3_LEED_Checklist_AirCrew_TypeB3__30_Dec_2015.pdf

2015 2015

Categories

Prereq 1 Construction Activity Pollution

Prevention

USGBC

Prereq X $0 $0 A-E Comment: This credit is feasible and already included as a matter of standard construction practice.

Credit 1 Site Selection 1 1 $0 1 $0 A-E Comment: The site is previously developed & qualifies for this credit.

Credit 2 Development Density & Community

Connectivity 5 n/a 5 n/a

A-E Comment: This site is not located in an area that complies with this credit.

Credit 3 Brownfield Redevelopment 1 n/a 1 n/a A-E Comment: This site is not a brownfield.

Credit 4.1 Alternative Transportation, Public Transportation Access 6 n/a 6 n/a

A-E Comment: Public transportation is not accessible from this site.

ANG Recommended. A-E must evaluate feasibility and achieve if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: Easily feasible by adding a bicycle rack. The project already has shower and changing facilities. Base to advise if this is appropriate for a facility within the flighline secure fence.

Credit 4.3 Alternative Transportation, Low-Emitting & Fuel-Efficient Vehicles 3 n/a 3 n/a

A-E Comment: This building has no designated parking.

Credit 4.4 Alternative Transportation, Parking Capacity 2 2 $0 2 $0

A-E Comment: This building has no parking, therfore it complies with this credit.

Credit 5.1 Site Development, Protect or Restore Habitat 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: This credit is not feasible due to the site's location on the flightline.

Credit 5.2 Site Development, Maximize Open Space 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: This credit is not feasible due to the site's location on the flightline.

n/a n/a ANG Recommended. A-E must evaluate feasibility and achieve if applicable by project scope.

n/a n/a

A-E Comment: A 25% decrease in the volume of stormwater runoff from the two-year, 24-hour design storm is unattainable because we are adding impervious area with the new aircrew facility building.

n/a n/a ANG Recommended. A-E must evaluate project feasibility and achieve if applicable by project scope.

n/a n/a

A-E Comment: This credit is unattainable because we are adding impervious area within the project limits. This credit would likely require installing a hydrodynamic separation BMP to treat the stormwater runoff from 90% of the average annual rainfall. There is inadequate space on site and it almost certainly falls outside of the project budget.

ANG Recommended. A-E must evaluate project feasibility and achieve if applicable by project scope and budget.

A-E Comment: Use of all light colored concrete -with required maintenance plan to keep clean - in lieu of base bid use of standard concrete or asphalt. Relatively high unit cost, but given the limited pavement required this credit is recommended.

ANG Required. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

ANG Recom.

(1 point)

Credit 6.1 Stormwater Design, Quantity Control

ANG Recom.

(1 point)

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

$7,500 1 $7,5001

Sustainable Sites Possible Points: 26

Credit 7.1 Heat Island Effect, Non-Roof

$2,350 1 $2,350

ANG Recom.

(1 point)

Credit 6.2 Stormwater Design, Quality Control

ANG Recom.

(1 point) Credit 4.2

Alternative Transportation, Bicycle Storage & Changing Rooms

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

A-E Comment: This credit is easily achieveable though the use of a white membrane or High SRI standing seam metal roof. There may be a slight upcharge for the membrane or panel, but in all likelihood it can be achieved with a manufacturer standard roof panel at no additional cost.

Credit 8 Light Pollution Reduction 1 1 $0 1 $0

A-E Comment: This point may be possible by using cut-off exterior fixtures depending on base requiements for security lighting. These fixtures would be used regardless, so there would be no increase in project cost.

Prereq 1 Water Use Reduction

USGBC

Prereq X A-E Comment:

Credit 1 Water Efficient Landscaping 2 to 4 points

ANG Requirement. EPAct 2005 - Water

Conservation. E.O. 13423 - Reduce Water

Consumption. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: See WE credit 2 below.

ANG Recommended. Avoid use of irrigation systems as project, location and climate allow.

A-E Comment: No potable water will be used and no irrigiation will be installed as part of this project.

This credit adds no cost to the project.

Credit 2 Innovative Wastewater Technologies 2 n/a 2 n/a

A-E Comment: The infrastructure necessary for innovative waste water technologies are typically too expensive in small projects to support.

Credit 3 Water Use Reduction 2 to 4 points

ANG Requirement. EPAct 2005 - Water

Conservation. E.O. 13423 - Reduce Water

Consumption. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: This strategy to achieve this credit is to use low-flow fixtures for all plumbing fixtures.

Installation costs are unaffected. Fixture costs are slightly higher.

