AttachmentJ4_TrailMgmtObjectives_Class3DesignParameters.pdf

Trail Fundamentals and

Trail Management Objectives

Training Reference Package Updated 5/1/2011

ATTACHMENT J-4

May 1, 2011 Update

The Trail Fundamentals and Trail Management Objectives Training Reference Package was updated May 1, 2011 to include examples of electronically produced Infra Trails TMO forms, to rearrange the order of the Appendices, and to combine previous definition sections into one expanded Glossary section in Appendix C.

Contents

Trail Fundamentals Overview……………………………………………. 1

Trail Management Objectives (TMOs)…………………………………... 5

National Quality Standards……………………………………………….. 31

National Trail Management Classes……………………………………. 33

Trail Design Parameters……………………………………………….…. 49

Condition Assessment Survey Matrix (CASM) ………………………… 67

Appendices:

A. Federal Trail Data Standards ………………………………………... 69

B. References …………………………………….………………………. 71

C. Glossary……………………………….…………………………….….. 73

Trail Fundamentals - 1

Trail Fundamentals

Trail Type Trail Class Managed Use Designed Use Design Parameters

Trail Fundamentals are five concepts that are the cornerstones of Forest Service trail management:

Trail Type Trail Class * Managed Use * Designed Use * Design Parameters

Identify the five Trail Fundamentals for each National Forest System (NFS) trail or trail segment based on applicable land management plan direction, travel management decisions, trail-specific decisions, and other related direction (FSM 2353.13).

Trail Fundamentals provide an integrated means to consistently record and communicate the intended design and management guidelines for trail design, construction, maintenance and use. Before completing documentation for Trail Management Objectives (TMO), TRACS, or applying Trail Fundamentals in trail management, it is essential that their intent is clearly understood.

Trail Type (FSH 2309.18, sec. 14.1)

A category that reflects the predominant trail surface and general mode of travel accommodated by a trail

There are three Trails Types:

Standard/Terra Trail: A trail that has a surface consisting predominantly of the ground and that is designed and managed to accommodate use on that surface.

Snow Trail: A trail that has a surface consisting predominantly of snow or ice and that is designed and managed to accommodate use on that surface.

Water Trail: A trail that has a surface consisting predominantly of water (but may include land-based portages) and that is designed and managed to accommodate use on that surface.

This management concept allows managers to identify trail-specific Design Parameters, management needs, and the cost of managing the trail for particular uses and/or seasons by trail or trail segment.

1. Inventory trails and identify the appropriate Design Parameters, management needs, and management costs for NFS trails using the Trail Types.

2. Identify only one Trail Type per trail.

Trail Fundamentals - 2

3. Identify the Trail Type for each NFS trail based on applicable land management plan direction, travel management decisions, trail-specific decisions, and other related direction.

4. Inventory both trails and Trail Types in the Infra Trails Module when two National Forest System trails overlap, for example, when a Snow Trail overlaps a Standard Terra Trail.

Trail Class (FSH 2309.18, sec.14.2)

The prescribed scale of development for a trail, representing its intended design and management standards.

Trail Classes are general categories reflecting trail development scale, arranged along a continuum.

There are five Trail Classes, ranging from the least developed (Trail Class 1) to the most developed (Trail Class 5):

Trail Class 1: Minimally Developed

Trail Class 2: Moderately Developed

Trail Class 3: Developed

Trail Class 4: Highly Developed

Trail Class 5: Fully Developed

Use Trail Classes to inventory NFS trails and to identify the applicable Design Parameters and costs for meeting the National Quality Standards for Trails.

1. Identify only one Trail Class per trail or trail segment.

2. Trail Class descriptors reflect typical attributes of trails in each class. Local deviations from any Trail Class descriptor may be established based on trail-specific conditions, topography, or other factors, provided that the deviations are consistent with the general intent of the applicable Trail Class.

3. There is a direct relationship between Trail Class and Managed Uses (FHS 2309.18, sec.

14.3): generally, one cannot be determined without consideration of the other.

4. Identify the appropriate Trail Class for each NFS trail or trail segment based on the management intent in the applicable land management plan, travel management decisions, trail-specific decisions, and other related direction. Apply the Trail Class that most closely reflects the management intent for the trail or trail segment, which may or may not reflect the current condition of the trail.

For specifics on each Trail Class, refer to the Trail Class Matrix (FSH 2309.18, sec. 14.2, ex. 01).

Managed Use (FSH 2309.18, sec. 14.3)

A mode of travel that is actively managed and appropriate on a trail, based on its design and management.

Trail Fundamentals - 3

1. Managed Use indicates management intent to accommodate a specific use.

2. There can be more than one Managed Use per trail or trail segment.

3. The Managed Uses for a trail are usually a small subset of all the allowed uses on the trail, that is, uses that are allowed unless specifically prohibited. For example, on a trail that is closed to all motorized use but open to all non-motorized use, the Managed Uses could be Hiker/Pedestrian and Pack and Saddle. The allowed uses, however, would also include bicycles and all other non-motorized uses.

4. Identify the Managed Uses for each NFS trail or trail segment based on applicable land management plan direction, travel management decisions, trail-specific decisions, and other related direction.

5. There is a direct relationship between Managed Use and Trail Class: generally, one cannot be determined without consideration of the other. Not all Trail Classes are appropriate for all Managed Uses. For guidance on the potential appropriateness of each Trail Class to each Managed Use, see FSH 2309.18, section 14.3, exhibit 01.

Designed Use (FSH 2309.18, sec 14.4)

The Managed Use of a trail that requires the most demanding design, construction, and maintenance parameters and that, in conjunction with the applicable Trail Class, determines which Design Parameters will apply to a trail.

