Bldg_4738_Asbestos_Survey_Report_Final.pdf

General Asbestos Survey for Asbestos-Containing Materials

Prepared for:

Marshall Space Flight Center, AL

Building 4738 Marshall Space Flight Center

GSE - 017

April 30, 2009

Prepared by

Great Southern Engineering, Inc.

3795 Gordon Terry Parkway

Trinity, Alabama 35673

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1. Introduction

2. Summary

2.1. Suspect ACMs

2.2. Recommendations

3. Survey Scope

4. Limitations

5. Survey and Sample Collection Procedure

6. Previous Survey / Plans Review

7. Suspect ACM Materials Not Sampled

8. Survey Sampling Results

9. Appendices

Task Order GSE 017 Page 1 of 25

GENERAL ASBESTOS SURVEY OF

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

1. Introduction

In accordance with GSE Task Order No.GSE-017 dated August 15, 2008, Great Southern Engineering, Inc. (GSE) has performed an asbestos survey of Building 4738 located at George C.

Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama. The 5,089 square feet building was identified to have been originally constructed in 1957. A total of 27 samples were collected from the building.

The objective of the Asbestos Survey is to determine the location and quantity of asbestos-containing materials at the Property building.

GSE’s Scope of Work included:

Visual inspection and identification of suspect asbestos-containing materials (ACMs) in the Property building and collected a representative number of samples for analysis.

As part of this asbestos survey, GSE personnel collected samples of all suspect friable and suspect damaged non-friable building materials at the Property. The remaining suspect non-friable materials were not be sampled as part of this asbestos survey

Estimated quantities and locations of ACM.

Assessed the condition of the ACM identified.

Assigned a hazard rating to each type of ACM.

This report has been prepared for the use of George C. Marshall Space Flight Center. Our investigation was performed using the degree of care and skill ordinarily exercised under similar circumstances by professional consultants practicing in this or similar localities. No other warranty or guarantee, expressed or implied, is made as to the conclusions included in this report.

Task Order GSE 017 Page 2 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

The GSE, Inc. did not perform destructive sampling procedures at the site; therefore, regardless of the thoroughness of this survey, it is possible that suspected asbestos-containing materials (ACMs) might exist in the building beneath the floors, behind walls, within pipe chases, or in other inaccessible locations. If, during renovation or demolition activities, materials not addressed in this survey are discovered, these materials should be sampled and analyzed for asbestos content prior to disturbance.

Surveyed by:

John A Jackson

University of Alabama Safe State Program Accredited Inspector/Management Planner

Accreditation #AIN0908531941

Written by:

Manju Ramasamudra

University of Alabama Safe State Program Accredited Inspector/Management Planner

Accreditation #APL0308R5089

Task Order GSE 017 Page 3 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

2. Summary

GSE performed an Asbestos Survey and Hazard Assessment at Building 4738 in Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama on January 22, 2009. Sample collection was completed by licensed personnel

– John A Jackson. The following report summarizes the independent conclusions representing GSE’ best professional judgment based on information and data available to us during the course of this survey. Factual information regarding operations, conditions, and tests data provided by the client, owner or their representative has been assumed to be correct and complete.

Additionally, the conclusions presented are based on the conditions that existed on the date(s) of the assessment.

The 5,089 square feet building was identified to have been originally constructed in 1957. A total of 27 samples were collected from the building. Two (2) homogeneous materials were identified as asbestos-containing materials. A summary of the samples collected for this area and corresponding analytical results is presented below.

Building Number 4738

Sample Description

Sample

ID

Building Number

Sample Material

ACM

Quantity

Pipe Insulation4738 28 with Hard Insulation and Cotton Wrap 400 LF

Room Number Grid Numbers 100 C1-1, C1-2, C1-3, C1-4, C2-1, C2-2, C2-3, C2-4, C3-1, C3-2, C3-3, C3-4, C4-1, C4-2, C4-3, C4-4, WE1-1, WE1-2, WE1-3, WE1-4, WE2-1, WE2-2, WE2-3, WE2-4, WE3-1, WE3-2, WE3-3, WE3-4, WE4-1, WE4-2, WE4-3, WE4-4, WF1-1, WF1-2, WF1-3, WF1-4, WF2-1, WF2-2, WF2-3, WF2-4, WF3-1, WF3-2, WF3-3, WF3-4, WF4-1, WF4-2, WF4-3, WF4-4

