Asbestos-Lead_survey_2016-03-17.pdf

ENV\OH39762,BSR_PbC,GSA.doc

March 17, 2016

Mr. Byron Durham General Service Administration 230 South Dearborn Street, Room 3180 Chicago, Illinois 60604

RE: Asbestos and Lead Survey

Stairwell Dilution Venting, AJ Celebrezze Federal Building, Cleveland, Ohio

OH39762

Description of Work

EA Group, Mentor, Ohio was contracted by General Service Administration to conduct a survey for suspect asbestos-containing materials (ACM) limited to designated shafts and stairwells to be affected by dilution venting when new air handlers are installed in the AJ Celebrezze Federal Building at 1240 East 9th Street in Cleveland, Ohio. Representative painted surfaces were also sampled for lead content analysis. Surveying and sampling activities were performed by EA Group representative Paul Brown on March 7, 2016.

Asbestos Survey

EA Group’s licensed Asbestos Hazard Evaluation Specialist Paul Brown, ES31234, inspected the designated areas, developed a sampling strategy, and procured bulk samples of suspect ACMs on March 7, 2016. Homogeneous groups of suspect ACMs are identified on the Asbestos Inspection Data Sheet forms in Appendix A. Classification of any positively identified ACM has been made per National Emission Standard for Hazardous Air Pollutants (NESHAP) regulations, with notations for compliance with Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) regulations, if and where applicable. Sampling locations are provided on the attached field drawings in Appendix A.

Analytical results are detailed in the laboratory report in Appendix B.

Objective and Limitations of the Inspection

The objective of this survey was to identify and sample suspect ACM associated with shafts and stairwells to be affected by dilution venting when new air handlers are installed in the AJ Celebrezze Federal Building at 1240 East 9th Street in Cleveland, Ohio, pursuant to NESHAP and OSHA regulations. Sampling was limited to accessible areas on the 32nd Floor, 31st Floor and 16th Floor, as designated by the GSA representative. No other materials or areas were evaluated.

It is noted that roofing materials were not to be sampled.

General Services Administration Asbestos and Lead Survey Stairwell Dilution Venting, AJ Celebrezze Federal Building, Cleveland, Ohio

GENERAL LIMITATIONS

1. The work did not constitute a “survey” or “inspection” for the presence of suspect ACM, and was limited to “client-directed sampling.”

2. Additional asbestos materials, not previously identified or quantified, are frequently encountered during renovation or demolition.

3. Actual quantities of asbestos material may vary from any estimates provided in EA Group’s report due to identification of additional materials and difficulties in quantifying hidden or inaccessible materials.

4. Prior to alteration or renovation of any structure or equipment, suspect materials that were previously inaccessible or excluded from sampling should be sampled and analyzed for asbestos.

Asbestos Analysis

The bulk samples were analyzed by polarized light microscopy for asbestos content at or through the Laboratory Division of EA Group, which is accredited by the National Institute of Standards and Technology – National Voluntary Laboratory Accreditation Program. The United States Environmental Protection Agency requires all materials containing greater than one percent asbestos by weight to be considered asbestos-containing materials. Composite or layered analyses were performed, depending on the nature of the material. Analytical results are provided in Appendix B.

Results of Asbestos Analysis

Five homogeneous material groups were identified, with 17 representative samples being collected from four of these groups. The remaining group consisted of transite wall panels labeled as ACM, which were therefore not sampled and are considered known ACM. The materials that were sampled as suspect and were determined to be ACM are identified in Table 1, which also includes materials determined to be non-ACM and known ACM.

Any activities that involve the handling of ACM should be carried out by a licensed abatement contractor or other appropriately trained personnel in accordance with all applicable regulations.

Paint Chip Sampling of Suspect Lead-Based Paint

It is noted that green paint on the HVAC equipment in the 31st floor Mechanical Room was labeled “lead paint” and was not sampled. Representative samples of other paints from five different surfaces

General Services Administration Asbestos and Lead Survey Stairwell Dilution Venting, AJ Celebrezze Federal Building, Cleveland, Ohio were secured for lead content analysis. Each sample was placed in a 4-mil resealable plastic bag, given a unique sample identification number, and then transported to the Laboratory Division of EA Group for analysis, in accordance with U.S. EPA SW846 Method 6010B. Results are summarized in Table 2, attached, and detailed in the laboratory analytical report in Appendix B.

