ATTM 024(b).xlsx

XLSX spreadsheet 24 KB Posted

Attached to
Pharmacy Benefit Services (PBS)
Solicitation number
5400029905
Issued by
Richland County, South Carolina

About this file

This document is a Service Provider Security Assessment Questionnaire (SPSAQ) Supplement issued by the South Carolina Department of Health and Human Services (SCDHHS) for proposals containing Artificial Intelligence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) components. The questionnaire establishes seven mandatory minimal requirements that all proposed solutions must meet. These requirements address AI/ML compliance, disclosure, decision-making processes, data protection, bias assessment, and data separation. The document provides detailed response options for each requirement, distinguishing between existing instances and new buildouts, and includes conditional approval pathways where appropriate. Additionally, the document defines key terminology including AI, Machine Learning, models, PII, and PHI to ensure consistent understanding among vendors completing the assessment.

The seven required compliance areas mandate that vendors demonstrate: NIST AI Risk Management Framework standards compliance; full disclosure of all AI/ML uses and workflows; explicit disclosure of AI/ML involvement in eligibility and benefit determinations; documented human review and override capabilities for all final decisions; prohibition on using SCDHHS PHI or PII for model training without written authorization; implementation of bias, fairness, and impact assessments before deployment and on a recurring basis; and strict logical and physical separation of SCDHHS data with prohibition of cross-customer AI/ML training. The questionnaire accommodates scenarios where SCDHHS will maintain solutions internally or where vendors will provide certain functions, offering "Not Applicable" response options for those circumstances. This supplement ensures that any AI/ML-enabled proposals submitted to SCDHHS meet rigorous security, privacy, and operational standards before consideration.

View the file

Other files

File Type Posted
ATTM 021.pdf PDF
ATTM 022.pdf PDF
ATTM 024(a).docx DOCX document
ATTM 016.pdf PDF
ATTM 014.pdf PDF
ATTM 005.docx DOCX document
ATTM 006.docx DOCX document
ATTM 008.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
PL 001.docx DOCX document
PL 003.pdf PDF
ATTM 009.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
ATTM 017.pdf PDF
ATTM 018.pdf PDF
PL 002.pdf PDF
ATTM 003.docx DOCX document
ATTM 013.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
ATTM 019.pdf PDF
ATTM 011.pdf PDF
ATTM 015.pdf PDF
ATTM 023.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
ATTM 010.docx DOCX document
ATTM 026.docx DOCX document
ATTM 020.pdf PDF
ATTM 007.docx DOCX document
Solicitation 5400029905.docx DOCX document
ATTM 025.docx DOCX document
ATTM 012.xlsx XLSX spreadsheet
ATTM 004.docx DOCX document
ATTM 001.docx DOCX document
ATTM 002.docx DOCX document
Show all 30

On GovTribe

Work with this file

  • Download the original file
  • Contacts named in this file
  • Similar government files
  • Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Text version

Minimal Requirements

SERVICE PROVIDER SECURITY ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRE (SPSAQ) SUPPLEMENT

Proposals with Artificial Intellegence (AI) and Machine Learning (ML) components

ATTM 024(b)
ALL PROPOSED SOLUTIONS MUST MEET THE BELOW REQUIREMENTS.
Instructions:
For each item below, please select the most appropriate response from those provided in the pulldown menus and add any comments, as needed.
ID#ItemResponseComments:
1Is / will the AI/ML solution be compliant with National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST) AI Risk Management Framework (RMF)'s standards and measures, as amended?
REQUIRED<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>
2Does the proposed solution fully disclose all uses of AI/ML within the proposed solution, including all workflows, data processing activities, and decision-making functions?
REQUIRED<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>
3Does the proposed solution explicitly disclose whether AI/ML is used to make or influence eligibility determinations, claims decisions, or benefit approvals?
REQUIRED<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>
4Does the proposed solution ensure that no final decisions impacting eligibility, benefits, claims are made solely by AI/ML without documented human review and override capability?
REQUIRED<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>
5Does the proposed solution prohibit the use of SCDHHS’ PHI or PII for AI/ML model training, fine-tuning, or improvement unless explicitly authorized in writing by SCDHHS’ Security and Privacy Teams?
REQUIRED<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>
6Does the proposal include how the Offeror will conduct documented bias, fairness, and impact assessments before deployment and on a recurring basis for all decision-impacting AI/ML models?
REQUIRED<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>
7Does the proposed solution ensure strict logical and physical separation of SCDHHS’ data and prohibit cross-customer AI/ML training?
REQUIRED<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>
OPTIONAL:
<Provide any clarifying comments, as needed.>

Glossary

Glossary
TermDefinition
AgencyThis is South Carolina Department of Health and Human Services (SCDHHS).
Artificial Learning (AI)A machine-based system that can, for a given set of human-defined objectives, make predictions, recommendations, or decisions influencing real or virtual environments.
Machine Learning (ML)The development and use of computer systems that adapt and learn from data with the goal of improving accuracy.
Model <for AI/ML>A component of an information system that implements AI technology and uses computational, statistical, or machine-learning techniques to produce outputs from a given set of inputs.
OfferorThis is the vendor who is filling out this questionnaire.
Personally Identifiable Information (PII)Information that can be used to distinguish or trace an individual’s identity, either alone or when combined with other information that is linked or linkable to a specific individual.
Protected Health Information (PHI)Individually identifiable health information: (1) Except as provided in paragraph (2) of this definition, that is: (i) Transmitted by electronic media; (ii) Maintained in electronic media; or (iii) Transmitted or maintained in any other form or medium. (2) Protected health information excludes individually identifiable health information in: (i) Education records covered by the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, as amended, 20 USC. 1232g; (ii) Records described at 20 USC. 1232g(a)(4)(B)(iv); and (iii) Employment records held by a covered entity in its role as employer.