1. There is only one Designed Use per trail or trail segment. Although a trail or trail segment may have more than one Managed Use and numerous uses may be allowed, only one Managed Use is identified as the design driver or Designed Use.

2. Determine the Designed Use for a trail or trail segment from the Managed Uses identified for that trail. When making this determination, consider all Managed Uses that occur during all seasons of use of the trail or trail segment. Assess any essential or limiting geometry for the Managed Uses of the trail or trail segment to determine whether any trail-specific adjustments are necessary to the applicable Design Parameters.

a. In some situations, when there is more than one Managed Use identified for a trail, the Designed Use may be readily apparent. For example, on a trail with Managed Uses of all-terrain vehicle and Motorcycle, all-terrain vehicle use would be the Designed Use because this use requires wider tread widths and has lower tolerances for surface obstacles and maximum trail grades.

b. In other situations involving more than one Managed Use, the Designed Use may not be readily apparent, as is often the case when there are fewer differences between the applicable sets of Design Parameters than in the example above. For example, on a trail that is actively managed for hiker and pedestrian, pack and saddle, and bicycle use, pack and saddle use would likely be the Designed Use because of the three Managed Uses, pack and saddle use generally has the most limiting design requirements. While the Bicycle Design Parameters are very similar to the Pack and Saddle Design Parameters, the Design Parameters for this trail may need to be adjusted to accommodate bicycles.

Trail Fundamentals - 4

Designed Use / Managed Use Types

Hiker / Pedestrian Cross-Country Ski Pack and Saddle Snowshoe Bicycle Snowmobile Motorcycle Motorized Watercraft All Terrain Vehicle Non-Motorized Watercraft Four-Wheel Drive Vehicle > 50” in Width

Design Parameters (FSH 2309.18, sec. 14.5)

Technical guidelines for the survey, design, construction, maintenance, and assessment of a trail, based on its Designed Use and Trail Class.

1. Design Parameters reflect the design objectives for NFS trails and determine the dominant physical criteria that most define their geometric shape. These criteria include:

a. Design Tread Width. Design Tread Width is expressed in terms of single lane, double lane, and the minimum tread width on trail structures.

b. Design Surface. Design Surface is expressed in terms of surface type, protrusions, and obstacles.

c. Design Grade. Design Grade is expressed in terms of Target Grade, Short Pitch Maximum Grade, and Maximum Pitch Density.

d. Design Cross Slope. Design Cross Slope is expressed in terms of Target Cross Slope and Maximum Cross Slope.

e. Design Clearing. Design Clearing is expressed in terms of width, height, and shoulder clearance.

f. Design Turns. Design Turns are expressed in terms of the turning radius.

2. Local deviations from any Design Parameter may be established based on trail-specific conditions, topography, and other factors (for example, mitigation of site-specific safety concerns and adjustments to accommodate other Managed Uses), provided that the deviations are consistent with the general intent of the applicable Trail Class.

3. Identify the Design Parameters for a NFS trail or trail segment based on its Trail Class and Designed Use. For a Design Parameter such as Design Tread Width, Design Clearing Width, and Design Turns that is expressed as a range of values, identify a specific value for each trail or trail segment.

For the complete set of Design Parameters, refer to FSH 2309.18, section 23.11, exhibit 01, through section 23.33, exhibit 01.

* This management concept / attribute is included in the Federal Trail Data Standards developed by the US Forest Service, National Park Service, Bureau of Land Management and US Fish and Wildlife Service.

Trail Fundamentals - 5

Trail Management Objectives

TMO: Setting the Standard

Trail Management Objective (TMOs) are documentation of the intended purpose and management of an NFS trail based on management direction, including access objectives.

Manage each trail to meet the TMOs identified for that trail, based on applicable land management plan direction, travel management decisions, trail-specific decisions, and other related direction, and based on management priorities and available resources. For each NFS trail or NFS trail segment, identify and document its TMOs, including the five Trail Fundamentals, Recreation Opportunity Spectrum classifications, design criteria, travel management strategies, and maintenance criteria. (FSM 2353.12)

Why TMOs?

TMOs are fundamental building blocks for trail management. They synthesize and document, in one convenient place, the management intention for the trail and provide basic reference information for subsequent trail planning, management, condition surveys, and reporting.

The documentation of TMOs for each NFS trail makes good management sense and are a pre-requisite for completing an effective trail condition assessment survey and subsequent prescription for work needed to meet standard

A trail can not be effectively managed or a determination made of what’s needed to meet standard until basic questions like these have been answered: What is the purpose of the trail?

What type of use is the trail being managed for? What is the intended level of development of the trail? In the past, some trails have been managed based largely on the type or amount of use they were currently getting, without sufficient consideration of the intended use or future trends and needs. This sometimes resulted in managing a trail for a type or level of use that was not compatible with the trail management direction, design, or location. Establishing and communicating the intended TMOs for each system trail is a proactive step that prevents this from occurring.

Developing Effective TMOs

District Rangers are responsible for approving TMOs, unless that responsibility has been reserved by the Forest Supervisor. (FSM 2325.04h)

Each TMO should be approved by a line officer after review and recommendation from the unit trail manager. For districts, it is recommended that the forest planning group and trail coordinator review these objectives prior to district ranger approval. This will ensure that the objectives for a trail are consistent with the forest plan, district and forest travel management plans, and anticipated future land management actions. This will also ensure consistency

Trail Fundamentals - 6 between units so that one trail will not be motorized on one district then switch to pack and saddle stock at the district boundary.

TMOs are not static documents. They reflect the management intent and special considerations that are important for effective management of the trail. TMOs should be updated if the management intent for the trail, special considerations, or other factors change.

Instructions and reference material for developing TMOs are provided on the following pages of this section, on the USFS internal website for Recreation & Heritage Resources Integrated Business Systems (http://fsweb.wo.fs.fed.us/rhwr/ibsc/index.shtml), and on the USFS external website for Trail Management (http://www.fs.fed.us/recreation/programs/trail-management/index.shtml). Review these materials for step-by-step instructions, examples, and basic guidance on documenting TMOs.

Instructions for electronically recording TMOs in Infra Trails are available on the I-Web Net website (http://basenet.fs.fed.us/) and via Infra On-line Help from within the Infra Trails module.

Trail Fundamentals - 7

TMO Form (Excel Form)1

1 The Excel TMO form presented here is for reference to discuss TMO terminology and data fields.

For Instructions on using the Infra Trails electronic TMO form, refer to Infra Trails Online Help.

Trail Fundamentals - 8

Trail Fundamentals - 9

Trail Fundamentals - 10

Trail Fundamentals - 11

TMO Form

Instructions

Establishing and documenting Trail Management Objectives (TMOs) prior to doing a trail condition survey is essential for getting high quality results— results that will benefit trail management efforts for years to come.

The instructions below explain how to complete each field on the TMO Form. Refer also to the attached TMO Form and TMO Example on the following pages. Additional guidance and TMO reference materials can be found in FSM 2353 and FSH 2309.18, the TRACS User Guide, Infra Trails documentation, and on the USFS Recreation, & Heritage Resources Integrated Business Systems website: http://fsweb.wo.fs.fed.us/rhwr/ibsc/index.shtml

Overall Trail Information

Region / Forest / District: Enter the Region number, Forest name (or number), and District name (or number).

Trail Name & Trail Number: Enter the official trail name and trail number. These should correspond exactly to the Trail Name and Trail Number recorded in Infra Trails. Double-check for correct spelling and use of spaces.

Trail Beginning & Ending Termini: Enter a brief narrative description identifying the location of the beginning and ending trail termini. These should correspond exactly with what is recorded in Infra Trails.

Beginning & Ending Mileposts: Enter the beginning milepost or measure point, and the ending milepost for the trail. These should correspond exactly with what is recorded in Infra Trails.

Trail Inventory Length: Enter the length of the trail in miles. This mileage should match what is recorded in Infra Trails. Mileage accuracy recorded on the TMO should correspond to the method of collection (Trail Mileage Source):

Wheel: If the length was wheeled with a cyclometer, use three decimal places (i.e.3.641).

[Note: 0.001 miles equals approx. 5 feet]

GPS: If the length was collected by GPS, use two decimal places (i.e. 3.64).

Map or Unknown: If the actual length is unknown, or was determined by cartographic feature file (CFF) or by vehicle, use no more than one decimal place of accuracy (i.e. 3.6).

Trail Mileage Source: Check the box that corresponds to the source of the mileage above.

This is the mileage metadata for reference.

Trail Fundamentals - 12

TMO Trail Section

Some trails may have more than one set of objectives. Normally this occurs when a TMO variable changes along distinct segments of the trail, such as between junctions or destinations.

Examples can include changes in Trail Class, ROS, Design Parameters, or Prohibited Uses.

If applicable, use the TMO Trail Section block to identify multiple TMOs by trail section. If not applicable, leave this section blank.

Section #: Enter a number or letter to sequentially identify the trail section and corresponding TMO (i.e. Segment #: 1, 2, 3, etc.).

Section Beginning & Ending Termini: Enter a brief narrative description identifying the location of the beginning and ending termini for this trail segment.

Section Beginning & Ending Milepost: Enter the beginning milepost or measure point, and the ending milepost for this trail segment.

Designed Use Objectives

Trail Type: A category that reflects the predominant trail surface and general mode of travel accommodated by a trail

The Trail Type differentiates between the three basic kinds of trails: Standard Terra Trail, Snow Trail, or Water Trail. Each Trail Type is stored in the Infra database as a separate record, even when, for example, a Snow Trail mostly or totally overlaps a Standard/Terra Trail.

Assign one Trail Type for the trail.

Trail Class: The prescribed scale of development for a trail, representing its intended design and management standards.

The National Trail Management Classes are outlined in the National Trails Management Class Matrix (.FSH 2309.18, sec. 14.2, ex. 01).

Assign the most appropriate Trail Class for the trail or trail segment. If more than one Trail Class is assigned to the trail, identify each Trail Class by individual trail segment (see TMO Trail Section above).

ROS/WROS Class: The Recreational Opportunity Spectrum (ROS) class has likely been assigned to the area by the forest plan and helps ensure the transportation system is managed accordingly. ROS and Wilderness ROS (WROS) classes are mutually exclusive.

Locate and refer to the forest ROS and/or Wilderness classification maps.

Assign the appropriate ROS/WROS to this segment of the trail. If multiple ROS/WROS classes exist along the trail, consider either segmenting the trail or using the dominant class (see TMO Trail Section above).

Note: Pending finalization of nationally standardized definitions for WROS categories, refer to regional protocols for WROS definitions, with WROS 1 representing the most

Trail Fundamentals - 13 pristine and WROS 5 representing the most modified end of the WROS spectrum. The WROS 6 category can be used for Other.

Designed Use: The Managed Use of a trail that requires the most demanding design, construction, and maintenance parameters and that, in conjunction with the applicable Trail Class, determines which Design Parameters will apply to a trail.