The U.S. EPA defines paint that contains more than 5000 milligrams per kilogram (mg/kg) [equivalent to parts per million (ppm)] of lead as lead-based paint (LBP). The Consumer Product Safety Act “Ban of Lead-containing Paint and Certain Consumer Products Bearing Lead-Based Paint” defines paint that contains more than 600 mg/kg as lead-containing paint. OSHA regulates potential employee exposure to lead, regardless of the concentration of lead in the paint.

As shown in Table 2, in addition to the above-mentioned paint labeled “lead paint,” four of the five samples had detectable concentrations of lead, all below those defining lead-based paint or lead-containing paint. All contractors who will be disturbing the painted surfaces where lead was detected should be provided a copy of these results so they are able to follow required OSHA regulations.

If you have any questions or concerns regarding the above information, please contact the undersigned. Thank you for consulting EA Group.

Sincerely, EA Group

Timothy S. Bowen, Paul Brown, Vice President/Technical Director ES31234

Table 1. Summary of Results ‐ AJ Celebrezze Federal Building, Shafts/Stairwells (Dilution Venting)

ID #

OH39762

A 01 Spray‐On Fireproofing S 0

A 02 Spray‐On Fireproofing S 0

A 03 Spray‐On Fireproofing S 0

A 04 Spray‐On Fireproofing S 0

A 05 Spray‐On Fireproofing S 0

A 06 Spray‐On Fireproofing S 0

A 07 Spray‐On Fireproofing S 0

B 08 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard Fittings T [+]

B 09 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard Fittings T [+]

B 10 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard Fittings T [+]

B 11 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard Fittings T [+]

C Known ACM Transite Panel; Wall M/NF2 [+]

D 12 Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering T 0

D 13 Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering T 0

D 14 Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering T 0

E 15 Duct Mastic; Gray M/NF2 0

E 16 Duct Mastic; Gray M/NF2 0

E 17 Duct Mastic; Gray M/NF2 0

Group = Homogeneous Group identification

Material Type: S = Surfacing

T = Thermal System Insulation

M = Miscellaneous

NF1 = Non‐Friable Category I

NF2 = Non‐Friable Category II

Result: 0 = non‐ACM

[+] = ACM

RESULTGroup MATERIAL DESCRIPTION Material

Type

ASB\OH39762,GSA,IDS.xls EA GROUP

Table 2. Summary of Paint Chip Sample Analysis for Lead

General Services Administration ‐ IL

AJ Celebrezze Federal Building, Shafts/Stairwells (Dilution Venting)

March 7, 2016 Sampling

Location Component Color

OH39762‐ 01Pb Room 3234, Northeast Area Duct, Steel Beige 256

OH39762‐ 02Pb Pillar, Corner of 32 Storage Concrete Beige 202

OH39762‐ 03Pb Room 3219 Cinderblock Beige 141

OH39762‐ 04Pb Room 3282 Duct, Steel Beige 50.4

OH39762‐ 05Pb Wall, 16th Floor Duct Shaft Wall Plaster White < 25

Results expressed in milligrams per kilogram (mg/kg).

‡ = Lead‐based paint as defined by U.S. EPA (>5000 mg/kg)

† = Lead‐containing paint as defined by Consumer Product Safety Act (>600 mg/kg)

OSHA regulations apply to any detectable concentration of lead

Note: Green paint on HVAC equipment in 31st Floor Mechanical Room is labeled "lead paint."

Lead

Content Sample ID

ENV\OH39762,PbC.xls EA GROUP

APPENDIX A

Floor Plans Showing Sampling Locations and

Asbestos Inspection Data Sheet(s)

Room/Area Designations and Sampling Locations AJ Celebrezze Federal Building

1240 East 9th Street, Cleveland, Ohio

F :\P

R O

JE

C

T S

\E N

V \O

H

G

E N

E R

A

LS

E R

V

IC

E S

A D

M

IN

\3

2, G S

A ,D

W G

.V S

D

OH39762 Date: Figure 1EAG No. March 17, 2016

EA GROUP

DRAWING FOR GENERAL REFERENCE PURPOSES ONLY.

BASE PROVIDED BY CLIENT, ACTUAL ROOM CONFIGURATIONS MAY DIFFER FROM THOSE SHOWN; ANNOTATIONS BY EA GROUP.