Response References

IDResponse
1Yes.
(Existing Instance / Buildout) The solution is compliant with NIST AI RMF's standards and measures, as amended.Question 1:FOR SCDHHS:
Yes.
(New Instance / Buildout) The solution will be compliant with NIST AI RMF's standards and measures, as amended.Is / will the AI/ML solution be compliant with National Institute for Standards and Technology (NIST) AI Risk Management Framework (RMF)'s standards and measures, as amended?
REQUIREDThis tab will be hidden from vendors to see. The tab is a reference tab for the "Drop Arrow" responses.
No.

The solution will NOT be compliant with NIST AI RMF's standards and measures, as amended.

2Yes.
The proposal does fully disclose all uses of AI and ML within the proposed solution, including all workflows, data processing activities, and decision-making functions.Question 2:
Yes, Conditionally.
The proposal does fully disclose all uses of AI and ML within the proposed solution, including all workflows, data processing activities, and decision-making functions. HOWEVER, appropriate agreements will be required (e.g. - Non-disclosure agreements, etc).Will the proposal fully disclose all uses of AI/ML within the proposed solution, including all workflows, data processing activities, and decision-making functions?

REQUIRED

No.

The proposal does NOT fully disclose all uses of AI and ML within the proposed solution, including all workflows, data processing activities, and decision-making functions.

3Yes.
(Existing Instance / Buildout) The solution DOES ALREADY explicitly disclose whether AI/ML is used to make or influence eligibility determinations, claims decisions, or benefit approvals.Question 3:
Yes.
(New Instance / Buildout) The solution WILL explicitly disclose whether AI/ML is used to make or influence eligibility determinations, claims decisions, or benefit approvals.Will the solution explicitly disclose whether AI/ML is used to make or influence eligibility determinations, claims decisions, or benefit approvals?

REQUIRED

No.

The solution DOES NOT / WILL NOT explicitly disclose whether AI/ML is used to make or influence eligibility determinations, claims decisions, or benefit approvals.

Not Applicable.

The solution will be hosted within SCDHHS's network and SCDHHS will be required to perform this disclosure to users.

4Yes.
(Existing Instance / Buildout) The solution DOES NOT make any final decisions impacting eligibility, benefits, and/or claims that are made solely by AI/ML without documented human review and override capability.Question 4:
Yes.
(New Instance/Buildout) - The solution WILL NOT make any final decisions impacting eligibility, benefits, and/or claims that are made solely by AI/ML without documented human review and override capability.Will the proposed solution ensure that no final decisions impacting eligibility, benefits, claims are made solely by AI/ML without documented human review and override capability?

REQUIRED

No.

The solution DOES / WILL make final decisions impacting eligibility, benefits, and/or claims that are made solely by AI/ML without documented human review and override capability.

5Yes.
(Existing Instance / Buildout) The proposed solution DOES prohibit the use of SCDHHS’ PHI or PII for AI/ML model training, fine-tuning, or improvement unless explicitly authorized in writing by SCDHHS’ Security and Privacy Teams.Question 5:
Yes.
(New Instance / Buildout) The proposed solution WILL prohibit the use of SCDHHS’ PHI or PII for AI/ML model training, fine-tuning, or improvement unless explicitly authorized in writing by SCDHHS’ Security and Privacy Teams.Will the proposed solution prohibit the use of SCDHHS’ PHI or PII for AI/ML model training, fine-tuning, or improvement unless explicitly authorized in writing by SCDHHS’ Security and Privacy Teams?

REQUIRED

No.

The proposed solution REQUIRES the use of SCDHHS’ PHI or PII for AI/ML model training, fine-tuning, or improvement. This is/will be REGARDLESS if authorized in writing by SCDHHS’ Security and Privacy Teams.

6Yes.
The proposed solution include how the Offeror will conduct documented bias, fairness, and impact assessments before deployment and on a recurring basis for all decision-impacting AI models.Question 6:
No.
The Offeror DOES NOT / WILL NOT conduct documented bias, fairness, and impact assessments before deployment and on a recurring basis for all decision-impacting AI models.Does the proposal include how the Offeror will conduct documented bias, fairness, and impact assessments before deployment and on a recurring basis for all decision-impacting AI/ML models?

REQUIRED

Not Applicable.

The proposed solution will be maintained FULLY BY SCDHHS and all bias, fairness, and impact assessments will be required to be performed by SCDHHS.

7Yes.
(Existing Instance / Buildout) The proposed solution DOES ensure strict logical and physical separation of SCDHHS’ data and prohibit cross-customer AI/ML training.Question 7:
Yes.
(New Instance / Buildout) The proposed solution WILL ensure strict logical and physical separation of SCDHHS’ data and prohibit cross-customer AI/ML training.Does the proposed solution ensure strict logical and physical separation of SCDHHS’ data and prohibit cross-customer AI/ML training?

REQUIRED

No.

The proposed solution WILL NOT have strict logical and physical separation of SCDHHS’ data and prohibit cross-customer AI/ML training.

Not Applicable.

The proposed solution will be hosted within SCDHHS's network and the SCDHHS will be required to perform all logical and physical seperation.

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .