Pre-Solicitation_PD_comments_19_April.xlsx

XLSX spreadsheet 17 KB Posted Apr 19, 2013

Attached to: TW and HW RAT Boots
Solicitation number: M67854-13-R-1017
Issued by: United States Marine Corps

About this file

From the source

Responses to Pre-Solicitation Questions concerning 28 January 2013 Purchase Descriptions.

View the file

Other files

File	Type	Posted
13R1017_Amendment_0001_Attachment_J4_Fair_Opportunity_Ordering_Procedures.pdf	PDF	Aug 14, 2013
13R1017_Amendment_0001_Attachment_J1_TW_RAT_Boot_Purchase_Description_12_August_2013.pdf	PDF	Aug 14, 2013
13R1017_Amendment_0001.pdf	PDF	Aug 14, 2013
Responses_to_Industry_Questions_14_August.pdf	PDF	Aug 14, 2013
13R1017_Amendment_0001_Attachment_J2_HW_RAT_Boot_Purchase_Description_12_August_2013.pdf	PDF	Aug 14, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J2_HW_RAT_Boot_Purchase_Description_6_May_2013.pdf	PDF	Jul 30, 2013
13R1017_RFP_30_July.pdf	PDF	Jul 30, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J4_Fair_Opportunity_Ordering_Procedures.pdf	PDF	Jul 30, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J3_Contract_Data_List_Requirements_(updated_10_May).pdf	PDF	Jul 30, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J5_Past_Performance_Questionnaire.pdf	PDF	Jul 30, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J6_Past_Performance_Participant_Summary.pdf	PDF	Jul 30, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J1_TW_RAT_Boot_Purchase_Description_6_May_2013.pdf	PDF	Jul 30, 2013
13R1017_TW_PD_comments.xls	XLS spreadsheet	May 31, 2013
13R1017_HW_PD_comments.xls	XLS spreadsheet	May 31, 2013
RAT_TW_Boot_PD_6_May_13.pdf	PDF	May 31, 2013
RAT_HW_Boot_PD_6_May_13.pdf	PDF	May 31, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J2_HW_RAT_Boot_Purchase_Description_19_April_2013.doc	DOC document	Apr 19, 2013
13R1017_Attachment_J1_TW_RAT_Boot_Purchase_Description_19_April_2013.doc	DOC document	Apr 19, 2013
TW_RAT_Boot_PD_JAN_2013.pdf	PDF	Jan 30, 2013
HW_RAT_Boot_PD_JAN_2013.pdf	PDF	Jan 30, 2013

Show all 20

On GovTribe

Work with this file

Download the original file
Contacts named in this file
Similar government files
Ask GovTribe AI about this file

Try for free Login

Text version

The file's text, extracted by GovTribe without its formatting.

HW PD updates

Comments on RAT Hot Weather Marine Corps. Boot RAT PD 12-02

Draft 28 Jan 2013

Item	Section	Page	Comment	Response
1	3.4.3 Gusset	9	1)Figures 2A and 2B do not show the gusset of the boot so the desired construction can be observed.	Figures 2A and 2B have been updated in PD dated 19 April 2013.
			2)With a fabric gusset a leather eyelet stay lining will have to be added to assemble the gusset to the upper.	The gusset will be leather as provided in the udpated PD dated 19 April 2013.

2	3.4.4 Boot Lining	9	1) The minimum moisture vapor permeability of 1000 grams per sq meter is incorrect. It should match the 640 grams that is in the component requirement TABLE II.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for correction.
			2) The bond strength requirement between the lining and insole board does not list an ASTM method or a method is not listed in section 4.0 of the PD. What is the test method and can DLA Lab perform this test currently?	This is a not a testable component. Bond strength must be maintained through the life of the boot.

3 3.4.13.3.1 Rubber Compound Requirements, Table VI 13 The 5 iron midsole requirements need to be for a non-oil resistant rubber. Requirement remains as stated in the draft PD and the updated PD dated 19 April 2013.