REFER TO SURVEY FOR DETAILS.

NO SCALE.

11 = asbestos sample number/general location

KEY

01Pb = paint sample number/general location

32nd Level

Duct shaftSouth stairs

Hallway

16th Level

HVAC Unit

Mezz steps

31st Level NW Mechanical Room

15 16

05 07

06 04

09 12

GSA

Storage 01

05Pb

04Pb

02Pb

03Pb

01Pb

EA GROUP

ASBESTOS INSPECTION DATA SHEET KEY

Client and Project Information provided by either Work Order or Scope of Work

Building - Name or address of building.

Functional Space - A room, group of rooms, or homogeneous area designated by the inspector to prepare management plans, design abatement projects, or conduct response actions.

Group No. - An arbitrary number/letter assigned to each homogeneous material (material that is uniform in color and texture, serves the same function, and was installed at the same time) encountered during sampling.

ID # - A sample number assigned by the inspector which begins with the work order number (OH XXXXX) at the top of the column and then a unique sample number for each sample.

Material Description - Distinguishing characteristics that may include system type, function, size, color, shape etc.

Location - Location of homogeneous material being sampled or occurrence of homogeneous material.

Quantity - Defined as linear footage (LF), square footage (SF), or number of fittings or miscellaneous items, each (EA)

Material Type - Abbreviations provided on the form as:

S - Surfacing Material (troweled or sprayed-on) NF1 - Non-friable Category I T - Thermal System Insulation NF2 - Non-friable Category II M - Miscellaneous

Material Condition ND - No Damage. The material is in visibly good condition with no apparent damage.

D - Damage. Material that has "Damage" is defined as damage to less than 10% of the entire homogeneous group or less than 25% of a localized section of the homogeneous group.

SD - Significant Damage. Material that is "Significantly Damaged" is defined as damage to greater than 10% of the entire homogeneous group or greater than 25% of a localized section of the homogeneous group.

Cause of Damage - P - Physical. Vandalism or accidental damage D - Deterioration. Deterioration from age

W - Water. Water damage Other - Additional influences that may cause damage

Present Disturbance Factors - Visible, Accessible, Air Movement, Activity, and Friable

Visible - Can it be seen; Yes or No Accessible - Yes - The material is accessible to both the occupants of the building and custodial and maintenance personnel.

No - The material is not easily accessible to people; i.e., crawl spaces, pipe tunnels, pipe chases, etc.

Air Movement - Low - No air flow/plenum; air flow not recognizable to human touch.

Medium - Air flow/plenum present; noticeable air flow; recognizable to human touch.

High - Air flow/plenum/air handling unit/fan present; steady to gusty air flow; air flow obvious to human touch.

Activity - Low - No traffic/vibrations.

Medium - Moderate traffic and/or vibration.

High - High traffic and/or continuous vibration.

Friable - A material is considered friable if, when dry, it may be crumbled, pulverized, or reduced to powder by hand pressure.

Present Potential for Damage - Low Potential for Damage - Accessibility, Influence for Vibration and Air Erosion must be no, low or insignificant.

Potential for Damage - Accessible with any combination of low or medium ratings in the Influence for Vibration and Air Erosion categories Potential for Significant Damage - Accessible with any combination with a high rating in Influence of Vibration and Air Erosion categories.

Hazard Assessment - Abbreviations provided on the form: PD = Potential for Damage; PSD = Potential for Significant Damage; 0 and Alphabetical abbreviations will be provided during reporting.

Client: General Services Administration ‐ IL Building: AJ Celebrezze Federal Building

Project: Pre‐Alteration Asbestos Survey Functional Space: Shafts/Stairwells (Dilution Venting)

ID #

OH39762

Type Cond

32nd Floor (Southwest) A 01 Spray‐On Fireproofing 2100 0

B 08 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard

Fittings

135 LF [12 EA] T Y [+]

C Known

ACM

Transite Panel; Wall 700 M/NF2 N [+]

Labeled "ACM"

32nd Floor (Southwest), GSA Storage A 02 Spray‐On Fireproofing 4800 0

B 09 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard

Fittings

200 LF [19 EA] T Y [+]

C Known

ACM

Transite Panel; Wall 520 M/NF2 N [+]

Labeled "ACM"

D 12 Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering 0

32nd Floor, Room 3219 A 03 Spray‐On Fireproofing 4100 0

B ‐‐‐ Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard

Fittings

300 LF [20 EA] T Y [+]

ASBESTOS INSPECTION DATA SHEET

NOTESGroup MATERIAL DESCRIPTION Quantity RESULT Material

LOCATION

FR

IA

B

LE

Fittings

C Known

ACM

Transite Panel; Wall 1200 M/NF2 N [+]

Labeled "ACM"

D 13 Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering 0

MATERIALS: QUANTITY = Square Feet unless noted COMMENTS:

TYPE: LF = Linear Feet; EA = each

S ‐ Surfacing Sampling limited to designated material(s) in designated area(s) T ‐ Thermal FRIABLE:

M ‐ Miscellaneous Y = Regulated ACM (RACM) by definition

NF1 ‐ Non‐friable Cat. I N = not RACM by definition

NF2 ‐ Non‐friable Cat. II NF1/NF2 may be friable due to condition

N/S = not suspect or may become friable during reno/demo

CONDITION: [if relevant] RESULT:

ND ‐ No Damage 0 ‐ Non‐ACM

D ‐ Damage [+] = ACM [no other assessment required]

SD ‐ Significant Damage B = Verified by layering/point counting

EA GROUP EAG Technician(s): Paul Brown ES 31234 EAG OH39762 7118 Industrial Park Blvd.

Mentor, OH 44060‐5314

(440) 951‐3514 Survey Date(s): March 7, 2016 Page 1 of 3

ID #

OH39762

Type Cond

32nd Floor, Room 3282 A ‐‐‐ Spray‐On Fireproofing 3750 0

B ‐‐‐ Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard

Fittings

400 LF [26 EA] T Y [+]

C Known

ACM

Transite Panel; Wall 4000 M/NF2 N [+]

Labeled "ACM"

D ‐‐‐ Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering 0

32nd Floor, Room 3285 A ‐‐‐ Spray‐On Fireproofing 3125 0

B ‐‐‐ Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard

Fittings

100 LF [11 EA] T Y [+]

C Known

ACM

Transite Panel; Wall 2800 M/NF2 N [+]

Labeled "ACM"

D ‐‐‐ Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering 0

16th Floor Shaft B 10 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard

Fittings

155 LF [33 EA] T Y [+]

ASBESTOS INSPECTION DATA SHEET

LOCATION Group MATERIAL DESCRIPTION Quantity Material

FR

IA

B

LE

RESULT NOTES

D 14 Duct Insulation; Fiberglass w/ covering 0

E 15 Duct Mastic; Gray 0

E 16 Duct Mastic; Gray 0

E 17 Duct Mastic; Gray 0

MATERIALS: QUANTITY = Square Feet unless noted COMMENTS:

TYPE: LF = Linear Feet; EA = each

S ‐ Surfacing Sampling limited to designated material(s) in designated area(s) T ‐ Thermal FRIABLE:

M ‐ Miscellaneous Y = Regulated ACM (RACM) by definition

NF1 ‐ Non‐friable Cat. I N = not RACM by definition

NF2 ‐ Non‐friable Cat. II NF1/NF2 may be friable due to condition

N/S = not suspect or may become friable during reno/demo

CONDITION: [if relevant] RESULT:

ND ‐ No Damage 0 ‐ Non‐ACM

D ‐ Damage [+] = ACM [no other assessment required]

SD ‐ Significant Damage B = Verified by layering/point counting

EA GROUP EAG Technician(s): Paul Brown ES 31234 EAG OH39762 7118 Industrial Park Blvd.

(440) 951‐3514 Survey Date(s): March 7, 2016 Page 2 of 3

ID #

OH39762

Type Cond

31st Floor (Northwest), Mechanical Room A 04 Spray‐On Fireproofing 0

A 05 Spray‐On Fireproofing 0

A 06 Spray‐On Fireproofing 0

A 07 Spray‐On Fireproofing 0

B 11 Pipe Insulation on Fiberglass Lines w/ Hard

Fittings

250 LF [50 EA] T Y [+]

C Known

ACM

Transite Panel; Wall 4060 M/NF2 N [+]

Labeled "ACM"

