Equipment Comparison Form
91 KB Posted
- Attached to
- Playground Replacement at Collins Hill Park
- Solicitation number
- BL020-22
- Issued by
- Gwinnett County, Georgia
About this file
This is an Equipment Comparison Form related to a Playground Replacement project at Collins Hill Park under the Gwinnett County Board of Commissioners in Georgia. The form serves as a supporting document for the formal solicitation process, which requires all bids and proposals to be received no later than 2:50 p.m. on the specified due date. The document appears designed to facilitate evaluation of equipment options for the playground replacement project, allowing bidders to present comparable equipment specifications and pricing information in a standardized format.
Key submission requirements include that Gwinnett County does not accept electronic submittals for formal solicitations at this time, and all submissions must be made in accordance with county procedures. Additionally, any firms currently listed on the Gwinnett County ineligible source list or those who have been debarred, suspended, or placed on the list during the relevant period are prohibited from submitting offers or bids. Non-compliant submittals, including those received after the 2:50 p.m. deadline on the due date, will not be considered for evaluation.
Text of this file
CHP BB Pgd
| Playground Renovations at Collins Hill Park | ||||||
| BL#XXXX | ||||||
| Baseball Playground | ||||||
| Equipment Comparison | ||||||
| Revised 12/7/2021 | ||||||
| Name of Bidder | ||||||
| Name of Manufacturer | ||||||
| Date | ||||||
| Play Items - Kid (Age 5-12) | ||||||
| Slides-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90157 | Triple slide | 5' tall,w/curves | ||||
| 90579 | double swerve zip slide | 5' tall, steep double curved steep slide | ||||
| Vertical Climbers-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90244 | Chain Link Climber | 4' tall, stacked metal loops set at right angles | ||||
| 90391 | Overhead climber access ladder | vertical ladder for loop ladder access | ||||
| 90573 | scramble up | 4'6" tall. Four angled bars & flat plasic pieces with hand holes | ||||
| 91500 | Olympus Climber | 5' tall, flat plastic sheet with hand holes & knobs | ||||
| Angled/Horiz/Arch/3D Climbers-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90296 | Wavy Tree climber | 4'6" tall, angled/wavy post with metal loops on sides | ||||
| 90619 | Ergo Climber | Arched bar with climbing knobs, 4' tall | ||||
| 91268 | Sprouts climber | 4 vertical curved metal posts with small spiral steps freestanding between 3 & 4' decks | ||||
| ADA Transfer Stations/Ramps-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Bridges/Tunnels/Connections-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 91538 | Around the World Link | Rails with sphere shape in middle, between decks | metal & rope link with vertical elements & a 3D spherical element to climb around | |||
| Overhead Activities-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Ladder Loop | circular overhead ladder with 10 bars | |||||
| Activity Panels-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 3950 | Roller balls panel insert | large marble balls that can be spun in place (19) | ||||
| 3952 | Twis tBall Bearing insert | Ball Maze that can be spun. | ||||
| 81666 | Fun Seat (2) | bench style seats below deck | ||||
| 90354 | Counter panel | Full width plastic countertop | ||||
| 90425 | letters maze | 2-sided finger maze | ||||
| 91364 | sensory wave panel w/chimes | panel with 2 chime buttons w/auditory sensors & space for an insert | ||||
| 91365 | sensory wave panel w/stained glass | panel with yellow plexiglass window & space for an insert | ||||
| Other Items Attached to Modular Structure-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Rockers/Riders/Spinners-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Freestanding Climbers-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Swings-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| SS8918 | Belt seat (4) | flexible swing seat | ||||
| Other Freestanding Activity Items-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 6201 | Tilted Sky Runner | Large overhead multi-person spinner in tilted post | ||||
| 5916SP | GT Wave | Large net climber with 5' tall slide, HC accessible platform & ramp, suspended crawl-trhu rings, rop bridge, vertical rope climbers & angled net climbers inside it | ||||
| Total scores for play items (Kid): | ||||||
| Play Elements | Proposed | |||||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 0 | 0 | |||||
| Non-Play Items - Kid (Age 5-12) | ||||||
| Decks-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 16700 | square deck (2) | 49" punched steel, vinyl coated, 16 S.F. | ||||
| 16803 | ADA wide trianglular platform (6) | Punched steel, vinyl coated, 8 S.F. | ||||
| 80082 | Slide Transfer platform | +/- 14 S.F. | ||||
| Posts - kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| G90262 | 4' upright, galv.(2) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| G90268 | 10' upright, galv. (4) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| G90269 | 11' Upright, galv. (6) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| G90270 | 12' Upright, galv. (1) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| Steps-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Roofs/Shade - kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 80192 | Sunblox umbrella canopy | +/- 8' diameter shade - 50 s.f. | ||||
| 5193 | Triple Bay Swing Shade | Integral shade canopy on swingset +/-720 s.f. | ||||
| Barrier/Access/Entry Panels-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90306 | Climber archway w/socket & barrier | |||||
| 90336 | climber offset archway w/barrier (2) | |||||
| 90207 | Overhead climber access package | |||||
| 91139 | Entryway barrier | |||||
| 91209 | climber entryway barrier (4) | |||||
| 90216 | Rung Enclosure Barrier | Spare barrier panel for slide/climber replacement | ||||
| 81593 | Ladder loop link | overhead ladder attachment | ||||
| Decorative/Graphic Panels-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Signs/Decorations-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Rubber Wear Pads-Kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 161292 | Rubber wear pads (4) | 44" x 48" x 1", under belt swings | ||||
| Other Non-Play Items - Kid | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Total Scores for Non-Play Items (Kid) | ||||||
| Elements from | Proposed | |||||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 0 | 0 | |||||
| Play Items - Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| Slides-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90507 | Rumble & Roll Zip Slide | Double slide w/textures on bedways, 3' deck | ||||
| 90530 | Littlefoot slide | molded "toes" @exit 2' tall deck | ||||
| Vertical Climbers-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Angled/Horiz/Arch/3D Climbers- Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90250 | Leaning wall climber | 2'-6" tall, plastic sheet with wave & hand holes | ||||
| ADA Transfer Stations/Ramps-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 16805 | ADA Wide ramp (2) | 49"wide punched steel, vinyl coated, 65 SF x2 = 130 SF | ||||
| 90672 | ADA wide ramp (1) | 49"wide punched steel, vinyl coated, 65 SF | ||||
| Bridges/Tunnels/Connections-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Overhead Activities-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Activity Panels-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 3907 | Bells insert | 2 different size bells with attached movable ringer | ||||
| 3931 | Fun Mirror Insert | 2 sided mirror | ||||
| 3943 | Hourglass Insert | 2-sided hourglass, can spin to make sand fall | ||||
| 81664 | Single Thunderring | roller that makes noise | ||||
| 81699 | Bongos | 2 drums mounted on post | ||||
| 90516 | wide enclosure w/double steering wheels | railing with 2 steering wheels | ||||
| 91364 | sensory wave panel w/chimes | panel with 2 chime buttons w/auditory sensors & space for an insert | ||||
| 91365 | sensory wave panel w/stained glass (2) | panel with yellow plexiglass window & space for an insert | ||||
| 91570 | Answer Ball Panel | crystal ball graphic w/star-shaped flaps over the answers | ||||
| Other Items Attached to Modular Structure-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 81669 | Hand Cycler | pedals for arm exercise | ||||
| 81688 | Theraputic Rings | hanging rings for upper-body exercise | ||||
| Rockers/Riders/Spinners-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 16464 | Rock N Raft | Large boat-style rocker w/2 bench seats and space for wheelchair | ||||
| Freestanding Climbers-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 38206 | Ant with Legs | molded ant climber | ||||
| 38100 | Ant Hill | molded Hollow ant nest climber | ||||
| 38225 | Hopper Rock (2) | small climbing boulders | ||||
| 38228 | Plateau Boulder (2) | medium size climbing boulders | ||||
| 38226 | Dome Boulder | medium size climbing boulder | ||||
| 38233 | Forked Balance Beam | wishbone-shaped molded concrete log | ||||
| Swings-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 5145 | Expression Swing (2) | Tandem swing w/tot seat opposite bench seat | ||||
| Other Freestanding Activity Items-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Total scores for play items (Inclusive/Tot) | ||||||
| Play Elements | Proposed | |||||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 0 | 0 | |||||
| Non-Play Items - Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| Decks-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 16700 | square deck (8) | 49" punched steel, vinyl coated, 16 SF x 8 = 128 SF | ||||
| 16803 | ADA wide trianglular platform (9) | Punched steel, vinyl coated, 8 SF x 9 =72 SF | ||||
| 16806 | ADA stepped platform (2) | Punched steel, vinyl coated, 5 SF x 2 = 10 SF | ||||
| Posts - Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90264 | 6' upright (2) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| 90265 | 7' upright (3) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| 90266 | 8' upright (5) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| 90267 | 9' upright (7) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| 90268 | 10' upright (6) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| 90269 | 11' upright (6) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| 90270 | 12' upright (2) | 5" Diameter | ||||
| Steps-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Roofs/Shade - Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 80193 | Sunblox Square Canopy (2) | 20" square shade canopies - +/-800 s.f. | ||||
| QR1208 | Custom shade canopy | cantilevered shade +/- 780 s.f. | ||||
| Barrier/Access/Entry Panels-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 90015 | Wide deck archway w/barrier (2) | |||||
| 90216 | Rung enclosure w/barrier | |||||
| 90396 | 2' Rung kickplate | |||||
| 90493 | wide rung kick plate | |||||
| 91139 | Entryway barrier | |||||
| 91209 | climber entryway barrier | |||||
| 16812 | ADA switchback link | |||||
| Decorative/Graphic Panels-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Signs/Decorations-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 14928 | Inclusive Play Sign Package | Arched metal with plastic insert | ||||
