Pathways-CM-Selection-Shortlist-Results.pdf

This document is a Shortlist Meeting Results spreadsheet from the Facilities Planning and Construction department of Volusia County Schools, detailing the evaluation of Construction Management firms for the Pathways Elementary School 11-Classroom Addition project. The document reveals the scoring of nine construction firms across ten weighted criteria, with the top three firms selected for interviews on April 22, 2025, at Facilities Services in Daytona Beach, Florida. The evaluation weighted factors include Strategy to Utilize Local Businesses (5 points), Business Structure (10 points), Experience and Past Performance (30 points), Proposed Project Staff and Functions (20 points), Project Approach (15 points), Scheduling Methodology (90 points), and Workload (10 points), for a total possible score of 100 points.

WELBRO Building Corporation emerged as the top-scoring firm with 76.33 points, followed by A.M. Weigel Construction at 72.67 points and Charles Perry Partners Inc. at 70 points. The remaining firms scored progressively lower, with Coleman Goodemote Construction Company scoring the lowest at 46.5 points. The document indicates a competitive selection process focused on comprehensive evaluation of the firms' qualifications, with emphasis on experience, performance, project approach, and local business utilization. While specific financial details are not provided in this document, it is part of the procurement process for a $12,000,000 educational facility construction project at Pathways Elementary School in Ormond Beach, Florida.