ASBESTOS INSPECTION DATA SHEET

LOCATION Group MATERIAL DESCRIPTION Quantity Material

FR

IA

B

LE

RESULT NOTES

MATERIALS: QUANTITY = Square Feet unless noted COMMENTS:

TYPE: LF = Linear Feet; EA = each

S ‐ Surfacing Sampling limited to designated material(s) in designated area(s) T ‐ Thermal FRIABLE:

M ‐ Miscellaneous Y = Regulated ACM (RACM) by definition

NF1 ‐ Non‐friable Cat. I N = not RACM by definition

NF2 ‐ Non‐friable Cat. II NF1/NF2 may be friable due to condition

N/S = not suspect or may become friable during reno/demo

CONDITION: [if relevant] RESULT:

ND ‐ No Damage 0 ‐ Non‐ACM

D ‐ Damage [+] = ACM [no other assessment required]

SD ‐ Significant Damage B = Verified by layering/point counting

EA GROUP EAG Technician(s): Paul Brown ES 31234 EAG OH39762 7118 Industrial Park Blvd.

(440) 951‐3514 Survey Date(s): March 7, 2016 Page 3 of 3

APPENDIX B

Laboratory Analytical Report(s)

EA Group Workorder Number:

Client Project:

The following analytical report contains results as requested for samples submitted to EA Group. The results included in this report have been reviewed for compliance with the analytical methods indicated in this report. All data has been found to be compliant with accepted laboratory protocol, except as noted in the QC narrative. Industrial hygiene reports, air and/or surface concentrations results are based upon sampling information provided by the client. Industrial hygiene results will not be blank corrected. Analyst initials of REF indicate analysis performed at a subcontract facility.

160300107

Byron Durham

General Services Admin.

Received on March 7, 2016

If you have questions, comments or require further assistance regarding this report, please contact your client services representative or one of the individuals listed below.

Data or reporting:

Debbie Lauer - Lab Manager Mike Herbert - General Manager dlauer@eagroupohio.com mherbert@eagroupohio.com

Sample tracking, supplies:

Haley Imler - Sample Control sreceiving@eagroupohio.com

Invoice Related:

Bonnie Renbarger - Office Manager brenbarger@eagroupohio.com

Reproduction of this report is prohibited except in its entirety . Unless noted, soil, sludge and sediment results are reported on dry weight basis. The "Sample Reporting Limit" is based on the method used for analysis and does not refer to any regulatory limit. These results relate only to the items tested.

7118 Industrial Park Blvd. , Mentor, Ohio 44060-5314

(440) 951-3514 (800) 875-3514 FAX (440) 951-3774 www.eagroupohio.com

230 S. Dearborn St., #3180 Chicago, IL 60604

A.J. Celebrezze Fed. Bldg Stairwell Dilution Venting

701710

Laboratory Analytical Report

230 S. Dearborn St., #3180

General Services Admin.

Chicago, IL 60604

Project Identification

Byron Durham Attention:

Purchase Order:

EA Group

1603-00107 Order Number

March 15, 2016

7118 Industrial Park Blvd., Mentor, Ohio 44060-5314

(440) 951-3514 (800) 875-3514 FAX (440) 951-3774 www.eagroupohio.com

OH39762

Carl R. Eggebraaten Microscopist

Deborah L. Lauer Laboratory Manager

A.J. Celebrezze Fed. Bldg Stairwell Dilution Venting

The following analytical report contains the results as requested for samples submitted to EA Group. The results included in this report have been reviewed for compliance with the analytical methods indicated in this report. All data have been found to be compliant with accepted laboratory protocol. Exceptions, if any, are noted below.

Project Summary

Sample Summary

Sample Receive Date:

EAG

Sample Identification

Client EAG Sample Identification

Client Sample Identification

3/ 7/2016

Sample Identification

160300107-01A OH39762-1 160300107-02A OH39762-2

160300107-03A OH39762-3 160300107-04A OH39762-4

160300107-05A OH39762-5 160300107-06A OH39762-6

160300107-07A OH39762-7 160300107-08A OH39762-8

160300107-09A OH39762-9 160300107-10A OH39762-10

160300107-11A OH39762-11 160300107-12A OH39762-12

160300107-12B OH39762-12 160300107-13A OH39762-13

160300107-13B OH39762-13 160300107-14A OH39762-14

160300107-14B OH39762-14 160300107-15A OH39762-15

160300107-16A OH39762-16 160300107-17A OH39762-17

Quality Control Narrative

This report contains data which was produced by a subcontracted laboratory

NVLAP Lab Code 101165-0 for Asbestos Analysis.