Sample Description

Sample

ID

Building Number

Sample Material

ACM

Quantity

Pipe Insulation4738 4 Hard Insulation on Elbows and Fittings 80 Elbows

Room Number Grid Numbers 100 C1-1, C1-2, C1-3, C1-4, C2-1, C2-2, C2-3, C2-4, C3-1, C3-2, C3-3, C3-4, C4-1, C4-2, C4-3, C4-4, WE1-1, WE1-2, WE1-3, WE1-4, WE2-1, WE2-2, WE2-3, WE2-4, WE3-1, WE3-2, WE3-3, WE3-4, WE4-1, WE4-2, WE4-3, WE4-4, WF1-1, WF1-2, WF1-3, WF1-4, WF2-1, WF2-2, WF2-3, WF2-4, WF3-1, WF3-2, WF3-3, WF3-4, WF4-1, WF4-2, WF4-3, WF4-4

WL1-1

WR2-1

WR1-1

WL3-1

WL2-1

WR4-1

WR3-1

F1-1 F2-1 F3-1 F4-1

C1-1 C2-1 C3-1 C4-1

C1-2

C1-3

C1-4

C2-2

C2-3

C2-4

C3-2

C3-3

C3-4

C4-2

C4-3

C4-4

WR4-2

WR4-3

WR4-4

WR3-2

WR3-3

WR3-4

WR2-2

WR2-3

WR2-4

WR1-2

WR1-3

WR1-4

F4-2

F4-3

F4-4

F3-2

F3-4

F2-2

F2-3

F2-4

F1-2

F1-3

F1-4

WL1-2

WL1-3

WL1-4

WL2-2

WL2-3

WL2-4

WL3-2

WL3-3

WL3-4

WL4-2

WL4-3

WL4-4

F3-3

WL4-1

WF4-1 WF4-2 WF4-3 WF4-4

WF3-1

WF2-1

WF1-1

WF3-2

WF2-2

WF1-2

WF3-3

WF2-3

WF1-3

WF3-4

WF2-4

WF1-4

WE4-1WE4-2WE4-3WE4-4

WE3-1

WE2-1

WE1-1

WE3-2

WE2-2

WE1-2

WE3-3

WE2-3

WE1-3

WE3-4

WE2-4

WE1-4

Map Document: (G:\asbestos\Asbestos_Room_grid.mxd)

1. Note: Entry wall depicted is as seen from inside the room, therefore grid WE4-4 is located at the top left corner of wall. The main entry door is located within the entry wall.

2. Entry wall location shall be described as N (North) S (South) E (East) or W (West) as seen from the inside of the room. Utilizing the facilities data book, N is located at the top of page, S at bottom of page, E at right of page and W and left of page regardless of bearing shown on drawing for all buildings. (The directional bearing symbol is pointing to either NE or NW for approximately 29 buildings in the facilities data book. Consider these NE or NW bearings as being Plan N when identifying the direction of the entry wall.)

The only exception is building 4705, this drawing shall be oriented towards North as shown on drawing.

3. Type of grid system uses 4 grids by length and 4 grids by width irrespective of the room size.

Grid: C - ceiling, WF - far wall, WE - entry wall, WL - left wall, WR - right wall, F - floor

Asbestos Survey Room Grid Note: Asbestos containing material above the ceiling should be noted on the ceiling grid

Far Wall Entry Wall

Far Wall

WL1-1

WR2-1

WR1-1

WL3-1

WL2-1

WR4-1

WR3-1

WR4-2

WR4-3

WR4-4

WR3-2

WR3-3

WR3-4

WR2-2

WR2-3

WR2-4

WR1-2

WR1-3

WR1-4

WL1-2

WL1-3

WL1-4

WL2-2

WL2-3

WL2-4

WL3-2

WL3-3

WL3-4

WL4-2

WL4-3

WL4-4

WL4-1

C1-1 C2-1 C3-1 C4-1

C1-2

C1-3

C1-4

C2-2

C2-3

C2-4

C3-2

C3-3

C3-4

C4-2

C4-3

C4-4

WF4-1 WF4-2 WF4-3 WF4-4

WF3-1

WF2-1

WF1-1

WF3-2

WF2-2

WF1-2

WF3-3

WF2-3

WF1-3

WF3-4

WF2-4

WF1-4

WE4-1WE4-2WE4-3WE4-4

WE3-1

WE2-1

WE1-1

WE3-2

WE2-2

WE1-2

WE3-3

WE2-3

WE1-3

WE3-4

WE2-4

WE1-4

F1-1 F2-1 F3-1 F4-1

F4-2

F4-3

F4-4

F3-2

F3-4

F2-2

F2-3

F2-4

F1-2

F1-3

F1-4

F3-3

Map Document: (G:\asbestos\Asbestos_Hall_grid.mxd)

1. Note: Entry wall and far wall are optional; there maybe neither that are identified in the hallway. Entry wall depicted is as seen from inside the room, therefore grid WE4-1 is located at the top left corner of wall.