The Designed Use must be identified for each trail or trail segment. The Designed Use identifies the single use or limiting factor that drives technical Design Parameters for the trail (i.e. Design Tread Width, Design Grade, Design Clearing, etc.). The Designed Use is necessary to establish the trail’s geometric design standards from which the trail is designed, constructed, operated, and maintained. While several Managed Uses may occur on the trail, there is only one Designed Use for any given trail or trail segment.

For an expanded explanation of Designed Use, refer to FSH 2309.18, section 14.4.

Select only one Designed Use per trail or trail segment

Design Parameters: Technical guidelines for the survey, design, construction, maintenance, and assessment of a trail, based on its Designed Use and Trail Class.

Design Parameters reflect the design objectives for NFS trails and determine the dominant physical criteria that most define their geometric shape.

For each combination of Designed Use and Trail Class, there is a corresponding set of nationally established Design Parameters. These nationally established Design Parameters (FSH 2309.19, section 23.11 through section 23.33) should be used as a basis for determining specific Design Parameters for a trail or trail segment. Additional design criteria are also important, such as back slope angle for example, but are not included in the national Design Parameters as they tend to be very site-specific and require sound engineering judgment to define.

Some of the national Design Parameters are presented as specific values or narrative descriptions, while others are presented as an appropriate range of values. For those values presented as numeric ranges, a trail-specific value that falls within the range should be identified and recorded on the TMO form. For example, on a Hiker/Pedestrian Trail Class 4, the nationally established Design Tread Width for non-wilderness segments is listed as 24 to

60. The trail-specific Design Tread Width, however, should be recorded as a specific value appropriate for the trail (i.e. 48 inches).

Local deviations from any Design Parameter may be established based on trail-specific conditions, topography, and other factors (for example, mitigation of site-specific safety concerns and adjustments to accommodate other Managed Uses), provided that the deviations are consistent with the general intent of the applicable Trail Class.

Assign a specific value for each Design Parameter variable listed. This is not intended to be an all-encompassing list of specifications, but a list of only the dominant criteria that most define the geometric shape of the trail.

Footnote any trail-specific deviations from the national Design Parameters in the corresponding Design Parameter field, and explain or justify the deviation in the Remarks section of the TMO.

Add any additional Design Parameter factors and corresponding values that are deemed important to this specific segment of trail and are necessary for achieving the trail objectives.

Trail Fundamentals - 14

Target Frequency: Target Frequency indicates how often a routine task should be completed in order to maintain the trail to standard. Each trail requires a recurring interval for routine maintenance tasks in order to keep the trail functional, stable and useable. For example, brush grows at a certain rate and to keep a trail operational, the brush must be cut at fairly regular intervals. These intervals, which vary by trail and by task, are generally site or area-specific and require local experience to define.

For the applicable tasks, define the maintenance interval that best reflects the frequency necessary to keep this trail or trail segment to standard. Any period within that interval should be considered “to standard”.

The interval is expressed in years.

Examples:

Task: Frequency: Recorded As:

Trail Opening once every year 1.0

Brushing once every 3 years 0.33

Logging Out two times per year 2.0

Travel Management Strategies

Travel Management Strategies are very important for effective and efficient trail management.

Establishing Travel Management Strategies for major trail uses helps the manager balance the needs of conflicting uses, guides the manager on operational tradeoffs, and assist maintenance crews to efficiently target maintenance efforts to only necessary tasks. This section of the TMO form documents basic information that should also be recorded in the Access and Travel Management (ATM) portion of Infra Trails.

Managed Use: A mode of travel that is actively managed and appropriate on a trail, based on its design and management

Managed Use indicates a management intent to accommodate a specific use. Accommodating the Managed Use frequently results in user-specific trail maintenance and/or signing needs and costs.

Record each use that is actively managed on the trail or trail segment. There may be more than one Managed Use per trail or trail segment.

For each Managed Use, document the dates during which that use is actively managed for that use. If there is more than one season of use for a particular Managed Use, record that using the blank space provided under the list of Managed Uses.

Trail Fundamentals - 15

Managed Season of Use (To/From): The Managed Season of Use specifically defines the period of the time that the trail is available and managed in a safe and sufficient state for the defined user. It is intended to bracket the times that the Forest is responsible for providing that opportunity.

Examples:

One obvious example would be when a Standard Terra Trail is covered by snow and outside of the Managed Season of Use. During this time, the Forest does not intend to provide an accessible tread as this would require snow removal and is not part of the managed trail opportunity. Conversely, during the Managed Season of Use, the Forest intends to maintain the accessible tread in a safe and functional condition.

A less obvious example would be if the trail has a Hiker/Pedestrian Travel Management Strategy of Encourage with a Managed Season of Use from March 1 to November 15. In this case, the Forest would be responsible for providing stream crossings during high water in June (i.e. trail bridges). Changing the Managed Season of Use for the same example to June 30 to November 15, thus bypassing the June run-off, would alleviate this conflict and clearly define management expectations.

Prohibited Use: Mode of travel prohibited by official legal order.

Record any use that is prohibited by an official prohibition or closure order.

Document the dates during which the use is prohibited.

Footnote and cite the specific CFR under Remarks / Reference Information.

Other Use: This section is provided to document additional trail-specific information and Travel Management Strategies as needed.

If applicable, record other Travel Management Strategies for the trail that were not captured under Managed Use or Prohibited Use. Check whether the use is Accepted (allowed, while not actively managed for), Discouraged, or Eliminated.

Special Considerations

Use this section to identify any additional considerations that trail managers, design, construction or maintenance personnel should be aware of.