| Rubber Wear Pads-Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Other Non-Play Items - Inclusive/Tot | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 80687 | Handhold/Kickplate package | |||||
| 80689 | Handhold package | |||||
| Total Scores for Non-Play Items (Inclusive/Tot) | ||||||
| Elements from | Proposed | |||||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 0 | 0 | |||||
| General Site/Area Items: | ||||||
| Benches/Picnic Tables/Site Furnishings | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Drainage Materials | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| clean #57 stone | min 4" deep | |||||
| wrapped perforated pipe | 6" Dia. Min. | |||||
| Geotextile fabric | per specs. | |||||
| Other General Site Items | ||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | ||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| Engineered Wood Fiber, per specs. | ||||||
| Concrete Ramps, per plan (2) | ||||||
| 178749 | Owner's kit | maintenance instructions, special tools, touch-up paint, etc. | ||||
| Total Scores for General Site/Area Items | ||||||
| Elements from | Proposed | |||||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 0 | 0 | |||||
| Total Scores for Baseball Playground | ||||||
| Elements from | Proposed | |||||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | |||
| 0 | 0 |
CHP Pav Pgd
| Playground Renovations at Collins Hill Park | |||||||
| BL#XXXX | |||||||
| Pavilion Playground | |||||||
| Equipment Comparison | |||||||
| Revised 12/7/2021 | |||||||
| Name of Bidder | |||||||
| Name of Manufacturer | |||||||
| Date | |||||||
| Play Items - Tot (Age 2-5) | |||||||
| Slides-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Model # | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 90654 | Zip Swerve Slide, right | 4' tall from Mother Tree platform | |||||
| Vertical Climbers-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | model# | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Angled/Horiz/Arch/3D Climbers-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| ADA Transfer Stations/Ramps-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 91332 | Mother Tree Transfer Platform | ADA Height | |||||
| Bridges/Tunnels/Connections-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Overhead Activities-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Model # | Proposed | Description | ||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Activity Panels-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Other Items Attached to Modular Structure-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Rockers/Riders/Spinners-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Freestanding Climbers-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 504TSA | Mother Tree | molded concrete hollow tree with slide | |||||
| Crocodile Climber | molded concrete crocodile | ||||||
| 579TSA | Tree Frog Climber | molded concrete frog | |||||
| 38112 | Log Crawl Through | molded concrete hollow log | |||||
| Swings-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Other Freestanding Activity Items-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Play Elements | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| CPSO-G-IG | Calypso | steel drum w/mallets | |||||
| PBELL-IG-REC | Pagoda Bells | vertical bells w/mallets - True Notes | |||||
| Total scores for play items (Tot) | |||||||
| Play Elements | Proposed | ||||||
| from Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 0 | 0 | ||||||
| Non-Play Items - Tot (Age 2-5) | |||||||
| Decks-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Posts - Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Steps-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 80657 | Access Attachment | ADA steps to Mother Tree, 5' tall | |||||
| Roofs/Shade - Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Barrier/Access/Entry Panels-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Decorative/Graphic Panels-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Signs/Decorations-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 38025 | Tree Dwellers Fun Facts Sign | Educational Sign | |||||
| 38024 | Pond Fun Facts Sign | Educational Sign | |||||
| Rubber Wear Pads-Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Other Non-Play Items - Tot | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Total Scores for Non-Play Items (Tot) | |||||||
| Elements from | Proposed | ||||||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 0 | 0 | ||||||
| General Site/Area Items: | |||||||
| Benches/Picnic Tables/Site Furnishings | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Drainage Materials | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| clean #57 stone | min 4" deep | ||||||
| wrapped perforated pipe | 6" Dia. Min. | ||||||
| Geotextile fabric | per specs. | ||||||
| Other General Site Items | |||||||
| model # | Elements from | Description | Proposed | Description | |||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| Engineered Wood Fiber, per specs. | |||||||
| Concrete Ramp, per plan | |||||||
| Total Scores for General Site/Area Items | |||||||
| Elements from | Proposed | ||||||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 0 | 0 | ||||||
| Total Scores for Pavilion Playground | |||||||
| Elements from | Proposed | ||||||
| Plan | value | Substitution | value | ||||
| 0 | 0 |
Other files
| File | Type | Posted |
|---|---|---|
| BL020-22 Addendum #1 | — | |
| BL020-22 Invitation to Bid | — | |
| Award Information | — | |
| Plans | — |
On GovTribe
Work with this file
- Download the original file
- Contacts named in this file
- Similar government files
- Ask GovTribe AI about this file
File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated .