Score Summary.pdf

This document is an RFP evaluation scorecard for a procurement involving five proposing companies: Boelter & Lincoln, Madison Ave. Worldwide, Affirm, Nonbox, and Nelson Schmidt. The evaluation covers two main sections with Section 4.0 "Proposer Information and Solutions" weighted at 75% (1,500 points) and Section 6.0 "Cost Proposal" weighted at 25% (500 points), for a total possible score of 2,000 points.

The procurement appears to be for marketing and communications services, with technical evaluation criteria including Presentation (400 points), Public Relations (250 points), Advertising (200 points), Management Qualifications (100 points), Creativity (200 points), Staff Qualifications (100 points), Research, Planning and Analysis Services (150 points), and Proposer Solutions (100 points). Based on the total scores, Affirm achieved the highest ranking with 1,694 points, followed by Boelter & Lincoln with 1,526 points, Madison Ave. Worldwide with 1,308 points, Nelson Schmidt with 665 points, and Nonbox with 570 points. Notably, Affirm received the maximum 500 points for the cost proposal section, while Nonbox and Nelson Schmidt received zero points for both the cost proposal and presentation sections, indicating potential non-responsive proposals.