with the facility
• Desired amenities and improvements
• Community programming opportunities
• Food and beverage services
• Banquet and event facilities
• Future recreational opportunities
• Opinions regarding operational priorities
The consultant shall summarize survey results and incorporate the findings into the final report.
Public Open House No. 1 – Visioning Session
Following completion of the initial data collection and existing conditions assessment, the consultant shall conduct one public open house to introduce the study, present existing conditions, and obtain public input regarding community priorities, opportunities, and concerns.
The meeting should include opportunities for attendees to provide written and verbal comments, participate in interactive exercises, and ask questions.
Parks and Recreation Board Workshop
Following completion of the existing conditions assessment and preliminary analysis, the consultant shall present findings and receive input from the Middletown Township Parks and Recreation Board at a publicly advertised meeting.
The presentation should include:
• Existing conditions
• Preliminary financial observations
• Operational strengths and weaknesses
• Community input received to date
• Potential operational alternatives
Comments from the Parks and Recreation Board shall be incorporated into the development of the draft recommendations.
Public Open House No. 2 – Draft Recommendations
Upon completion of the draft study, the consultant shall conduct a second public meeting to present preliminary recommendations and receive additional public comment prior to finalizing the report.
The meeting shall summarize:
• Financial findings
• Capital improvement priorities
• Operational alternatives
• Recommended management model
• Implementation strategy
The consultant shall provide an opportunity for public comment and prepare a summary of comments received.
Board of Supervisors Work Session
Prior to completion of the final report, the consultant shall conduct a work session with the
Board of Supervisors to review the draft recommendations, answer questions, and receive policy direction.
The purpose of this meeting shall be to ensure that the draft report addresses Township priorities before preparation of the final document.
Final Presentation
Upon completion of the study, the consultant shall present the final report and recommendations at a public meeting of the Board of Supervisors.
The presentation shall summarize:
• Existing conditions
• Financial analysis
• Market assessment
• Capital improvement recommendations
• Community engagement results
• Operational alternatives
• Recommended management model
• Ten-year implementation strategy
Electronic copies of all presentation materials, meeting summaries, public comments, survey results, and supporting documentation shall be provided to the Township as part of the final deliverables.
Community Engagement Deliverables
At the completion of the engagement process, the consultant shall provide:
• Community Engagement Plan
• Stakeholder Interview Summary
• Public Survey Results and Analysis
• Meeting Agendas and Presentation Materials
• Public Meeting Summaries
• Summary of Public Comments
• Responses to Major Themes Identified During Public Engagement
• Documentation describing how public input informed the consultant's recommendations
SECTION 4. ORGANIZATION AND REQUIRED PROPOSAL
SUBMITTALS
To facilitate a comprehensive and uniform evaluation of proposals, all firms responding to this Request for Proposals shall organize their submissions in the following format.
Letter of Transmittal
The proposal shall include a Letter of Transmittal signed by an individual authorized to bind the firm contractually. The letter shall include:
• A statement indicating the firm's understanding of the project and the services requested.
• A statement affirming the firm's ability and commitment to perform the required services.
• The name, title, address, telephone number, and email address of the firm's primary contact for the proposal.
• A statement identifying any actual or potential conflicts of interest.
• A disclosure of any current or previous contractual relationships with
Middletown Township or Middletown Country Club.
• A statement that the proposal shall remain valid for a period of ninety (90) days following the submission deadline.
Firm Qualifications and Experience
Provide a description of the firm, including:
• History of the firm.
• Office location(s).
• Areas of professional expertise.
• Experience with municipal golf courses.
• Experience with golf course operations and management.
• Experience evaluating municipal versus private operational models.
• Experience preparing financial feasibility studies and business plans.
• Experience conducting capital improvement planning.
• Experience facilitating public engagement processes.
• Any specialized qualifications relevant to this project.
Project Team
Identify the individuals who will be assigned to this project and provide:
• Organizational chart.
• Project Manager.
• Key personnel and their responsibilities.
• Relevant experience of each team member.
• Resumes of all principal staff.
• Any proposed subconsultants and their areas of responsibility.
The Township expects the individuals identified in the proposal to remain assigned to the project unless otherwise approved by the Township.
Project Understanding and Technical Approach
Describe the firm's understanding of the project and present a detailed work plan explaining how the study will be completed.
The proposal should include:
• Overall project approach.
• Methodology.
• Data collection methods.
• Financial analysis approach.
• Operational evaluation methodology.
• Capital asset assessment methodology.
• Public engagement strategy.
• Benchmarking approach.
• Risk assessment methodology.
• Deliverables.
• Quality assurance and quality control procedures.
The consultant is encouraged to identify any additional work elements that would enhance the value of the study.
Project Schedule
Provide a proposed project schedule identifying all major milestones, including:
• Project kickoff meeting.
• Existing conditions assessment.
• Stakeholder interviews.
• Public survey.
• Public Open House No. 1.
• Parks and Recreation Board presentation.
• Draft report.
• Public Open House No. 2.
• Board of Supervisors work session.
• Final report.
• Final presentation to the Board of Supervisors.
Similar Project Experience
Provide descriptions of at least five (5) projects completed within the past ten (10) years that are similar in scope.
Preference will be given to firms with demonstrated experience involving:
• Municipally owned golf courses.
• Public golf facilities.
• Country club operational studies.
• Municipal recreation facilities.
• Financial feasibility studies.
• Public-private partnership evaluations.
For each project provide:
• Client name.
• Project location.
• Project description.
• Date completed.
• Total project cost.
• Name and contact information for the client representative.
References
Provide a minimum of five (5) client references, with preference of three (3) municipal clients for whom comparable work has been completed.
References shall include:
• Organization.
• Contact person.
• Title.
• Telephone number.
• Email address.
• Brief description of services provided.
Cost Proposal
Provide a detailed cost proposal including:
• Lump sum fee.
• Hourly billing rates.
• Estimated hours by task.
• Estimated hours by staff member.
• Reimbursable expenses.
• Optional services, if any.
• Total not-to-exceed fee.
Costs shall be organized by each major task identified in the Scope of Work.
Proposed Deliverables
Describe all reports, presentations, graphics, financial models, and supporting materials that will be provided.
Indicate the number of printed copies, electronic copies, GIS files (if applicable), spreadsheets, and presentation materials that will be included.
Required Certifications
The proposal shall include all required Township forms and certifications, including but not limited to:
• Non-Collusion Affidavit.
• Non-Discrimination Certification.
• Certificate of Insurance (upon award).
• W-9.
• Professional Licenses, where applicable.
• Any additional forms required by the Township.
Optional Value-Added Services
The Township encourages firms to identify additional services or innovative ideas that may improve the overall value of the study. Such recommendations may include additional analysis, visualization tools, public engagement techniques, implementation planning, grant funding strategies, or operational best practices that are not specifically identified in this Request for Proposals.
Consultant Perspective and Experience
In addition to the information requested elsewhere in this Request for Proposals, the
Township requests that each proposer provide narrative responses to the following questions. Responses should demonstrate the firm's understanding of the project, its experience with similar assignments, and its ability to provide practical, implementable recommendations.
1. Opportunities for Middletown Country Club
Based on the information provided in this Request for Proposals and the consultant’s professional experience, identify what you believe are the three (3) greatest opportunities for Middletown Country Club over the next ten (10) years.
The Township recognizes that proposers have not yet completed a comprehensive analysis of the facility. The intent of this question is to better understand the proposer’s initial observations, strategic thinking, creativity, and approach to municipal golf and recreational facility operations.
In addition to identifying the three greatest overall opportunities, proposers should provide brief initial observations regarding the following:
• Golf operations and customer experience
• Banquet, event, food and beverage, and other clubhouse opportunities
• Former swimming pool and recreational amenities
• Capital investment and facility improvements
• Community programming and public benefit
• Management and governance structure
• Liability, risk management, and operational risk
For each of the three (3) greatest opportunities identified, the proposer should briefly describe:
• Why the opportunity is significant
• The potential benefit to the Township and community
• Key considerations or challenges associated with pursuing the opportunity
• What additional information or analysis would be necessary to determine its feasibility
Proposers are not expected to perform detailed financial, engineering, market, legal, or operational analysis as part of their response. The Township is seeking high-level strategic observations based on the information available at the proposal stage.