ANG Recommended. A-E must evaluate project feasibility and achieve if applicable by project scope and budget.

A-E Comment:Due to the newest LEED baseline fixture comsumption requirements, this will not be achievable in the facility.

40% Reduction 1 1 $1,000 n/a

A-E Comment: A-E Comment:Due to the newest

LEED baseline fixture comsumption requirements, this will not be achievable in the facility.

1 $1,500

No Potable Water Use or Irrigation $0

$3,500

$0 n/a

Credit 7.2 Heat Island Effect, Roof 1 $3,500

2 $0

Energy & Atmosphere Possible Points: 35

ANG

Required

(2 points)

Reduce by 50%

Water Efficiency Possible Points: 10

ANG Recom.

(2 points) $02

ANG

Required

$3,500

ANG Recom.

(1 point)35% Reduction

30% Reduction $3,500 2

ANG

Required

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

Prereq 1 Fundamental Commissioning of

Building Energy Systems

USGBC

Prereq X $13,000 $13,000

A-E Comment: Meeting this USGBC prerequisite will add to the cost of the project, above what is currently required by ANG design policy.

IMPORTANT NOTE: Decision to go after enhanced commissioning point (later in score sheet) must be decided prior to Type B services so that the appropriate and required type of commissioning agent can be integrated into the design team.

Prereq 2 Minimum Energy Performance

USGBC

Prereq X $0 $0

A-E Comment: This point is met by conformance with basic ANG design policy and is within the overall scope of the project.

Prereq 3 Fundamental Refrigerant

Management

USGBC

Prereq X $0 $0

A-E Comment: Requirements for management will be iincluded in the project specifications. This credit is required regardless of LEED, so it represents no additional cost to the project.

Credit 1 Optimize Energy Performance 1 to 19 Points

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

See below

See below

See below

See below

See below See below

See below

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

16% New Buildings or 12%

Existing Building Renovations

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

14% New Buildings or 10%

Existing Building Renovations

12% New Buildings or 8%

Existing Building Renovations

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point) 1 See below

See below1

See below

18% New Buildings or 14%

Existing Building Renovations

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

20% New Buildings or 16%

Existing Building Renovations

See below

22% New Buildings or 18%

Existing Building Renovations

1See below ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as necessary for project to meet EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: See 30% threshold for comments.

ANG Provisional Requirement. EPAct 2005 -

30% Energy Use Reduction. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E to ensure project achieves this point, only as life cycle cost effective and meet 2005 EPAct 30% reduction.

A-E Comment: A/E will design the building to achieve the required 2005 EPACT 30% savings for a new building (26% for a renovation) only as life cycle cost effective. The design will take in to account electrical systems, mechanical systems, and building envelope.

32% New Buildings or 28%

Existing Building Renovations 1 1 See above See above

A-E Comment:

34% New Buildings or 30%

36% New Buildings or 32%

38% New Buildings or 34%

40% New Buildings or 36%

42% New Buildings or 38%

44% New Buildings or 40%

46% New Buildings or 42%

48% New Buildings or 44%

1 1 See above See above

A-E Comment:

Credit 2 On-Site Renewable Energy 1 to 7 Points

See below

$156,000

See below

See below1

26% New Buildings or 22%

Existing Building Renovations

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

28% New Buildings or 24%

Existing Building Renovations

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

$156,000

See below

30% New Buildings or 26%

Existing Building Renovations

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point)

24% New Buildings or 20%

Existing Building Renovations

ANG Prov.

Required

(1 point) 1 See below

See below

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

ANG Recommended. EPAct 2005 and EISA

2007. Provide 30% domestic hot water via solar system if LCC effective. Provide roof mounted photovoltaic systems if LCC effective. A-E must thoroughly evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid items or options. Provide complete LCC analysis.

A-E Comment: EA 2 will be an Option or ABI.

Based on initial reaction to the budget, it is unlikely these systems will fall within the budget scope.

The design team will also need guidance related to limitations of roof mounted collectors on a facility that sits on the flightilne.

ANG Recommended. EPAct 2005 and EISA

2007. Provide 30% domestic hot water via solar system if LCC effective. Provide roof mounted photovoltaic systems if LCC effective. A-E must thoroughly evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid items or options. Provide complete LCC analysis.

A-E Comment:

ANG Recommended. EPAct 2005 and EISA

2007. Provide 30% domestic hot water via solar system if LCC effective. Provide roof mounted photovoltaic systems if LCC effective. A-E must thoroughly evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid items or options. Provide complete LCC analysis.