Check any applicable special consideration for the trail or trail segment, underlining the appropriate clarifier shown in parenthesis.

Footnote the consideration, and provide details and/or reference for corresponding direction or decision documents under Remarks / Reference Information.

Remarks / Reference Information

Use this area to provide additional information or clarification, or to cite reference decisions and materials related to information documented earlier in the TMO. When clarifying information documented in previous sections of the TMO, it is recommended that a footnote be added next to the TMO entry, followed by a footnoted explanation in the Remarks / Reference section.

Trail Fundamentals - 16

Example:

Footnoted Items in TMO Sections:

Design Parameters

Basic Tread Width, inches 24” 1

Maintenance Frequency

Trail Opening 1 2

Special Considerations T&E or Sensitive Species Present X 3

Footnote Explanations in Remarks:

Remarks / Reference Information

1 Tread width exceptions allowed at existing wood trail structures.

2 Complete annual Trail Opening by 6/15.

3 Goose grass sedge, sensitive plant, located in 1st mile of trail, refer to 3/15/1999 BE for Smith Ridge Trail for mitigation specifications.

Line Officer Approval

District Rangers are responsible for approving TMOs, unless that responsibility has been reserved by the Forest Supervisor (FSM 2353.04j).

Having the line officer approve Trail Management Objectives is essential. The TMO pulls together and documents management direction and expectations for the trail. A documented, approved TMO provides the trail manager, trail technicians, and trail maintenance crews with the key tool they need to confidently work on the trail without having to second-guess operational and maintenance choices.

The TMO establishes the base standards against which trail condition surveys and prescriptions are measured and completed. It also ensures a management framework of continuity and consistency over time and through personnel changes. Succinctly put, the TMO pulls it all together.

Trail Fundamentals - 17

TMO Example 1 (Excel Form)

Trail Fundamentals - 18

Trail Fundamentals - 19

TMO Example 1 (Infra Trails Form)

Trail Fundamentals - 20

Trail Fundamentals - 21

Trail Fundamentals - 22

Trail Fundamentals - 23

TMO Example 2 (Excel Form)

Trail Fundamentals - 24

Trail Fundamentals - 25

Trail Fundamentals - 26

Trail Fundamentals - 27

TMO Example 2 (Infra Trails Form)

Trail Fundamentals - 28

Trail Fundamentals - 29

Trail Fundamentals - 30

Trail Fundamentals - 31

National Quality Standards for Trails

National Quality Standards are national criteria that establish the level of quality in terms of health and cleanliness, resource setting, safety and security, responsiveness, and condition of facilities for National Forest System trails managed at a full-service level.

Apply the National Quality Standards for Trails in planning, constructing, and managing National Forest System trails and related trail projects. (FSH 2353.15)

1. The National Quality Standards for Trails establish desired outcomes for National Forest

System trails managed at a full-service level. These standards also form the baseline for estimating the cost of managing NFS trails. The National Quality Standards for Trails consist of five key measures: health and cleanliness, safety and security, condition of facilities, responsiveness, and resource setting.

2. The complete set of National Quality Standards for Trails is contained in FSH 2353.15, exhibit 01.

3. Critical National Quality Standards are identified with an asterisk. If any of these standards is not met, the resulting conditions pose a high probability of immediate and permanent injury to persons or property. If any of the critical standards cannot be met due to budget or other constraints, take action as soon as practicable to correct or mitigate the problem. Corrective or mitigating measures may include closing the trail, portions of the trail, or associated trail structures to public use.

4. Take mitigating steps if conditions, facilities, or services addressed by noncritical standards decline to the point where visitor’s health or safety is threatened. Examples include repairing the trail, portions of the trail, or associated trail structure or removing trail structures that are in disrepair and no longer needed.

5. The National Quality Standards for Trails apply to NFS trails and associated trail structures. The National Quality Standards for Trails do not apply to trailheads.

Trailheads, which are constructed with the primary purpose of providing visitor amenities, are typically considered developed sites. Trailheads constructed with the primary purpose of resource protection are typically considered concentrated use areas within General Forest Areas.

Trail Fundamentals - 32

National Quality Standards for Trails

FSH 2309.18., Section 15

Key Measure: HEALTH AND CLEANLINESS

1. Visitors are not exposed to human waste along trails.

2. The trail and trailside are free of litter.

3. The trail and trailside are free of graffiti.

Key Measure: RESOURCE SETTING

1. *Effects from trail use do not conflict with environmental laws (such as the Endangered Species Act, National Historic Preservation Act, and Clean Water Act).1

2. Resource management adjacent to and along the trail corridor is consistent with ROS objectives and desired conditions of adjacent management areas.

3. Trail opportunities, trail development, and trail management are consistent with Recreation Management System (ROS, SMS, and BBM) objectives and the applicable land management plan.

4. The trail, use of the trail, and trail maintenance do not cause unacceptable damage to other resources.

5. Trail use does not exceed established trail capacity.

Key Measure: SAFETY & SECURITY

1. *Hazards do not exist on or along the trail.1

2. Applicable laws, regulations, and special orders are enforced.

Key Measure: RESPONSIVENESS

1. *When a trail is signed as accessible, it meets current agency policy and accessibility guidelines.1

2. Information is posted in a clear and professional manner.

3. Visitors are provided opportunities to communicate their expectations for and satisfaction with NFS trails.

Key Measure: CONDITION OF FACILITIES

1. Annual/Routine Maintenance. The trail and its structures are serviceable and in good repair throughout their designed service life.2

2. Deferred Maintenance. Trails that are in disrepair due to lack of scheduled maintenance, are in violation of applicable safety codes or other regulatory requirements (such as applicable accessibility guidelines), or are beyond their designed service life are repaired, rehabilitated, replaced, or decommissioned, as appropriate.2

3. Capital Improvement. New, altered, or expanded trails meet Forest Service design standards and are consistent with standards and guidelines in the applicable land management plan.2

1 Indicates a Critical National Quality Standard. If it cannot be met, action must be taken as soon as practicable to correct or mitigate the problem. Refer to FSH 2309.18, section 15.

2 For definitions of Annual Maintenance, Deferred Maintenance, and Capital Improvement, refer to Appendix A of this Training Package.

Trail Fundamentals - 33

Trail Class Matrix (FSH 2353.142, Exhibit 01)

Trail Classes are general categories reflecting trail development scale, arranged along a continuum. The Trail Class identified for a National Forest System (NFS) trail prescribes its development scale, representing its intended design and management standards.1 Local deviations from any Trail Class descriptor may be established based on trail-specific conditions, topography, or other factors, provided that the deviations are consistent with the general intent of the applicable Trail Class.

Identify the appropriate Trail Class for each NFS trail or trail segment based on the management intent in the applicable land management plan, travel management decisions, trail-specific decisions, and other related direction. Apply the Trail Class that most closely reflects the management intent for the trail or trail segment, which may or may not reflect the current condition of the trail.

Trail Attributes

Trail Class 1 Minimally Developed

Trail Class 2 Moderately Developed

Trail Class 3 Developed

Trail Class 4 Highly Developed

Trail Class 5 Fully Developed

Tread

Traffic Flow

Tread intermittent and often indistinct.

May require route finding.

Single lane, with no allowances constructed for passing.

Predominantly native materials.

Tread continuous and discernible, but narrow and rough.

Single lane, with minor allowances constructed for passing.

Typically native materials.

Tread continuous and obvious.

Single lane, with allowances constructed for passing where required by traffic volume in places where there is no reasonable opportunity to pass.

Native or imported materials.

Tread wide and relatively smooth, with few irregularities.

Single lane, with allowances constructed for passing where required by traffic volume in places where there is no reasonable opportunity to pass.

Double lane where traffic volume is high and passing is frequent.

Native or imported materials.

May be hardened.

Tread wide, firm, stable, and generally uniform.

Single lane, with frequent turnouts where traffic volume is low to moderate.

Double lane where traffic volume is moderate to high.

Commonly hardened with asphalt or other imported material.

Obstacles Obstacles common, naturally ocurring, often substantial, and intended to provide increased challenge.

Narrow passages; brush, steep grades, rocks and logs present.

Obstacles may be common, substantial, and intended to provide increased challenge.

Blockages cleared to define route and protect resources.

Vegetation may encroach into trailway.

Obstacles may be common, but not substantial or intended to provide challenge.

Vegetation cleared outside of trailway.

Obstacles infrequent and insubstantial.

Vegetation cleared outside of trailway.

Obstacles not present.

Grades typically < 8%.

10/16/2008

Trail Fundamentals - 34

Trail Attributes

Trail Class 1 Minimally Developed

Trail Class 2 Moderately Developed

Trail Class 3 Developed

Trail Class 4 Highly Developed

Trail Class 5 Fully Developed

Constructed Features

Trail

Elements

Structures minimal to non-existent.

Drainage typically provided without structures.

Natural fords.

Typically no bridges.

Structures of limited size, scale, and quantity; typically constructed of native materials.

Structures adequate to protect trail infrastructure and resources.

Natural fords.

Bridges as needed for resource protection and appropriate access.

Structures may be common and substantial; constructed of imported or native materials.

Natural or constructed fords.

Bridges as needed for resource protection and appropriate access.

Structures frequent and substantial; typically constructed of imported materials.

Contructed or natural fords.

Bridges as needed for resource protection and user convenience.

Trailside amenities may be present.

Structures frequent or continuous; typically constructed of imported materials.

May include bridges, boardwalks, curbs, handrails, trailside amenities, and similar features.

Signs2 Route identification signing limited to junctions.

Route markers present when trail location is not evident.

Regulatory and resource protection signing infrequent.

Destination signing, unless required, generally not present.

Information and interpretive signing generally not present.

Route identification signing limited to junctions.

Route markers present when trail location is not evident.

Regulatory and resource protection signing infrequent.

Destination signing typically infrequent outside wilderness areas; generally not present in wilderness areas.

Information and interpretive signing uncommon.

Route identification signing at junctions and as needed for user reassurance.

Route markers as needed for user reassurance.

Regulatory and resource protection signing may be common.

Destination signing likely outside wilderness areas;

generally not present in wilderness areas.

Information and interpretive signs may be present outside wilderness areas.

Route identification signing at junctions and as needed for user reassurance.

Route markers as needed for user reassurance.

Regulatory and resource protection signing common.

Destination signing common outside wilderness areas; generally not present in wilderness areas.

Information and interpretive signs may be common outside wilderness areas.

Accessibility information likely displayed at trailhead.

Route identification signing at junctions and for user reassurance.

Route markers as needed for user reassurance.

Regulatory and resource protection signing common.

Destination signing common.

Information and interpretive signs common.

Accessibility information likely displayed at trailhead.

Typical Recreation Environs

Experience3

Natural and unmodified.

ROS: Typically Primitive to Roaded Natural.

WROS: Typically Primitive to Semi-Primitive.

Natural and essentially unmodified.

ROS: Typically Primitive to Roaded Natural.

WROS: Typically Primitive to Semi-Primitive.

Natural and primarily unmodified.

ROS: Typically Primitive to Roaded Natural.

WROS: Typically Semi- Primitive to Transition.

May be modified.

ROS: Typically Semi- Primitive to Rural

WROS: Typically Portal or Transition.

May be highly modified.

Commonly associated with visitor centers or high-use recreation sites.

ROS: Typically Roaded Natural to Urban.

Generally not present in Wilderness areas.

1 For National Quality Standards for Trails, Potential Appropriateness of Trail Classes for Managed Uses, Design Parameters, and other related guidance, refer to FSM 2353 and FSH 2309.18.

2 For standards and guidelines on the use of signs and posters on trails, refer to the Sign and Poster Guidelines for the Forest Service (EM-7100-15).

3 The Trail Class Matrix shows combinations of Trail Class and Recreation Opportunity Spectrum (ROS) or Wilderness Recreation Opportunity Spectrum (WROS) settings that commonly occur, although trails in all Trail Classes may and do occur in all settings. For guidance on the application of the ROS and WROS, refer to FSM 2310 and 2353 and FSH 2309.18.

Trail Fundamentals - 35

USFS Trail Classes

Photo Examples Updated 10/16/2008

The photos below provide visual examples of typical Trail Class scenarios. Remember that Trail Classes are general categories reflecting development scale, arranged along a continuum, with no hard and fast lines drawn between the classes. The photos below can be used as visual aids to assist in consistent application of trail classification.

Trail Class 1

TC1 – Tread: Tread intermittent and indistinct.

TC1 – Obstacles: Obstacles common, naturally occurring, often substantial

Trail Fundamentals - 36

TC1 – Constructed Features: Constructed features minimal to non-existent.

TC1 – Signs: Route identification signing limited to junctions. Route markers present when trail location is not evident.

Trail Fundamentals - 37

TC1 – Typical Rec. Environment / Experience: Recreation environment natural and unmodified.

Trail Fundamentals - 38

Trail Class 2

TC2 – Tread: Tread continuous and discernible, but narrow and rough.

TC2 – Obstacles: Obstacles may be common and substantial. Blockages cleared to define route and protect resource. Vegetation may encroach into trailway.

Trail Fundamentals - 39

TC2 – Constructed Features: Structures are of limited size, scale, and quantity.

Trail Fundamentals - 40

TC2 – Signs: Route identification signing limited to junctions. Route markers present when location is not evident.

TC2 – Typical Rec. Environment / Experience: Recreation environment natural and essentially unmodified.

Trail Fundamentals - 41

Trail Class 3

TC3 – Tread: Tread continuous and obvious.

TC3 – Obstacles: Obstacles may be common. Vegetation cleared outside of trailway.

Trail Fundamentals - 42

TC3 – Constructed Features:

Trail structures (walls, steps drainage, raised trail) may be common and substantial.

TC3 – Signs: Route identification signing at junctions and as needed for user reassurance. Route markers as needed for user reassurance. Destination signing likely outside of wilderness.

Trail Fundamentals - 43

TC3 – Typical Rec. Environment / Experience: Recreation environment natural and primarily unmodified.

Trail Fundamentals - 44

Trail Class 4

TC4 – Tread: Tread wide and relatively smooth, with few irregularities.

TC4 – Obstacles: Obstacles infrequent and insubstantial. Vegetation cleared outside of trailway.

Trail Fundamentals - 45

TC4 – Constructed Features: Structures frequent and substantial. Trailside amenities may be present.

Trail Fundamentals - 46

TC4 – Signs: Wide variety of signs likely present, informational signs likely, interpretive signs possible.

TC4 – Typical Rec. Environment / Experience: Recreation environment may be modified.

Trail Fundamentals - 47

Trail Class 5

TC5 – Tread: Tread wide, firm, stable, and generally uniform. Commonly hardened with asphalt or other imported material.

TC5 – Obstacles: Obstacles not present. Grades typically < 8%.

Trail Fundamentals - 48

TC5 – Constructed Features: Structures frequent or continuous; may include bridges, boardwalks, curbs, handrails, trailside amenities, and similar features.

TC5: – Signs: Wide variety of signs present, information and interpretive signs common.

TC5 – Typical Rec. Environment / Experience: Recreation environment may be highly modified.

Trail Fundamentals - 49

Design Parameters (FSH 2309.18, Section 23.11, Exhibit 01)

Design Parameters are technical guidelines for the survey, design, construction, maintenance, and assessment of National Forest System trails, based on their Designed Use and Trail Class and consistent with their management intent1. Local deviations from any Design Parameter may be established based on trail-specific conditions, topography, or other factors, provided that the deviations are consistent with the general intent of the applicable Trail Class.

Designed Use

HIKER/PEDESTRIAN Trail Class 1 Trail Class 2 Trail Class 3 2 Trail Class 4 2 Trail Class 5 2

Design Tread Width

Wilderness (Single Lane)

0” – 12” 6” – 18” 12” – 24”

Exception: may be 36” – 48” at steep side slopes

18” – 24”

Exception: may be 36” – 48” at steep side slopes

Not applicable

Non-Wilderness (Single Lane)

0” – 12” 6” – 18” 18” – 36”

24” – 60”

36” – 72”

Non-Wilderness (Double Lane)

36” 36” 36” – 60” 48” – 72” 72” – 120”

Structures (Minimum Width)

18” 18” 18” 36” 36”

Design Surface3

Type Native, ungraded

May be continuously rough

Native, limited grading

May be continuously rough

Native, with some on-site borrow or imported material where needed for stabilization and occasional grading