2. Experience Evaluating Municipal Golf Operations
Describe your firm's experience evaluating municipally owned golf courses and determining whether facilities should be:
• Operated directly by a municipality;
• Managed by a third-party operator; or
• Operated through another public-private partnership model.
Provide examples of comparable projects, summarize the recommendations made, and describe the outcomes where available. The Township is particularly interested in understanding the factors your firm considers when recommending one operational model over another.
3. Experience Developing Implementation Strategies
Describe your experience preparing implementation plans that have been adopted by municipal governing bodies.
Include examples of projects where your recommendations resulted in measurable operational improvements, increased financial sustainability, enhanced public recreation opportunities, or successful capital investment planning.
Discuss how your firm develops practical, phased implementation strategies that recognize municipal budgeting, staffing, governance, and public engagement considerations.
4. Unique Qualifications
Describe any unique qualifications, innovative methodologies, specialized expertise, or value-added services that distinguish your firm from other consultants and would enhance the Township's ability to make informed decisions regarding the future of Middletown Country Club.
SECTION 5. EVALUATION CRITERIA
Proposals will be evaluated by the Township using the criteria outlined below. The
Township intends to select the proposal that, in its judgment, best demonstrates the qualifications, experience, technical expertise, and overall value necessary to successfully complete the requested services.
The Township reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, waive informalities or irregularities, request additional information from any proposer, conduct interviews, negotiate with one or more firms, and make an award that is determined to be in the best interest of the Township.
Evaluation Criteria
Proposals will be evaluated using the following criteria:
Evaluation Criteria Maximum
Points
Firm Qualifications and Experience 20
Experience with Municipal Golf Courses, Public Recreation Facilities, and Similar Projects
Project Understanding and Technical Approach 20
Qualifications and Experience of the Proposed Project Team 15
Community Engagement Strategy and Communication Approach 10
Quality of Similar Project Experience, References, and Sample Work
Product
Cost Proposal 5
Total 100
1. Firm Qualifications and Experience (20 Points)
The Township will evaluate the overall qualifications, stability, and experience of the consulting firm, including its demonstrated ability to complete projects of similar size and complexity for municipal clients.
Consideration will be given to:
• Experience providing professional consulting services to municipalities.
• Experience conducting operational and financial analyses.
• Experience preparing strategic plans and feasibility studies.
• Familiarity with municipal governance and public decision-making processes.
2. Municipal Golf and Recreation Experience (20 Points)
The Township places significant value on experience involving municipally owned golf courses and similar public recreational facilities.
Consideration will include:
• Experience evaluating municipal golf operations.
• Experience comparing municipal and third-party management models.
• Experience with golf course financial performance.
• Experience with clubhouse, food and beverage, banquet, and event operations.
• Experience preparing capital improvement and asset management plans.
3. Project Understanding and Technical Approach (20 Points)
The Township will evaluate the consultant's understanding of the project objectives and the proposed methodology for completing the Scope of Services.
Consideration will include:
• Thoroughness of the proposed work plan.
• Soundness of analytical methods.
• Understanding of operational and financial issues.
• Ability to develop practical and implementable recommendations.
• Overall quality and organization of the proposal.
4. Project Team (15 Points)
The Township will evaluate the qualifications and experience of the individuals assigned to the project.
Consideration will include:
• Experience of the Project Manager.
• Qualifications of key personnel.
• Relevant expertise of subconsultants.
• Availability of project staff.
• Experience working together on comparable assignments.
5. Community Engagement Strategy (10 Points)
The Township will evaluate the consultant's proposed approach to engaging residents, stakeholders, advisory boards, Township staff, and elected officials throughout the study process.
Consideration will include:
• Public engagement techniques.
• Stakeholder outreach.
• Communication methods.
• Facilitation experience.
• Ability to build consensus while obtaining meaningful public input.
6. Similar Project Experience, References, and Sample Work Product (10 Points)
The Township will evaluate the quality of comparable projects completed by the consultant, client references, and submitted sample work products.
Consideration will include:
• Relevance of comparable projects.