IATL, Inc.

9000 Commerce Parkway, Suite B

Mt. Laurel, NJ 08054

Reproduction of this report is prohibited except in its entirety. Unless noted, soil, sludge, and sediment results are reported on dry weight basis.

The "Sample Reporting Limit" is based on the method used for analysis and does not refer to any regulatory limit.

1603-00107Workorder: 1Page:

EAG ID: 1603-00107-01A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-1

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Tan insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-02A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-2

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Tan insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-03A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-3

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Tan insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-04A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-4

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Tan insulation

1603-00107Workorder: 2Page:

EAG ID: 1603-00107-05A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-5

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Tan insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-06A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-6

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Tan insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-07A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-7

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Tan insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-08A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-8

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos 20 % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 80

Sample Physical Description: White/silver/yellow wrap/insulation

1603-00107Workorder: 3Page:

EAG ID: 1603-00107-09A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-9

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos 20 % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 80 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: White/tan/silver/yellow wrap/insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-10A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-10

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos 15 % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 85 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: White/tan/silver/yellow wrap/insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-11A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-11

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos 20 % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 80 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: White/tan/green/silver/yellow wrap/insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-12A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-12

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100

Sample Physical Description: Off-white wrap

1603-00107Workorder: 4Page:

EAG ID: 1603-00107-12B Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-12

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Yellow insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-13A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-13

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Off-white/gray wrap

EAG ID: 1603-00107-13B Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-13

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Yellow/gray insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-14A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-14

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100

Sample Physical Description: Brown/silver wrap

1603-00107Workorder: 5Page:

EAG ID: 1603-00107-14B Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-14

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Yellow insulation

EAG ID: 1603-00107-15A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-15

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Gray caulk

EAG ID: 1603-00107-16A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-16

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100 Analysis Comments NA Sample Physical Description: Gray caulk

EAG ID: 1603-00107-17A Client ID:

Parameter Result

Analyst: REFDate Analyzed:Date Received: 03/07/2016Date Sampled: 03/07/2016 BulkMatrix:OH39762-17

03/13/2016

Asbestos Analysis - Bulk % Chrysotile Asbestos ND % Amosite Asbestos ND % Crocidolite Asbestos ND % Other Asbestos Fibers ND % Other Non-Asbestos Mat'ls 100

Sample Physical Description: Gray caulk

160300107Workorder:

These samples were analyzed as received for percentage composition of Asbestos and Non-Asbestos materials by Method(s) EPA-600/M4-82-020, December 1982 and/or EPA/600/R 93/116 July 1993, which have Detection Limits of less than 1% Asbestos.

The measurement of asbestos percentage is determined by visual estimation. Uncertainty is calculated quarterly in accordance with NISTIR 5951 by Verkouteren and Duewer. Please contact EA Group for the most recent information.

Asbestos Containing Materials (ACM) and Presumed Asbestos Containing Materials (PACM) are regulated by several different governmental regulatory agencies.

EPA NESHAP regulations cover certain buildings that are to be renovated or demolished. NESHAP regulations require that when a sample (or layer of a multi-layered sample) is analyzed and found to contain asbestos at a concentration of less than 10% by a method other than point counting by Polarized Light Microscopy (PLM), the owner/operator has the option of:

1) Assuming the amount to be greater than 1% and treating the material as regulated ACM .

OR

2) Requesting verification of the amount by point counting.

Building owners/operators covered by NESHAP should review the following for the full and specific regulations:

1) Federal Register, Vol. 55, No. 224, Tuesday, November 20, 1990

2) Clarification of NESHAP requirement to perform point counting, May 8, 1991

3) Federal Register, Vol. 59, No. 3, Wednesday, January 5, 1994

4) Federal Register, Vol. 59, No. 146, Monday, August 1, 1994

5) Federal Register, Vol. 60, No. 243, Tuesday, December 19, 1995

Building owners/operators and employers covered by OSHA regulations also have specific requirements regarding ACM and PACM.

Those who may be covered by these regulations should review 29 CFR 1910.1001 and 29 CFR 1926.1101 for specific requirements.

FLOOR TILES: PLM should only be considered a screening method for floor tile analysis. Any floor tile with a result of one percent or less asbestos by PLM should be assumed positive for asbestos until the sample is re-analyzed by Analytical Electron Microscopy.

Other difficult matrices (such as bituminous, organically bound, and cementitious materials) may obscure very small asbestos fibers.

Some samples may also contain asbestos fibers with diameters below the limit of resolution of the optical microscopes used in typical PLM analysis.

Therefore, negative results by PLM on these materials should be confirmed by Analytical Electron Microscopy.

EA Group has a sample retention policy of at least 30 days. After that time, the samples will be disposed of unless the client has requested that they be returned. The client will be charged a shipping and handling fee associated with returned samples only.

Key to analysis comments (if noted on samples):

* Asbestos content in this sample has been verified by the Chalkley point counting procedure.

** The client has the option of requesting verification of this analytical result by point counting as specified by the NESHAP standards .

*** Insufficient sample amount for quantitation and/or performing Quality Control functions.

**** Due to the nature of the sample (dust, debris, soil, or vacuum), percentages for the constituents could not be assigned.

+ After gravimetric reduction, the residue has been visually estimated as at least 10% asbestos. Therefore, point counting is not required to satisfy NESHAP requirements.

++ Contains fibers that may be an asbestos mineral but could not be positively identified by PLM. Analysis by Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) is recommended.

+++ See additional comment under Quality Control Narrative.

# This sample contains vermiculite mineral. It is not vermiculite attic insulation.

ND None Detected Trace Observed but less than 1% NH Non-Homogeneous sample, the result reflects the average.

Und. non-asb Undetermined non-asbestos fibers

This report applies only to sample(s) analyzed and may not be used by the client to claim product certification, approval, or endorsement by NVLAP or any agency of the U.S. Government.

EA Group Workorder Number:

Client Project:

The following analytical report contains results as requested for samples submitted to EA Group. The results included in this report have been reviewed for compliance with the analytical methods indicated in this report. All data has been found to be compliant with accepted laboratory protocol, except as noted in the QC narrative. Industrial hygiene reports, air and/or surface concentrations results are based upon sampling information provided by the client. Industrial hygiene results will not be blank corrected. Analyst initials of REF indicate analysis performed at a subcontract facility.

160300105

Byron Durham

General Services Admin.

Received on March 7, 2016

If you have questions, comments or require further assistance regarding this report, please contact your client services representative or one of the individuals listed below.

Data or reporting:

Debbie Lauer - Lab Manager Mike Herbert - General Manager dlauer@eagroupohio.com mherbert@eagroupohio.com

Sample tracking, supplies:

Haley Imler - Sample Control sreceiving@eagroupohio.com

Invoice Related:

Bonnie Renbarger - Office Manager brenbarger@eagroupohio.com

Reproduction of this report is prohibited except in its entirety . Unless noted, soil, sludge and sediment results are reported on dry weight basis. The "Sample Reporting Limit" is based on the method used for analysis and does not refer to any regulatory limit. These results relate only to the items tested.

7118 Industrial Park Blvd. , Mentor, Ohio 44060-5314

(440) 951-3514 (800) 875-3514 FAX (440) 951-3774 www.eagroupohio.com

230 S. Dearborn St., #3180 Chicago, IL 60604

A.J. Celebrezze 'Stairwell Dilution Venting'

701710

Laboratory Analytical Report

230 S. Dearborn St., #3180

General Services Admin.

Chicago, IL 60604

Client Project:

Byron Durham

Attention:

EA Group Workorder:

1603-00105

Deborah L. Lauer

Laboratory Manager

March 14, 2016

7118 Industrial Park Blvd. , Mentor, Ohio 44060-5314

(440) 951-3514 (800) 875-3514 FAX (440) 951-3774 www.eagroupohio.com

A.J. Celebrezze 'Stairwell Dilution Venting'

Sample Listing

Sample Receive Date

EAG

Sample Identification

Client EAG Sample Identification

Client Sample Identification

3/ 7/2016

Sample Identification

160300105 001- OH39762-1Pb 160300105 002- OH39762-2Pb

160300105 003- OH39762-3Pb 160300105 004- OH39762-4Pb

160300105 005- OH39762-5Pb

Project Narrative 1603-00105

Updated 7/29/09

All analyses performed by EA Group were done using established laboratory SOPs. Management has reviewed the data for compliance with the laboratory QA/QC plan and data have been found to be compliant with the laboratory protocols unless otherwise noted below. All results listed for this report relate only to the samples submitted on this work order.