Intermittently rough

Native with improved sections of borrow or imported material, and routine grading

Minor roughness

Likely imported material, and routine grading

Uniform, firm, and stable

Protrusions ≤ 24”

Likely common and continuous

≤ 6”

May be common and continuous

≤ 3”

May be common, not continuous

≤ 3 ”

Uncommon, not continuous

No protrusions

Obstacles (Maximum Height)

24”

14”

10”

8”

No obstacles

Design Grade 3

Target Grade 5% – 25%

5% – 18% 3% – 12% 2% – 10% 2% – 5%

Short Pitch Maximum

40% 35% 25% 15% 5%

FSTAG: 5% – 12%2

Maximum Pitch Density 20% – 40% of trail

20% – 30% of trail

10% – 20% of trail

5% – 20% of trail

0% – 5% of trail

Trail Fundamentals - 50

HIKER/PEDESTRIAN Trail Class 1 Trail Class 2 Trail Class 3 2 Trail Class 4 2 Trail Class 5 2

Design Cross Slope

Target Cross Slope Natural side slope

5% – 20% 5% – 10% 3% – 7% 2% – 3% (or crowned)

Maximum Cross Slope Natural side slope

25% 15% 10% 3%

Clearing

Height 6’

6’ – 7’ 7’ – 8’ 8’ – 10’ 8’ – 10’

Width ≥ 24”

Some vegetation may encroach into clearing area

24” – 48”

Some light vegetation may encroach into clearing area

36” – 60”

48” – 72”

60” – 72”

Shoulder Clearance 3” – 6”

6” – 12” 12” – 18” 12” – 18” 12” – 24”

Turn

Radius No minimum 2’ – 3’ 3’ – 6’ 4’ – 8’ 6’ – 8’

1 For definitions of Design Parameter attributes (e.g., Design Tread Width and Short Pitch Maximum) see FSH 2309.18, section 05.

2 Trail Classes 3, 4, and 5, in particular, have the potential to provide accessible passage. If assessing or designing trails for accessibility, refer to the Forest Service

Trail Accessibility Guidelines (FSTAG) for more specific technical provisions and tolerances (FSM 2350).

3 The determination of trail-specific Design Grade, Design Surface, and other Design Parameters should be based upon soils, hydrological conditions, use levels, erosion potential, and other factors contributing to surface stability and overall sustainability of the trail.

Trail Fundamentals - 51

Design Parameters (FSH 2309.18, Section 23.12, Exhibit 01)

Design Parameters are technical guidelines for the survey, design, construction, maintenance, and assessment of National Forest System trails, based on their Designed Use and Trail Class and consistent with their management intent1. Local deviations from any Design Parameter may be established based on trail-specific conditions, topography, or other factors, provided that the deviations are consistent with the general intent of the

PACK AND SADDLE Trail Class 1 Trail Class 2 Trail Class 3 Trail Class 4 Trail Class 5

Design Tread Width

Wilderness (Single Lane)

Typically not designed or actively managed for equestrians, although use may be allowed

12” – 18”

May be up to 48” along steep side slopes

48” – 60” or greater along precipices

18” – 24”

May be up to 48” along steep side slopes

48” – 60” or greater along precipices

24”

May be up to 48” along steep side slopes

48” – 60” or greater along precipices

Typically not designed or actively managed for equestrians, although use may be allowed

Non-Wilderness (Single Lane)

12” – 24”

May be up to 48” along steep side slopes

48” – 60” or greater along precipices

18” – 48”

48” – 60” or greater along precipices

24” – 96”

48” – 60” or greater along precipices

Non-Wilderness (Double Lane)

60” 60” – 84” 84” – 120”

Structures (Minimum Width)

Other than -bridges: 36”

Bridges without handrails: 60”

Bridges with handrails:

84” clear width

Other than bridges: 36”

Bridges without handrails:

60”

Bridges with handrails:

84” clear width

Other than bridges: 36”

Bridges without handrails:

60”

Bridges with handrails: 84” clear width

Design Surface2

Type Native, with limited grading

May be frequently rough

Native, with some on-site borrow or imported material where needed for stabilization and occasional grading

Intermittently rough

Native, with improved sections of borrow or imported material and routine grading

Minor roughness

Protrusions ≤ 6”

May be common and continuous

≤ 3”

May be common, not continuous

≤ 3”

Uncommon, not continuous

Obstacles

12”

6” 3”

Trail Fundamentals - 52

PACK AND SADDLE Trail Class 1 Trail Class 2 Trail Class 3 Trail Class 4 Trail Class 5

Design Grade 2

Target Grade 5% – 20%

3% – 12% 2% – 10%

30% 20% 15%

Maximum Pitch Density 15% – 20% of trail

5% – 15% of trail 5% – 10% of trail

Cross

Target Cross Slope 5% – 10%

3% – 5% 0% – 5%

Maximum Cross Slope 10%

8% 5%

Height 8’ – 10’

10’

10’ – 12’

Width 72”

Some light vegetation may encroach into

72” – 96”

96”

Shoulder Clearance 6” – 12”

Pack clearance: 36” x 36”

12” – 18”

Pack clearance: 36” x 36”

12” – 18”

Pack clearance: 36” x 36”

Design

Radius 4’ – 5’

5’ – 8’ 6’ – 10’

1 For definitions of Design Parameter attributes (e.g., Design Tread Width and Short Pitch Maximum) see FSH 2309.18, section 05.

2 The determination of trail-specific Design Grade, Design Surface, and other Design Parameters should be based upon soils, hydrological conditions, use levels, erosion potential, and other factors contributing to surface stability and overall…