Exhibit C - Consulting Rating Form.pdf

This is a Consultant Rating Form for the Crosstown Water Main Route Study Request for Proposal issued by the City of Ohio. The form serves as an evaluation tool for assessing consultant proposals submitted in response to this project opportunity. The rating form contains nine evaluation criteria designed to comprehensively assess consultant qualifications and proposal quality for the water main routing study project.

The evaluation criteria include Qualifications and Related Project Experience (15 points), Office Location (5 points), Familiarity with Local, State and Federal Regulations (10 points), Current Work Load (5 points), Performance on Previous Projects (15 points), Understanding of Project (15 points), Schedule/Staffing (15 points), Cost of Proposal (5 points), and Other factors as defined in Section 5.1, paragraph 5.1.1 (5 points), totaling 100 possible weighted points. Scoring follows a standardized scale: High (5 points), Above Average (4 points), Average (3 points), Below Average (2 points), Low (1 point), and Non-responsive (0 points). The form requires evaluators to assign individual scores to each criterion, multiply by the designated weight, and calculate a total weighted score for comparative analysis of competing consultant proposals.