A-E Comment:

ANG Provisional Recommendation - see above.

EPAct 2005 and EISA 2007. A-E must thoroughly evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid items or options. Provide complete LCC analysis.

A-E Comment:

ANG Provisional Recommendation - see above.

EPAct 2005 and EISA 2007. A-E must thoroughly evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid items or options. Provide complete LCC analysis.

A-E Comment:

ANG Provisional Recommendation - see above.

EPAct 2005 and EISA 2007. A-E must thoroughly evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid items or options. Provide complete LCC analysis.

A-E Comment:

ANG Provisional Recommendation - see above.

EPAct 2005 and EISA 2007. A-E must thoroughly evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid items or options. Provide complete LCC analysis.

A-E Comment:

TBD

TBD

TBD

TBD

TBD

TBD

TBD

TBD

TBD1

3% Renewable Energy ANG Recom.

(1 point) TBD1

1% Renewable Energy ANG Recom.

(1 point)

13% Renewable Energy ANG Prov.

Recom.

(1 point)

5% Renewable Energy ANG Recom.

(1 point)

9% Renewable Energy ANG Prov.

Recom.

(1 point)

7% Renewable Energy ANG Prov.

Recom.

(1 point)

11% Renewable Energy ANG Prov.

Recom.

(1 point)

TBD

1 TBD

1 TBD

TBD

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

ANG Recommended. EPAct 2005 - Energy

Conservation. E.O. 13423 - Energy

Conservation. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid item or option.

A-E Comment: URS recommends this point and will include it in the specifications as an option or

ABI.

ANG Recommended. E.O. 13423 - Reduction of

Toxic and Hazardous Materials Acquired.

Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E must evaluate feasibility of project achieving this point as base bid item or option.

A-E Comment:

ANG Requirement. EPAct 2005 - Metering of

Utility with Smart Metering. Federal

Sustainable Buildings MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: This LEED point includes the required smart metering and monitoring as required by EPAct. All metering is tied to the DDC system. Specifications will require the control system to include creation of specific monitoring and utility consumption data.

Credit 6 Green Power 2 2 $3,000 2 $3,000

A-E Comment: This credit is purely administrative and represents relatively inexpensive points if needed. However, purchase of Green Power has no impact on the construction of the building itself.

Must be evaluated against any military regulations pertaining to utility credit purchase contracts.

Also E.O. 13423 - Waste Prevention and

Recycling Programs in Facilities.

A-E Comment: Space for recycling will be accomodated in the kitchen and storage room as required.

Credit 1.1 Building Reuse, Maintain Existing

Walls, Floors & Roof

1 to 3

Points

Maintain 55% of Existing Walls, Floors

& Roof 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: This credit is not applicable for new construction.

Maintain 75% of Existing Walls, Floors

& Roof 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: This credit is not applicable for new construction.

Maintain 95% of Existing Walls, Floors

& Roof 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: This credit is not applicable for new construction.

Credit 1.2 Building Reuse, Maintain 50% of

Interior Non-Structural Elements 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: This credit is not applicable for new construction.

Credit 2 Construction Waste Management 1 to 2

Points

ANG Requirement. E.O. 13423 - Increase

Diversion of Solid Waste. Federal Sustainable

Buildings MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit.

$5,000

$1,000

$12,000

$2,500

$13,650

$13,650

$2,500

$12,000

Credit 3 Enhanced Commissioning ANG Recom.

(2 points)

Credit 5

Credit 4 Enhanced Refrigerant Management ANG Recom.

(2 points)

Measurement & Verification

ANG

Required 3

ANG

Required $5,000

Prereq 1 Storage & Collection of Recyclables

USGBC

Prereq X $1,000

Materials & Resources Possible Points: 14

Divert 50% from Landfill

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

ANG Requirement. E.O. 13423 - Increase

Diversion of Solid Waste. Federal Sustainable

Buildings MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit.

Credit 3 Materials Reuse 1 to 2

Points

Reuse 5% 1 n/a 1 n/a A-E Comment: Re-used or salvaged materials are not feasible for this project due to the nature of its construction.

Reuse 10% 1 n/a 1 n/a A-E Comment: Re-used or salvaged materials are not feasible for this project due to the nature of its construction.

Credit 4 Recycled Content 1 to 2

Points

ANG Required. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Recycled content is common place and should not add cost to the project. Administrative cost will be necessary for the contractor to track progress.

20% (post-consumer + ½ pre-consumer) 1 1 $0 1 $0

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Recycled content is common place and should not add cost to the project. Administrative cost will be necessary for the contractor to track progress.