2. Type of grid system uses 4 grids by length and 4 grids by width irrespective of the hall size.

3. The identification of hallway segments will be determined by the end rooms. Hallways will be measured from South to North and from East to West Ex. Room most south of hallway is Room 107 and room most North of hallway is Room 200. Using H as the designation of hallway. The identification of hallway is HS107N200. Likewise from east to west would be HE107W200. The room number sequencing is arbitrary; Ex. HE200W107 would be acceptable. NS&EW are used to distinguish between vertical and horizontal run corridors on drawings.

4. Utilizing the facilities data book, N is located at the top of page, S at bottom of page, E at right of page and W and left of page regardless of bearing shown on drawing for all buildings. (The directional bearing symbol is pointing to either NE or NW for approximately 29 buildings in the facilities data book. Consider these NE or NW bearings as being Plan N when identifying the hallway number.) The only exception is building 4705, this drawing shall be oriented towards North as shown on drawing.

Grid: C - ceiling, WF - far wall, WE - entry wall, WL - left wall, WR - right wall, F - floor

Asbestos Survey Hallway Grid Note: Asbestos containing material above the ceiling should be noted on the ceiling grid

Far Wall Entry Wall

Far Wall Room XXXBeginning

Room YYY N or W

S or E

Task Order GSE 017 Page 4 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

2.1. Suspect ACMs

The following information is included for informational purposes:

A. The following suspect asbestos-containing materials were not sampled as part of this scope of work:

Suspect fibrous electrical cable covering (danger of electrocution) were not sampled.

These materials are not subject to regulation under NESHAP for demolition and renovation as long as they are in good condition and are not subject to sanding, grinding, cutting, or abrading.

Since ordinary demolition activities do not include sanding, grinding, cutting, and abrading, these materials may remain in place during building demolition, as long as they remain in good condition and are not friable.

If the material is in poor condition and is friable at the time of demolition or renovation, or if it will be subjected to sanding, grinding, cutting, or abrading, it should first be removed by a licensed asbestos removal contractor and disposed of as asbestos-containing waste.

When removing asphalt-roofing products, the material should be removed using a method that does not subject the material to sanding, cutting, grinding, or abrading (hand tools).

Asbestos-containing roofing may be disposed of as construction debris.

2.2. Recommendations

The following additional actions are recommended:

The identified asbestos-containing hard pipe insulation with cotton wrap and all hard elbow and fitting insulations are in good condition. In addition suspect asbestos-containing materials in the form of caulking on exterior walls, electrical cable covering, and fire doors were not sampled as a part of this assessment. These materials can be maintained as part of the asbestos O&M Program. A properly designed O&M Program is sufficient to maintain the Project in accordance with current regulatory standards and sound business practice.

ACM maintained with an O&M Program can remain in place, provided the ACM and suspect ACM remain intact and undisturbed.

Task Order GSE 017 Page 5 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

3. Survey Scope

This survey was conducted for the purpose of identifying asbestos-containing materials (ACM) throughout the building and to conduct a hazard assessment on existing ACM. The survey was non-destructive in nature and limited only to those areas that were readily accessible.

Specific areas to which access was limited by occupant request, unavailability of keys, or by site conditions included the following:

Behind the walls

Beneath the floors

Any suspect ACM not sampled as part of the assessment and if any additional suspect materials were to be identified behind walls and beneath the floors should be sampled prior to repair, renovation, or demolition activities.

Task Order GSE 017 Page 6 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

4. Limitations

GSE did not attempt to disassemble mechanical equipment, open pipe chases or assess materials within wall voids. Regardless of the thoroughness of a survey, the possibility exists that some areas containing asbestos were not identified, inaccessible or different from those at specific locations. The findings and opinions presented are relative to the dates of our site work and should not be relied upon to represent conditions at substantially later dates due to changes in the condition ACM may change over time, renovations and repairs.

This report is for the exclusive use of the client and its agents and use by any unauthorized parties in whole or in part, except as directed by legal jurisdiction, is at the sole risk of the user.

If this assessment includes reliance on work products and/or documents prepared by others, GSE has no responsibility for the accuracy of information contained therein.

Although this assessment has attempted to identify the presence or absence of ACM, potential sources of ACM may have escaped detection due to: (1) the scope of this assessment, (2) the inaccuracy of records, interviews, work products or documents made available to GSE for this report, (3) the presence of undetected or unreported renovations and repairs, (4) inaccessible areas, and/or (5) deliberate concealment of detrimental information.

Estimates presented in this report are based upon observations during the survey and owner-provided information. These reasonable estimates may be affected by unanticipated conditions potentially present in inaccessible or un-surveyed areas. GSE does not warrant or guarantee the quantity estimates. The use of such estimates shall be at the user's own risk and shall constitute a release and agreement to defend and indemnify GSE from and against any liability. If questions arise during the planning for renovation, demolition, or other construction activities, GSE should be notified to permit review of the data and present recommendations.