The temperature of the sample(s) upon receipt was 20oC.

Misc. QC Comments

Percent Moisture is used to report results on a dry weight basis.

When necessary, reporting limits of individual samples may be raised due to high concentration of interfering compounds or target analytes, or quantity of sample available for analysis.

pH method note: If this analysis was performed in the laboratory, it may not meet the "immediate analysis" requirement that applies to most wastewater monitoring samples. In such cases, analysis for pH should be done at the time of sampling.

The results listed in this report relate only to the samples submitted to EA Group per the chain of custody.

Data Flag Table

B The method blank contained a standard laboratory contaminant (Methylene Chloride, Acetone, Hexane, Phthalates, etc.)

above the standard laboratory method detection limit. If the analyte is present in the sample at a concentration up to ten times the blank level, the result is reported with a “B” indicating method blank contamination. Samples will be reported without a “B” if the analyte concentration in the sample is greater than ten times the blank level.

E An analytical result marked with an “E” indicates the result reported is above the high end limit of the calibration curve and should be considered an estimated concentration.

DIL Due to matrix interference or high analyte concentration, a dilution was required. The spikes and/or surrogates results could not be quantitated and therefore marked “DIL”.

J An analytical result marked with a “J” indicates the result reported was below the standard reporting limit and above the method detection limit. As the observed level approaches the MDL there is an increasing probability of a false positive response.

MI Analytical results marked as “MI” indicate that due to inherent matrix interference, the result could not be quantitated.

# Results flagged “#” indicate the reported result may be outside allowable permit levels as provided by the client, when applicable.

NA A result or field marked as “NA” indicates that it was not applicable for this project.

Q A quality control result flagged with a “Q” indicates the percent recovery was outside the acceptable range as determined by the laboratory.

** Positive results for this analyte represent a probable combination of 3-Methylphenol (m-Cresol) and 4-Methylphenol (p-Cresol).

EAG Workorder: 1603-00105

Client Project: A.J. Celebrezze 'Stairwell Dilution Venting'

Parameter UnitsResult Limit

Client ID:

EAG ID: 1603-00105-1

3/07/2016Date/Time Sampled:

Reporting Date

OH39762-1Pb Received: 3/07/2016

AnalystCAS # Prep Date

/ 1000

Time Analysis

Lead in Paint: SW846-6010B 256 46 mg/kg 3/10/2016 3/14/2016 CMB7439-92-1

Parameter UnitsResult Limit

Client ID:

EAG ID: 1603-00105-2

3/07/2016Date/Time Sampled:

Reporting Date

OH39762-2Pb Received: 3/07/2016

AnalystCAS # Prep Date

/ 1000

Time Analysis

Lead in Paint: SW846-6010B 202 41 mg/kg 3/10/2016 3/14/2016 CMB7439-92-1

Parameter UnitsResult Limit

Client ID:

EAG ID: 1603-00105-3

3/07/2016Date/Time Sampled:

Reporting Date

OH39762-3Pb Received: 3/07/2016

AnalystCAS # Prep Date

/ 1000

Time Analysis

Lead in Paint: SW846-6010B 141 25 mg/kg 3/10/2016 3/14/2016 CMB7439-92-1

Parameter UnitsResult Limit

Client ID:

EAG ID: 1603-00105-4

3/07/2016Date/Time Sampled:

Reporting Date

OH39762-4Pb Received: 3/07/2016

AnalystCAS # Prep Date

/ 1000

Time Analysis

Lead in Paint: SW846-6010B 50.4 25 mg/kg 3/10/2016 3/14/2016 CMB7439-92-1

Parameter UnitsResult Limit

Client ID:

EAG ID: 1603-00105-5

3/07/2016Date/Time Sampled:

Reporting Date

OH39762-5Pb Received: 3/07/2016

AnalystCAS # Prep Date

/ 1000

Time Analysis mg/kg25 3/14/20163/10/2016<25Lead in Paint: SW846-6010B CMB 7439-92-1