Credit 5 Regional Materials 1 to 2

Points

ANG Required. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Given the location of the project, a large number of products are manufactured within the required radius and should not add material cost to the project. Administrative cost will be necessary for the contractor to track progress.

20% Extracted, Processed &

Manufactured Regionally 1 1 $0 1 $0

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit.

Credit 6 Rapidly Renewable Materials

ANG Recommended. Federal Sustainable

Buildings MOU. A-E must evaluate feasibility and achieve if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: Not feasible given construction type

& use. Rapidly renewable finish materials will not have the durability required for this facility.

Credit 7 Certified Wood

ANG Recommended. Federal Sustainable

Buildings MOU. A-E must evaluate feasibility and achieve if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Material costs and tracking this credit will add cost. Installation costs are unaffected.

$3,500

$1,000

$2,500 n/a

$1,000

Divert 75% from Landfill

ANG

Required

10% (post-consumer + ½ pre-consumer)

ANG

Recom.

(1 point)

$2,5001

ANG

Required

$1,000

Indoor Environmental Quality Possible Points: 15

11 $3,500 n/a 1

ANG

Recom.

(1 point)

10% Extracted, Processed &

Manufactured Regionally

ANG

Required 1 $1,000 1

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

Also Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU.

A-E Comment: This credit is a matter of good design practice and will not add cost to the project.

Also Federal, DoD and Air Force Regulation.

A-E Comment: Installation is non-smoking.

Credit 1 Outdoor Air Delivery Monitoring 1 1 $9,000 1 $9,000 A-E Comment:

Credit 2 Increased Ventilation 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: This point negatively affects enegry savings because a higher volume of air needs to be conditioned. Given the relative lack of indoor air contaminants likely in this building, URS does not recommend this credit.

ANG Required. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Proper IAQ during construction is a matter of good practice and should not add any cost to achieve.

ANG Requirement. Federal Sustainable

Buildings MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Added cost for air quality testing will be required.

ANG Required - If Applicable. E.O. 13423 -

Reduction of Toxic and Hazardous Materials

Acquired. Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU.

A-E must achieve if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Low-voc materials are common and do not represent any added costs.

ANG Required - If Applicable. E.O. 13423 -

Reduction of Toxic and Hazardous Materials

Acquired. Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU.

A-E must achieve if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Low-voc materials are common and do not represent any added costs.

ANG Required - If Applicable. E.O. 13423 -

Reduction of Toxic and Hazardous Materials

Acquired. Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU.

A-E must achieve if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Low-voc materials are common and do not represent any added costs.

ANG Required - If Applicable. E.O. 13423 -

Reduction of Toxic and Hazardous Materials

Acquired. Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU.

A-E must achieve if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: A-E will include specification language for the contractor to comply with this credit. Low-voc materials are common and do not represent any added costs.

$0

$0

$0

$0

$5,000

$0 1

$0

$0

$5,000

$0

$0

X

X $0

Prereq 2

$0 1

$0

1 $0

$0

ANG

Required

Environmental Tobacco Smoke

(ETS) Control

USGBC

Prereq

1Credit 3.2 Construction IAQ Management Plan, Before Occupancy

ANG

Required

Credit 3.1 Construction IAQ Management Plan, During Construction

Prereq 1 Minimum IAQ Performance

USGBC

Prereq

Credit 4.2 Low-Emitting Materials, Paints & Coatings

ANG

Required

Credit 4.1 Low-Emitting Materials, Adhesives & Sealants

ANG

Required

Low-Emitting Materials, Carpet Systems

ANG

Required

ANG

Required

Low-Emitting Materials, Composite Wood & Agrifiber Products Credit 4.4

Credit 4.3

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

Credit 5 Indoor Chemical & Pollutant Source

Control 1 1 $2,500 1 $2,500

A-E Comment: This credit requires recess walk-off grilles @ entries, mechanical exhaust isolation at rooms w/contaminants, and MERV 13 filtration for occupied areas.

ANG Required. EPAct 2005 - Energy

Conservation. E.O. 13423 - Energy

Conservation. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: Most of what is necessary to achieve this point is inscluded in the installation standards (occupancy sensors, etc.) and would be done anyway.

Credit 6.2 Controllability of Systems, Thermal Comfort

1 1 TBD TBD $1

A-E Comment: Controlability for thermal is possible, but cost will be dictated by the type of mechanical system selected.

ANG Recommended. Federal Sustainable

Buildings MOU. A-E must achieve this point if applicable by project scope.

A-E Comment: The facility will be designed per the requirements of this credit. This effort is already included in URS's contract.

Credit 7.2 Thermal Comfort, Verification 1 1 $0 1 $0 A-E Comment:A-E will include a sample thermal comfort survey for the ANG to administer.

ANG Required. Federal Sustainable Buildings

MOU. A-E must ensure that project achieves this point. A7O project manager can waive requirement if A-E demonstrates that obtaining point is not possible due to project scope.

A-E Comment: Due to the limited size and number of windows allowed for this facility, this ANG requirement is not feasible.

Credit 8.2 Daylight & Views, Views for 90% of Spaces 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: Due to the limited size and number of windows allowed for this facility, this ANG requirement is not feasible.

Credit 1.1

Innovation in Design:

MR Credit 4.2 - Exemplary

Performance

1 1 $0 $0

A-E Comment: MR exemplary performance credits will be pursued, but cannot be guaranteed.

Achieving this credit, if possible, represents no additional cost compared to the figure listed earlier for this credit.

Credit 1.2

Innovation in Design:

MR Credit 5.2 - Exemplary

Performance

1 1 $0 $0

A-E Comment: MR exemplary performance credits will be pursued, but cannot be guaranteed.

Achieving this credit, if possible, represents no additional cost compared to the figure listed earlier for this credit.

Credit 1.3 Innovation in Design:

MR Credit 7 - Exemplary Performance 1 1 $2,000 $2,000

A-E Comment: MR exemplary performance credits will be pursued, but cannot be guaranteed.

Credit 1.4 Innovation in Design:

EA Credit 6 - Exemplary Performance 1 1 $3,000 1 $3,000

A-E Comment: This credit is available by doubling the required purchase of Green Power. This credit is purely administrative and does not affect the actual building.

ANG Policy. EPAct 2005.

A-E must ensure project achieves this point.

A-E Comment: A LEED AP from URS is assigned to this project. This item is already included in

URS's contract.

n/a

$0

$5,000

$0

Credit 7.1 Thermal Comfort, Design

ANG

Recom.

(1 point)

1 $0 n/a 1

Credit 6.1 Controllability of Systems, Lighting

LEED

Accredited Professional

Innovation & Design Process Possible Points: 6

Credit 8.1 Daylight & Views, Daylight 75% of Spaces

ANG

Required

$01

ANG

Required 1Credit 2

ANG

Required 1 $5,000

Air National Guard Sustainable Design and Energy Conservation Score Sheet

Companion to USGBC LEED® for NC 2009 - Version ANGv2010(1) Includes Energy Policy Act 2005, Federal Sustainable Buildings MOU, Executive Order 13423 and Energy Independence and Security Act 2007 Implementation

Date:Base: Toledo Express Airport, OH

Points and Point Cost Impact

USGBC Project Registration Access #:

30-Dec-15 Type B3 Services

USGBC Project Title: ASA Alert Crew Quarters Facility ID:1000032542/Access Code:1494402642155957Program FY:

LEED

- AP Project Comments:

Project Design

Point Cost

Estimates

Project Num:

Project Title:

WYTD079032

ASA Alert Crew Quarters

Point and

Prereq.

Cost

Estimates

Design Status:

Project

Design

Points

(Goals)

Credit Description Other

Design

Points

Points

Non

Achieva ble

Points

ANG

Req.

Points

Credit

Credit 1.1 EA Credit 1 (30% new/26% Existing)

Optimize Energy Performance 1 1 $0 1 $0

A-E Comment: See above for a description of this point. Regional priority represents no additional cost beyond what is listed above.

Credit 1.2 SS Credit 6.1

Stormwater Design: Quantity Control 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: See above for a description of this point.

Credit 1.3 SS Credit 6.2

Stormwater Design: Quality Control 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: See above for a description of this point.

Credit 1.4 WE Credit 2

Innovative Wastewater Technologies 1 n/a 1 n/a

A-E Comment: See above for a description of this point.

Req.

Pts.

Oth.

Pts.

All Point

Cost Est.

X Pts.

Proj.

Goal

Proj. Goal

Cost Est.

Points and Point Cost Impact Summary 110 30 48 $260,000 31 53 $257,501

Summary: Project LEED Score and

Cost Estimate

USGBC Rating System:

ANG Category Requirements:

Score: 53

Vertical - USGBC Silver 50 to 59 points. Industrial - USGBC Silver 50 to 59 points.

Horizontal - 11-13 USGBC points. Utility - 9-10 USGBC points.

Certified 40 to 49 points Silver 50 to 59 points Gold 60 to 79 points Platinum 80+ points

Cost: $257,501

Regional Priority Possible Points: 4