2848_2.XLS

This document is a final evaluation score sheet from a competitive procurement process involving two separate contract awards: B-024-23 for Class 1-3 vehicles and C-002-23 for Class 4-13 vehicles. Two companies participated in the evaluation: Badger Truck Center and LWK Enterprise Inc. Four evaluators assessed the proposals across three categories: Proposer Qualification (Section 4.0), Technical Requirements (Section 5.0), and Cost (Section 6.0). For contract B-024-23 Class 1-3, LWK Enterprise Inc. achieved the highest total score of 3,095 points compared to Badger Truck Center's 1,774 points, while for contract C-002-23 Class 4-13, only Badger Truck Center submitted a proposal and received a total score of 2,022 points.

The procurement covers vehicle classes ranging from Class 1-3 (lighter commercial vehicles) to Class 4-13 (heavier commercial trucks), indicating a comprehensive vehicle acquisition program. The evaluation methodology weighted cost as worth 300 points across all evaluators for each contract, while technical requirements and proposer qualifications received varying point allocations from individual evaluators. LWK Enterprise Inc. consistently outperformed Badger Truck Center in the technical requirements and proposer qualification categories for the Class 1-3 contract, receiving perfect cost scores of 300 points from all evaluators. The scoring structure suggests this was a best-value procurement where technical merit and contractor qualifications were considered alongside pricing.