Interior of the following rooms were inaccessible during our Asbestos Survey on January 22, 2009: None.

Task Order GSE 017 Page 7 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

5. Survey and Sample Collection Procedure

Based on United States Environmental Protection Agency (USEPA) guidance documents, GSE considered all material applications identified during the visual assessment were suspect ACM and sampled as described below.

Bulk samples were collected of any materials, which were suspected of containing asbestos with the exception of fire doors. Fire doors were not sampled because the damage caused by sampling would render these materials friable and may also void the fire rating. Since these materials were not sampled, they should be assumed to be asbestos containing, unless sampled and proven otherwise. Sampling of these assumed ACMs should be performed prior to any renovation or other activity that may cause a material disturbance.

Samples of the remaining suspect ACM were taken in accordance with USEPA recommendations.

The number and location of samples collected was based on the type of material, the manner of application, and the homogeneity of the ACM (similarity of color, texture, and type). Each sample was collected and placed into an individual sample container. The sample location was noted on the field survey form and assigned an individual identification number. This number was affixed to the sample container as the sample was collected. The survey form was also used to note the material type and general condition of the material. During the inspection, each suspect material's accessibility, location, and friability were recorded. This information was used to assess the potential hazard of the ACM and to prioritize response action recommendations.

The USEPA defines asbestos-containing materials (ACM) as those that contain greater than one percent asbestos. Friable materials are defined as those that can be crumbled or reduced to powder by hand pressure.

GSE utilized the “positive-stop” method of sample analysis. In this method, analysis is stopped on a group of samples once the first positive (e.g., greater than 1% asbestos) sample is analyzed.

According to the USEPA, if one sample of a homogenous material is identified to be asbestos containing, the entire material must be considered asbestos containing. By using the positive-stop method, GSE reduces the Client’s laboratory analysis cost by not analyzing the additional samples.

Samples collected were carried and submitted under Chain-of-Custody to Steve Moody Micro Services LLC, Farmers Branch, Texas for analysis of asbestos using USEPA Method 40 CFR, Chapter 1, Part 763, Subpart F, Appendix A, also known as Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM).

Steve Moody Micro Services LLC is certified by the National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program (NVLAP) and licensed by the Department of State Health Services.

Task Order GSE 017 Page 8 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

6. Previous Survey / Plans Review

GSE was not provided with any previously conducted asbestos surveys of the Property. As-built/renovation-site plans and construction drawings were reviewed at the Facilities Department Drawing Room. Review of these documents did not identify building material specifications requiring the use of ACM. However, this does not preclude or prevent the potential use of ACM.

Task Order GSE 017 Page 9 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

7. Suspect ACM Materials Not Sampled

During the course of the property visit, GSE performed a preliminary review of interior, accessible areas of the subject building for the presence of suspect asbestos-containing materials (ACMs). This asbestos survey was conducted for overview purposes only; additional suspect materials may exist in concealed locations (behind walls and above ceilings, beneath the floors, within machinery, etc.). Also, not all suspect materials may have been sampled due to the condition or the location of the suspect materials. Destructive sampling of suspect ACMs was not performed. GSE will not be responsible for damaging materials or causing the materials to become friable. The USEPA defines asbestos-containing material as material containing greater than one percent asbestos. This review was not a pre-demolition/renovation survey or for regulatory submittal purposes.

Suspect and/or presumed ACMs were observed within the subject building during the property visit. These suspect and/or presumed ACMs that were not sampled as part of this asbestos survey are listed in the following table.

Sample Description Physical Condition

Friable Yes/No

Type of

ACM

Sample ID

4738Building Number

Caulking, On Exterior Wall Joints UPS4 NoM

Wiring, Fibrous Electrical Cable Covering UPS6 NoM

Fire Doors, Fire Door Insulation UPS7 NoM

Task Order GSE 017 Page 10 of 25

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

8. Survey Sampling Results

The results of the Survey are presented in the tables on the following pages. The tables describe the entire suspect Asbestos-Containing Materials (ACMs) identified in the building and list respective sample numbers and laboratory results. Sample numbers presented in the tables correspond to the sample numbers on attached Laboratory Analysis Forms. Also presented in the tables is the estimated quantity and assessed friability for each suspect ACM. For each suspect material identified as ACM, the assessed hazard potential is presented along with GSE’ recommended response action. Hazard potential for each material application is based on the material condition and accessibility to the public and maintenance personnel.

Glossary of Items for the following Table

Type of Asbestos (1) CH = Chrysotile AM = Amosite CR = Crocidolite AN = Anthophyllite TR = Tremolite AC = Actinolite ND = No Asbestos Detected PC = Point Count Method

Type of ACM (2) M = Miscellaneous S = Surfacing TSI = Thermal Systems Insulation

Friability (3) F = Friable NF = Non Friable

Physical Condition (4) U = Good D = Damaged SD = Significantly Damaged

Potential for Disturbance (5) NPD = No Potential for Disturbance PD = Potential for Disturbance PSD = Potential for Significant Disturbance

Assessment Category (6) 1 = Damaged or significantly damaged TSI ACBM, 2 = Damaged friable surfacing ACBM 3 = Significantly damaged friable surfacing ACBM 4 = Damaged or significantly damaged friable miscellaneous ACBM 5 = ACBM with potential for damaged 6 = ACBM potential for significant damage 7 = Any remaining friable ACBM or friable suspected

ACBM

X = not applicable

Unit of Measurement SF = Square Feet

LF = Linear Feet

Description

Sample Location

Sample Analyzed

Yes/No

Estimated Quantity of

ACM

Assessment Category

Physical Condition

Friable Yes/No

Type of

ACM

% and Type of Asbestos Detected

Sample ID Potential For

Distrubance

4738Building Number

Homogeneous Area 1

Insulation Foam Insulation on Walls

Yes M Yes U XRoom: 100A Grid: WR1-4

ND - Foam Insulation

1 PD

Yes M Yes U XRoom: 100A Grid: WR2-4

ND - Foam Insulation

2 PD

Yes M Yes U XRoom: 100A Grid: WR2-2

ND - Foam Insulation

3 PD

Homogeneous Area 2

Pipe Insulation Hard Insulation on Elbows and Fittings

Yes 80 Elbows TSI Yes U 5Room: 100 Grid: WE3-1

3% CH - Thermal Insulation ND - Cotton Wrap ND - White Mastic

4 PD

No TSI Yes U 5Room: 100 Grid: WE3-3

Not Analyzed Positive Stop

5 PD

No TSI Yes U 5Room: 100 Grid: WE3-3

Not Analyzed Positive Stop

6 PD

Sample Location

Sample Analyzed

Yes/No

Estimated Quantity of

ACM

Assessment Category

Physical Condition

Friable Yes/No

Type of

ACM

% and Type of Asbestos Detected

Sample ID Potential For

Distrubance

4738Building Number

Homogeneous Area 3

Pipe Insulation with White Mastic

Yes TSI Yes U XRoom: 100 Grid: WL2-2

ND - Insulation ND - Black Mastic ND - Paper/ Foil Wrap ND - White Mastic

10 PD

Yes TSI Yes U XRoom: 100 Grid: WF2-4

ND - Insulation ND - Paper/ Foil Wrap ND - White Mastic

11 PD

Yes TSI Yes U XRoom: 100 Grid: WR2-4

ND - Insulation ND - Paper/ Foil Wrap ND - White Mastic

12 PD

Homogeneous Area 4

Expansion Joint Material on Floor

Yes M No U XRoom: 100 Grid: F3-4

ND - Expansion Joint Material

13 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 100 Grid: F3-4

ND - Expansion Joint Material

14 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 100 Grid: F3-3

ND - Expansion Joint Material

15 PD

Sample Location

Sample Analyzed

Yes/No

Estimated Quantity of

ACM

Assessment Category

Physical Condition

Friable Yes/No

Type of

ACM

% and Type of Asbestos Detected

Sample ID Potential For

Distrubance

4738Building Number

Homogeneous Area 5

Window Glazing Debris From Window Repairs on Sills

Yes M Yes D XRoom: 100 Grid: WL2-3

ND - Window Glazing

16 PD

Yes M Yes D XRoom: 100 Grid: WL2-3

ND - Window Glazing

17 PD

Yes M Yes D XRoom: 100 Grid: WL2-1

ND - Window Glazing

18 PD

Homogeneous Area 6

Insulation Fiberglass Insulation on Walls

Yes M No U XRoom: 101 Grid: WE1-2

ND - Insulation ND - Vinyl Facing

19 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 101 Grid: WL2-3

ND - Insulation ND - Vinyl Facing

20 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 101 Grid: WR2-4

ND - insulation ND - Vinyl Facing

21 PD

Sample Location

Sample Analyzed

Yes/No

Estimated Quantity of

ACM

Assessment Category

Physical Condition

Friable Yes/No

Type of

ACM

% and Type of Asbestos Detected

Sample ID Potential For

Distrubance

4738Building Number

Homogeneous Area 7

Caulking Around Door Frames

Yes M No U XRoom: 100 Grid: WE2-1

ND - Caulking22 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 100 Grid: WF2-4

ND - Caulking23 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 100 Grid: WF2-4

ND - Caulking24 PD

Homogeneous Area 8

Caulking Around Metal Column Joints

Yes M No U XRoom: 101 Grid: WE1-1

ND - Caulking25 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 101 Grid: WE1-1

ND - Caulking26 PD

Yes M No U XRoom: 101 Grid: WF2-4

ND - Caulking27 PD

Sample Location

Sample Analyzed

Yes/No

Estimated Quantity of

ACM

Assessment Category

Physical Condition

Friable Yes/No

Type of

ACM

% and Type of Asbestos Detected

Sample ID Potential For

Distrubance

4738Building Number

Homogeneous Area 9

Pipe Insulation with Hard Insulation and Cotton Wrap

Yes 400 LF TSI Yes U 5Room: 100 Grid: WE3-1

10% AM - Thermal Insulation 5% CH - Thermal Insulation ND - Cotton Wrap ND - White Mastic

28 PD

No TSI Yes U 5Room: 100 Grid: WE3-3

Not Analyzed Positive Stop

29 PD

No TSI Yes U 5Room: 100 Grid: WF3-4

Not Analyzed Positive Stop

30 PD

1. CH = Chrysotile; AM = Amosite; CR = Crocidolite; AN = Anthophyllite; TR = Tremolite; AC = Actinolite; ND = No Asbestos Detected; or PC = Point Count Method

2. M = Miscellaneous; S = Surfacing; or TSI = Thermal Systems Insulation

3. F = Friable or NF = Non Friable

4. U = Good; D = Damaged; or SD = Significantly Damaged

5. NPD = No Potential for Disturbance; PD = Potential for Disturbance; or PSD = Potential for Significant Disturbance

6. 1 = Damaged or significantly damaged TSI ACBM, 2 = Damaged friable surfacing ACBM, 3 = Significantly damaged friable surfacing ACBM, 4 = Damaged or significantly damaged friable miscellaneous ACBM, 5 = ACBM with potential for damage, 6 = ACBM potential for significant damage, 7 = Any remaining friable ACBM or friable suspected ACBM, or X = not applicable

SF = Square Feet LF = Linear Feet

9. Appendices

Appendix A— Laboratory Results and Chain of Custody Appendix B— ACM Sample Location Drawings Appendix C— ACM Location Diagrams Appendix D— Photographs Appendix E— Certificates and Licenses

Appendix A

Laboratory Results

PLM Summary Report NVLAP Lab No. 102056

TDSHS License No. 30-0084

Client :

Project :

Project # :

Identification :

Test Method :

Great Southern Engineering

MSFC, Building 4738

GSE-017

Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis

Polarized Light Microscopy / Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600 / R-93 / 116

Sample Number Client Sample Description / Location Asbestos Content

Sample Date :

On 1/28/2009, twenty seven (27) bulk material samples were submitted by John Jackson of Great Southern Engineering for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

The PLM Detail Report is attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Steve Moody Micro Services, LLC

Lab Job No. :

Report Date :

09B-00855

01/22/2009

01/28/2009

2051 Valley View Lane

Farmers Branch, TX 75234 (Phone 972-241-8460)

01 Foam Sealant None Detected - Foam Insulation

02 Foam Sealant None Detected - Foam Insulation

03 Foam Sealant None Detected - Foam Insulation

04 Hard Pipe Insulation on Elbow and Fittings 3% Chrysotile - Thermal Insulation

None Detected - Cotton Wrap

None Detected - White Mastic

05 Hard Pipe Insulation on Elbow and Fittings Not Analyzed - Positive Stop

06 Hard Pipe Insulation on Elbow and Fittings Not Analyzed - Positive Stop

10 Mastic (White) on Pipe Insulation None Detected - Insulation

None Detected - Black Mastic

None Detected - Paper / Foil Wrap

None Detected - White Mastic

11 Mastic (White) on Pipe Insulation None Detected - Insulation

None Detected - Paper / Foil Wrap

None Detected - White Mastic

12 Mastic (White) on Pipe Insulation None Detected - Insulation

None Detected - Paper / Foil Wrap

None Detected - White Mastic

13 Expansion Joint Material None Detected - Expansion Joint

Material

14 Expansion Joint Material None Detected - Expansion Joint

Material

15 Expansion Joint Material None Detected - Expansion Joint

Material

16 Window Glazing None Detected - Window Glazing

17 Window Glazing None Detected - Window Glazing

18 Window Glazing None Detected - Window Glazing

PLM Summary Report NVLAP Lab No. 102056

TDSHS License No. 30-0084

Client :

Project :

Project # :

Identification :

Test Method :

Great Southern Engineering

MSFC, Building 4738

GSE-017

Asbestos, Bulk Sample Analysis

Polarized Light Microscopy / Dispersion Staining (PLM/DS)

EPA Method 600 / R-93 / 116

Sample Number Client Sample Description / Location Asbestos Content

Sample Date :

On 1/28/2009, twenty seven (27) bulk material samples were submitted by John Jackson of Great Southern Engineering for asbestos analysis by PLM/DS.

The PLM Detail Report is attached; additional information may be found therein. The results are summarized below:

Steve Moody Micro Services, LLC

Lab Job No. :

Report Date :

09B-00855

01/22/2009

01/28/2009

2051 Valley View Lane

Farmers Branch, TX 75234 (Phone 972-241-8460)

19 Fiberglass Insulation None Detected - Insulation

None Detected - Vinyl Facing

20 Fiberglass Insulation None Detected - Insulation

None Detected - Vinyl Facing

21 Fiberglass Insulation None Detected - Insulation

None Detected - Vinyl Facing

22 Caulking, Around Door Frame None Detected - Caulking

23 Caulking, Around Door Frame None Detected - Caulking

24 Caulking, Around Door Frame None Detected - Caulking

25 Caulking, Around Metal Column Joints None Detected - Caulking

26 Caulking, Around Metal Column Joints None Detected - Caulking

27 Caulking, Around Metal Column Joints None Detected - Caulking

28 Hard Insulation on Pipes 10% Amosite - Thermal Insulation

5% Chrysotile - Thermal Insulation

None Detected - Cotton Wrap

None Detected - White Mastic

29 Hard Insulation on Pipes Not Analyzed - Positive Stop

30 Hard Insulation on Pipes Not Analyzed - Positive Stop

Greg WerchanAnalyst(s):

Lab Director : Steve Moody Approved Signatory :

Thank you for choosing Steve Moody Micro Services

These samples were analyzed by layers. Quantification, unless otherwise noted, is performed by calibrated visual estimate. Results may not be reproduced except in full. This test report relates only to the samples tested. These test results do not imply endorsement by NVLAP or any agency of the U.S. Government. Accredited by the

National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program for Bulk Asbestos Fiber Analysis under Lab Code 102056.

Lab Manager : Bruce Crabb Approved Signatory :

Steve Moody Micro Services, LLC PLM Detail Report NVLAP Lab No. 102056

TDSHS License No. 30-0084

Project # : GSE-017

Sample Number Layer Components % Of

Sample

Analysis

Date

% of

Layer Analyst

Supplement to PLM Summary Report 2051 Valley View Lane

Farmers Branch, TX 75234

Client :

Project :

Great Southern Engineering

MSFC, Building 4738

Lab Job No. :

Report Date :

09B-00855

01/28/2009

Synthetic Foam01 Foam Insulation (Light Yellow) 100% 01/28100% GW

Synthetic Foam02 Foam Insulation (Light Yellow) 100% 01/28100% GW

Synthetic Foam03 Foam Insulation (Light Yellow) 100% 01/28100% GW

Chrysotile04 Thermal Insulation (Light Grey) 77% 01/283% GW

Mineral Wool Fibers04 Thermal Insulation (Light Grey) 77% 01/2820% GW

Binders / Fillers04 Thermal Insulation (Light Grey) 77% 01/2877% GW

Cotton Fibers04 Cotton Wrap (Off-White) 20% 01/28100% GW

Pigment / Binders04 White Mastic (Off-White) 3% 01/28100% GW

05 Not Analyzed - Positive Stop 100% 01/28 GW

06 Not Analyzed - Positive Stop 100% 01/28 GW

Mineral Wool Fibers10 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/2895% GW

Resin Binders10 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/285% GW

Tar Binders10 Black Mastic (Black) 5% 01/28100% GW

Cellulose Fibers10 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 3% 01/2860% GW

Glass Wool Fibers10 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 3% 01/2820% GW

Metal Foil10 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 3% 01/2820% GW

Cellulose Fibers10 White Mastic (White) 2% 01/285% GW

Pigment / Binders10 White Mastic (White) 2% 01/2895% GW

Mineral Wool Fibers11 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/2895% GW

Resin Binders11 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/285% GW

Cellulose Fibers11 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 5% 01/2860% GW

Glass Wool Fibers11 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 5% 01/2820% GW

Metal Foil11 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 5% 01/2820% GW

Cellulose Fibers11 White Mastic (White) 5% 01/285% GW

Pigment / Binders11 White Mastic (White) 5% 01/2895% GW

Project # : GSE-017

Sample Number Layer Components % Of

Sample

Analysis

Date

% of

Layer Analyst

Supplement to PLM Summary Report 2051 Valley View Lane

Farmers Branch, TX 75234

Client :

Project :

Great Southern Engineering

MSFC, Building 4738

Lab Job No. :

Report Date :

09B-00855

01/28/2009

Mineral Wool Fibers12 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/2895% GW

Resin Binders12 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/285% GW

Cellulose Fibers12 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 5% 01/2860% GW

Glass Wool Fibers12 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 5% 01/2820% GW

Metal Foil12 Paper / Foil Wrap (White / Silver) 5% 01/2820% GW

Cellulose Fibers12 White Mastic (White) 5% 01/285% GW

Pigment / Binders12 White Mastic (White) 5% 01/2895% GW

Cellulose Fibers13 Expansion Joint Material (Black) 100% 01/2885% GW

Tar Binders13 Expansion Joint Material (Black) 100% 01/2815% GW

Cellulose Fibers14 Expansion Joint Material (Black) 100% 01/2885% GW

Tar Binders14 Expansion Joint Material (Black) 100% 01/2815% GW

Cellulose Fibers15 Expansion Joint Material (Black) 100% 01/2885% GW

Tar Binders15 Expansion Joint Material (Black) 100% 01/2815% GW

Calcite16 Window Glazing (Light Tan) 100% 01/2860% GW

Binders / Fillers16 Window Glazing (Light Tan) 100% 01/2840% GW

Calcite17 Window Glazing (Light Tan) 100% 01/2860% GW

Binders / Fillers17 Window Glazing (Light Tan) 100% 01/2840% GW

Calcite18 Window Glazing (Light Tan) 100% 01/2860% GW

Binders / Fillers18 Window Glazing (Light Tan) 100% 01/2840% GW

Mineral Wool Fibers19 Insulation (Yellow) 85% 01/2895% GW

Resin Binders19 Insulation (Yellow) 85% 01/285% GW

Vinyl Binders19 Vinyl Facing (White) 15% 01/28100% GW

Mineral Wool Fibers20 Insulation (Yellow) 95% 01/2895% GW

Resin Binders20 Insulation (Yellow) 95% 01/285% GW

Vinyl Binders20 Vinyl Facing (White) 5% 01/28100% GW

Mineral Wool Fibers21 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/2895% GW

Resin Binders21 Insulation (Yellow) 90% 01/285% GW

Vinyl Binders21 Vinyl Facing (White) 10% 01/28100% GW

Binders / Fillers22 Caulking (White) 100% 01/28100% GW

Project # : GSE-017

Sample Number Layer Components % Of

Sample

Analysis

Date

% of

Layer Analyst

Supplement to PLM Summary Report 2051 Valley View Lane

Farmers Branch, TX 75234

Client :

Project :

Great Southern Engineering

MSFC, Building 4738

Lab Job No. :

Report Date :

09B-00855

01/28/2009

Calcite23 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Binders / Fillers23 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Calcite24 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Binders / Fillers24 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Calcite25 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Binders / Fillers25 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Calcite26 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Binders / Fillers26 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Calcite27 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Binders / Fillers27 Caulking (White) 100% 01/2850% GW

Amosite28 Thermal Insulation (White) 88% 01/2810% GW

Chrysotile28 Thermal Insulation (White) 88% 01/285% GW

Binders / Fillers28 Thermal Insulation (White) 88% 01/2885% GW

Cotton Fibers28 Cotton Wrap (Off-White) 10% 01/28100% GW

Pigment / Binders28 White Mastic (Off-White) 2% 01/28100% GW

29 Not Analyzed - Positive Stop 100% 01/28 GW

30 Not Analyzed - Positive Stop 100% 01/28 GW

Appendix B

ACM Sample Location Drawings

First Floor Building 4738

Marshall Space Flight Center Marshall Space Flight Center, AL

Task Order #GSE-017

13629541817

25 22 19

Appendix C

ACM Location Diagrams

Manju Ramasamudra Rectangle

Manju Ramasamudra Text Box Hard Pipe Insulation with Cotton Wrap and All Hard Elbow and Fitting Insulations

Appendix D

Photographs

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

PHOTO 1. View of the building PHOTO 2. View of the building

PHOTO 3. Interior view of the building PHOTO 4. Foam sealant

PHOTO 5. Hard elbow and fitting insulation PHOTO 6. Pipe insulation with white mastic

Building 4738, George C. Marshall Space Flight Center, Marshall Space Flight Center, Alabama

PHOTO 7. Expansion joint material on floor PHOTO 8. Window glazing

PHOTO 9. Batt insulation on walls PHOTO 10. Caulking around door frames

PHOTO 11. Caulking around column joints PHOTO 12. Hard pipe insulation

Appendix E

License and Certifications