4	Table IX Thickness of leather uppers	15	1) Add inside eyelet stay since the gusset is fabric. (SEE QUESTION 1)	Please see response to question #1.
			2) If the ankle strap is changed to webbing it should be dropped from this table.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.

5 3.6.2 Skiving 15 If the ankle strap is changed to webbing it needs to be removed from this section. Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.

6 3.8.2 Seam Stitch Strength 17 No definition of what parts to test. The entire upper is subject to test.

7 3.8.2.1 Gusset Seam Strength 17 Need a better definition of which seam to test. Only one seam exists on the gusset and is therefore subject to test.

8	Table XVII End Item Tests	26	1) Weight is listed as 2.10 lbs, need to update section 3.3.1 it currently shows as 2 lbs.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.
			2) Shock attenuation for the rear foot is listed as 14.0g it should be 12.0g.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.
9	Webbing ankle support	n/a	In the presolicitation notice in the Synopsis section of the notice it lists modifications to the design. One modification is changing the ankle support strap from leather to nylon webbing. This change needs to be defined in the PD including placement and material width requirements.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.
10	PU Midsole Table V	13	Meramec currently manufactures a 0.40 to 0.50 cushion midsole. Is the PD going to reflect a 0.40 to 0.60 density?	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.

TW PD Updates

	Comments to RAT Temperate Weather Marine Corps. Boot RAT PD 12-01
	Draft 28 Jan 2013
			4/16/13
Item	Section	Page	Comment	Response
1	3.4.3 Gusset	9	1)Figures 2A and 2B do not show the gusset of the boot so the desired construction can be observed.	Figures 2A and 2B have been updated in PD dated 19 April 2013.
			2)With a fabric gusset a leather eyelet stay lining will have to be added to assemble the gusset to the upper.	The gusset will be leather as provided in the udpated PD dated 19 April 2013.

2	3.4.4 Boot Lining	9	1) The minimum moisture vapor permeability of 1000 grams per sq meter is incorrect. It should match the 640 grams that is in the component requirement TABLE II.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for correction.
			2) The bond strength requirement between the lining and insole board does not list an ASTM method or a method is not listed in section 4.0 of the PD. What is the test method and can DLA Lab perform this test currently?	This is a not a testable component. Bond strength must be maintained through the life of the boot.

3 3.4.13.3.1 Rubber Compound Requirements, Table VI 14 The 5 iron midsole requirements need to be for a non-oil resistant rubber. Requirement remains as stated in the draft PD and the updated PD dated 19 April 2013.

4	Table IX Thickness of leather uppers	16	1) Add inside eyelet stay since the gusset is fabric. (SEE QUESTION 1)	Please see response to question #1.
			2) If the ankle strap is changed to webbing it should be dropped from this table.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.

5 3.6.2 Skiving 16 If the ankle strap is changed to webbing it needs to be removed from this section. Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.

6 3.8.2 Seam Stitch Strength 18 No definition of what parts to test. The entire upper is subject to test.

7 3.8.2.1 Gusset Seam Strength 18 Need a better definition of which seam to test. Only one seam exists on the gusset and is therefore subject to test.

8	Table XVII End Item Tests	30	1) Weight is listed as 2.10 lbs, need to update section 3.3.1 it currently shows as 2 lbs.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.
			2) Shock attenuation for the rear foot is listed as 14.0g it should be 12.0g.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.

9	Webbing ankle support	n/a	In the presolicitation notice in the Synopsis section of the notice it lists modifications to the design. One modification is changing the ankle support strap from leather to nylon webbing. This change needs to be defined in the PD including placement and material width requirements.	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.
10	PU Midsole Table V	13	Meramec currently manufactures a 0.40 to 0.50 cushion midsole. Is the PD going to reflect a 0.40 to 0.60 density?	Please see updated PD dated 19 April 2013 for clarification.

Sheet1

File details come from the government source that posted it. Updated Nov 14, 2017.