• Client satisfaction.
• Demonstrated implementation of recommendations.
• Quality, clarity, and usefulness of previous reports.
7. Cost Proposal (5 Points)
The Township will evaluate the proposed fee in relation to the scope of services, project approach, level of effort, qualifications of the proposed team, and overall value provided.
Selection will not be based solely upon the lowest proposed cost.
Interviews
Following review of the written proposals, the Township may invite one or more firms to participate in interviews or presentations.
Interviews may include discussions of:
• The consultant's understanding of the project.
• Technical approach.
• Project team.
• Community engagement strategy.
• Project schedule.
• Cost proposal.
• Responses to questions from the evaluation committee.
The Township reserves the right to select a consultant based solely upon the written proposals or, alternatively, to conduct interviews prior to making a final selection.
Award
The Township intends to award a contract to the consultant whose proposal is determined to be most advantageous to the Township, taking into consideration the evaluation criteria outlined herein.
SECTION 6. GENERAL CONDITIONS
Right to Reject Proposals
The Township reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, to waive any informalities or irregularities in the proposals received, to request additional information from any proposer, and to accept the proposal that, in the judgment of the Township, is in the best interest of the Township.
Right to Negotiate
The Township reserves the right to negotiate the scope of services, project schedule, compensation, and contract terms with the highest-ranked proposer. If negotiations are unsuccessful, the Township reserves the right to terminate negotiations and begin negotiations with another qualified proposer.
Proposal Validity
All proposals submitted in response to this Request for Proposals shall remain valid for a period of ninety (90) calendar days following the proposal submission deadline.
Requests for Clarification
The Township reserves the right to request clarification, supplemental information, or supporting documentation from any proposer during the evaluation process. Requests for clarification shall not permit material changes to the proposal.
Questions and Addenda
Questions concerning this Request for Proposals shall be submitted in writing to the
Township by the deadline established in the procurement schedule.
Responses to questions and any revisions to this Request for Proposals shall be issued by written addendum. All addenda shall become part of the Request for Proposals and shall be acknowledged by each proposer in its submission.
Ownership of Proposals
Upon submission, all proposals and supporting materials shall become the property of
Middletown Township and will not be returned.
Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law
Proposals submitted to the Township may be subject to public disclosure pursuant to the
Pennsylvania Right-to-Know Law (65 P.S. §§ 67.101 et seq.).
If a proposer believes portions of its proposal contain confidential proprietary or trade secret information exempt from disclosure, those portions shall be clearly identified and marked. The Township shall make any determination regarding disclosure in accordance with applicable law and does not guarantee that information identified by a proposer as confidential will be exempt from disclosure.
Reservation of Rights
The Township reserves the right to:
• Reject any or all proposals.
• Waive informalities or minor irregularities.
• Request additional information from any proposer.
• Conduct interviews or presentations.
• Investigate the qualifications of any proposer.
• Negotiate with one or more proposers.
• Award a contract in whole or in part.
• Amend or cancel this Request for Proposals.
• Reissue the Request for Proposals.
• Make an award that is determined to be in the best interest of the Township.
Contract Negotiations
The successful proposer shall enter into a Professional Services Agreement with
Middletown Township. The final agreement shall incorporate the requirements of this
Request for Proposals, the consultant's proposal, negotiated modifications, and any other terms deemed necessary by the Township and Township Solicitor.
The Township reserves the right to negotiate revisions to the scope of services, project schedule, compensation, staffing, and deliverables prior to execution of the agreement.
No Guarantee of Award
Issuance of this Request for Proposals does not obligate the Township to award a contract or to pay any costs incurred in preparing or submitting a proposal.
The Township reserves the right to cancel this solicitation at any time before execution of a contract if it is determined to be in the Township's best interest.
Proposal Preparation Costs
All costs associated with preparing and submitting a proposal, participating in interviews, responding to requests for clarification, or otherwise participating in the procurement process shall be borne solely by the proposer.
The Township shall not reimburse any proposer for such costs.
Compliance with Laws
The successful consultant shall comply with all applicable federal, Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania, and local…
This is the start of the file's text. The full file is on GovTribe.
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .