BPM003283_Evaluation_Consensus_Score_Nara_Sin.pdf
PDF 152 KB Posted
- Attached to
- Master Agreement AZ|CTR054804
- Contract number
- CTR054804
- Issued by
- Arizona
About this file
This document is an evaluation scoring sheet for Contract BPM003283 for Wildlife Waters Construction and Redevelopment/Wildlife Habitat Construction, involving multiple general contractors bidding for a project in Arizona. The document originates from the SSDV (State of Arizona) and involves evaluators scoring proposals from eight different construction firms: Action Direct (Redpoint Contracting), Clay Bundy Construction Inc, Copperstate Earthworks, DBA Construction, Hylan-West, IOI Construction Corp, MD Merrett, and Ranch to Ranch.
The evaluation assesses contractors across three primary criteria: Experience and Reliability (40 points maximum), Firm's Demonstrated Experience (40 points maximum), and Method of Approach (10 points maximum). Three independent evaluators scored each firm, with a consensus score determining final rankings. The top-performing contractors were Copperstate Earthworks and MD Merrett, both achieving a total consensus score of 79.00 out of a possible 100 points. The lowest-scoring firm was DBA Construction with 41.00 points. The document is dated 03/30/21 and signed by an engineer from the SSDV-AZGFD (Arizona Game and Fish Department), indicating this is likely a state-level contract for wildlife habitat construction services.
View the file
Other files
Show all 27
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
Text version
BPM003283 Wildlife Waters Construction and Redevelopment/Wildlife Habitat Construction General Contractor
EVALUATOR'S SCORES M
A
XI
M
U M
PO
IN
TS
A ct io n
D ire ct db a
R ed po in t C on tr ac tin g C la y
B un dy
C on st ru ct io n In c
C op pe rs ta te
Ea rt hw or ks
D B
A
C on st ru ct io n
H yl an -W es t
IO
I
C on st ru ct io n C or p
M D
M er re tt
R an ch to
R an ch
SD
B
In c
Sm ith
S hu rt lif f an d Sm ith
Sp en ce r
C on st ru ct io n
W in ds or
U nd er gr ou nd
Evaluator #1 25 33 35 35 25 25 30 20 33 35 33 30
#2 30 35 38 35 30 30 40 35 30 40 35 30 #3 35 30 35 35 5 33 36 35 33 35 36 28
CONSENSUS SCORE 30 32.667 36 35 20 29.333 35.333 30 32 36.667 34.667 29.333
Evaluator #1 20 35 35 33 20 30 30 35 35 35 33 29
#2 30 30 35 35 20 30 40 30 30 40 30 25 #3 34 10 30 34 5 28 36 35 35 35 33 10
CONSENSUS SCORE 28 25 33.333 34 15 29.333 35.333 33.333 33.333 36.667 32 21.333
10 0 0 0 Evaluator #1 7 8 10 8 7 7 8 8 8 8 7 7
#2 8 6 10 10 5 8 10 8 8 10 6 8 #3 8 7 9 8 6 8 7 8 8 8 8 7
CONSENSUS SCORE 7.66667 7 9.6667 8.6667 6 7.6667 8.3333 8 8 8.6667 7 7.3333
Totals
Evaluator #1 52 76 80 76 52 62 68 63 76 78 73 66 #2 68 71 83 80 55 68 90 73 68 90 71 63 #3 77 47 74 77 16 69 79 78 76 78 77 45
CONSENSUS TOTAL 65.67 64.67 79.00 77.67 41.00 66.33 79.00 71.33 73.33 82.00 73.67 58.00 8 10 2 4 12 8 2 7 6 1 5 11
SIGNATURE TITLE BRANCH/ENTITY DATE
Engineer SSDV - AZGFD 03/30/21
SMITH SHURTLIFF AND SMITH, COPPERSTATE EARTHWORKS, MD MERRETT, DBA CONSTRUCTION, and SPENCER CONSTRUCTION
I HEREBY ATTEST THAT THE POINTS AWARDED TO EACH OFFEROR LISTED ABOVE WERE SCORED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE ESTABLISHED EVALUATION CRITERIA AND REPRESENT MY BEST JUDGEMENT OF THE OFFEROR'S PROPOSAL. AS INDICATED BY THE HIGHEST TOTAL SCORE, MY SELECTION OF THE PROPOSALS WHICH OFFERS THE MOST ADVANTAGEOUS SERVICE TO THE STATE OF ARIZONA ARE:
Ranking
Experience and Reliability
Firm's Demonstrated Experience
Method of Approach
Nara Stamp
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .